Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate double entry bookkeeping?

114 replies

SunFlowerRose · 03/07/2021 09:26

I’m really hoping you will be able to help me, because this is my last ditch attempt before I throw away 8 months worth of payments on a bookkeeping and accounting course which would cost even more in an early get out fee.

I work full time in finance for a small company, but they use an accounting software so most of it’s all done in the background.

I’m on the first model of the level 2 online course and I just cannot retain the information or make it sink in.

The double entry part and transactions just isn’t making sense and I’m about to lose all hope on it.

If anyone has any resources that helped them such as YouTube videos, links or books then please please do share them.

I’m off to WH Smith later to look at the books they have, in hopes to find one that may help. Along with A3 paper that I plan to right notes on and stick all over the house.

If any bookkeepers would be willing to inbox me and help me with this I’d be super grateful.

I’ve wasted 8 months on this so far and just feel incredibly stupid. And I want this so badly for my current career, it would help me progress so much.

Apologies for putting it in AIBU I was hoping more people would see it and maybe be able to help. Please be kind as I already feel crap enough.

OP posts:
user1497207191 · 03/07/2021 18:40

[quote ineedaholidaynow]@user1497207191 I remember people talking about debits on the window side but never understood that![/quote]
I think it comes from the old days where big firms had a room full of ledger clerks, all sat at desks facing the same way (old fashioned classroom style). There seems to be a reason why they were usually sat with the window to the left, perhaps it was just custom, or maybe because that favours the right handed majority (so the hand is away from the window thus no shadows to make reading the ledger harder?). I went to an old fashioned school in the 70s and all their classrooms were configured so you were sat in rows with the window to the left in the same way!

ineedaholidaynow · 03/07/2021 17:51

@user1497207191 I remember people talking about debits on the window side but never understood that!

user1497207191 · 03/07/2021 17:15

When I learned it, we were taught to concentrate more on debits on the left, credits on the right, but that was back in the 80's when balance sheets were landscape orientated, i.e. assets on the left, liabilities on the right. Even modern columnar P&L is similar, i.e. usually with sales as first line, but on the right, with expenses etc inset to the left (although there is now a trend for everything in single column). If you're struggling, it may be good to try going back to the "old" fashioned way of left and right rather than the more modern way of columns.

(There is also the wonderful old story of people saying they were taught "debits on the window" side which only works if you're desk is positioned the right way! Whether true or not, it's another way of remembering which side debits and credits are on. A modern alternative may be to have a big Debit sign on the left of your desk and a big Credit sign on the right).

You need to find whatever works for you. It's just a short term "crutch" whilst you're learning and you'll soon find you don't need it.

Bakingdiva · 03/07/2021 16:59

[quote Welshflowerpower]@Bakingdiva do you offer your teaching to anyone or just through courses? Thanks[/quote]
@Welshflowerpower I mostly teach courses but I do some 1-2-1 tutoring at times too

burnoutbabe · 03/07/2021 16:18

is it that double entry is hard?

or that the P&L and balance sheet split is hard?

so its logical to think that buying something credits cash and then Debits the expense. But some expenses go to P&L and some are assets on balance sheet so SEEM to be the other way round.

Mostly it goes to the P&L if short term expense (rent for a month) and Balance sheet if a long term expense (buying a building)

so i think you need to work debits and credits into TB's and Bal sheet/P&L all at same time to understand.

there are only 10 or so main types of things that can happen though

pay expense/make a sale/buy stock/sell stock. Buy an asset (then depreciate it). then you have it when you don't pay or get the cash immediately and it becomes a debtor or creditor. and when you do things in advance or areares of the benefit (ie pay a years rent upfront and have to split the expense into correct periods)

So you can keep practising the main types of transaction.

Welshflowerpower · 03/07/2021 16:04

@Bakingdiva do you offer your teaching to anyone or just through courses? Thanks

Merryoldgoat · 03/07/2021 15:53

Genuinely OP - drop me a DM if you’d like someone to go through some sample questions - I think that knowing the approach to take is half the battle.

All the acronyms etc can be helpful but understanding how all of the transactions affect the accounts is the key.

It’s what will enable you to visualise what the effect should be and pick out anomalies by sight.

I can look at my draft management accounts and see immediately where I need to spend some extra time or look into something that looks off.

That comes with time and experience and a solid foundation will get you there.

SunFlowerRose · 03/07/2021 13:44

I haven’t caught up on all the posts yet but will read through them all after I’ve eaten lunch.
We went to WH Smith and they didn’t have a single accounting or bookkeeping book in stock.
So I’ve come home with A4 plain paper, felt tip pens and blue tack. It’s a start and still means I can get notes around the house on hopes if I see it whatever I’m doing I’ll hopefully get it right?

