Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry with bike shop for selling me a second hand bike as new?

432 replies

YellowBellyCat · 04/07/2021 07:23

I bought an expensive bike last week from a well known National bike shop chain. Bike was reduced from £2700 to £2200 as I was told it was last year’s model. It’s a seriously well specced bike.

Turned up for a club ride yesterday and people there recognised the bike, it’s had custom bar tape put on it which makes it distinctive. Someone who works at the bike shop was there and made a comment about how the bike had won a National Grand Prix. I didn’t click at first and thought he meant that make/model. But later on other people were saying oh that’s x’s old bike. I’ve now found public posts from x on the bike shops fb page dated from 2019 with photos of her with the bike saying how she’s entered numerous races with the bike.

I tried to register it with the manufacturer yesterday on their registration scheme and can’t register it as it’s already registered.

So they’ve basically sold me a 2yo second hand bike and pretended it’s new. Don’t get me wrong…it looks in good condition, they’ve obviously cleaned it well, possibly they’ve put a new chain/cassette on 🤷‍♀️ But I wouldn’t have paid that amount of money for a second hand bike. At the end of the 2019 season another National chain were selling them new for £1900!

I’m going back to the bike shop today to attempt some serious price negotiation but not sure how far I’m going to get. If they don’t budge on price I think I will have to insist on a refund as it’s just making me angry now. A similar spec bike in this year’s models is about 4k though as the bike model has been seriously redesigned and upgraded (disc brakes from rim brakes) and I can’t afford 4k. They’re also all out of stock.

A friend was with me when I bought it and she’s as shocked as me, says she also thought it was a new bike. It was lined up with this year’s bikes.

OP posts:
billy1966 · 09/07/2021 13:33

OP, they are completely wrong here.

I think you should go to the papers, one of the money/customer service writers that have been recommended.

Companies do this shit because they think they can get away with it.

I have had a couple of run ins with different companies over the years and they are all guff until they realise you are really serious AND annoyed enough to do something about it.

WITHOUT EXCEPTION I have had every single situation rectified with an apology.

They are a disgrace and people spending thousands on bikes need to know.

Go to the papers and see how they feel about their defence of defrauding/misleading customers looks when in print.

Accept deferment of a decision for 9 weeks but inform them that you intend to investigate further have they acted illegally and your intention to contact X journalist.

Years ago I was telling a friend of mine how I had recently been expecting a battle with a large company over some faulty goods when they capitulated.

She explained that most people accept the Fxxk off that they get from customer service when they complain, but when a customer actually tells them NO and they are prepared to cause a stink about what has occurred, they suddenly find the company very amenable.

I have subsequently found my first interaction now to be better to layout that I am their worst nightmare and will cause them a major problem and am bloody minded enough to do it.

They can't be arsed dealing with me, and sort it out quickly.

You should insist on using the bike for 9 weeks and get the new model in exchange plus your 200 voucher.

If they laugh at you, say fine I will go to the papers about Giant's policy of selling old used bikes as new.

Find your anger, do NOT accept this.
Flowers

Shedbuilder · 09/07/2021 13:17

Yes, they've offered a refund because they know they don't have a leg to stand on and they're hoping the OP will go away and won't attract any negative attention to the fact that they've sold a secondhand bike as new. But what the OP needs advice on is whether she can legally claim a partial refund, having just discovered that an otherwise ideal bike which she would like to keep is actually a secondhand bike that has been well-used and has already had repairs.

Imagine buying a the perfect handbag/ sofa/ car offered at a slight discount on the basis that it's last year's model, only to discover that someone else has owned and used it for the last two years — and that it was so well-used that it had to be refurbished before it could be passed-off as 'new'. You might want to keep the item, but you'd want the fact that it had been well-used and repaired and that you'd been miss-sold to be reflected in the price. Well, I would, anyway.

YellowBellyCat · 09/07/2021 13:07

The manufacturer also has no liability here. If you bought a Sony tv from John Lewis and found out it was not new you have no recourse to Sony. However you would think they might be sympathetic if it their name is associated with this mess.

