Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand the appeal of dogs as pets?

371 replies

Gardentiger · 06/07/2021 13:31

I just don't get it and would love to understand! As much as I like certain dogs I meet and think they are cute, the list of downsides is massive

  • they smell and make your house and car and clothes smell bad
-they can't be left alone for a length of a working day -behavioural problems and agression -if you get a barky one it can ruin your relationship with neighbours -the amount of time you have to spend training them -some seem to need constant supervision -chewing things and generally wrecking the housr -having to pick up warm freshly baked turds

I walked a friend of mines dog the other day and it was awful! He pulled on the lead the entire way, and kept trying to pee on people's doorsteps / flowerpots.

So what is the appeal!? I say this as an animal lover who has had pet rabbits, cats and hamsters in the past.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Wouldyoudothesame · 06/07/2021 16:52

I feel exactly the same, although I read the list back and thought Gosh that does also sound a lot like having children 😂 I guess I'm more of a children person than a dog person. Also always had a preference for cats although now I've got three young kids even a cat seems like extra hassle right now! I don't mind dogs but that's pretty much the extent of my affection towards them. YANBU x

GrouchyKiwi · 06/07/2021 16:50

My girl has just climbed up on the sofa beside me for a cuddle (she doesn't do this often). She burped in my face, and is drooling all over my top (she's a Newfie), but every time I stop scritching her ears she demands more by bashing a paw on my arm.

It's adorable. Grin

queenMab99 · 06/07/2021 16:50

I suppose it's a bit like why some women are attracted to men who are bastards, I can't understand that. I love my dog, he never makes me cry. (except sometimes in frustration)

vodkaredbullgirl · 06/07/2021 16:47

1 way about having a dog in the house, no visitors to your house Smile

Blossomtoes · 06/07/2021 16:43

[quote PattyPan]@LifeinPieces21 I know it must be subjective but I just genuinely cannot understand how anyone can look at a Jack Russell and find it cute Confused their faces creep me out![/quote]
Not cute? Really?

To not understand the appeal of dogs as pets?
rantymcrantface66 · 06/07/2021 16:42

I just don't get it and would love to understand! As much as I like certain dogs I meet and think they are cute, the list of downsides is massive

  • they smell and make your house and car and clothes smell bad
-they can't be left alone for a length of a working day -behavioural problems and agression -if you get a barky one it can ruin your relationship with neighbours -the amount of time you have to spend training them -some seem to need constant supervision -chewing things and generally wrecking the housr -having to pick up warm freshly baked turds

-Mine doesn't smell. She might when she's older but not at the moment. My car smells bad anyway from kicking out horses then getting in it .
-I have someone to look after her when i work

  • she doesn't have behavioural problems or aggression
-she doesn't bark in the house. And she's a breed renowned for being barky -she was simple to train -she doesn't need constant supervision -she doesn't chew and has never chewed anything she wasn't supposed to
  • I've been around horses all my life, I don't care about picking up turds
  • she only pulls her lead if she sees a cat or squirrel
Most of the problems you list are only an issue if you don't give a dog enough time, enrichment and attention, especially when young. I got my dog at a time when I had a chance to do that so she's grown in to a well behaved, well balanced dog who is great company, especially when dc are at their dads so it's just me. She's a lot less effort than dc or a male partner 😆
GordonsAliveAndEatsPies · 06/07/2021 16:40

With you 100%. Don’t get the appeal at all

hookiewookie29 · 06/07/2021 16:39

Bought a Staffy puppy in January. He doesn't smell, rarely barks, is well trained and hardly sheds any fur. Agree with the poo though!
However, he has done wonders for my daughter's mental health and that outweighs everything else!
And most dogs are nicer than people!

PattyPan · 06/07/2021 16:38

@LifeinPieces21 Alsatians are striking I suppose but they have kind of harsh faces imo

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 06/07/2021 16:36

@Needapoodle

When i eventually get a dog i can't wait to do training with it. Agility, obedience, flyball, tricks whatever my dog likes to do we can do that. Long walks in the countryside are bloody boring without a dog. I love walking a dog to see the joy they get out of something simple. Much like young children, they're fascinated with everything. I find dog behaviour really interesting and reading about different training techniques. I love grooming dogs, i find it very therapeutic. I am allergic though, hence my username I'll be getting a poodle. Dogs can sense good and bad people. So yeah all that stuff will outweigh having to pick up shit and having a smelly house.

And who the hell washes their hands every time they touch a dog Confused

Me! Who wants sticky dog hands?
MoiraRose4 · 06/07/2021 16:35

My dog is never not pleased to see me. You get devotion and unconditional love. He makes me laugh on a daily basis. I adore him.

He’s also a twat, I call him every name under the sun every day, he stinks, my boot is covered in dog hair, he hates other people so I can’t leave him with anyone.

So if you’re not a dog person, the good maybe doesn’t outweigh the bad. Because you’re right, there is potentially a lot of bad. But for me, it’s 100% worth it.

CharlieWorkCharlieSad · 06/07/2021 16:34

@User1357

I feel the same. I once looked after my friends dog for a week and the smell was just horrific. I don’t think dog owners notice it as much because they are used to it.

I gave the dog a bath 3x that week and it still smelled like ‘dog smell’.

@User1357

Probably because its a dog 😂

LifeinPieces21 · 06/07/2021 16:34

[quote PattyPan]@LifeinPieces21 I know it must be subjective but I just genuinely cannot understand how anyone can look at a Jack Russell and find it cute Confused their faces creep me out![/quote]
I haven't got any of those mentioned but I do think Alsatians are gorgeous.

One of mine are laid on the sofa snoring and obviously dreaming. She is so cute and part of the family.

I do understand why some people don't want them though.

Needapoodle · 06/07/2021 16:33

You don't see the attraction of living with a creature which absolutely adores you unconditionally? That wants to be near you, to touch you, to comfort you when you sad, to jump for joy with you when you're happy, to fight for you if you're attacked? To know that the genuine highlight of their day, every day, is the moment you walk in the door? I don't have a dog but think it's pretty easy to see what the attraction is.

You just described my childhood dog perfectly. She was a beautiful soul.

fredstick · 06/07/2021 16:31

As a fairly new, first time dog owner I completely understand why you would feel this way, for my life would be a little easier for all the reasons you say. That said ..there is something terribly life affirming, humbling, connective to owning a dog. Picking up poo felt like a big deal at first, one I wretched at but now I'm used to it and sometimes laugh to myself how grounding it actually is - I think everyone needs to shovel shit to realise how human and infallible we all are.

Needapoodle · 06/07/2021 16:30

When i eventually get a dog i can't wait to do training with it. Agility, obedience, flyball, tricks whatever my dog likes to do we can do that. Long walks in the countryside are bloody boring without a dog. I love walking a dog to see the joy they get out of something simple. Much like young children, they're fascinated with everything. I find dog behaviour really interesting and reading about different training techniques. I love grooming dogs, i find it very therapeutic. I am allergic though, hence my username I'll be getting a poodle. Dogs can sense good and bad people. So yeah all that stuff will outweigh having to pick up shit and having a smelly house.

And who the hell washes their hands every time they touch a dog Confused

Kottbullar · 06/07/2021 16:25

@BarkingUpTheWrongRoseBush

i feel similarly about children...
I opened this thread wondering how long it would take for this comment to be posted and boom! it was first reply GrinGrinGrin I
PattyPan · 06/07/2021 16:25

@LifeinPieces21 I know it must be subjective but I just genuinely cannot understand how anyone can look at a Jack Russell and find it cute Confused their faces creep me out!

LifeinPieces21 · 06/07/2021 16:23

@PattyPan

Yanbu not to mention issues going on holiday. And loads of dogs aren’t even cute to make it worthwhile! Like Jack Russells, Bichon frise, pugs/any with a shrivelled face, chihuahuas, Alsatians, westies, terriers, greyhounds etc all not even cute Confused
You are going to annoy lots of people with that comment.
Gardentiger · 06/07/2021 16:22

Also some of the cat hate on this thread has been ridiculous, when in my opening post I stated some downsides that apply to some dogs. I haven't said that people shouldn't have dogs, or that they are horrible. Piping up that cats are evil or unnaffectionate is uncalled for.

People who aren't dog people seem to be expected to be more tolerant than the other way round.

OP posts:
Zari29 · 06/07/2021 16:19

Op lots of people validly love pets for whatever reason. We had a much loved indoor dog for 18years. I loved the dog, but I clearly remember the amount of work it was. I hated absolutely every bit of the work so much that it has put me off from having a pet. Some people equate them as children, I really don't get that. But each to their own.

Gardentiger · 06/07/2021 16:19

@Mabelene

Why do you need to understand? Just ignore them if you don’t like them. Or are you just stirring the pot?
As I said in a previous post, I don't have the option to ignore them as there are digs around me at work and whenever I walk anywhere.

I just wanted to get perspectives from dog lovers, to try and understand. I didn't expect so many snarky responses

OP posts:
PattyPan · 06/07/2021 16:19

Yanbu not to mention issues going on holiday. And loads of dogs aren’t even cute to make it worthwhile! Like Jack Russells, Bichon frise, pugs/any with a shrivelled face, chihuahuas, Alsatians, westies, terriers, greyhounds etc all not even cute Confused

Gardentiger · 06/07/2021 16:17

[quote Goldenfan]@LibertyMole
^^On here there seem to be people who are constantly persecuted by gangs of marauding dogs every time they leave the house.

exactly. 30 years here of walking dogs and I have never had such incidents as posters describe.[/quote]
Perhaps the fact you have a dog with you makes others off lead dogs less likely to come bounding up to you?

OP posts:
Chimboo · 06/07/2021 16:14

My dogs make me smile every single day. Nothing and no one else has ever done that for me!

Swipe left for the next trending thread