Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if you would pay for this?

179 replies

Sunflowers095 · 02/07/2021 20:52

I have a business idea but I wonder if there would actually be a demand. Essentially, I've been thinking a lot about how different backgrounds affect your ability to succeed professionally, as well as how graduates are struggling for work.

It would be a platform for women, the main idea is mentoring. So for example, a student (or someone looking for a career change) would have access to things like CV templates/reviews, forum, 1 on 1 calls with women who have experience/are accomplished in their careers and can act as a mentor.

This would exist as a free and premium version (mentoring would be premium).

It would be a partnership with the mentors directly (where they would be paid a fee) or an agreement with their company to have them represent the business as a mentor. The companies/mentors would benefit by having younger people with skills but no experience provide ideas/small projects. A bit like a competition but the company can use winning ideas.

I am yet to iron out exactly the details but want to validate it first. Personally I would pay for a service like this & I think new generations are less family oriented and more career driven.

It could make a great addition to the CV of the younger women as well as the mentors, serve as a community aimed at helping women succeed professionally.

If the premium version cost for example £20 would you buy it? Assuming it's a monthly rolling subscription that can be cancelled anytime and you can benefit from unlimited resources and a monthly mentoring call? Thanks in advance!

OP posts:
Sunflowers095 · 02/07/2021 21:26

@FizzyPink

There’s also already a company who do this type of thing with students from diverse backgrounds, connecting them with big corporate companies for experience and mentorship that you might like to look at - MyKindaFuture
I'll have a look, thank you so much!
OP posts:
NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 02/07/2021 21:25

There are already various organisations trying to do variants of this and struggling to get people to pay for it because it can be very hard to demonstrate/attribute real value.

I say as a senior professional woman that a bit of paid for mentoring is nothing compared to an upbringing and background full of support and opportunity.

Furthermore, generic mentoring isn't that great. Mentoring has greatest effect when it happens naturally between people in quite similar roles, and it's very difficult to match supply of suitable mentors in the right career areas to demand.

No I don't think any one would pay for this. I certainly wouldnt. I could invited to join a women's network targeting increasing female representation on boards which has tried to charge for some events and services and take up is low.

Sunflowers095 · 02/07/2021 21:25

@foobio

Sorry having re-read, it is not clear whether it is your intention for this to be a money making business, or a charity (which would only need to break even)?
I would like it to be profitable, as a regular business. And I have a few ideas about how to make it profitable without leaving the entire burden of that on the people using the service, but a fee would definitely help.

I think including a probono aspect of it would be good to expand the reach & it would make it easier to engage more mentors to participate and also provide more value to those who genuinely can't afford it.

OP posts:
PercyPiginaWig · 02/07/2021 21:24

How do you know the mentors would even give good objective advice, and not just trot out their particular path. Or what if they got there partly through connections?
What if the mentee doesn't get anywhere? I wouldn't pay £20/month for advice if I didn't have a job.
I personally also feel so busy in my job that I don't know how much time I'd want/feel able to commit as a mentor.

I could just be out of touch though, maybe your target market will react differently.

Have you already got potential mentors in mind? Can you ask them what they think, same goes for potential clients of the service.

FizzyPink · 02/07/2021 21:24

There’s also already a company who do this type of thing with students from diverse backgrounds, connecting them with big corporate companies for experience and mentorship that you might like to look at - MyKindaFuture

Sunflowers095 · 02/07/2021 21:24

@BakedTattie

I think this is a good idea. I found it so so hard to get a foot in the door of any company after I graduated. I was awful at interviews, my cv was shit etc. I would have loved a bit of ‘proper’ guidance. It’s all very well friends and family encouraging you. But it’s awful feeling so downtrodden getting so many rejections and not having any one help you realise your mistakes or help you improve.

I say go for it!

Same here! Took a long time to really understand how to prep for interviews, how to negotiate, how to advance, etc. I'm really happy at where I am now but I think having some guidance would have helped me get here with more ease/sooner. Thanks for the feedback!
OP posts:
foobio · 02/07/2021 21:23

Sorry having re-read, it is not clear whether it is your intention for this to be a money making business, or a charity (which would only need to break even)?

FizzyPink · 02/07/2021 21:21

No, most industries already have mentorship schemes for women and there are plenty of groups/events for “women in advertising” or “women who code” for example.

I also regularly get LinkedIn messages from women with these type of businesses asking if I need help with developing my career/finding my next role. To be honest, it feels a bit like these MLM career coaches that are popping up all over the place at the moment and I consider them to be spam.

Sunflowers095 · 02/07/2021 21:21

@SmellThat

No, 'you might be a young woman from a working class background', how much more patronising can you be I'd avoid you like the plague
??? I'm literally just pointing out that it's harder to advance your career if you're from a working class background.

I myself struggled a lot with adjusting to building my own career since my parents didn't have any experience or understanding of how corporate environments work. Not sure why it's wrong to point this out, maybe you should relax a bit.

OP posts:
BakedTattie · 02/07/2021 21:21

I think this is a good idea. I found it so so hard to get a foot in the door of any company after I graduated. I was awful at interviews, my cv was shit etc. I would have loved a bit of ‘proper’ guidance. It’s all very well friends and family encouraging you. But it’s awful feeling so downtrodden getting so many rejections and not having any one help you realise your mistakes or help you improve.

I say go for it!

Ellewoods20 · 02/07/2021 21:20

I know someone who’s doing something similar for free. She has a popular YouTube and Instagram. Started off as a studytuber and now she’s graduated, she’s doing mentoring.

foobio · 02/07/2021 21:20

Have you run the financials of this, how is it going to make any money? Are you expecting the mentors to volunteer their time? £20 gets you 1 hour 50 minutes of someone's time at London Living Wage, and I think it would be safe to assume that mentors of the calibre you describe would expect significantly more than this. £20pm might be realistic for access to preprepared materials, but anything personalised would be loss making at this price.

GrandDuchessRomanov · 02/07/2021 21:19

No

Maggiesfarm · 02/07/2021 21:19

I don't know but it's a worth a try if it costs little to start up. If it doesn't thrive you will have learned a lot and not lost too much.

SmellThat · 02/07/2021 21:18

No, 'you might be a young woman from a working class background', how much more patronising can you be
I'd avoid you like the plague

girlmom21 · 02/07/2021 21:18

I wouldn't use the service. I'm not a graduate but I do work in a profession where experience is valued and mentoring is literally my job. I think the platform would be way too narrowly focussed and wouldn't lend itself to supporting young women in an accessible way.

I certainly wouldn't pay for use of the platform or feel comfort using it as a mentor.

Sunflowers095 · 02/07/2021 21:17

@MoveOnTheCards

Are you expecting young women from low-income backgrounds to pay a monthly fee for this? I don’t think that would work. It also feels at odds with the ethos of the initiative.

Unless I’m missing something.

People pay for Spotify, Netflix, sky, and other stuff. I think career driven women would be able to prioritize this cost as it could deliver them value rather than entertainment.

There could be a probono initiative where the premium subscription is free for people from the most underprivileged backgrounds.

Also though, often it doesn't come down to money but more a lack of support - if your parents are working class and you want a corporate career it's a lot harder to advance than for someone who has a lot of guidance from family.

OP posts:
Sunflowers095 · 02/07/2021 21:15

Surprised at some of the responses here. I would have thought if mentoring from uni/current job would be that easily available graduates and many women wouldn't struggle professionally but they do.

In terms of how mentors will be paid/how this will work operationally it's still not decided. Its just an idea and my key question is as someone using the service, would you see value in it.

For example, having an opportunity to sit in with talks from women working at Google or Microsoft. Being mentored one on one by women in your field etc.

Please for the sake of this assume that the mentors are being rewarded accordingly, they're verified, etc. - would you see value in it to use the service in a premium model?

OP posts:
MoveOnTheCards · 02/07/2021 21:11

Are you expecting young women from low-income backgrounds to pay a monthly fee for this? I don’t think that would work. It also feels at odds with the ethos of the initiative.

Unless I’m missing something.

girlmom21 · 02/07/2021 21:11

@Sunflowers095 so do the mentors get paid? What training and support do they have?

How do these young, working class women with no career path afford to pay for the service? At what point do they stop paying? How are you qualified to give this guidance? What if the guidance doesn't help them?

You mention networking but who do they network with if you're not supporting with recruitment?

Cabinfever10 · 02/07/2021 21:08

What qualifications would your mentors have?
What qualifications would you actually be giving people that they can put on their CVs?
Why would anyone pay to give away their own ideas whilst paying you to work for the "mentor"?
Also how would you guarantee that it's women only and how do you define a woman?
How would you protect your students/mentee(sp) from being taken advantage of (in regard of any unpaid work that mentors pass their way)?
Tbh it screams scam to me but I could just be particularly jaded and suspicious but I wouldn't use it and would advise others to avoid it as it sounds really dodgy

takealettermsjones · 02/07/2021 21:07

If the person doesn't have a job, it's an expense they probably couldn't afford.
If the person does have a job, they'd be far better asking for mentoring opportunities within their company.

AmyDudley · 02/07/2021 21:06

As you describe it, the graduate pays for a mentor (what training for the mentors?) and provides ideas for projects and feasible ideas for free, and there is no guarantee that they will get any benefit, employment or anything out of it. You can get CV templates and reviews for free in various places already - not sure why anyone would want to pay for this.

Maybe I am missing something but I can't see much in it for the mentoree.

QuestionableMouse · 02/07/2021 21:05

Sorry but not for me. I have all of that for free through my uni's alumni group.

Sunflowers095 · 02/07/2021 21:05

@girlmom21

Are you basically wanting to create a recruitment agency for graduates?

I wouldn't pay for the platform personally in terms of a subscription if that was the intention.

Nope not recruitment, more focused on career guidance (although a good opportunity to network too).

For example you might be a young woman from a working class background, looking to start a career in field x. You'd have access to resources about paths you could take to get there & connect with a mentor who is established in this career.

Should you do an apprenticeship? If so, which? Go to uni? Is experience important? What should be on your CV?

Your mentor could be a great support in this. Same for women who are stuck in their careers or for example stuck in their current role with no progression. How to negotiate salary? How to get promoted?

It's more like a skillshare/experience share platform aimed at women to help them exceed, with a personal touch not just resources aimed at everyone.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread