Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want my “stepmother” at my brother’s funeral?

388 replies

EllebellyBeeblebrox · 04/07/2021 18:45

My brother died suddenly two weeks ago, he was only 34 and we are just heartbroken. Postmortem didn’t give a cause of death so we are awaiting results of further investigations, although I strongly suspect it was alcohol abuse that killed him, he had horrendous mental health and a drink problem.
The short version, my parents had a nasty divorce when I was 18, so coming up to 20years ago. Dad was having an affair, with someone he has now remarried to, so now effectively my stepmother although I have as little to do with her as possible, tolerating her so I can see my dad, and my dcs their grandad. My mum has never ever got over their separation and has never been the same since. My dad wants to bring her to my brother’s funeral although my mum has specifically said she does not want her there. At such a horrendous time for everyone anyway, am I being unreasonable in thinking he shouldn’t bring her? He has his sister and mother coming to support him and I will be there with both of them.
Thankyou in advance for any advice or thoughts, honestly I’m fucking broken and miss him so desperately already, wracked with guilt about how I should have done more, and can’t deal with the added family shit Sad

OP posts:
Taliskerskye · 05/07/2021 19:37

It really doesn’t matter wtf is held to be good form or not.
This op is drawn into yet another family saga over her mother not being able to let go and concentrate on the positives that came out of a marriage instead of all the anger and bitterness. When the OP should be grieving

People, of either sex. If your other half is a total cunt, be better than them. Lead a happy life, wish them happiness. Then your children might not end up totally fucking destroyed along with you.

paniniswapx3 · 05/07/2021 19:36

@G00d0mens

Interestingly, voting indicates the OP is NBU at all (72%)

Ideally, the stepmum should have the decency to stay away. OPs brother tolerated her at best and resented having to see her with his father.

The father’s need for his “rock” does not trump the mother’s needs to say goodbye to her son without the additional historic pain of their betrayal flung at her. She does not have to suck it up - even after 20 years if she does not wish to. The reality is both parents will have additional family members they can rely upon for support on the day - no need for controversy or extra painful memories.

Another factor might be to consider the wishes of the parent who gave the most care and love to OP and her brother following the nuclear bomb that the father dropped on their family life and in general after that…that parent should get to decide who does and who does not attend.

We don’t always have to agree with what the men want.

This is very well said - completely agree.
mbosnz · 05/07/2021 19:32

I believe it's commonly held to be good form to actually formally leave one relationship before - no I won't say it - before commencing another. Anything else can lead to a certain degree of confusion, resentment, ill feeling, and loss of closure on those who were blindsided by the one leaving - particularly the children.

MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously · 05/07/2021 19:29

Leaving is fine. Lying and cheating isn't.
Hth Jennie

JennieLee · 05/07/2021 19:26

I really don't get why, when women are unhappy in a marriage, they are told to Leave The Bastard.

But if men are unhappy and go,, then they are Bastards For Leaving.

Could someone explain?

Thanks

Jennie

mbosnz · 05/07/2021 19:19

Well, the son, poor boy, no longer has lingering issues. My sincere condolences to you, OP, and your Mother, on your loss.

Taliskerskye · 05/07/2021 19:19

Op I’ve read your posts. Not everyone’s responses.

I have to say, as much as it might be very tough to deal with, your mother holding onto anger and bitterness and having your brother be the only one at home that had to deal with that is probably a much larger contributor to his over all issues regarding the divorce. Unless I am completely wrong and he didn’t know any of the reasons for the divorce.

Children suffer when adults load them with their own anger and issues. Many many many people divorce because of an affair, in all my anecdotal memories of children destroyed by it, it is largely in the main, the spouse who couldn’t let go or move on who caused the most harm in the long run.

mbosnz · 05/07/2021 19:18

Well, it sounds like the son, the daughter, and the wife he left, to bring up these children alone, have lingering issues - whether it's 20 years or not since he left their care and upbringing to their mother alone is really neither here nor there. This is how they feel. He acted, these are the consequences. If anyone has to bear them, surely it's him and the woman he went into a relationship with, before squaring his existing marriage and children away. It sounds like they've had enough to put up with, as a result of his actions.

