Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Responding to people asking why I'm not wearing a mask

309 replies

PhasedRay · 03/07/2021 19:09

I can't wear a face mask and am exempt due to having issues which make it extremely uncomfortable and difficult to wear. At the start of the pandemic I used to explain to people who asked why I can't, but I was getting some nasty comments and it's made me quite cynical. When someone asks now, I just tell them to mind their own business.

AIBU? I think that rather abrupt response probably would sound unreasonable from the perspective of someone who has just asked a single question, but I have been getting questioned (feels more like an interrogation sometimes) for nearly a year and I am just sick of it.

OP posts:
LetsGoFlyAKiteee · 04/07/2021 14:10

People don’t have eyes in the back of their head. You can’t control who is going to sit next to you on a bus or queue behind you at the checkouts. I can stop myself getting too close to someone, but I can’t stop them getting to close to me

But that's different to approaching someone and asking. Or filming which seemed to be the thing last year which thankfully has stopped. People in queue still should be distancing so nothing wrong with asking to step back.

But from the 19th the whole mask questions will be no more from sounds anyway. If that goes ahead but being reported more now so guessing it's true.

DroopyClematis · 04/07/2021 14:09

Daughter commutes to London. She says that more than half of people either don't wear their masks or pull them down once on the train.

She works in a major tourist attraction and is regularly abused by members of the public when she politely asks them to wear a mask, which they usually refuse to anyway.

Lilibet2022 · 04/07/2021 14:03

When all the vulnerable people have long been vaccinated, and a huge portion of the overall adult population, isn't it time we stopped wearing the sodding mask

Only they haven't. One of my parents had terminal cancer. They only just had their second vaccine last month. Long after the likes of Stanley two jabs didn't need to wear a mask Johnson did.
Said parent was in a line of cancer patients who aren't fully vaccinated yet.

StickyStick · 04/07/2021 13:56

I have been wearing a sunflower lanyard from the start and in all that time I’ve only been challenged once, and that was from a very aggressive guy in a post office who was coming out as I was going in with a large parcel, and I don’t think he’d seen it when he said what he said.

I don’t think anyone really wants to know (or tell) personal medical history in public, or cause a confrontation unnecessarily, so I think wearing a lanyard is a polite thing to do. It also has the huge advantage that people are much more likely to keep their distance. It’s much safer to be 2-3 metres away from someone than be jammed up right next to them wearing loose face coverings.

SmudgeButt · 04/07/2021 13:46

I can't wear one and so have opted for a highly ridiculously florescent orange baseball cap with a clip on visor. The joy of it is that it really attracts the attention of small children and they can see when I poke my tongue out at them. (best done when the accompanying adult isn't looking)

What really bugs me though is that people with masks often feel there's no need to distance from me and will lean across me in the shops to get they urgently needed tin of beans. If irritated enough I'll loudly tell them to keep clear as they are not safe from my germs.

TakesTheHindLeg · 04/07/2021 13:46

Why are you going out if you can’t wear a mask to protect other people?

Work, school and nursery runs, grocery shopping, playgrounds with kids, seeing friends. Life goes on. People with disabilities or lung problems have as much right to go out as anyone else. My friend’s a nurse, she caught covid that caused serious damage to her lungs. She can’t wear a mask anymore as she struggles to breathe. A lot of keyworkers (who kept the country running and cared for ill people in the peaks) now have long term breathing difficulties. Should we punish them?

I've certainly got up and moved when someone without a mask has sat right next to me (literally 2 inches rather than 2 metres) on a train or bus.

Remember people without masks may have hidden disabilities that mean they can’t stand for long. That seat on the bus/train/bench might be more important than the 2m rule! If you’re in pain or about to faint, social distancing and masks aren’t going to be top priory.

Aprilinspringtimeshower · 04/07/2021 13:40

I think a quick friendly “have you forget your mask” is acceptable. I have twice gone into a shop slightly distracted and forgotten to put my mask on first. The person can then respond “I’m exempt” . Not that I’ve done this myself. But someone did say it to me when I forgot and I was glad they did and scuttled out quick to put it on.
But then I have worked introduction facilities for years that demanded hair covers and face masks- it was absolutely consider the appropriate thing to tell someone who wasn’t wearing their mask to go and put it on- usually all it took was a pointing to their mouth or hair and then the person was usually mortified they forgot and dashed back out to put one on.
It doesn’t need to be high stakes, aggressive …just a friendly check in

user1497207191 · 04/07/2021 13:30

@LetsGoFlyAKiteee

But from sounds..if rumours are true. Masks will become a choice anyway in 2 weeks. Might just be paper talk and speculation but will see.

I just dont get people going close to a maskless person to ask them. Especially cause if their answer is because of past trauma then what would you say. Just wall away?

Recording confrontation seems to be a bit look a me how many likes can this get

People don’t have eyes in the back of their head. You can’t control who is going to sit next to you on a bus or queue behind you at the checkouts. I can stop myself getting too close to someone, but I can’t stop them getting to close to me.
2021DNA · 04/07/2021 13:22

COVID is here to stay.

I didn’t suggest that Covid-19 would go away.

Were you ever this concerned over other people getting the flu?

I’m not concerned about people catching the ful or Covid for that matter.

Or do you only but I to the fear that's playing out at the moment?

I’ll need an English translation to this statement before I can respond.

QueenBee52 · 04/07/2021 13:15

I would like to know exactly who and where OP was challenged about lack of Mask but has not returned. 🌸

Happy36 · 04/07/2021 13:13

Is this in the UK?

I've lived in 2 EU countries during the pandemic and neither of them has exceptions. Many people here would be frightened / panicked to see someone without a mask, particularly somewhere like inside a food shop or on public transport.

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 04/07/2021 13:11

@2021DNA

Ah so now people with ill health, disabilities and past trauma should now stay home forever and ever amen because it's too hard for you to stay 2m away from them

You do understand that the nature of a pandemic means it won’t go on forever?

COVID is here to stay.

Were you ever this concerned over other people getting the flu? Or do you only but I to the fear that's playing out at the moment?

LakieLady · 04/07/2021 13:09

@Lilibet2022

They’re for people with hidden disabilities if they choose to wear one - been around long before the pandemic. Somehow they’ve been co-opted to mean “mask exempt”.

This. I dislike the fact they've been appropriated significantly by the cranks. A friend of mine who's genuinely exempt and I know the reasons behind it gets questioned every time because of the selfish arseholes. There are very few actually exempt people in the circles I know of. All very genuine reasons which they chose to share and weren't forced to. The others because they don't want to be controlled Hmm
A supermarket worker here has been posting covid is a hoax stuff all over their social media posts for a year to the point I blocked them but has an 'I'm exempt' badge when at work. So yes whilst most exempt cases will be genuine it can't be denied that a tiny minority are abusing the lanyard and exempt conditions. I'm exempt. I wear one. The only time I truly struggled was for an extended waiting period at a hospital appointment. I can manage perfectly fine in the 20 minutes it takes to do a shop etc.

This.

My idiot stepson and his Covid-denying friends just say they're exempt if they're challenged.

They ignore all the other social distancing rules too and have been mixing socially since the start, so they've probably transmitted Covid to dozens of people.

slashlover · 04/07/2021 12:49

@Awwlookatmybabyspider

Is it not against the Disabilities act (Not sure of the full name, sorry) to ask why a,person isn't wearing a mask. Wasn't a women awarded £7K a few months back after being quizzed. These little Hitlers could find themselves in deep trouble
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin%27s_law
slashlover · 04/07/2021 12:48

[quote StamfordHill]Yes, the cdc says so. As do many others. While it's too early for conclusive data, preliminary studies suggest vaccination is highly effective in curbing infection.

