Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brother meeting my boyfriend. AIBU?

161 replies

PurpleSlate · 03/07/2021 19:32

10 years ago, I split up from my husband. It's amicable well enough now. Certainly no dramas. I rarely talk about him but when I do, it's largely positive. We were together 12 years, married 4 and it ended when he had an affair.

My brother and he were really close. They went away for the weekend alone, my ex husband was a groomsman at his wedding. You get the picture.

They haven't seen each other since we split up and my brother was really angry at the time. He kept talking about how his wedding photos were ruined because my ex was on them, how his daughter had lost her only uncle etc.

Over the past 10 years, I've dated a bit here and there but nothing serious. Not suggested introducing my brother to any of them.

I've now been with someone for 18 months. My children have a good relationship with him.

My brother has invited my children and me over to his house next weekend on the only night I would be able to see my boyfriend this week due to work commitments. I've explained this and asked if he can come along. It will only be for a couple of hours in the evening.

My children are adult/older teen. They will be making their own way to my brother's and stopping overnight. My brother has 'met' my bf when he called for a video chat not knowing he was round.

Anyway, my brother has previously expressed quite clearly that he has no interest in meeting anyone I date and has been lukewarm when I have suggested meeting him. He doesn't want to get close to someone else only to lose them and he doesn't want his daughter to lose another uncle. We don't see him often so none of that would happen anyway.

He wants 24 hours to discuss with his wife and make a decision on whether my bf is allowed to visit with me.

It makes feel like a child. I think that, after 18 months and, for the first time in 10 years, he should be open to meeting someone I'm in a relationship with. Were all in our 40s/50s.

Am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
PurpleSlate · 04/07/2021 19:55

Bridezillamaybe

It's just ridiculous, isn't it?

Still no word from him...

OP posts:
PurpleSlate · 04/07/2021 19:54

Just bizarre.

Tbh, as I've said, we don't spending time together as it is. I just don't like this default position he's assumed where his is the one who gets to make the final decision.

I wouldn't even be able to suggest a day out or something in the summer because he'll know I'd take him along and he just wouldn't commit. Makes me feel like a second class citizen in my own family so, no, I won't be meeting up with him and leaving bf behind. I just won't see him.

I've already invited them to come and see me perform in something over the summer and despite being very keen initially, is now dragging his heels about committing to that since I said bf would be going. I'd forgotten about that.

OP posts:
Bridezillamaybe · 04/07/2021 19:35

I met my DP a couple of years after he broke up from his wife. It was she who instigated the split and she moved on with a new partner. They have three children, teenagers who we had about 40% of the time.

DP's family live in another country, the flight is one hour away. We were living together when his sister suggested a holiday over to hers. I was in the same room and as she speaks very loudly could hear the misunderstood conversation between them, when she said 'you must all' she didn't mean me, she meant he and his children. He assumed me too given they had chatted about us moving in together. She asked him if he trusted me around children. He laughed and said obviously. When she realised he wanted me to join on the trip she said very dramatically that would have to be discussed with her husband. My DP thought this was strange. I did too but shrugged, her house, whatever.

She granted permission but shortly after we arrived she invited me for a private walk. On the walk she told me her husband doesn't approve of my DP's ex wife because of how she behaves during the breakup and she is not allowed visit. I had no interest in this. She then went on to say she was quite shocked my dp (her brother) had assumed he could invite me to the house but her husband had ok'd it so not to worry. I said about two words for this entire exchange.

Unsurprisingly she is a totally drama llama and I have as little to do with her as possible. I just nod and excuse myself when the inevitable mountain out of molehill begins. Her husband I am nearly positive has absolutely no input into any of this.

There's every chance your boyfriend will give your brother a similar wide berth if it's going to be this complicated.

PurpleSlate · 04/07/2021 19:13

He was perfectly friendly and chatty with him during the accidental video chat so I really can't see what the problem is. It does seem that it's more about control than anything else.

OP posts:
PurpleSlate · 04/07/2021 18:50

Wow. 27 years? Looks like I won't be seeing much of my brother then...

Stupid thing is that, when his daughter comes to stay over the summer, she'll see him again then! He might be able to dictate what happens in his house/when he's there but he can't when he's not.

Last year, I contemplated not seeing him for the week my niece stayed until i got a grip!

