Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Under the cover of 'FREEDOM' Day the Police Bill was passed that bans your right to protest

60 replies

flashbac · 05/07/2021 23:40

Without the right to protest we're screwed. 365 MPs voted for it.
If this isn't the path to fascism I don't know what it is.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
echt · 25/07/2021 02:25

Startied?????

echt · 25/07/2021 02:23

@moonbedazzled

Always a good way to make your argument, comparing a democratically elected government that can be thrown out at the next election, to a totalitarian country.
Well, that's how the National Socialists startied in Germany.
FaceyRomford · 25/07/2021 01:42

[quote CalamityJaneDoe]@FaceyRomford

Tell that to the suffragettes, some of whom gave their lives in protest for women’s right to vote.[/quote]
Their protests were illegal at the time and further laws were passed against them while their campaign was going on. Women's suffrage owes nothing to peaceful protest,

flashbac · 06/07/2021 22:53

@Takingthewee

Ah Govt website defends the changes in the law and we should now be all reassured? lol !
You've said it much better than I could!

People forget what happened at the Sarah Everard vigil.

OP posts:
Takingthewee · 06/07/2021 22:19

Ah Govt website defends the changes in the law and we should now be all reassured? lol !

StMarysKettle · 06/07/2021 19:02

@flashbac

The threat of 10 years in jail makes a difference in terms of deterring protest otherwise why impose it as a maximum? Sleepwalking into totalitarianism. And don't bet on getting rid of this lot next election. Not with voter ID coming in and more data surveillance and targeting of voters with bullshit in the same way vote leave was done.
This is quite a short read. From the site I linked earlier.

Will protesters face 10-year sentences for being a nuisance?
The public nuisance offence is not a new offence, but an existing, centuries old, common law offence which currently has a maximum sentence of life imprisonment.

We are introducing the offence in statute, and abolishing the common law offence, in line with the recommendations of the independent Law Commission. In doing so, we are narrowing the scope of the offence and lowering the maximum penalty from unlimited crown court penalties, to 10 years’ imprisonment.

The offence of public nuisance covers behaviours beyond those related to public order. The Law Commission identified the need for this offence as “Human inventiveness being so great, it is desirable to have a general offence for culpable acts that injure the public but do not fall within any of the specialised [existing] offences.”

Any protesters found guilty of public nuisance are likely to face penalties in line with existing sentences for public order offences.

Stricter sentences under this offence are likely to only occur in exceptional circumstances, the Law Commission recommended “as the offence is intended to address serious cases for which other offences are not adequate, if a maximum sentence is set it should be high enough to cover these cases.” Sentencing in individual cases is a matter for the independent judiciary.

invisiblesuit · 06/07/2021 18:33

This is not about preventing violence. It's about making it impossible to demonstrate. Because you never know whether some small noise might disturb someone on a phone call in a nearby office.

Takingthewee · 06/07/2021 16:42

@Weebleweeble

I just read about how the government is slipping through a new oil rig in the North Sea (Cambo?) that is not allowed under international climate change treaties.

Yeah, much better that we ship it thousands of miles in tankers from 'old' wells in Saudi. And we pay through the nose for it and gain no jobs or tax payment.

How about we use less fossil fuels in the first place including those tankers? Even now, homes we build are shabbily insulated, people still allowed to drive around in big gas guzzling SUV's.

No transport plan to get us using our cars less

Weebleweeble · 06/07/2021 16:18

I just read about how the government is slipping through a new oil rig in the North Sea (Cambo?) that is not allowed under international climate change treaties.

Yeah, much better that we ship it thousands of miles in tankers from 'old' wells in Saudi. And we pay through the nose for it and gain no jobs or tax payment.

LemonRoses · 06/07/2021 16:02

You are right - path to fascism.

BraveBraveMouse · 06/07/2021 15:59

All kinds of awful stuff is happening quietly under the cover of Covid. I just read about how the government is slipping through a new oil rig in the North Sea (Cambo?) that is not allowed under international climate change treaties. Have not heard anything in the news.

Takingthewee · 06/07/2021 15:54

They're introducing a maximum sentence. Honestly have you even done a little bit of research into this? Or just read the link from the Labour website and immediately taken it as gospel?

No have Labour got a website?
What message does that sort of sentence send to would be protestors?

I did note that whilst keen to protect statues, the Government weren't so keen to protect women from violence, allocating just 90m to councils for more refuge's (despite tory policies cutting them over the last 10 years) and not the 380m councils were calling for.

flashbac · 06/07/2021 15:52

The threat of 10 years in jail makes a difference in terms of deterring protest otherwise why impose it as a maximum?
Sleepwalking into totalitarianism.
And don't bet on getting rid of this lot next election. Not with voter ID coming in and more data surveillance and targeting of voters with bullshit in the same way vote leave was done.

OP posts:
StMarysKettle · 06/07/2021 15:27

@Takingthewee

Rubbish. Nobody ever changed anything by marching through the streets. Protest marches are one of the most pointless exercises ever dreamt up by the human brain

If that were true, why is the government putting in some very draconian laws to limit/prevent them?

