Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Responding to people asking why I'm not wearing a mask

309 replies

PhasedRay · 03/07/2021 19:09

I can't wear a face mask and am exempt due to having issues which make it extremely uncomfortable and difficult to wear. At the start of the pandemic I used to explain to people who asked why I can't, but I was getting some nasty comments and it's made me quite cynical. When someone asks now, I just tell them to mind their own business.

AIBU? I think that rather abrupt response probably would sound unreasonable from the perspective of someone who has just asked a single question, but I have been getting questioned (feels more like an interrogation sometimes) for nearly a year and I am just sick of it.

OP posts:
Stinkysteamy · 05/07/2021 08:21

Again if you live somewhere with no exemptions it means that some people are not being allowed out. Countries of course can make their own rules but don't think for one minute that it means everyone in that country can wear a masj and that there aren't severely disabled people unable to access services and in some cases getting very distressed indoors.

MrsSchadenfreude · 05/07/2021 08:06

@Gavellar me too. No mask, no entry to shops or public transport, and until a couple of weeks ago we had to wear masks in the street as well. I got a bus home with a friend the other week, we were the only 2 on the bus and the bus driver told us to make sure we kept our masks on.

Stinkysteamy · 05/07/2021 06:04

"Elsewhere people just do it."

I think you will find there are severely disabled people in every country. It is just that in some countries they are not allowed out.

Gavellar · 05/07/2021 05:00

Because they are so visible masks are like a badge in the UK and US. Either wearing one and or making a statement against civud or telling the world you are special. I will be glad when the damn things have gone, they make people weird.

Gavellar · 05/07/2021 04:56

I'm torn on this. I live overseas where there is no exemption and it just doesn't seem to be an issue. I never see people collapsing or any drame about wearing a mask, people just do. I think some of this exemption stuff is just attention seeking nonsense to be honest. Elsewhere people just do it.

ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 05/07/2021 01:39

@JediGnot

I think, OP, that you need to target your anger at those who choose not to wear masks, choose to ignore the rules, choose to spread lies about vaccines. Those are the people responsible for the fact that I will view you with contempt when I see you without a mask, even though I know (or rather, am lead to believe) that a tiny minority of people can't wear one.
Agreed as otherwise the same issue with fake blue badge parking as it makes a mockery of any system based on trust (when most can’t be trusted) and a sense of civic duty of care to each other when record per capita Covid fatalities data indicates this is not the case. When every DIY sticker or most lanyard purchased online is fake - is when the spreading continues as those with least health privilege disproportionately suffer the harm caused by others. These less medically health privileged people also have ever right to enter private premises like retail where public are invited to enter subject to sensible but safe as possible health and safety rules and measures suitable in mitigating known risks. Shop keepers have every right to reject trouble makers be it those who enter to steal or cause a disturbance or even wearing inappropriate attire as to offend unless for instance in a beach or swimming pool side retail setting where clothing is more relaxed. Shop keepers have a legal duty to keep their staff and premises safe as well as the safety of invited shoppers. They therefore have a right in a pandemic control entry into their private indoor property which may indeed include all globally accepted and agreed best practice Covid risk mitigation measures. In a pandemic one cannot pander to the few but endeavour to implement measures to save as many as possible. It is offensive and disproportionate to think certain rights of a very minority of individuals trump the health and safety of the rest of the population. Reasonable pragmatic adaptations are required in exceptional cases. No one is exempt from the pandemic. There is no exempt as exempt from what exactly? No one is asking why you are exempt from anything or what items of clothing you wear or don’t/can’t wear as the real question is are you Covid free and safe for others as if so, it is immaterial what you put around your head or not. We are either all in this together or some are potentially a part of problem and not a part of the solution prolonging restrictions and potentially leading to more lives and livelihoods lost. The UK government has evidently not been proactive as testament to the world beating per capita Covid data and can not be trusted to follow the data let alone the science.
XenoBitch · 05/07/2021 00:32

@CrouchEndTiger12

Something along the lines of

I'm not wearing any knickers either

That will shut them right up Smile

One of those comebacks I think of when I get home...

Along with "my mask is in the same section as the 'mind your own business' aisle".

CrouchEndTiger12 · 05/07/2021 00:30

Something along the lines of

I'm not wearing any knickers either

That will shut them right up Smile

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 05/07/2021 00:26

Dd is asthmatic and can’t wear one - I know some asthmatics can but they affected her really badly.

She’s got a prepared thing to say about how you don’t have to explain why, I forget the exact words. Sadly people are even more likely to challenge teens.