OP posts:
QueeniesCroft · 04/07/2021 18:45

I've been married for 27 years, and my husband still hasn't met my (half) brother. My brother is an attention-seeking drama llama, and it sounds like yours might be too.

PurpleSlate · 04/07/2021 18:34

When bf and I started seeing each other and meeting friends, I told him that meeting my brother was out of the question for this reason. I don't think he really believed me...

OP posts:
PurpleSlate · 04/07/2021 18:32

You'd think, wouldn't you?

OP posts:
sonjadog · 04/07/2021 18:26

Even if he doesn't end up a long term partner, it really isn't that traumatic to meet a new person for a couple of hours one afternoon!

PurpleSlate · 04/07/2021 18:22

Tbh, I have no idea how 'serious' it is. But it's been 18 months which is the longest I've dated anyone ever without marrying them!

I wouldn't want to make a big deal out of it either because, if we do split up, I'll have to listen to the supercilious, "And this is why we didn't want him coming round to the house..." nonsense.

OP posts:
PurpleSlate · 04/07/2021 18:19

@CrotchetyQuaver

YANBU. If your brother graciously permits your new boyfriend to tag along, then you do realise he's likely to be horrible to him all night don't you? I'd message him and tell him you won't be going and then leave him hanging...
Oh, he wouldn't he horrible at all. H I'd imagine he would he charm personified. But then, it's never been tested so I wouldn't know!

But I knew he'd be unlikely to say yes when I asked him.

I'm anticipating him presenting it as a 'safeguarding' issue and saying he doesn't want someone he's never met before in his house. But he's rejected/ignored my previous suggestions to meet up in the pub too.

If he says yes after today, I'll say its too late and we've made other plans now. Because we will have.

OP posts:
Datsandcogs · 04/07/2021 18:19

It would be a no from me. If the boyfriend is serious then prioritise him over your controlling and unreasonable brother.

PurpleSlate · 04/07/2021 18:16

Tbf, when my son was little, we saw him a lot. But when my daughter was born, we severely cut contact. Like I say we meet up before Christmas, over the summer and sometime around Easter now. Very rarely more often than this. His daughter comes to stay with us for a week in the summer. We rarely speak in between. Occasional messages in the family WhatsApp group but that's it.

It's a real shame tbh.

OP posts:
CrotchetyQuaver · 04/07/2021 18:13

YANBU.

If your brother graciously permits your new boyfriend to tag along, then you do realise he's likely to be horrible to him all night don't you?

I'd message him and tell him you won't be going and then leave him hanging...

PurpleSlate · 04/07/2021 18:11

No, nothing cultural. He's just a perfect example of white male entitlement I think Wink

Aside from this, we do get on well but his need to be in charge and to impose these rules gets very wearing.

OP posts:
PurpleSlate · 04/07/2021 18:09

@honeylulu

Was/ is your brother the golden child in the family by any chance? And everyone tends to dance around trying not to "upset" him? If so I recognise this dynamic.

My mum and sister have seemingly been more upset about things that happened to me (for their own sake) than they thought I was entitled to be.

This included:
Me dumping my uni boyfriend who they'd decided I was going to marry and ruined the wedding plans they'd apparently been discussing.

Me being made redundant (about 6 weeks after I'd got my first mortgage!) from a company I'd got my sister a few weeks freelance work with. It is relevant that she'd completed the work and been paid in full several months before my redundancy. All my mum banged on about awful it would have been if she'd ended up not getting paid.

It raining torrentially on the morning of my wedding and ruining our (sister was bridesmaid) newly done hair. Sister wailed and cried. Mum still talks about how awful it was that she was so upset that day when she "only wanted to look nice". I was the bride and mine looked shit as well!

Me daring to have a baby girl. Sister has two sons and was so jealous she cut me off. Parents defended her "because she sensitive" and won't put any photos of my daughter up at their house in case it upsets her.

Now VLC.

Sorry for the hijack. Aaaahhh ... I feel better now!

Grin no apology needed. Its very cathartic to have a rant!

Yes, he was the golden child.

He got a 2:2 in his degree. I got a first. Our mum said I was bound to do better than him because he worked during his degree and I didn't. He lived in halls and did one 4hour shift a week at the SU Bar. I commuted daily to another city by public transport with a toddler in tow... tbf, he recognised this and was very proud of me.

