Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand the appeal of dogs as pets?

371 replies

Gardentiger · 06/07/2021 13:31

I just don't get it and would love to understand! As much as I like certain dogs I meet and think they are cute, the list of downsides is massive

  • they smell and make your house and car and clothes smell bad
-they can't be left alone for a length of a working day -behavioural problems and agression -if you get a barky one it can ruin your relationship with neighbours -the amount of time you have to spend training them -some seem to need constant supervision -chewing things and generally wrecking the housr -having to pick up warm freshly baked turds

I walked a friend of mines dog the other day and it was awful! He pulled on the lead the entire way, and kept trying to pee on people's doorsteps / flowerpots.

So what is the appeal!? I say this as an animal lover who has had pet rabbits, cats and hamsters in the past.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
SecretSpAD · 06/07/2021 17:27

Genuinely no 😆. Have you? Why was it sticky?

We chose not to ask him. Asking my dog why he's sticky is like asking my dog what he's eating....something we don't want to knkw the answer to!

I think it was a squished slug that he'd lain on when sunbathing. He's a bit skanky, but I love him.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 06/07/2021 17:25

If you can’t see it, OP, I doubt anyone here will be able to make you understand.

It’s a visceral thing - you either have it or you don’t.

We’ve had cats, and I’ve been fond of them, but it’s never been the same as I’ve felt for our dogs. I can’t understand people who are potty about cats.
Just as well we’re not all the same.

blueangel19 · 06/07/2021 17:24

Dogs are anti depressants without the side effects. Best decision ever and some of the things you mentioned are generalisations. Some dogs are very well behave. Mine is and I did not even trained her much. She is just very well mannered and good natured. I groomed her often so very clean too.

aprilanne · 06/07/2021 17:22

Well yes dogs do smell a bit especially ones who love the muck .but regular baths grooms and a shed load of yankee candles solve that particular problem. Yes they are hairy but special hair collectors help .yes they cost money .flea treatment every month solves the fleas never once had any .yes the vet Bill's can be eye watering .yes a thousand other reasons why it's not a good idea .but and a big but they get you out of house they never judge when you look less than your best .there loyalty is like no other .mines is a hairy nightmare. Always in muck always barking at the cat but I adore him really I do .

frigglerock · 06/07/2021 17:18

Also: Some dogs truly don't smell the way that some people think they all do. I have a keen nose, and some breeds do really stink. I've had a stinky dog before, and I knew she was stinky. My current dogs don't have nearly that level of smell.

As for the suggestion that cats don't smell... I thought it was understood that you could always tell when someone had an indoor cat the moment you walk through the door. Most pets create some degree of odour. It's part of the deal!

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 06/07/2021 17:16

Stinky

Typo

Leonberger · 06/07/2021 17:16
  • Me! Who wants sticky dog hands

I work with hundreds of dogs a day and can’t say Ive touched many sticky ones either Grin

rantymcrantface66 · 06/07/2021 17:14

@SecretSpAD

Why are the dogs you are stroking sticky? I've never touched a sticky dog before

Haven't you? 😂🤣🤣

Genuinely no 😆. Have you? Why was it sticky?
SecretSpAD · 06/07/2021 17:13

Why are the dogs you are stroking sticky? I've never touched a sticky dog before

Haven't you? 😂🤣🤣

frigglerock · 06/07/2021 17:12

I don't see the appeal of a rabbit or a hamster as a pet. To me, they're work (less than a dog, but still work). They can also smell, etc., but my main problem with them is that they seem less companionable than a dog or a cat. They're not as intelligent or soulful, can't do tricks, and don't seem to love their owners in the same way that a dog can.

If you don't love dogs, you won't understand, just as I can't understand why someone bothers with rabbits or hamsters. They can be cute to look at, but to me, their cuteness isn't worth the trouble of keeping them. I just don't love them the way I love dogs.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 06/07/2021 17:10

@rantymcrantface66

*Me! Who wants sticky dog hands?*

Why are the dogs you are stroking sticky? I've never touched a sticky dog before? Confused

All dogs smell. Some more than others granted.
Fanacapan · 06/07/2021 17:08

I have cats and dogs, love them both. People - not so much!

rantymcrantface66 · 06/07/2021 17:05

Bar a few I know and like, I prefer them from a distance where I can't smell them and they can't touch me, sniff me, jump up at me, ruin my clothes, pin me up against the wall and try to hump me because they can smell my period or deafen me. They are not allowed in my lovely home. Even if I liked them more, I wouldn't have one- I don't like them enough to put in the time and effort required, and that would be massively unfair to the dog. Also DP is frightened of them and I'd rather have him. He doesn't smell and he cleans up after himself.

