Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate double entry bookkeeping?

114 replies

SunFlowerRose · 03/07/2021 09:26

I’m really hoping you will be able to help me, because this is my last ditch attempt before I throw away 8 months worth of payments on a bookkeeping and accounting course which would cost even more in an early get out fee.

I work full time in finance for a small company, but they use an accounting software so most of it’s all done in the background.

I’m on the first model of the level 2 online course and I just cannot retain the information or make it sink in.

The double entry part and transactions just isn’t making sense and I’m about to lose all hope on it.

If anyone has any resources that helped them such as YouTube videos, links or books then please please do share them.

I’m off to WH Smith later to look at the books they have, in hopes to find one that may help. Along with A3 paper that I plan to right notes on and stick all over the house.

If any bookkeepers would be willing to inbox me and help me with this I’d be super grateful.

I’ve wasted 8 months on this so far and just feel incredibly stupid. And I want this so badly for my current career, it would help me progress so much.

Apologies for putting it in AIBU I was hoping more people would see it and maybe be able to help. Please be kind as I already feel crap enough.

OP posts:
Merryoldgoat · 03/07/2021 10:07

I would recommend you stop trying to rationalise that particular part of accounting. I think I got an explanation for it when I started out thirty years ago, but mainly I accept that it is an accounting convention that assets are debits and liabilities are credits.

I agree wholeheartedly with this. Learn and accept the definitions. It is what it is and once you get it and move forward it will crystallise.

StormzyinaTCup · 03/07/2021 10:06

I came into bookkeeping and accounting after spending 18 years in banking/finance. The biggest challenge for me was posting debits and credits in the reverse way. In the early days I had to check myself constantly as my brain was programmed to banking.

I used to just remind myself in the early days:

“Debit all that comes in and credit all that goes out.”

then allocate accordingly DR income (loans, sales, grants etc) CR outgoings/expenses (salaries, loan repayments, vat, etc).

I'm not sure if that's any help and I might be 'teaching granny to suck eggs' with the above simplified explanation but I do feel your frustration.

Merryoldgoat · 03/07/2021 10:05

Look here:

opentuition.com/fia/fa1/?amp

Free open source accounting tutorials with associated YouTube tutorials - they’re quite good. A bit dry. But it IS accountancy… 🤷🏾‍♀️

Aprilx · 03/07/2021 10:04

@SunFlowerRose

Aprilx I think it confuses me that when you receive money into the bank it’s classes as a debit, and then whatever was paid is classed as a credit, so for example Cost of Goods Sold?

I think because I spend 8 hours a day at work staring at spreadsheets and invoices and dealing with stuff that takes concentration, by the time I get home and try and focus on learning this my poor brain is done.

I would recommend you stop trying to rationalise that particular part of accounting. I think I got an explanation for it when I started out thirty years ago, but mainly I accept that it is an accounting convention that assets are debits and liabilities are credits.

So if you get more assets you need to dr assets, whereas if you get rid of / spend some, then it is going down so your asset is credited.

GrrrlPwr · 03/07/2021 10:02

Get a pad of A3 paper, turn it sideways. Grab pencils pens and felt tips.
Make it colourful!
Draw wee pictures of money, stuff you buy, then picture what happens to it- using that D acronym.

Then do lots of worked examples.

You will get it

Morgan12 · 03/07/2021 10:02

I with you. Luca Pacioli is a dick.

Merryoldgoat · 03/07/2021 09:59

@SunFlowerRose

Ok so let’s look at another one.

If I purchase something on a 30 day credit account would it be…
Debit to the assets?
Credit to the purchase ledger?

Then once paid would it be..
Debit to purchase ledger
Credit to bank?

Your are purchasing something. What is it? Because it’s either an normal expense or an asset. BOTH are debits but the type of purchase is what determines whether expenses or assets are debited.

So you have the opposing credit.

If you are paying immediately with no credit account you just credit the bank. Job done.

But this is a credit account - a creditor. So your credit goes here and goes into the pot of all items due to be paid at some point.

When you’re ready to pay what is happening? Cash out so you credit cash and the debit goes to creditors to reduce the liability in creditors.

JeanClaudeVanDammit · 03/07/2021 09:58

@MartyHart

Think of the bank being the wrong way round. That really helped me. It's from their point of view iyswim
This is what helped me the most tbh.
mrsbyers · 03/07/2021 09:58

I recommend a book called double entry or double Dutch - helped me loads

Itstoofuckingwarm · 03/07/2021 09:57

You’re saying it isn’t sinking in with DEADCLIC - it will you just need to give it more time.

When I first started AAT I would overthink it and put things on the wrong side but I think if you just don’t over complicate it or overthink it and accept that to begin with you might not understand why a liability is a credit but just accept that it is - eventually you’ll get there.

So for example you have a loan of 30000 and 15000 in your bank. To pay back 5000 of that loan your credit your bank by 5000 because you’re reducing your asset (being the 15000 currently in the bank) and you’d debit the loan because you’re decreasing that liability.

ineedaholidaynow · 03/07/2021 09:57

When I first started to learn bookkeeping I used to get confused as the way I looked at my bank account and the terminology I used seemed to be at odds with debits and credits, but I soon got used to it.

If you think about it along the lines if you receive something be it physical or a service that will be a debit, and the opposite entry will be a credit.

So in your example above if you buy a PC you physically have an asset (the PC) so that will be a debit and you will have reduced the money in your bank account so that will be a credit to that account.

If you pay your electricity bill, you have received electricity, an expense, so a debit and again reduced the money in your bank account, a credit.

With sales you receive money so increased your bank account, a debit, and provided someone else with an asset or service so a credit for you. If someone doesn’t pay immediately the debit entry would be to debtors. When you receive the money you would debit your bank account and reduce (credit) debtors.

Summernamechange2021 · 03/07/2021 09:57

@SunFlowerRose

Ok so let’s look at another one.

If I purchase something on a 30 day credit account would it be…
Debit to the assets?
Credit to the purchase ledger?

Then once paid would it be..
Debit to purchase ledger
Credit to bank?

Yeah, you have that one right

Debit the asset/expense depending on what youbhave bought
Credit the liability (the creditor/payable)

Then when paid you are
Debiting that liability to clear it
Crediting the bank to reduce your cash balance

Nacreous · 03/07/2021 09:55

Can you borrow "accounting for dummies" from the library? I don't know if it will help so probably not worth buying it til you've had a look but that really helped me.

Doing Drs and Crs confused me for ages, it took a long time for me to understand it.

What I ended up doing to start with was doing it as "increase" and "decrease" and then fitting the debits and credits on later.

E.g. the first principle is the debits and credits of every transaction add up to zero.

So say we sell something for cash: we know we need to increase cash by e.g. £10 and sales by £10.

So we know cash is an asset, which means under DEAD CLIC, increasing an asset is a debit. That means we know we have to debit cash £10. Give. The debits and credits add up to zero we then know this:

Increase cash: DR Cash £10
Increase sales: ? Sales £10.

So then we know we must have to credit sales, because that's the only way the debits and the credits of the transaction add up to zero.

1lov3comps · 03/07/2021 09:55

Debit the receiver, credit the giver

Always worked for me. So if you get money into a bank account, it's a debit on the T account because that Account is receiving it.

It's a credit on your bank statement because the bank owe it to you so it's more equivalent to a creditor account as far as they're concerned,

SunFlowerRose · 03/07/2021 09:55

Merry I finally do have a tutor supporting me but haven’t spoken to him on the phone yet because I’m just so frustrated that I suspect it will end up in a big rant.

For the first 6 months I was assigned a different tutor and she ignored all my emails so I had no help at all!

So it’s all kind of snow balled to me getting frustrated and angry at myself and to a point where my brains just given up with it.

OP posts:
Summernamechange2021 · 03/07/2021 09:54

@SunFlowerRose

Merry I think I understand some of it but not all. I know that money into the bank is a debit and money out is a credit. That if you sell goods then that account would be credited. If you pay a supplier the bank is credited but the supplier account is surely also credited?

If you by a pc for the company then bank account is debit and assets credited?

See I’m all confused again! Grrrr.

Paying a creditor:

Credit the bank (decreasing your asset)
Debit the supplier account (decreasing your creditor/liability)

Spinningaround18 · 03/07/2021 09:54

First Intuition are fab and have quite a few YouTube videos that may help! There are AAT Fb groups too where people ask questions when stuck so they may be useful :)

SunFlowerRose · 03/07/2021 09:53

Ok so let’s look at another one.

If I purchase something on a 30 day credit account would it be…
Debit to the assets?
Credit to the purchase ledger?

Then once paid would it be..
Debit to purchase ledger
Credit to bank?

OP posts:
Merryoldgoat · 03/07/2021 09:53

What support are you getting from your tutors OP and how long have you been studying this module?

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 03/07/2021 09:52

Because there is always an opposite, when money comes into the bank, the actual bank account is credited, so in the books it's a debit.

Itstoofuckingwarm · 03/07/2021 09:51

Yes DEADCLIC helps so much.

It does take a while to get it but once you’re there it makes sense and it’s the fundamental of everything you’ll do in bookkeeping/accountancy so you’re definitely doing the right thing putting the time and effort in to understand it.

Mack33 · 03/07/2021 09:51

In your example buying a computer you debit to increase fixed assets as you now have a computer and credit the bank as you reduced your cash balance.

goodnessidontknow · 03/07/2021 09:49

You need to learn the PEARLS of wisdom!
images.app.goo.gl/7CrBGYyJyqaRzbCb6

It's one of those things where you have to learn the rules by rote then after you've chanted "credit creditors" enough times it seems to fall into place and in 10 years you'll struggle to understand why someone finds it confusing 😁

The bank is always a tricky one to start with as it's the other way round from the statement we're used to looking at. My tutor helped by explaining that the bank statement for your personal bank account is prepared from the banks perspective not yours, so by paying in money you increase the liability the bank has to repay you, hence it's a credit on your statement.

covidcloser · 03/07/2021 09:48

@MartyHart

Think of the bank being the wrong way round. That really helped me. It's from their point of view iyswim

This.

It took me so long before finally realising the bank didn't make sense because I was viewing it from my POV.

SunFlowerRose · 03/07/2021 09:48

I’ve tried deadclic and other ways and it just isn’t sinking in.
I’m going to buy A3 paper and sharpies later and stick paper all over my house. So anything recommended by you lovely people I’ll be writing on them.
I really really want to get these and for work I remember at least 20 processes some of them really complicated. So I just don’t understand why I can’t get this one ☹️

Most people have passed the course by now and I can’t even think about booking my first exam. Even some of the invoice and credit stuff where you have to list the items and totals I get wrong as the rounding up the decimal point for vat and none vat I can’t retain.

I’ve been to uni in the past and managed to get really good grades. If it were essay writing I’d be fine but it’s all numbers and brain power.

I really do feel stupid.

OP posts: