Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

'Don't worry, he's friendly'

467 replies

PraiseBee · 04/07/2021 07:50

Too flippin friendly. Yet again, another dog running up to my four year old DC with a chunk of a branch in its mouth, firmly ignoring it's owners recall whilst they yell at me 'don't worry, Fluffyballs is friendly'. My DC loves dogs but hates dogs rushing up to him and is obviously scared. Large dogs are the same height as him and can easily knock him over. Imagine as an adult being rushed up to by a horse with a bit of tree trunk in its mouth trying to lick your face. I think most adults would be perturbed by this. It seems to be happening more often. Are dogs getting less well trained? I think the thing that makes my blood boil over is that the dog owners seem to think their dog is the most amazing thing ever so of course me and my DC want to bowled over by Fluffyballs. No we really don't and no, I give a shit what your dog is called. AIBU to be so annoyed by this happening every time we go to a children's park?!

OP posts:
Freckers · 04/07/2021 13:08

@AdoptedBumpkin

This is a pet hate of mine (no pun intended!)

Strangers who might be scared of dogs don't know if your dog is friendly.

Also, it's a pointless thing to shout as you wouldn't shout the opposite if that was the case.

"Run, run, he's a savage and hasn't been fed in three days!"

pigsDOfly · 04/07/2021 13:07

Because every time I've been out where there are dogs playing, exercised on or off leash I have never seen a single child running up to pat a dog or jump on a dog

It does happen.

My dog is a pretty, fluffy one and children are really drawn to her. It's happened on more than one occasion that a child has run up to her and slung their arms around her neck.

Fortunately, she's very calm and gentle and her only reaction has been to pull her head back and look at me in a slightly alarmed manner.

cuparfull · 04/07/2021 13:01

Dogs are unpredictable animals, all dogs.
You can never be absolutely certain an unleashed dog will not cause harm.
All dogs walking in public outdoor space should be on a leash.
And this is from a police handler/trainer.

Dog owners are deemed to be responsible for their dogs actions....this is why dogs are licensed and owners can be held accountable.
Don't stand any nonsense from irresponsible dog owners.

A child trumps a dog anytime. Yes a child should be taught respect and not to approach a dog but equally NO dog should be allowed to run up to anyone without permission. Such a dog is not under control.

DontWiltMySpinachPlease · 04/07/2021 12:52

Such a good point and so rarely mentioned on this forum.

sergeilavrov · 04/07/2021 12:52

I’m a dog owner (of an anxious dog who would prefer to be carried to potty and then back Hmm), and I don’t want dogs off lead at parks. Go to a dedicated, gated dog park if you want that experience. Dogs aren’t allowed to be off lead in the country I live in, and my children have never had these issues, aren’t scared of dogs as I was at their age - and dog bites are very rare.

Ultimately if there are exceptions like ‘if their recall is good’ - everyone will exaggerate their dog’s recall. These things can’t be caught until something goes wrong, and that’s too big a risk.

rantymcrantface66 · 04/07/2021 12:52

Because every time I’ve been out where there are dogs playing, being exercised on or off leash I have never seen a single child running up to pat a dog or jump on a dog

I promise it does happen very regularly. It's probably not something you notice if you don't have a stranger reactive dog and more so as in my case a very cute one who still looks like a puppy, and who appears calm and relaxed. (because she is until someone directly approaches her). Children ignore you when they ask to stroke and their parents don't take it seriously either because she's tiny

Everything else you say though I agree with. It's my responsibility to keep her safe and the dc safe too and it's easy enough to do if you are vigilant and careful about where and when to let off lead. It is far less easy to have any control over an off lead dog

whynotwhatknot · 04/07/2021 12:51

I hate this too and i like dogs-my sil has two dogs they dont like other dogs she has them on leads around others

shes lost count of time othe dogs have come bounding up with the owners shouting over dont worry hes friendly-and she has to yank her dogs away saying well mine arent can you put them ona lead please

shes had no end of arguments saying your dogs should be friendly aswell its not right and loads of other crap-all these owners have no recall for their dogs and off lead-just take some reposnsibility fffs

Giraffe888 · 04/07/2021 12:51

I agree completely. My 2 year old DS is petrified of dogs seeing as everyday when we go out walking at least one dog charges at him with the owner casually strolling behind saying ‘it’s friendly’

Oceanbliss · 04/07/2021 12:45

@vivainsomnia There are far too many people who have been killed by dogs, mauled to death. Babies, toddlers, adults, elderly. It is not ok. I don’t care how much you love your dog. Your dog is an animal not a substitute baby, friend, person and does not have more importance then a person.