I’m answer regarding the company I work for, as it’s such a small company the FD does all the major accounting stuff and makes sure the company runs as it should. We did have a full time bookkeeper who retired and my current role at the time wasn’t take my full time hours so the FD taught me the parts she could hand over.

I love my job because it’s not just admin and finance that I do. I do so many different things as part of my role so I never get bored.

But this means if I can become qualified I
Could take even more off the FD which would mean a pay rise and more responsibility.

I’d also love to have the possibility to set up my own self employed company on the side for vat returns and things that people would rather pay someone else to do. I’m not saying it’s as simple as that, but it’s an idea.

Of all the processes I do every day at work, not all financial, I do around 20-25 every day or week. And I remember all the steps even the really complicated ones. So if I can get my head around this and it sinks in I’ll do well. It’s just getting to that stage before my course runs out.

I have until November to complete the whole of level 2 and then level 3 starts! My tutor has offered me a 3 month extension but that’s still a really short amount of time to cram in and learn the whole of level 2 ☹️

OP posts:
soooooooG · 03/07/2021 13:34

My colleague taught me to think of debits with your left arm waving in and credits with your right arm waving out.

No idea but it always helped me.

Also looking at how things relate to the P&L/balance sheet.

Bakingdiva · 03/07/2021 13:23

I am a retired accountant and now I teach accounting. When my students are struggling I tell them to always write DEADCLIC at the top of the page as that is the best acronym I’ve found for knowing what goes where.

After that when you are starting out, don’t try to think in ‘accounting’. Put what is happening into ‘normal’ language, and kind of talk around what is happening.

So using your buying goods for sale and paying a supplier. Firstly you are buying goods which is an expense for the business and you are creating a payable to a supplier. DEADCLIC tells us that Debits increase EXPENSES, assets and drawings so you know that you are going to debit the expense account for the purchase of goods. DEADCLIC also says that credits increase LIABILITIES, income and capital. The payable to a supplier is a liability so you need to credit it.

When you pay the supplier, you are paying money out of the bank, so reducing your asset and reducing your payable liability. DEADCLIC says that debits INCREASE ASSETS but you are reducing it, so you need to do the opposite and credit the bank asset. Credits INCREASE LIABILITIES but again, you are reducing the payable liability so you need to do the opposite and debit the payable.

When it comes to the bank, the bank statement is from the banks perspective, so when you see a credit on your statement as money in, it is because to the bank, it is a liability that they owe you. A debit on your statement is money out because the bank is reducing their liability to you.

Feel free to PM me if you want any specific help.

Ariela · 03/07/2021 13:01

@SunflowerRose if you're in WHS they should have Bookkeeping for Dummies.

I found this useful when I did the same course (useless very boring tutor who answered questions from the viewpoint of 'you should know what I mean'

Merryoldgoat · 03/07/2021 12:50

@123ZYX

We are likely to have a junior accountant vacancy in about a year and I think I’ll go down the apprenticeship route.

Our auditors (big but not Big Four) have a big school leaver intake to do AAT and then ACA - they are the best auditors I’ve come across. All dedicated, lots of practical experience and very bright.

If any young person came asking about accountancy as a career I’d recommend bypassing university for a course like that. No fees and qualified sooner.

123ZYX · 03/07/2021 12:15

[quote Merryoldgoat]@123ZYX

In my first wholly accounting role I had zero quals. I was a bit shocked to get hired but my very excellent manager (ACA from big firm) told me months later that I had performed way better in the test than all the other candidates, several fully exam qualified. Because I’d worked ‘on the ground’ for a while my technical skills were just stronger.

I always consider QBE and test at interview. I’ve had fully qual applicants who can’t reconcile a bank account.[/quote]
Absolutely. I'm really pleased to see the increase apprenticeships as an entry point to the career. The only real way to learn accountancy is to do it (over, and over, and over...)

cortex10 · 03/07/2021 12:14

Another vote for Frank Woods' manuals - it's been many years since I last used them but they got me through my exams.

user1497207191 · 03/07/2021 12:09

@SunFlowerRose

Merry.. I do admin and some financial tasks. All taught by the FD who is incredibly busy so it was done to free up some of their time. I import invoices, reconcile payments in the bank and approve supplier invoices to reconcile payments out. So I select accounts and catagorys daily on auto entry but it’s mostly automated. Eg if we had an invoice from an electric company then it would be posted onto the company and also under electricity charges.

Sits super hard to get my head around what happens in the background because I’ve never had to even consider that before.

We use Xero for our accounting software.

To be honest, I think you'd have been best having some advanced training on Xero specific to your employers' business. Formal book-keeping/accounting training covers a very broad spectrum and a lot of it won't be relevant to your boss's job, and lots of things that are relevant, won't be taught in the formal book-keeping course.