Plus a million other examples!

To answer other questions, no, I haven't heard anything so, as far as I'm concerned, that's a "no" and I'm not going.

He has replied to my daughter in the family group chat so he's not not had chance to reply yet.

My children are making their own way there together anyway so bf and I would have been travelling separately. So they are still going.

He just has to be civil, he doesn't have to bond.

Yeah, I know.

And yes, he does have a tendency to make everything about him.

We didn't see him for a year about 6 years ago because he behaved awfully during a family meal out and my children were really upset. It was utterly humiliating as we'd eaten out somewhere I visit a lot and knew the staff. The children told my ex husband (who told me) that they didn't like the "two arguments" that we always had when we met up.

There weren't any arguments. He would begin every meet up with a lengthy rant about how disadvantaged he was and how the government and his parents had screwed him over, then we'd have a nice time and then, at the end of the nice time, whilst reflecting upon the nice time, he would return to the earlier rant. It was always the same and his wife and I said very little.

He doesn't do that anymore though.

OP posts:
Drivingmeupthewall · 04/07/2021 17:42

He doesn't want to get close to someone else only to lose them and he doesn't want his daughter to lose another uncle

Just came to reiterate literally everyone else’s remarks.

SO FUCKING WEIRD.

Why is he making it all about him?
Why does he think he has some sort of control or power over you?
Is there something cultural at play here?
Or is he just a fucking lunatic overly invested in his sister’s love life? 😂

notacooldad · 04/07/2021 16:29

I'm imaging my brother telling me he needs 24hrs to think about something like this.

I would ask him if he is having a laugh and if not to go screw himself. How bloody dare he!!!

Maybe you should have said that and stop being your brother's doormat.

1forAll74 · 04/07/2021 16:12

Your Brother is really odd, childish, and immature, for a man of this kind of age. and needs 24 hours to discuss this issue with his partner, good heavens, what a laugh. It would be awkward, even if you decided to visit.

SmugglersHaunt · 04/07/2021 16:11

Good grief - talk about making it all about him! He’s basically putting conditions on you having a relationship with your only remaining family member - either be single, or pretend to be single in his presence.

Can your kids go on their own?

itsaccrualworld · 04/07/2021 15:58

I understand why your brother is cautious about making friends with a new boyfriend of yours, given how close he was to the last serious fella and how he lost that relationship when you broke up.

However, your ex had an affair. It's not exactly your fault that your relationship ended and consequently so did the bromance between your ex and your brother. His anger and caution is misplaced.

Plus, this visit is so the kids can go round. It's not so your new man and your brother can go on a date. He just has to be civil, he doesn't have to bond.

notacooldad · 04/07/2021 15:57

After being told he needed 24 hrs to think about it I would have told him to forget the whole thing and say I was no longer interested.
I would then be stepping back from your brother significantly.

PopcornMuncher · 04/07/2021 15:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

saraclara · 04/07/2021 15:45

How did your divorce become your brother's heartbreak to nurse?

Exactly. He seems to have made your break up all about himself.

Does he see himself as some kind of parent figure to you? Is he over protective?

honeylulu · 04/07/2021 15:40

Was/ is your brother the golden child in the family by any chance? And everyone tends to dance around trying not to "upset" him? If so I recognise this dynamic.

My mum and sister have seemingly been more upset about things that happened to me (for their own sake) than they thought I was entitled to be.

This included:
Me dumping my uni boyfriend who they'd decided I was going to marry and ruined the wedding plans they'd apparently been discussing.

Me being made redundant (about 6 weeks after I'd got my first mortgage!) from a company I'd got my sister a few weeks freelance work with. It is relevant that she'd completed the work and been paid in full several months before my redundancy. All my mum banged on about awful it would have been if she'd ended up not getting paid.

It raining torrentially on the morning of my wedding and ruining our (sister was bridesmaid) newly done hair. Sister wailed and cried. Mum still talks about how awful it was that she was so upset that day when she "only wanted to look nice". I was the bride and mine looked shit as well!

Me daring to have a baby girl. Sister has two sons and was so jealous she cut me off. Parents defended her "because she sensitive" and won't put any photos of my daughter up at their house in case it upsets her.

Now VLC.

Sorry for the hijack. Aaaahhh ... I feel better now!

Swipe left for the next trending thread