aSofaNearYou · 05/07/2021 19:12

@imscaredpleasehelp

I can't believe everyone is suggesting your dm is being unreasonable for not moving on and holding this against the man. He lied and cheated on her for god knows how long. The person who wS supposed to love her more than anything hurt her more than anyone else could. Maybe her trust was shattered? Maybe she thought love wasn't worth the risk of betrayal? The fact that you didn't attend his wedding speaks volumes. You weren't invited. She isn't. I will say it again, this is the risk you take cheating on rather than leaving your wife. You risk falling in love and marrying your affair partner and them being hated by your children or your family. People don't get over this stuff. If it was a case of Husband leaves wife and wife hated husbands new wife then yabu and she should come, but thats not what happened. Husband destroyed wife trust and his own family. we know cheating is wrong every one knows it. It makes you feel crazy. no nobody left me for another woman but it makes me so sick that people are saying the ops mother is being selfish! why not? its her turn!
Well, people do get over stuff. She has to take some responsibility is she hasn't, it's been twenty years.
imscaredpleasehelp · 05/07/2021 19:04

I can't believe everyone is suggesting your dm is being unreasonable for not moving on and holding this against the man.
He lied and cheated on her for god knows how long. The person who wS supposed to love her more than anything hurt her more than anyone else could.
Maybe her trust was shattered?
Maybe she thought love wasn't worth the risk of betrayal?
The fact that you didn't attend his wedding speaks volumes.
You weren't invited. She isn't.
I will say it again, this is the risk you take cheating on rather than leaving your wife. You risk falling in love and marrying your affair partner and them being hated by your children or your family. People don't get over this stuff. If it was a case of Husband leaves wife and wife hated husbands new wife then yabu and she should come, but thats not what happened. Husband destroyed wife trust and his own family.
we know cheating is wrong every one knows it.
It makes you feel crazy.
no nobody left me for another woman but it makes me so sick that people are saying the ops mother is being selfish! why not? its her turn!

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 05/07/2021 19:03

@HOkieCOkie

Her son has died unexpectedly, of course she doesn’t want the women who stole her husband at his funeral. A decent person would stay away out of respect.
I can see that a grieving father would want his wife at his sons funeral...

BUT it's more complicated than that isn't it? .. He largely lost the right to have her at family events when she was the cause of his marriage break up? And the injured party (the dead persons MOTHER) SPECIFICALLY asked for her not to be there.

For all the people say, she must move on/it was 20 years ago... It sounds like she may hold their affair responsible as one of the reasons for her dead son's poor MH /alcoholism.

I don't think I would want to play happy families in this circumstance.

Yabish · 05/07/2021 15:08

@Overitallnow

This is exactly the same situation as in my family. And I can 100% guarantee that my "Stepmother" would NOT be attending my brother's funeral. And if my father insisted, he would not be attending either. It's going to be an awful enough day for you and your mother without this added drama.
You and your DF would both have an equal right to say who should be at the funeral. Why would you have more of a say? This poor chap has lost his child just as much as the mother has.
1forAll74 · 05/07/2021 15:03

This kind of issue often happens in bereaved families, as in people remarrying and some people being at odds with others. If your Dad is going to speak to you soon, maybe you will get another view point on the funeral arrangements. To add upset and strife on your Brothers funeral day, would be very upsetting for everyone, and would stay in your memory for a long time.

Overitallnow · 05/07/2021 14:59

This is exactly the same situation as in my family. And I can 100% guarantee that my "Stepmother" would NOT be attending my brother's funeral. And if my father insisted, he would not be attending either. It's going to be an awful enough day for you and your mother without this added drama.

PrincessNutella · 05/07/2021 14:49

Your father has the same rights as your mother.
This happened 20 years ago. And the sad truth for your mother is, he was not a serial adulterer, he was more in love/suited for the second woman than he was for your mother. For some reason, they just seemed to be a better fit for him. Your mother has had 20 years to come to terms with that. Your father has every right to bring his wifenot his secret mistress, his WIFE, who is his familyto the funeral. A funeral is a ceremony of reconciling people to the bitter reality of loss. Let the healing begin.

Summersnake · 05/07/2021 14:48

Your dad needs to show some respect to the woman who birthed his son.
This is not a day for the other woman to be involved.
I’d be having very strong words with your dad op

Blossomtoes · 05/07/2021 14:16

I agree too @DifficultBloodyWoman.

