Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know IABU in not wanting to ask for maintenance. Need some sense!

242 replies

swiftt · 06/07/2021 14:52

I’ve posted about this situation before. Back story: I have a 3 week old baby. Her dad is involved but we are not together, and we never have been. He stayed with me for 2 weeks after her birth and is currently seeing her for a few hours every other evening and more at the weekend. He works full time. I’m on maternity leave and it drops down to approx £150/week as of this month.

I asked if we could have a discussion about maintenance amounts months ago and he put it off, we argued and eventually he said we’d sort it nearer the time. Well, she’s here now and we still haven’t come to an agreement. I know I need to bring this up with him again but he has made some comments recently about money and I feel like I’m walking on eggshells when I think about bringing it up. We had a newborn photo shoot done last week and when I asked him to transfer me his half for the photos (this was agreed well in advance of doing the photo shoot) he said, ‘oh, I want a new TV. Will you pay half?’ Then said he was just joking about how he wants something and I should pay half for it. I asked him in advance if he wanted the photos done and gave him the option of saying no, so to pass that off as a joke really felt like more of a dig to me.

He’s also made other comments in the past about how unfair maintenance is etc, and I feel like I’m just anticipating an argument about him basically not wanting to give me money, even though it’s for our daughter. I said to him before that even if I don’t end up needing the money for her, I’d save it in a bank account for her. I’m not the type to go and spend it on crap for the sake of it.

He’s coming over to see her tonight and I really need to nail this conversation as I’m well aware that I’m just dragging it on and making it worse but I feel so anxious about it. For context, he has bought a couple of packs of nappies and brings some stuff in from the shops for me when he visits (had a c section so I can’t drive yet). I’ve bought anything else we’ve needed for baby since she was born and haven’t asked him to contribute.

Also very aware of how pathetic I sound in this situation. I usually don’t have issues with assertiveness but he’s really difficult to have a conversation with and I’m not feeling totally in the right headspace just yet, with dealing with a newborn, sleep deprivation and doing it mostly on my own. From my other threads, I also know this doesn’t bode well for co-parenting but I just need advice on the here and now.

Bottom line here: I feel irrationally guilty about asking for child maintenance money even though my daughter is entitled to it. How do I grow some balls?!

OP posts:
Pingued · 23/07/2021 17:01

@DameFanny

"it's out of my hands now, anyway baby did a cute thing/isn't this sun lovely/are you doing bath time on Monday" etc etc
That's a good idea. Keeps the relationship with his child seperate to the maintenance.
DameFanny · 23/07/2021 16:59

"it's out of my hands now, anyway baby did a cute thing/isn't this sun lovely/are you doing bath time on Monday" etc etc

Ju11tne · 23/07/2021 16:59

Stick with the CMS OP!
You will know when your child's father earnings increase or decrease and they will decide on the amount. It's easier and fairer for the sake of your child.

CMS won't charge him extra if he complies.

Pingued · 23/07/2021 16:53

He needs to learn his boundaries and stop pestering you about the money.

Pingued · 23/07/2021 16:52

Just repeat..I am not discussing it with you, you need to talk to CMS.

swiftt · 23/07/2021 16:49

Another update.

He’s paid me the amount that he’s calculated. Apparently CMS have used last years income and he did loads of overtime so it’s way higher than it should be. I’ve told him he needs to get in touch with them to sort it out. He said he’d phone them today and he hasn’t. I haven’t heard from CMS myself. He has 2 weeks to sort it out with them. Today he said it doesn’t matter as he’s paid me now. I just kept repeating that it needs to be sorted through them. That was the whole point of this, I don’t want to have these awkward discussions with him. I hope he does sort it with them, otherwise he’ll be liable for this higher amount that CMS has calculated until he proves to them his income otherwise, won’t he? He seems to think I’ll just go along with him paying whatever he likes, despite the CMS calculation but he’ll soon realise that’s not the case.

OP posts:
GrandmasCat · 21/07/2021 23:30

True, and it is very important you let him take care of her from early on. A lot of men turn into useless parents because the mum is doing all the care and they never learn to take proper care of their kids or appreciate the huge amount of time and effort raising a kid is.

KnobJockey · 21/07/2021 16:38

Well done @swiftt! If ever you feel uncomfortable about saying something or doing something, just remind yourself that he's feeling fine about making you uncomfortable, leaving you to deal with being short of money, letting you run around after him, even going in a different room in YOUR HOUSE to sulk! You wouldn't need to be cheeky if he wasn't doing it first.

So money in hand, what's next? How would you like his visits to your daughter to be like? Do you want to be in the room and responsible for her care, or do you want him to genuinely be able to do everything you do? Because if you do (and I definitely suggest you should!) then it's time for you to stop being responsible for everything for her and hide to let him get on with it. Don't wait for him to offer to get her ready for bed/bath, simply say- you know where the bathroom is for bathtime, hers is the purple bubble bath, her sleepsuit is in the drawer, I'll be down at x time to feed her once you've done. Then go lay on your bed with a book. He won't do it til you make it clear he is responsible for it.

WeAllHaveWings · 21/07/2021 16:07

You've done the right thing don't let him make you doubt yourself.

MrsTerryPratchett · 21/07/2021 15:20

He's squirming now so don't let him off the hook or he'll just try every time. If you have boundaries at the beginning, you need them less as time goes on.

He's going to keep trying tactics for a little while though.