This thread is on a parenting forum where parents can support each other, share experiences, bounce ideas off of each other.

This thread has been started by a parent sharing their experiences of irresponsible dog owners putting their children at risk. Other parents can come here and share their experiences too.

But you seem to be intent on derailing this conversation in defence of dog owners and their dogs. Attacking parents for sharing their experiences, concerns and support for one another.

Why don’t you start a forum on reddit specifically aimed at dog owners supporting one another instead of being deliberately provocative on a parenting forum.

Because every time I’ve been out where there are dogs playing, being exercised on or off leash I have never seen a single child running up to pat a dog or jump on a dog or be rough with a dog or bite a dog or maul it to death. I have seen on a daily basis dogs running at, jumping on, intruding in a person or group of peoples relaxation, exercise, sport, play, picnic with their owners allowing it.

I have read on the news of unprovoked dog attacks such as sleeping baby or child killed by dog, elderly couple minding their own business on a beach being mauled to death.

These are very serious examples of irresponsible pet ownership. Trivialising this very important topic is to condone it.

Playgrounds are purposely built for children. They are not built for our pets. All people have a right to feel safe. Children should never be made to feel unsafe in a playground or space specifically designed for them. They shouldn’t be prevented from entering that space specifically made for them because they are too afraid to go in there because of an unrestrained dog.

This is a parenting forum. If you don’t like parents or their children bugger off.

burritofan · 04/07/2021 12:42

We went to a no-dogs park recently on holiday and it was bliss: no worrying about poo, no having your picnic nicked, no seeing them piss on patches of grass a crawling baby might go for, no having to be constantly fucking alert.

pigsDOfly · 04/07/2021 12:36

I'm not sure this problem is any worse than it's always been if I'm honest.

In the 10 years I've had my dog, having other dogs with no recall and clueless owners running up to us and leaping all over one or both of us has always been a regular occurrence when we're out and about.

I don't care whether the dog is 'friendly' or a vicious brute I don't want its filthy paws all over me and neither does my dog.

@FlaminEckVera Those dogs are clearly not under the owner's control if they're out on their own and that's an offence; if the dog caused a road accident, for instance, the owner would be liable. They don't necessarily have to be on a lead but they should be under the owner's control at all times.

Report it to your local dog warden. If the council doesn't have a dog warden. whoever answers the phone at the council offices should be able to put you onto the right department.

Twofurrycats · 04/07/2021 12:35

I'm currently dog sitting for a friend. He's a very friendly dog but his training has been somewhat lax. So he's on a lead unless we're on my own land because his recall is rubbish. If I had him for longer I'd probably be able to sort it out but I know when he goes home it will be back to ineffectual faffing with him.

Stinkysteamy · 04/07/2021 12:27

"In my opinion non dog owners don't want dogs off lead full stop in parks."

I'm fine with off lead dogs under control. I live rurally and we see lots of dogs on paths that are not on leads but the owner is watching them and not letting them run right up to people. It's always worse on the more popular paths where you meet the badly trained dogs, sunday dog walkers and people who think everyone loves their furbaby.

rantymcrantface66 · 04/07/2021 12:23

My retired neighbour was knocked to the ground by dogs last week. They'd met in the park and raced off together ignoring their owners calls to come back then charged right in to my neighbours legs taking them from under her and she landed hard and was winded and is still limping now. 2 chihuahuas wouldn't have caused that so large dog owners do need to be even more on it. All dogs should be under control however and that means being able to be recalled before an incident is allowed to happen. As I said before friendly dogs out of control are a problem too. Out of control doesnt just mean going round biting people.

DontLookEthel · 04/07/2021 12:23

My dog is always on a lead if there might be children about as they make him very anxious.
Although I avoid the obvious places I have to be constantly on the look out for very young kids unexpectedly running up to dog intent on stroking him.
As they move quickly there's no time for polite explanations and I've sometimes had to physically shield the dog and shout "NO, LEAVE HIM ALONE", resulting in upset child and annoyed parents.