Bibidy · 05/07/2021 14:15

I doubt the step mother wants to be there. I’m going to project a little here but I reckon the step mother would rather be anywhere else than at a funeral, especially one where emotions are running high and someone could end up telling her to fuck off. But I also reckon the step mother, a wife of twenty years, might want to support her husband. She might even feel it is her responsibility or obligation to do so. So, she might suck it up and stand by her husband despite not wanting to be there and knowing that only her husband wants her there.

I agree.

Also it doesn't seem to matter what the stepmum's relationship was with OP's brother, the issue is that her mum doesn't want her there because of a break-up that happened 20 years ago.

Conkergame · 05/07/2021 14:12

OP, so sorry for your loss. And that you are now in this horrible position.

I personally feel that your dad’s exceptionally selfish actions have caused enough pain for your family already and now he needs to put someone else first for once and not bring his wife when he knows how much pain it will cause your poor mum.

If you have a good enough relationship with your dad’s wife then I would have a quiet word with her and ask her not to come for the sake of the funeral going as well as possible. If you don’t then I’d ask your dad to ask her to just wait outside for him.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 05/07/2021 14:05

@Divineswirls

The gracious and dignified behaviour would be for the stepmother to not come if she did not have a proper close relationship with your brother.

If the relationship was close then of course she should go but it doesn't seem like they did.

I doubt the step mother wants to be there. I’m going to project a little here but I reckon the step mother would rather be anywhere else than at a funeral, especially one where emotions are running high and someone could end up telling her to fuck off. But I also reckon the step mother, a wife of twenty years, might want to support her husband. She might even feel it is her responsibility or obligation to do so. So, she might suck it up and stand by her husband despite not wanting to be there and knowing that only her husband wants her there.

As I said, there is some projecting in there but fuck tonne less than that of other posters.

A lot of people on this thread should clearly be on the Jerry springer show!

Divineswirls · 05/07/2021 13:49

The gracious and dignified behaviour would be for the stepmother to not come if she did not have a proper close relationship with your brother.

If the relationship was close then of course she should go but it doesn't seem like they did.

Sssloou · 05/07/2021 13:48

As you are seeing emotions are raw, volatile and escalate in traumatic times.

Rage needs to get discharged and sometimes it is distorted, magnified, amplified directed in the wrong direction often disproportionately into older traumas.

There are no winners in any of this and it’s v cruel for you to be cast as piggy in the middle of two people who need to deal with each other directly.

It seems that your DM was able to talk through funeral arrangements with your Dad civilly - so there is some foundation for them be able to collaborate.

I am really sorry that in top of everything you feel that this mess is for you to manage.

It really isn’t.

billy1966 · 05/07/2021 13:45

@EllebellyBeeblebrox

My brother was (in the words of one of his closest friends recently) “destroyed” when dad left. I had just started at uni so wasn’t at home as much as I wanted to be, so he dealt with a lot of her hurt initially. She definitely wouldn’t blame it all on their separation and the OW/stepmum, he had many demons but I suppose that reason is the most tangible to her. She’s blaming herself more than anyone else though.
I don't think she should be there.

Your father is a piece of work whose actions caused your brother enormous pain.

Your father is responsible for that.

Your mothers feelings trump your fathers 100% in my view.

The OW's views don't count.
She didn't have any real relationship with him and he barely tolerated her.

Tell your father what your brother's friend told you if he wishes to be a selfish dick.

He cheated on your brother 20 years ago and if it destroyed him then, there is every reason to imagine it impacted your brother terribly.

Your poor mother.
You have my heartfelt sympathy and condolences.

Support your mother and let your selfish father suck it up.

He is not the priority here.

Your mother is IMO.
Flowers

aSofaNearYou · 05/07/2021 13:30

The father’s need for his “rock” does not trump the mother’s needs to say goodbye to her son without the additional historic pain of their betrayal flung at her. She does not have to suck it up - even after 20 years if she does not wish to. The reality is both parents will have additional family members they can rely upon for support on the day - no need for controversy or extra painful memories.

I would argue that it does, actually, because a parents grief should be of far more significance than an ex wife's about a divorce from 20 years ago. Quite frankly she should have moved on from that by now.

SinisterBumFacedCat · 05/07/2021 13:28

People are projecting all over this thread, dads wife has been referred to as a whore, a bunny boiler.

Op you are your mums rock, not your dads. You will not be available to support him, he needs support on this day too.