DameFanny · 21/07/2021 14:10

Well done @swiftt. Make sure CMS know when he gets that pay rise too Wink

QueenBee52 · 21/07/2021 12:50

@Uramaki

Just stick with the CMS he's had long enough

he most certainly has 🌸

Uramaki · 21/07/2021 08:06

Just stick with the CMS he's had long enough

GrandmasCat · 21/07/2021 07:41

Honestly, it is a bit silly to keep engaging on maintenance issues directly with him when you have already the CMS doing it for you. For the sake of your DD and the future relationship with her dad, stop discussing maintenance with him directly, you are only creating more animosity and lowering your chances to get what it should if he shows CMS that you are happy to get less, and FGS do not return the money, he has not paid anything so far!

CMS is on the case, from now on, he pays what he should and you report him to them if he doesn’t. Period.

cptartapp · 21/07/2021 07:34

Pay him back nothing. He'll be underpaying the true cost for years even using the calculator.
What has he contributed or bought so far?

OurChristmasMiracle · 21/07/2021 07:32

Keep the CMS claim open. He’s shown that he will use emotions to manipulate you. Him using phrases such as “if your that desperate” making it sound as if yhe isn’t can’t provide for your child when you can is just a way of getting you to say that you don’t need his money.

I highly doubt his calculation will be anywhere near accurate either.

I would also get a contact arrangement set up and agreed to

swiftt · 21/07/2021 07:27

I haven’t cancelled the claim. I told him that’s fine for this month and that I’m sure the amount will end up being the same anyway since he used their calculator, but if for some reason he’s worked it out to be more than they have then I will, of course, pay him back the extra. I’m 99% sure they’ll actually calculate it to be more than the figure he’s said.

Thanks again everyone. I think I’d definitely have just backed down and dropped the claim and been a doormat without the support here. It’s these comments that I really need to hear, and I remind myself every time I’m feeling unsure that this isn’t for me and I need to do the right thing by my daughter.

I really think he’s annoyed because he’s lost a sense of control that he had. Everything up until this point has been on his terms. I let so many things slide for the sake of keeping the peace but I realise now how silly that is.

OP posts:
MeanMrMustardSeed · 21/07/2021 07:15

Don't cancel the CMS for two reasons.
One because when you’re dealing with someone like this, it’s good to go official. Two, because you’ve shown him that you’re not a pushover and when you say you are going to do something, you’ve proved you’ll do it. He obviously did not think that you would contact CMS the next morning and was shocked you had. Good on you! Don’t roll over now and undo the great work you’ve done. You’ve shown you’ll try and talk to him about stuff a number of times, but then take it into your own hands when nothing it done. This is a great lesson for him and you are being a great mum to you DD.

cptartapp · 21/07/2021 07:03

It won't be in the best interests of your DD for you to cancel the CMS claim. Keep that thought in your head. He's trying to pay as little as possible. He'll lie to you. You'll only ever have his word for what he's earning. How can you not see this?
Has he given you any money at all yet? Bought nappies? Formula? Anything?
Do not cancel.

bigbaggyeyes · 21/07/2021 06:58

Don't cancel the cms claim, going via the cms protects everyone. They will calculate the amount and then email you both. You can choose to take a different amount if that's what you both agree. However if for some reason he stops paying, if you have an open account with cms you can go via them to recover the amount and they will deal with him. It will also get reviewed with you both annually which means if he gets a pay rise or his pay drops then this is reflected in the new amount.

I strongly suspect he wants you to close the cms account as he's offering you less than he should.

LittleOwl153 · 20/07/2021 13:03

Whilst you are on a roll with sorting arrangements you could tackle the visitation.

This site - although American I think - gives some interesting info on age appropriate visits...
www.mediate.com/divorce/pg1034.cfm

A suggestion:

"Whilst we are on the subject of arrangements, now dd is getting bigger and restrictions are lifting how about the following for the basis of visits?
Mon/Wed/Friday 6-7.30. Maybe we can build up Wednesday night so that you do bath/bed?
And Sunday 10-11.30. We'll need to review when I go back to work of course".

Then I'd have dinner FOR ONE in the oven /on the side had her over to him and leave him to it on those evenings. The Sunday gives you the option of a shower (if that's safe whilst he's in the house) or whatever you need to recharge and also the option to send him.out for a pram walk/extend time so he can do something with her as she gets older. I'd probably look at the court order to give you resident/primary carer status before I'd let him take her off out though!

You are doing so well! And the vipers here will support you all the way!

QueenBee52 · 20/07/2021 12:48

Do NOT cancel that CMS Claim...

everything he is now doing, is to stop this claim.

Don't be fooled into trusting him, because up until now has literally fobbed you off with excuses.

Tell him that's great, but you respectfully prefer things were done officially.

He's not going to like losing control. 🌸

LittleOwl153 · 20/07/2021 12:30

I would not cancel the CMS calculation. Let them keep tabs on him. Saves you a lot of hassle.

I'd just say to him that it's fine in the interim but that you will keep the CMS claim live as it will make things easier going forward. Once the CMS have made their calculation you will get the notice as well as him so you will be able to see from there what his reaction is!

If you have any idea of his salary - he should be handing over 12% gross - assuming he doesn't have any other kids tucked away...

TotorosCatBus · 20/07/2021 12:12

I bet he knows that have problems being assertive with him hence him trying to get you to cancel the claim. I suspect that if you cancel the claim then there will be months when he tries to stiff you because it's Christmas or whatever. With CMS you don't have the embarrassment of having to ask where his maintenance payment is so I agree it's the best plan for you. CMS will have his annual income so will be the ones who can judge if the payment is fair. He can top it up if he wants but I'd want to know if he was trying to get me to accept less than the minimum.

Newestname001 · 20/07/2021 11:47

Sounds like he was more in love with the idea of having a baby and being "dad" than the actual impact of being a proper father to a real child who he would need to be financially as well as emotionally responsible for.

Time for him to grow up and accept the fact of his decision to be a father to a child he helped create. 🌹