Thekormachameleon · 04/07/2021 23:46

Just don't let it bother you

I'm exempt, I do try and wear a mask where possible but I'm also having a severe asthma flare so it's incredibly difficult
I don't go out much as a CEV person but on the rare occasion I've been challenged I just say mind your business
And if pressed I find a "fuck off" is a good way to end the conversation

XenoBitch · 04/07/2021 23:29

[quote MercyBooth]@XenoBitch Bet they wouldnt say anything to him.[/quote]
Of course. They go for easy targets like women on their own.

MercyBooth · 04/07/2021 23:23

@XenoBitch Bet they wouldnt say anything to him.

XenoBitch · 04/07/2021 23:09

Id say 95% of people use it as an excuse....what makes me more angry is those then smoking too

What has smoking got to do with it? I have a friend who smokes like a chimney but can't wear a mask due to mental health issues. He is also a big man with tattoos. I would imagine most people would see him without a mask and think he is taking the piss.

IceBearRocks · 04/07/2021 23:05

My dad has COPD. Uses oxygen over night at SATS usually 92. He wears a mask. Wore one for 4 hours on a train.

Sometimes I think it is an excuse..... I am not you so I can never understand but I know if my dad can do it then most people can!!! Its hilarious watching families of 4 walking around with Lanyards.
My disabled boy can't wear a face mask...we have tried...but then he can't brush his teeth due to sensory problems!!!
Id say 95% of people use it as an excuse....what makes me more angry is those then smoking too.

user1497207191 · 04/07/2021 19:28

@ShortBacknSides

Seems silly to take both masks and distancing away but that's how it's heading.

I think it's going to be disastrous ...

I don't see rates of infection rising any faster than they are already. People who don't care, don't care anyway. Those who do care will continue to take precautions according to personal risk assessment and personal responsibility.

Schools closing for Summer at around the same time will make a massive difference and the reduction in school infection will offset any increase in other activities.

ShortBacknSides · 04/07/2021 19:01

They ended in my state 21 days ago, and new cases are trending down, and there have been zero deaths

That's good to read @steff13 Do you have the Delta variant there ?

WhiskeyTangoFoxtrot1 · 04/07/2021 18:37

@Soverymuchfruit

It also depends on how you behave. You know that, however valid your reasons for exemption, if you talk to a person indoors at close quarters then you will be putting them at greater risk and may very reasonably make them uncomfortable? If you are careful to keep your distance esp when taking then fair enough.

(But if, otoh, you plonk yourself right down next to a visible vulnerable person on public transport, along with your non mask wearing mate, and then have a long loud conversation in her face, don't be surprised if you piss people off.)

This is how I feel, if someone can't wear a mask then that's on them, but please at least SD from me. You don't know mine or my family's vulnerability, and just because you're exempt from a mask, doesn't make you exempt from covid.

Same with people who wear masks under their noses.

steff13 · 04/07/2021 18:13

@ShortBacknSides

Seems silly to take both masks and distancing away but that's how it's heading.

I think it's going to be disastrous ...

They ended in my state 21 days ago, and new cases are trending down, and there have been zero deaths.
TheGenealogist · 04/07/2021 18:06

All you need to say is "I'm exempt". Repeatedly, if the numpty concerned is not getting the message.

Why are you not wearing a mask?
I'm exempt.
But what's wrong with you?
I'm exempt.
Do you have an illness or something.
I'm exempt.

And so on. Although to be fair, I'd have walked off after the first "i'm exempt".

Dobbyisahouseelf · 04/07/2021 18:04

Perhaps a sunflower lanyard? Most people have realised what these represent so don't question the wearer, not that I would dream of asking someone.

Although I might raise an eyebrow to a group of 'males/youngsters' who all were unable to wear a face mask.

MercyBooth · 04/07/2021 17:46

Or it would be if it had happened

Ableists when you relate an experience...............it never happened.
Ableists when you relate an experience and also upload the film you took on your phone "how dare you film someone without their consent"

memberofthewedding · 04/07/2021 17:33

Ive only worn a mask on one occasion and for all the good it would have done it was a lace one.

Shanghaisprize · 04/07/2021 17:31

Say you're exempt? If that isn't enough, they're being rude.

KurtWilde · 04/07/2021 17:31

@XenoBitch my son in law was told to remove his when he was with my DD when she was in labour last week. The midwife said to him 'pointless thing, take it off, she needs to see your face.'

Hopefully we're coming to the end of all this ridiculousness over masks, although I'm sure some will continue to wear them as virtue signals.

Newkitchen123 · 04/07/2021 17:28

Has this topic not been done to death over the last year or so?