The comparison is more buying a Sony Tv from a Sony Shop. The brand of the bike is the same as the name as the shop.

Anyway I really don't have the headspace or energy for it. So although I feel I've paid over the odds I do really like the bike. I've accepted the vouchers.

They did yesterday also offer that I can keep the bike for 12 weeks until new stock comes in and then have a refund and then buy a new bike, so guess that was quite decent of them. Issue is the new model of bike has been upgraded and the rrp for this year's model has increased by about 33%. So it would cost considerably more, though arguably the bike as well as being newer is a better spec. But I don't need the better spec.

OP posts:
christinarossetti19 · 09/07/2021 12:47

She was mis-sold the bike.

It wasn't new nor was it last year's model.

They are trading standards/consumer affairs issue, regardless of whether they offered a refund or not.

Mumski45 · 09/07/2021 12:11

Morally I think the OP should be offered a hefty discount so she can keep the bike.

However legally she has been offered a full refund to return the bike so has the retailer not fulfilled their legal duty here. She may want to take this further but I'm not sure she has legal grounds to be able to pursue a claim.

The manufacturer also has no liability here. If you bought a Sony tv from John Lewis and found out it was not new you have no recourse to Sony. However you would think they might be sympathetic if it their name is associated with this mess.

christinarossetti19 · 09/07/2021 09:31

Primarily, OP is angry that she bought what she thought was a new bike, discounted because she was told that it was last years stock.

It was neither new nor last years stock.

She would not have paid what she did for a second-hand bike, and she wouldn't have sold her old bike if she hadn't believed that she'd just bought a new one.

If she accepts a refund, she won't be able to go on holiday tomorrow as she will be bike-less. The alternative is an instore voucher, which isn't even the the same amount as which she was deceived into overpaying.

That, and the fact that the head office of Giant, a major, high end bike retailer, are taking the line that their shops defrauding customers isn't their concern.

Shedbuilder · 08/07/2021 21:05

@tallduckandhandsome

They have offered her a full cash refund if she returns the bike, or £200 store credit (vouchers) if she keeps it

Why is OP angry then? Shock

The bike's the right size and spec for her and she'd have to wait weeks for a new order. And a full refund just gets them off the hook for mis-selling. They'll just sell it to someone else.
HermioneKipper · 08/07/2021 16:25

Cheeky bastards. Totally chanced their arm and have lied through their teeth about you getting a secondhand bike. Tell them you’re planning spread it all over social media and around local forums/cycling groups and see if that might change their mind

EveryoneIsThere · 08/07/2021 16:14

@tallduckandhandsome

They have offered her a full cash refund if she returns the bike, or £200 store credit (vouchers) if she keeps it

Why is OP angry then? Shock

All the info is in the thread.... If you read it you will see that the reason the OP is annoyed is because she got rid of her old bike when she bought her (not) new bike. If she gives the (not) new bike back for a refund she will be left without a bike. There is a huge shortage of bikes so she can't find another bike to buy that would be the correct type and size. She has a biking holiday coming up so needs to have a bike.
tallduckandhandsome · 08/07/2021 16:03

They have offered her a full cash refund if she returns the bike, or £200 store credit (vouchers) if she keeps it

Why is OP angry then? Shock

HaveringWavering · 08/07/2021 15:56

@Shedbuilder

OP, I'd tell them I'm taking legal advice regarding my consumer rights and options, that I'm due to go on holiday shortly and I will give them my decision when I get back.

Your situation won't have changed. You've still been sold a secondhand bike as new and at higher price than you would have paid had you known it had done thousands of miles and been ridden hard in competition. It's still a bike that comes without a manufacturer"s warranty.

I agree that is good advice.
Shedbuilder · 08/07/2021 14:17

OP, I'd tell them I'm taking legal advice regarding my consumer rights and options, that I'm due to go on holiday shortly and I will give them my decision when I get back.

Your situation won't have changed. You've still been sold a secondhand bike as new and at higher price than you would have paid had you known it had done thousands of miles and been ridden hard in competition. It's still a bike that comes without a manufacturer"s warranty.

LookItsMeAgain · 08/07/2021 10:32

If they are going to offer you a full refund and take the bike back, will they be trying to flog it to someone else as "New" or "As-New" or "Nearly New" I'd wonder? They can't sell it as a new bike as it isn't, it's had two careful owners.
They can't sell it as "As New" or "Nearly New" as neither of those descriptions fit either. They would have to sell it as at best "Second hand" which you say they don't do in this branch @YellowBellyCat or more accurately "Two previous careful owners".

I'd tackle them on how they plan to resell the bike and with your refund, if they reduce the price, buy it back!

Wormwoodgal · 08/07/2021 10:01

I haven’t time to RTFT, but tell them you will contact Anna Tims, the ‘Your Problems’ person at the Guardian, if they don’t budge. She will love this, as so many consumer laws have been broken!
If they still don’t budge, do it!
She gets results, and they will get a whole lot of very bad publicity.
But give them the chance to do the right thing first.

vivariumvivariumsvivaria · 08/07/2021 09:32

I'd send them a copy of this thread too.

I've figured out which bike brand it is. I don't spend that sort of cash on bikes, but I do need to sort out bikes for teenagers this year. I have no brand loyalty to bikes but I'd discount that one purely because they are defrauding and ignoring a woman.

NeilBuchananisBanksy · 08/07/2021 09:17

Don't do anything yet. Say you are considering your options and taking advice from trading standards and a lawyer.

Please go further with the op.

Thunderpunt · 08/07/2021 08:44

I'd take the bike on holiday (meanwhile tell them you're considering your next steps.... appointment with solicitor, etc) then deal with it when you get back. It's second hand so unless you really scuff it up bad, how will they know you have used it? (Disclaimer, not a cyclist so no idea if this is possible)

Confusedandshaken · 08/07/2021 08:30

I can see you are screwed and will probably have to accept the offer in order to go on your cycling holiday holiday, but I would still refer this to trading standards. It's good they have a record of this fraudulent practice. Copy the shop and head office in on your report. It's too late for you but it might help future buyers.

HaveringWavering · 08/07/2021 07:55

@AmberIsACertainty

What about those no win no fee lawyers? I can imagine they'd take this case on as the company has broken the law so it'd be an easy job for them?
This would be too small for that type of lawyer. No win no fee is generally for personal injury work or large commercial disputes.
HaveringWavering · 08/07/2021 07:52

@tallduckandhandsome

But they have offered me a full refund so don’t think trading standards, etc would be interested.

I think I’m going to have to accept the offer of vouchers and a bike fit….I’m so bloody angry though.

Have they offered a full refund or vouchers? Vouchers isn't a full refund, and that is what you are entitled to. Get your money back, don't give the fuckers your money.

They have offered her a full cash refund if she returns the bike, or £200 store credit (vouchers) if she keeps it.
Duvetflower · 08/07/2021 07:21

I'd take the full refund and suggest they loan you a bike as compensation as their error has left you bikeless.

DobbyTheHouseElk · 08/07/2021 07:18

Don’t accept vouchers.

tallduckandhandsome · 08/07/2021 07:06

But they have offered me a full refund so don’t think trading standards, etc would be interested.

I think I’m going to have to accept the offer of vouchers and a bike fit….I’m so bloody angry though.

Have they offered a full refund or vouchers? Vouchers isn't a full refund, and that is what you are entitled to. Get your money back, don't give the fuckers your money.

DobbyTheHouseElk · 08/07/2021 06:45

@skoobidoobidoop

Giant Bicycles

Mr Ian Beasant Chief Executive

Email [email protected]
Telephone 0115 9775900
Switchboard 0115 9775900
Website www.giant-bicycle.com
Personal Twitter @ianbeasant

He needs someone to show him this thread. It’s not a great advert for the brand. Where are the likes of the Sun etc when you need them? They love to pick up on MN stories.
AmberIsACertainty · 08/07/2021 00:48

What about those no win no fee lawyers? I can imagine they'd take this case on as the company has broken the law so it'd be an easy job for them?

Swipe left for the next trending thread