I've "taught" dozens of clients how to use Xero, Quickbooks, Sage and other software, but I teach it backwards from what they "need" to know as either the owner or book-keeping/administrator of the client firm. No point teaching them payroll matters if they have no staff, nor VAT if they're not VAT registered. But, if they have, say, CIS subbies, they need to know how to do that, but it's not covered in basic book-keeping courses!

If you're main motivation is being trained up to help your boss, then I think you/they have gone down the wrong road. A few hours with your firm's external accountant/auditor (someone who knows the business), would be far more useful to train you up to take some of the strain away from your boss/in-house accountant.

Summernamechange2021 · 03/07/2021 12:04

@ineedaholidaynow I still do manual extended trial balances and its probably my favourite part of my job - I am a very sad person too!

Merryoldgoat · 03/07/2021 12:04

@123ZYX

In my first wholly accounting role I had zero quals. I was a bit shocked to get hired but my very excellent manager (ACA from big firm) told me months later that I had performed way better in the test than all the other candidates, several fully exam qualified. Because I’d worked ‘on the ground’ for a while my technical skills were just stronger.

I always consider QBE and test at interview. I’ve had fully qual applicants who can’t reconcile a bank account.

user1497207191 · 03/07/2021 12:03

[quote ineedaholidaynow]@PullAFace DH and I (both accountants) often reminisce about manual extended trial balances, we must be a very sad couple![/quote]
Funnily enough, my DS has just been doing an accounting module as part of his degree. He was struggling, not with the theory, but the layout of T accounts, etc. I have a pad of old A3 ETB paper from years ago, and showed him how it works. He took to it like a duck to water!

StopCryingYourHeartOut · 03/07/2021 12:02

I'm currently doing this course OP.
I passed the first module (bookkeeping transactions) a couple of months ago.
Do you have the Kaplan manual and integrated workbook?
I do reading the manual first. And doing all the example questions and test your understanding questions one by one.
Then do the integrated workbook afterwards.

I'm actually struggling more with the second unit, Bookkeeping Controls.

ChubbyLittleManInACampervan · 03/07/2021 12:01
user1497207191 · 03/07/2021 11:59

I've been an ACCA for over 30 years, have taught book-keeping at a local college of FE and was responsible for training staff at a couple of accounting practices.

Double entry is hard, it's counter-intuitive. You shouldn't beat yourself up over it. The best staff/students I've had mostly struggled at first. The worst staff/students were the ones who just rote-learned the accounting equation, memorised the debits/credits, but didn't actually understand any of it.

There is only one way to beat it and that's practice, practice and practice some more. The more you do it, the more you start to understand it. Baby steps is the way forward. Don't progress until you've mastered the earlier basics.

I always strongly recommend the Frank Woods basic book-keeping book. You can pick the old ones up from ebay for just a few pounds. No need at all to buy a modern version. The basics of double entry havn't changed in the decades since his books were first written. Not only do they start at a very basic level, there's also lots of practice questions (with answers). The "official" text books for AAT, ACCA etc tend to skirt over the basics too much and move too quickly onto more complex things. That's why Frank Woods books are more useful as they go at a slower pace and concentrate more on the basics.

That's the key, just do loads and loads of practice questions, and once you've done that, do some more. Double entry is really something you can't learn successfully by reading - it's not an "academic" subject, it's a practical subject.

Merryoldgoat · 03/07/2021 11:59

@ineedaholidaynow

I’m fairly sure that learning to keep a set of books in my big red ledger is a reason I found DE fairly intuitive.

I have an old manager who I send questions to when I come across something tricky - when she comes back saying ‘hmmmm, tricky’ I know it’s not an obvious one. You need people you can bounce things off.

123ZYX · 03/07/2021 11:57

Just as reassurance - I'm an auditor, so see the work done by a lot of qualified accountants, and there are a scarily high number of very highly paid qualified accountants who get it wrong.

That's not to say you won't get it. You're clearly willing to put in the work until it clicks for you. I suspect the bad examples I've seen are where they didn't try to get it right in the first place, because they tend to have taken short cuts in other areas as well

Merryoldgoat · 03/07/2021 11:56

@SunFlowerRose

That’s a shame - small company I suppose so no wider team.

If you have an external accountant I’d consider asking if you could shadow one of their bookkeepers one day.

I had a different post a few days ago - I am recruiting for an assistant accountant but having real trouble as lots haven’t had practical bookkeeping experience.

It’s all well and good using software but I need people who can calculate prepayments, accruals, deferred income and dispose of assets etc. All basic double entry but easy to avoid if you work in a small business.

The bookkeepers at your accountants will likely do those entries for some clients monthly/quarterly and I think spending time with them watching them prepare schedules and calculating the amounts would be really useful.

Merryoldgoat · 03/07/2021 11:50

@DwangelaForever

She hasn’t said she finds her job mundane or that or depresses her - it’s that she’s struggling with an aspect.

Finding something hard doesn’t mean you hate it or that it’s not worth persevering with.