www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/vaccines/keythingstoknow.html[/quote]
Vaccinated people don't spread it in the first place

is different to what you linked which says

COVID-19 vaccines reduce the risk of people spreading the virus

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 04/07/2021 12:44

Is it not against the Disabilities act (Not sure of the full name, sorry) to ask why a,person isn't wearing a mask. Wasn't a women awarded £7K a few months back after being quizzed. These little Hitlers could find themselves in deep trouble

StamfordHill · 04/07/2021 12:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

LetsGoFlyAKiteee · 04/07/2021 12:38

Walk*

LetsGoFlyAKiteee · 04/07/2021 12:38

But from sounds..if rumours are true. Masks will become a choice anyway in 2 weeks. Might just be paper talk and speculation but will see.

I just dont get people going close to a maskless person to ask them. Especially cause if their answer is because of past trauma then what would you say. Just wall away?

Recording confrontation seems to be a bit look a me how many likes can this get

slashlover · 04/07/2021 12:33

@Soverymuchfruit

It also depends on how you behave. You know that, however valid your reasons for exemption, if you talk to a person indoors at close quarters then you will be putting them at greater risk and may very reasonably make them uncomfortable? If you are careful to keep your distance esp when taking then fair enough.

(But if, otoh, you plonk yourself right down next to a visible vulnerable person on public transport, along with your non mask wearing mate, and then have a long loud conversation in her face, don't be surprised if you piss people off.)

This. I have never asked someone not wearing a mask why, and I absolutely never would. However, there were two maskless women sitting on the front seats of the bus yesterday having a loud conversation across the aisle so that every person who got on or off of the bus had to walk between them.

It also seems to be maskless people (or those wearing them on their chin) who don't seem able to follow the arrows on the floor of the local shopping centre or not brush against me in shops.

Turkishangora · 04/07/2021 12:32

@FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop

Also I don't think you can blame Dominic Cummings. People were compliant, now their liberties are being taken away over something that, it turns out, wasn't as bad as was promised. Unless your freedom includes attending football or Ascot. Everyone is getting sick of it, and we as a nation are being gaslighted into thinking it's acceptable that 60,000 football fans can congregate but we can't attend our children's sports days. I don't blame people for ditching masks and refusing to buy into the melodramatic fear.
Completely agree with this 100%. A lot of "friends" seem to be visibly enjoying the melodrama and all that goes with the fear. Makes me seethe that yet again the younger generation are coming off worse, no sports days, no proms, no transition days, languishing at home for "self isolation" and it goes on and on and on...
shivawn · 04/07/2021 12:31

People who genuinely have respiratory conditions will wear a mask. My asthma, copd and lung cancer patients will all wear masks no problem because they know they're high risk and aren't going to make a fuss about protecting themselves. I have to roll my eyes when I hear people loudly declaring they have asthma while walking in to shops with no mask.

@walkoflifewoohoo that was rude of them. Or it would be if it had happened.

GrinGrinGrin Yep!

TheFoundations · 04/07/2021 12:29

@StamfordHill

When all the vulnerable people have long been vaccinated, and a huge portion of the overall adult population, isn't it time we stopped wearing the sodding masks?

Vaccinated people don't spread it in the first place (far better evidence for that than for masks), and anyone posting here is probably vaccinated, so almost no risk of getting infected.

Have you got a link to any articles regarding vaccinated people not spreading it? It's different from what I thought.
PumpkinKlNG · 04/07/2021 12:25

I’ve seen plenty of recordings online of people being confronted by members of the public for not wearing a mask

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 04/07/2021 12:22

Ive not seen anyone bar employees of establishments reminding people to wear one where they can.

I just avoid people with a wide berth if no mask as it’s seems more haven’t than have at present and they can’t all be truly exempt. Given how many aren’t testing or isolating currently we will limit our exposure to others as much as is possible.