Jeez, I'm not surprised you don't like dogs if this has been your experience. Thankfully it's not the norm and you've just met some poorly trained/controlled dogs

GrumpyMiddleAgedWoman · 06/07/2021 17:04

@HandsSpaceArse, well, maybe not actually dog, but some sort of canine/human Esperanto that we both grasp enough of to make simple conversations possible.
Dog: Can you open this door.
Me: No, you are wet. Go and lie down.

theemmadilemma · 06/07/2021 17:03

@BarkingUpTheWrongRoseBush

i feel similarly about children...
I was going to say, they take far more work. I'll stick with dogs thanks.
BeyondMyWits · 06/07/2021 17:03

I hate the hard graft of having a dog, the smell, the effort, the walking in all weather's, the disturbance when there is a fox outside, or fireworks, or a fly in the room.

But I look up and dd is lain on the sofa with the dog curled in the crook of her arm looking over at her face with utter devotion.

SecretSpAD · 06/07/2021 17:03

And with humans the power balance isn't like it is with dogs. The "unconditional" love is unconditional at all. It's based on you feeding them and treating them well and that's why they love you (sorry

Oh just saw this little gem.

No, that's bollocks.

rantymcrantface66 · 06/07/2021 17:03

Me!
Who wants sticky dog hands?

Why are the dogs you are stroking sticky? I've never touched a sticky dog before? Confused

MrsToothyBitch · 06/07/2021 17:02

Dogs have their uses and it's a good thing that we exploit these.

Bar a few I know and like, I prefer them from a distance where I can't smell them and they can't touch me, sniff me, jump up at me, ruin my clothes, pin me up against the wall and try to hump me because they can smell my period or deafen me. They are not allowed in my lovely home. Even if I liked them more, I wouldn't have one- I don't like them enough to put in the time and effort required, and that would be massively unfair to the dog. Also DP is frightened of them and I'd rather have him. He doesn't smell and he cleans up after himself.

Cats, on the other hand, are very welcome here. They don't smell and I adore them. To be loved by a cat is to be The Chosen One. My parents have a bengal rescue. She is delightful and comes for a cuddle with/guards anyone who is poorly. She puts paws around your hand to ask you to keep petting her and gives kisses. Shes is silk and velvet wrapped purring bliss.

SecretSpAD · 06/07/2021 16:59

But reading these sorts of threads always makes me very thankful that there are dogs in this world. And cats too. And rabbits and hamsters even.
I'm thankful because humans - and I include myself in that - are disgusting, judgemental creatures who have a superiority complex and frankly this planet would be better off without us.

Dogs on the other hand, find joy in the smallest thing.

Kottbullar · 06/07/2021 16:57

Picking up poo felt like a big deal at first, one I wretched at but now I'm used to it and sometimes laugh to myself how grounding it actually is - I think everyone needs to shovel shit to realise how human and infallible we all are.
I regularly have pick up the poo of dogs who's owners can't be arsed to do it and it's nothing but disgusting and infuriating.
I do not laugh or feel grounded.

SecretSpAD · 06/07/2021 16:57

I'm saying it's sad when people don't have that human connection because to me it's powerful and unparalleled.

To you, maybe, but love is always subjective so what you think is a fantastic human connection, someone else might think is cloying and annoying or feel detached and distant.

Some people may not want a lot of human connections but instead value and love their animals. To them, that is a rich and fulfilling life in the same way that your life with your family is.

Other people just may not have a family or friends so animals are where they get their love.

I personally have never experienced unconditional love from a human, with the exception maybe of my dad, but certainly not my mother. Our dislike and indifference towards each other was long lasting.

I love my adopted children, but it's not unconditional and nor is my love for my husband. They feel the same. It's all good as far as I'm concerned because I am one of those people who prefer the love of an animal.

rantymcrantface66 · 06/07/2021 16:56

[quote PattyPan]@LifeinPieces21 I know it must be subjective but I just genuinely cannot understand how anyone can look at a Jack Russell and find it cute Confused their faces creep me out![/quote]
I know beauty is in the eye of the beholder and all but you'd have to have a hard heart not to find this even slightly cute (unless dogs really aren't your thing of course)

To not understand the appeal of dogs as pets?
To not understand the appeal of dogs as pets?
vodkaredbullgirl · 06/07/2021 16:56

I find putting socks on my dogs paws and t-shirt, help with shedding and muddy paws Grin

StrangeToSee · 06/07/2021 16:52

Mine has a heated kennel in the garden, and free range of the garden. He’s a great guard dog but very loving and gentle with us. He’s quite independent and very well trained. Doesn’t bark unless he feels there’s a threat, doesn’t pull on the lead, is a joy to get home to and also gets DH active on his work breaks (wfh) as needs walking. I feel safe in the countryside when I’m with the dog. We can enjoy picnics and family outings without other dogs ruining them (he keeps them away). He goes to a local dog sitter when we need to go away overnight or on holiday.

I don’t understand dogs indoors though. I think it’s unhygienic and makes the house smell even if you vacuum and mop daily. Even non shedding dogs smell, you just stop noticing it. And unless you wash their paws after every walk it’s like wearing shoes indoors! Plus the shedding, damage to furniture, dominance issues that can occur when a dog is kept indoors and treated like a human, allowed on the furniture etc.

Most working dogs are very content in outdoor kennels, with heating, toys, soft bedding. It’s their own space. Many houses are too hot and noisy for dogs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread