Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs in Restaurants

916 replies

IDontGetOutMuch · 04/07/2021 20:05

Took my mum out to lunch today. It was a nice enough place-£25 per head.
Have expectations changed with regard to dogs in restaurants? There were four other tables in our section and three had a dog with them.
Two of them barked at least three times during the meal. One jumped up at a waitress carrying puddings to another table, paws on her apron. One jumped up at the table wanting to be fed. One was petted by another waitress who then went straight to a table to take orders without washing hands. One was lying in the way so that I had to ask the owner to move it to allow my mother to get through with her Walker.
We had a dog when I was a child. He never went to a restaurant. What about people with allergies?
Is it okay that they do? Do I need to get over myself? I tried to compare to children. I expect my children to cause no disturbance to others at a restaurant and to stay at the table. We expected this even when they were little and actually rarely went to restaurants anyway.

OP posts:
LST · 05/07/2021 11:26

@FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop

How do people think about bringing other 'family members' - such as cats, goldfish, guinea pigs and rabbits into restaurants?
My cats and guinea pigs would get so stressed in a restaurant environment. so why would I put them through it?
PattyPan · 05/07/2021 11:25

If I went to a restaurant and saw there were dogs other than guide dogs inside I’d walk straight back out again. Pub gardens/tables outside cafes fine. But not indoors.

KimmyAndMe · 05/07/2021 11:24

Lots of dogs get plenty out of lying peacefully beside their humans rather than being left alone. Unless you have an air conditioning system that works separately from the engine, which most people don't, then putting in a van isn't really an option unless you can guarantee the sun won't come out or you'll come back to a dog with heat stroke or worse

Yes the van has air conditioning that works when the engine is off thanks.

ForeverAintEnough3 · 05/07/2021 11:24

@TheWagesOfSin

Not just guinea pigs *@FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop*. I consider my Kawasaki motorcycle to be a family member. It's just a matter of opinion after all. If I take it to restaurants it sits next to the table not bothering anyone so where's the harm? Likewise my yukka plant, which gets lonely if left in the house all day.
If a restaurant is happy for you to bring your motorbike then bring it! Are you seriously comparing live sentient animals to plants though? Don’t tell me you’re one of those nutters who thinks carrots feel pain when pulled from the ground so you can’t eat them! 🙈 otherwise that’s comparison makes no sense.
LST · 05/07/2021 11:21

My dog comes to the pub and places we eat if allowed. He is well behaved though and I wouldn't take him if he wasn't. If you don't like dogs just avoid places that allow them. But I must admit it must be getting a lot harder to find somewhere that doesn't allow dogs. Most places apart from Whetherspoons allow them in my town.

ForeverAintEnough3 · 05/07/2021 11:20

@MachiaNelly

A dog can’t just be discarded like a unused toy when it doesn’t suit @MachiaNelly**

It's not really a matter of it 'not suiting' when it's a health issue for your child. I would think it's incredibly difficult to keep the pet and the child apart, when the child knows the dog is there. It sounds like it could be very wearing after a time. If a mild allergy then the consequences aren't too bad, but sometimes an allergy can cause a really frightening reaction in a child. That's not something I'd like to mess around with. It's not 'not suiting' if the pet is causing a child to be ill.

It’s definitely a lot of hard work but like I said most decent people don’t just discard a dog. They work hard at it, pay more for care and clean thoroughly. Prior to finding out it was a dog allergy the child was ending up in hospital constantly with lung issues. Since they found out and new routine all is fine.

Anyway I was responding to your presumption that dogs wouldn’t be considered family members if another family member ended up having an allergy. You are incorrect. In alot of households dogs are part of the family and the family adjusts to any issues.

OrangeBlossomMacaron · 05/07/2021 11:19

Where is this restaurant? It sounds like a right bit of me.. I’m lucky enough to live in a very dog friendly area, there are dogs EVERYWHERE!! They are never ever as annoying as other people’s badly behaved kids.

Like children, there are well behaved dogs and not so well behaved, you just have to suck it up, just like I have to put up with feral, screaming kids ruining my dinner when I go out 🤷🏻‍♀️

TheFoundations · 05/07/2021 11:16

@Missillusioned

You can't choose to not partake if the dog is in the room

You leave the room. If someone with strong perfume comes into the room when I'm eating out, I move tables so that I don't get a migraine. If there's nowhere else to sit, I'm a bit screwed and might simply have to leave altogether. It's a pain in the arse, but I don't expect others to cater to my sensitivity by not wearing perfume, because it's me that's sensitive to it, and not them breaking the rules.

Most people are OK with dogs in pubs and restaurants - it's clear from regular and ongoing interactions that dog owners have. If the majority were against it, dog owners would be uncomfortable taking their dogs in, and rules would be tightening rather than loosening. It's crap having an allergy but it's not the world's job to make sure that you or I never encounter an allergen. It's our job to manage our allergies like responsible adults.

lazylinguist · 05/07/2021 11:14

When it comes to guide or hearing dogs, that person's need for them trumps my wish not to have dogs around me. That does not apply to the people who won't leave their (badly trained) dogs at home because they think the rest of the world should accommodate their pet.

No, what trumps your wish is the decision of the establishment to welcome dogs.

Hoppinggreen · 05/07/2021 11:11

It’s like kids, well behaved ones great, ones with owners/parents who don’t correct bad behaviour are the issue

lazylinguist · 05/07/2021 11:09

It is a matter of opinion whether a family group can include members who aren't people.

It really, really isn't.

Saying 'really' twice doesn't make it true. A dog isn't genetically part of its human family, nor is it part of the family by marriage. But I'm not sure there's a law on whom you are allowed to consider part of your family. If there is, please point me to it.

You're absolutely right that you cannot be forced to consider my dog a part of my family. If I had a non-related human living with me and my husband and children for years I might consider them part of the family group too. And again, you would be under no obligation to agree.

Whom you are related to by birth, marriage or adoption is a matter of fact. Whom you consider part of your family unit is a matter of personal view.

TheFoundations · 05/07/2021 11:09

The default position should be 'no dogs'

Why? Your default position is without a dog. My default position is with a dog. Nobody is right or wrong. Nobody gets to make the rules. So we all have to be responsible for ourselves. If you don't like dogs, check there won't be any, or ask to be seated away from them.

I don't like butter, so I ask every time I order food that it be omitted. I don't expect kitchens not to use butter, and for those that do or don't to put a sign up about it.

Missillusioned · 05/07/2021 11:08

@TheFoundations a dog allergy is not the same as being vegetarian or not drinking alcohol. You can't choose to not partake if the dog is in the room. And it's a fairly widespread common allergy. As for flower allergies, this is a nightmare for a lot of people in hayfever season and being indoors is usually better than outdoors.

thing47 · 05/07/2021 11:02

When it comes to guide or hearing dogs, that person's need for them trumps my wish not to have dogs around me. That does not apply to the people who won't leave their (badly trained) dogs at home because they think the rest of the world should accommodate their pet.

Finally, someone has summarised this succinctly and correctly, thank you igelkott2021. Exactly this.

I don't have any objection to dog-friendly restaurants/bars etc as long as it is made clear that they welcome dogs. The default position should be 'no dogs' and any divergence from that should be obvious on the website, Facebook page, front door or whatever so those of us who don't wish to eat our food around dogs (whether we are dog owners ourselves or not), can be certain we won't have to.

igelkott2021 · 05/07/2021 10:53

@MachiaNelly

fail to see the difference between the two

The difference to most people who don't like dogs, is that an assistance dog is invariably highly trained and you can put a high level of trust in its good behaviour. Also, assistance dogs are few and far between, whereas in a dog friendly establishment you can get several at a time. If you don't like dogs, that's obviously an uncomfortable situation.

Exactly. This came up on the thread about the yellow lead/harness a few weeks ago. The OP said that she would use a yellow lead/harness on her dog to indicate that it was highly strung and needed extra care taken around it, but some posters made the point that from a distance, a yellow jacket would look like the dog was an assistance dog so actually the impression given would be the opposite of what she intended - ie a calm, well trained, well behaved dog that won't bother other people.

Anyway, when it comes to guide or hearing dogs, that person's need for them trumps my wish not to have dogs around me. That does not apply to the people who won't leave their (badly trained) dogs at home because they think the rest of the world should accommodate their pet.

Westfacing · 05/07/2021 10:53

This issue came up the other day when I had lunch with my son in a local 'gastro' pub. It's not cheap, full menu at restaurant prices, and since there's no standing at the bar and it's waiter service, it's basically a restaurant.

I was surprised to see at least three dogs inside - well behaved and silent sitting under their tables. You wouldn't normally see dogs in a restaurant pre-Covid, pubs yes but not in the eating area indoors.

I was a bit irritated by the situation but would have been very annoyed had the dogs been barking and jumping up!

This place is very busy and always booked so it's not as though they had to take all comers.

Wanttocry · 05/07/2021 10:51

Urgh even in a dog friendly restaurant they should be under control enough to not be jumping up at a waitress carrying food surely??

Spidey66 · 05/07/2021 10:49

We took our dog to the pub yesterday, where she was fussed over by staff and customers, and got to play with some kids in the garden. Great fun was had by all.

TheFoundations · 05/07/2021 10:44

@TheWagesOfSin

It is a matter of opinion whether a family group can include members who aren't people.

It really, really isn't.

Where are the rules you're referring to here? It's fascinating me that you're so insistent on this 'fact'. How is it a fact? Why is it not an opinion?
Wizzbangfizz · 05/07/2021 10:43

Would expect to see dogs in pubs/cafes but never experienced one in a restaurant!

TheFoundations · 05/07/2021 10:42

@TheWagesOfSin

Not just guinea pigs *@FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop*. I consider my Kawasaki motorcycle to be a family member. It's just a matter of opinion after all. If I take it to restaurants it sits next to the table not bothering anyone so where's the harm? Likewise my yukka plant, which gets lonely if left in the house all day.
It's your call. Why wouldn't it be?
TheFoundations · 05/07/2021 10:40

@Missillusioned

Lots of people get migraines when there is a strong perfume smell. Should their sensitivities be catered for? Should we be banning perfume? And fresh flowers, come to think of it? Also, lots of people have issues with alcohol, so we should probably ban that in pubs and restaurants. Shouldn't we? And there's lots of vegetarians, so maybe also meat should never be served.

How far do you want to go with catering for individual sensitivities? If you make it clear to a restaurant that you have a raging dog allergy, they'll either seat you far from any dogs, or say they can't do anything about it, in which case you'll take your business elsewhere. Businesses will cater to the majority, because that's how they get more customers. The majority of people are fine about dogs in pubs and restaurants; I've had my dog 8 years and generally people smile when they see her, and if they look uncomfortable, I'll talk to them, and sit elsewhere if my dog's presence is causing them a problem.

There needs to be respect, both ways. I don't let my dog in people's space unless they actively welcome her. I don't expect people to try to control what I'm doing in my space.

TheWagesOfSin · 05/07/2021 10:33

Not just guinea pigs @FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop. I consider my Kawasaki motorcycle to be a family member. It's just a matter of opinion after all. If I take it to restaurants it sits next to the table not bothering anyone so where's the harm? Likewise my yukka plant, which gets lonely if left in the house all day.

Rosebel · 05/07/2021 10:31

I wouldn't be happy about eating in a restaurant with dogs. If they are quiet and well behaved it wouldn't be so bad. But if they are barking and jumping up then they shouldn't be there.
I would have asked the manager to have a word with the owners of the barking dogs.

TheWagesOfSin · 05/07/2021 10:30

It is a matter of opinion whether a family group can include members who aren't people.

It really, really isn't.