Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs in Restaurants

916 replies

IDontGetOutMuch · 04/07/2021 20:05

Took my mum out to lunch today. It was a nice enough place-£25 per head.
Have expectations changed with regard to dogs in restaurants? There were four other tables in our section and three had a dog with them.
Two of them barked at least three times during the meal. One jumped up at a waitress carrying puddings to another table, paws on her apron. One jumped up at the table wanting to be fed. One was petted by another waitress who then went straight to a table to take orders without washing hands. One was lying in the way so that I had to ask the owner to move it to allow my mother to get through with her Walker.
We had a dog when I was a child. He never went to a restaurant. What about people with allergies?
Is it okay that they do? Do I need to get over myself? I tried to compare to children. I expect my children to cause no disturbance to others at a restaurant and to stay at the table. We expected this even when they were little and actually rarely went to restaurants anyway.

OP posts:
lazylinguist · 05/07/2021 10:27

It isn't a matter of opinion whether or not a dog is a person but a matter of fact that it is not.

It is a matter of opinion whether a family group can include members who aren't people. People often regard dogs as part of their family because they share a close affectionate bond and a home. That requires no anthropomorphism whatsoever. I don't attribute human characteristics to my dog, except the characteristics that humans and dogs do actually share.

However the rest of us are under no obligation to collude in your delusional anthropomorphism and therefore are under no obligation to treat or to consider your dog as a family member, whether in online discussions or in restaurants.

I'm not sure how you think people are expecting you to 'treat their dogs as a family member' in a pub or restaurant, since you have no control over whether pubs or restaurants allow dogs, and you are not expected to go and welcome them by shaking their paw. Feel free to sit and think furiously to yourself "That dog is not a family member!" though.

TheWagesOfSin · 05/07/2021 10:26

It matters whenever your delusions impinge on other people's lives because you believe your dog is a family member and take it into restaurants and shops accordingly.

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 05/07/2021 10:26

How do people think about bringing other 'family members' - such as cats, goldfish, guinea pigs and rabbits into restaurants?

Missillusioned · 05/07/2021 10:25

Dogs in restaurants is minging. They smell. Dog owners are nose blind to it, but everyone else can smell it.

I remember going on a first date to a local restaurant and there was a dog there. It didn't come to our table, but my date was allergic to dogs and the poor guy spent the evening with streaming eyes and we had to leave early and go to the supermarket for anti histamines. Just being in the same room did this.

It hadn't occurred to either of us that dogs would be present when we booked (this was a couple of years ago before dog friendly places were as popular).

There are lots of people who have dog allergies, are they to be shut out of most venues just to accommodate dogs?

And yes I know guide dogs exist, but they are relatively few in number.

TheFoundations · 05/07/2021 10:22

@TheWagesOfSin

OK then. We disagree. It doesn't matter.

TheWagesOfSin · 05/07/2021 10:18

And people are saying they take their dogs into restaurants and shops because they consider their dogs to be family members.

TheWagesOfSin · 05/07/2021 10:17

Being a family member is a human characteristic.

TheFoundations · 05/07/2021 10:06

[quote TheWagesOfSin]@TheFoundations agree that it's absolutely up to you or any other dog owner if you wish to delude yourself. However the rest of us are under no obligation to collude in your delusional anthropomorphism and therefore are under no obligation to treat or to consider your dog as a family member, whether in online discussions or in restaurants.[/quote]
As I said, keep going. You can think I'm delusional. It doesn't matter. Whether you or anybody else thinks that dogs are members of families isn't even a salient point on this thread, let alone in a pub or a restaurant.

Anthropomorphism is 'the attribution of human characteristics or behaviour to a god, animal, or object'. Nobody in this discussion is talking about whether dogs have human characteristics, so that's irrelevant to the discussion too.

TheFoundations · 05/07/2021 09:57

@MachiaNelly

What's your point with this 'who would you choose if you couldn't keep both your dog and your child'?

People's dogs are very important to them. It's very unlikely that they'd ever have to make the choice you're suggesting, and, if they did, most people would pass their dog to someone who would take good care of it.

What point does that prove?

TheWagesOfSin · 05/07/2021 09:51

@TheFoundations agree that it's absolutely up to you or any other dog owner if you wish to delude yourself. However the rest of us are under no obligation to collude in your delusional anthropomorphism and therefore are under no obligation to treat or to consider your dog as a family member, whether in online discussions or in restaurants.

MachiaNelly · 05/07/2021 09:48

A dog can’t just be discarded like a unused toy when it doesn’t suit @MachiaNelly**

It's not really a matter of it 'not suiting' when it's a health issue for your child. I would think it's incredibly difficult to keep the pet and the child apart, when the child knows the dog is there. It sounds like it could be very wearing after a time. If a mild allergy then the consequences aren't too bad, but sometimes an allergy can cause a really frightening reaction in a child. That's not something I'd like to mess around with. It's not 'not suiting' if the pet is causing a child to be ill.

Figgygal · 05/07/2021 09:45

We have a dog we take him to the local village pub but only in the bar or garden not in the restaurant side. It wouldn’t have ever crossed my mind that a restaurant would be a suitable place for him

rantymcrantface66 · 05/07/2021 09:43

I've never been anywhere be it pub or hotel where there isn't dog free areas. Not saying there aren't some that exist but most places have a small selection of dog rooms I one area and the rest dog free and frequently dogs are allowed in the garden and more casual bar area so there is somewhere to go when it rains but not in the starter dining area. There are also plenty completely dog free hotels and restaurants. Something for everyone - badly behaved and inconsiderate people exist everywhere sadly and can spoil your experience whether it's by dog or badly behaved child or many other ways. No one is saying that's acceptable.

CounsellorTroi · 05/07/2021 09:38

When ever we’ve taken DB’s lab into a restaurant he has always behaved perfectly, lying under the table chilling and minding his own business.

ForeverAintEnough3 · 05/07/2021 09:27

@MachiaNelly

One child is frighten after being bitten and my other is allergic

Mine too. It makes me wonder, people who claim dogs are part of the family if their child developed a sudden and intense allergy to said dog, which one would have to go? Hard to choose between beloved family members then. Or is it?

My friends are in this situation and there is no choice. The dog is part of the family. They pay more now for a dog daycare so the dog has fun during the day and in the evening once their child has gone to bed they let the dog into the sitting room for the night with them. Clean up thoroughly before they go to bed so all is fine for their little boy the next day. A dog can’t just be discarded like a unused toy when it doesn’t suit @MachiaNelly

I have a dog, we’ve brought him to outdoor cafes and pubs and he’s sat under the picnic table quietly. He would never pee or poo in an area like that and he doesn’t shed. Personally I wouldn’t bring him to a dog friendly hotel as I don’t like the idea of dogs who may not be as well trained/toilet trained or who shed being around me when eating food so I totally understand why others here don’t like this. But I am lucky I have family nearby who will take him when I want to go to a hotel. I’d say lots of dog owners have no choice to but seek out dog friendly places so there is a demand there for that kind of hotel & service. So people really need to check in advance if they really wouldn’t want to go somewhere with dogs allowed.

MachiaNelly · 05/07/2021 09:19

fail to see the difference between the two

The difference to most people who don't like dogs, is that an assistance dog is invariably highly trained and you can put a high level of trust in its good behaviour. Also, assistance dogs are few and far between, whereas in a dog friendly establishment you can get several at a time. If you don't like dogs, that's obviously an uncomfortable situation.

TheFoundations · 05/07/2021 09:17

@TheWagesOfSin

Family members are people.

It isn't a matter of opinion whether or not a dog is a person but a matter of fact that it is not.

Nobody is saying that dogs are human. You don't get to define how other people define their own family. If you think you have that right, your ego is a bit too big. It isn't up to you to tell me whether I feel that my dog is a member of my family. You can keep trying to if you want to?

@Moonwatcher1234

I think it's a shame that some dog owners are irresponsible. Bothersome dogs bother me too. It happened yesterday in a pub beer garden, where my dog lay quietly under the table, and two other families came in and let their dogs howl and squeal at each other. It gives us all a bad name.

lazylinguist · 05/07/2021 09:12

Owners should leave their animals at home.

Owners should obey the law and the rules of the establishments they frequent. If the owners of the pub or restaurant welcome dogs, it is not up to other customers to say that people should leave their dogs at home. It is your choice whether you go to those establishments or not.

Essentially, within the law, businesses will decide whether it makes financial and PR sense for them to allow dogs on their premises or not. It's a question of market forces. If it does make sense, then individual people being unhappy about it is going to make no difference.

I'm a responsible dog owner. I am aware that some people don't like dogs and I sympathise. I keep my dog under good control, whether out and about or in pubs etc. I only take him to pubs when it is inconvenient not to, and I will sit at a table outside unless it's cold or rainy. People should complain to the landlord if a customer is not controlling their dog appropriately on the premises.

Moonwatcher1234 · 05/07/2021 09:09

[quote TheFoundations]@Moonwatcher1234

You keep saying people can leave and go elsewhere if they don’t like it but, actually, why should they have to

Because lots of human have dogs, like dogs, enjoy dogs, accept dogs. Not liking dogs doesn't give anybody the right to say what anybody else can do with their own dog.

I could say that I don't like trousers, and 'Why should I have to sit in a pub where people insist on having trousers on?', but trousers are popular and the world isn't built to cater for my preferences. I just have to deal with that, and take myself to places that don't rub up against my preferences.

I'm not sure which bit of what I said you think is wrong? Are you saying that children should be allowed to disturb other tables and dogs shouldn't? I think we are in agreement that dogs need to be kept firmly under control, and that if they're not, then the owner is in the wrong, and the establishment needs to sort the situation out. It's a bit crap that your park cafe is allowing out of control dogs to essentially 'bully' families out of the park cafe. Did you speak to them about it? What did they say?[/quote]
Well we’re never going to agree. I think children take precedence and that, for this reason, dogs shouldn’t be allowed into restaurants full stop. I did speak to the cafe but as they are located in a park with lots of regular dog walkers they were wary of upsetting them although they agreed some were very unpleasant to be around. Anyway, hopefully more of these owners will take your approach which seems to be considered and respectful of those around but sadly I won’t hold my breath. Lockdown has led to an exponential increase in people with dogs who don’t seem to know what they are doing.

TheWagesOfSin · 05/07/2021 09:09

Family members are people.

It isn't a matter of opinion whether or not a dog is a person but a matter of fact that it is not.

TheFoundations · 05/07/2021 09:02

@TheWagesOfSin

It's nothing to do with being precious or entitled but all to do with treating our dog as a full member of the family.

So, "deranged", then?

It's a commonly held view, that the dog is a member of the family.

I could say that people are deranged for liking the cinema. But it'd just make me look a bit daft, because so many people do it, I'd clearly be wrong.

TheGenealogist · 05/07/2021 08:59

I would expect/not be surprised to find dogs in a pub, or with people sitting at outside tables in a restaurant.

I would not be impressed to find animals in other parts of a restaurant. I don't like dogs. Many people are allergic to dogs. Owners should leave their animals at home.

TheWagesOfSin · 05/07/2021 08:55

It's nothing to do with being precious or entitled but all to do with treating our dog as a full member of the family.

So, "deranged", then?

vivainsomnia · 05/07/2021 08:51

some dog owners are so precious/entitled about their digs that they clearly think they should be taken everywhere
It's nothing to do with being precious or entitled but all to do with treating our dog as a full member of the family. I expect my dog to be perfectly well behaved though as I did with my kids.

As a whole, I find dogs much better behaved than kids in restaurants.

vivainsomnia · 05/07/2021 08:49

New dog we got two years ago, we were amazed when we looked, post covid at places that accepted dogs and found that the majority accepted them.

The reality is that dogs have become very much like kids to many owners. Ours is. Disturbance is then in par with kids disturbance. Neither should negatively impact on others experience, but sadly we know that the reality is very different and too many parents and owners see it as their right for others to tolerate their kids/dogs. Nothing that can be done but plan as best as possible to go places that is least likely to attract one or the other.