Because this is what this bill will do, the threat of 10 years in jail, is a far higher jail sentence than anything the Chinese have used on HK protestors

They're introducing a maximum sentence. Honestly have you even done a little bit of research into this? Or just read the link from the Labour website and immediately taken it as gospel?
moonbedazzled · 06/07/2021 14:45

Always a good way to make your argument, comparing a democratically elected government that can be thrown out at the next election, to a totalitarian country.

Takingthewee · 06/07/2021 13:56

Rubbish. Nobody ever changed anything by marching through the streets. Protest marches are one of the most pointless exercises ever dreamt up by the human brain

If that were true, why is the government putting in some very draconian laws to limit/prevent them?

Because this is what this bill will do, the threat of 10 years in jail, is a far higher jail sentence than anything the Chinese have used on HK protestors

ClippettyClop · 06/07/2021 13:40

Ensure vehicular entrances to the Parliament Estate remain unobstructed

The rationale for that particular measure is to ensure democracy can continue without interference. Do you object to that, OP? What do you perceive to be the problem there?

Gilead · 06/07/2021 13:34

@ FaceyRomford I think you’ll find the poll tax riots were pretty successful.

flashbac · 06/07/2021 13:31

Some people wouldn't see the onward march of fascism even if it bit them on the arse.

OP posts:
flashbac · 06/07/2021 13:30

[quote StMarysKettle]This site gets more and more like the daily mail every day.

Try reading something other than labour propaganda. These all seem like entirely sensible proposals

www.gov.uk/government/publications/police-crime-sentencing-and-courts-bill-2021-factsheets/police-crime-sentencing-and-courts-bill-2021-protest-powers-factsheet[/quote]
I have already read that actually but without any rose tinted glasses.

This bit particularly stood out:
Ensure vehicular entrances to the Parliament Estate remain unobstructed

Hmm

OP posts:
StMarysKettle · 06/07/2021 13:10

This site gets more and more like the daily mail every day.

Try reading something other than labour propaganda. These all seem like entirely sensible proposals

www.gov.uk/government/publications/police-crime-sentencing-and-courts-bill-2021-factsheets/police-crime-sentencing-and-courts-bill-2021-protest-powers-factsheet

steakandcheeseplease · 06/07/2021 12:58

@ChainJane

It's a big leap from banning protests that harass or intimidate innocent people to assuming we're going down the route of a fascist state.

Why should people have the right to prevent others from going about their daily business in peace? Why should someone have the right to disrupt public transport or block roads?

Most importantly, why should my right to shout about and intimidate people over a certain cause trump their right to not give a fuck?

Peaceful, quiet, not-disruptive protests will still be allowed. This bill is a good thing, because protestors will have to persuade people that their cause is just. Better that than scaring them into agreeing with you.

Well it depends who deems it peaceful.

20 hippies sat on the grass waving flowers about or 4000 people walking down the street in a non aggressive way, holding banners about taxs/cuts/womens rights ect..

Well thats gonna piss some one off isn't it.

Both have a right to be there.

I just can't believe so many people are happy to wave good bye to their rights so easily. People fought hard unpleasant fights to get what we had, now so many people are sat on their arses enjoying those hard won rights they are happy to wave good bye to the very thing that won the - protesting.

flashbac · 06/07/2021 12:35

@VeganVeal

I have been caught up in a so called 'peaceful protest'. I was out shopping with an elderly relative when we encountered this protest. Bottles were being thrown at police, abuse being shouted, we were very scared. I really dont think this type of thing is good at all. I later read some were given a prison sentence. Good and throw away the key
So the police already had powers to prosecute those who got violent so why do they need more powers? They are trying to put people law abiding people off that's why.
OP posts:
VeganVeal · 06/07/2021 11:24

I have been caught up in a so called 'peaceful protest'. I was out shopping with an elderly relative when we encountered this protest. Bottles were being thrown at police, abuse being shouted, we were very scared. I really dont think this type of thing is good at all.
I later read some were given a prison sentence. Good and throw away the key

ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 06/07/2021 11:17

@flashbac

To the two posters above, it must be nice to trust the police and people who have power over you.

There are countless tales of protests turning violent after police have used force.

I personally of course do trust the police but however as highlighted in numerous high profile cases there are indeed bad apples within the police service. I have no reason to distrust the police as I have and always will uphold the law and indeed instil respect and appreciation on the next generation too. We have too much unwarranted hate and aggression for no tangible reason other than perhaps people looking different or having different opinions. We either have law and order or we have jungle cave man dysfunctional lawless anarchy. I prefer the former. I was in fact a bit concerned and indeed agreed with some of the initial issues raised by ecology (XR) and diversity equality (lives matters) protests until they lost me in the two wrongs make a right excuse for a riot. As long as the police is not corrupt nor politicalised and you are not a serial criminal - what’s the issue with respecting the police to keep us safe and lock up trouble makers? Police should only resort to proportional force to defend themselves, innocent bystanders and protect public property not to fight with rioters when attacked by criminals. Rioters should be removed and brought to account using the law and suffer the consequences for their criminality. I speak as someone who previously suffered criminal damage to my property during past London race riots. Surreal scenes as if a movie set bad and still brings back worrying issues witnessing police (including female officers) being too passive and so attacked by mobs.