Ijustknowitstimetogo · 04/07/2021 12:22

I think it's because most dogs find most adults boring - they run up to other dogs because it's instinct and small children because of the way the move all fast and unpredictable is exciting.

Oh I think you’re right. Most of my memories of dogs running up were from when I was a younger. They do seem to see children as small animals.

PigsEnigma · 04/07/2021 12:20

I hate idiots with dogs. I have two big dogs and a DS who's terrified of dogs. Why? Because other people's sodding dogs keep bowling him over letting them run up to him. My dogs are always on lead. One is reactive as its been attacked in the past and the other is terrified of the world and we're getting her used to being a dog and not a shed ornament that she was previously. We do not want any extra attention from flipping CoochiePoo. Since lockdown things have got so much worse.

ChubbyLittleManInACampervan · 04/07/2021 12:18

Totally with you OP

I have a large very friendly dig who likes to say hello. That’s why he’s on a lead if we’re in a place with kids

It’s not hard

I think there are a lot more first time dig owners about because of the pandemic. Teaching recall is hard work, quite a few people can’t be bothered

(My dog is not perfectly trained, as a lurcher he has ehm selective hearing, hence the lead)

PraiseBee · 04/07/2021 12:17

@vivainsomnia

I do not agree at all with this. You should not push a toddler. If your dog is as small as you say it is scoop it up. It's not the toddlers fault it isn't being helped to avoid the dog or approach carefully The double standards are staggering. It's ok to kick a dog but pushing even gently a toddler isn't. My dog welfare means as much to me as your kid does to you. I know hard to comprehend for many but nevertheless a fact.

I never said I would purposely harm the child, but if your toddler came running after my dog with a stick trying to strike my dog, I would do anything to stop them. If that means they fall in the process of me picking up my dog, it would be the irresponsible parent's fault, not mine.

Ahhh you have a fur baby. Your dog's welfare does not trump that of a human child. Pushing a child would be assault.
OP posts:
PraiseBee · 04/07/2021 12:15

My sister has just sent me a photo of her arm with a mighty great cut on it from being sent flying by a Labrador. Couldn't make it up

OP posts:
Mollylikestodance · 04/07/2021 12:14

YANBU. I grew up with dogs and am currently a 'part time' dog owner. I adore dogs but hate this. It's not fair on kids, and even the most placid dogs could snap unexpectedly if aggravated by a child. You just never know.

Too many people are getting dogs as pets/accessories without taking time to train them properly or know how to look after them when out and about.

rantymcrantface66 · 04/07/2021 12:12

In the car park a skanky dog owner let it piss up someone else's car and then we found shit on the buggy wheels

the other day a man was totally ignoring his off lead dogs whilst they left him and came sniff around the entrance of a child's play park. The dog then cocked its leg and pissed up against DD's jacket which was hanging on the fence Envy

Camphillgirl · 04/07/2021 12:10

My lovely neighbour has cute little dog but when she sees another dog while out walking she deliberately unleashes hers and says “go play” the dog then chases other unleashed dogs and gets bit of exercise but is now highly charged and excited. It proceeds to run wild and rushes up to children and dogs and won’t be recalled. There should be an exam or licence before people are allowed dogs large or small.

PizzaCrust · 04/07/2021 12:09

I also think a big part of the issues with dogs nowadays is every moron who has bought a Frenchie (or another popular breed) has decided that they're a dog breeder and breeds it with their mate's equally inbred Frenchie, resulting in a lot of dogs being bred with awful temperaments (and health issues, might I add).

These people don't care. They just want their three grand per pup from Gumtree.

Similarly, those who rescue a dog (eg a dog who was abused and can't be around young children), then are suddenly shocked when they have a baby in a year's time and the dog's behaviour goes to pot. Alas, the dog is dumped back at the rescue centre with more emotional damage than before.

People genuinely don't have any ability to plan for the future.

Natty13 · 04/07/2021 12:09

There are more areas in my local parks and open spaces where dogs are allowed off lead than have to be kept one.

I tell people who complain if my dog walks within 5 feet of their precious brat while sniffing round (and she's scared of people so wouldn't go closer than that) to go to the no dogs allowed/dog areas. There are spaces which fit everyone's preferences and I'm not restricting my calm,well behaved dog to the lead all the time just because a small minority think all spaces should he as they like it all the time. Walk somewhere else if you don't like it.