Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if you would pay for this?

179 replies

Sunflowers095 · 02/07/2021 20:52

I have a business idea but I wonder if there would actually be a demand. Essentially, I've been thinking a lot about how different backgrounds affect your ability to succeed professionally, as well as how graduates are struggling for work.

It would be a platform for women, the main idea is mentoring. So for example, a student (or someone looking for a career change) would have access to things like CV templates/reviews, forum, 1 on 1 calls with women who have experience/are accomplished in their careers and can act as a mentor.

This would exist as a free and premium version (mentoring would be premium).

It would be a partnership with the mentors directly (where they would be paid a fee) or an agreement with their company to have them represent the business as a mentor. The companies/mentors would benefit by having younger people with skills but no experience provide ideas/small projects. A bit like a competition but the company can use winning ideas.

I am yet to iron out exactly the details but want to validate it first. Personally I would pay for a service like this & I think new generations are less family oriented and more career driven.

It could make a great addition to the CV of the younger women as well as the mentors, serve as a community aimed at helping women succeed professionally.

If the premium version cost for example £20 would you buy it? Assuming it's a monthly rolling subscription that can be cancelled anytime and you can benefit from unlimited resources and a monthly mentoring call? Thanks in advance!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
thebeatingofthedrums · 01/09/2021 09:16

I mentor young people through several charities, and have volunteered with others before. I am aware of many other great charities that I cannot support as I cannot stretch myself any further!

I also mentor former and current colleagues.

I agree that young people often are clueless, but that's why charities exist to connect them to people like me, who will invest their time in them for free. I wouldn't mentor with you - it feels exploitative charging a young person for advice that they should have got for free, had they been born into a family with successful working role models.

I would add that I'm uncomfortable with how you have brushed off criticism, implying that people who don't agree with you are not career-driven, rather than immediately accepting there might be a hole in your business plan. If you want to set up a business - and again, this is something I mentor people with! - you do need to learn how to respond more positively to feedback. Even if you have a good idea and a good plan, that doesn't guarantee plain sailing, so you need to build a bit more resilience.

As you said, back to the drawing board...

1forAll74 · 01/09/2021 03:35

What has a working class family got to do about anything..

But anyway, I think you will find, that many others have had the same ideas for a set up plan similar to yours.

abstractprojection · 01/09/2021 02:39

I’ve been involved in a lot of mentoring and it’s always been free and though a Uni or an industry non-profit origination or scheme.

So my first concern would be how would you monetise it.

The second is if this is for every industry or just one? If for every that’s an awful lot of ground to cover and when you give advise and information it must be correct.

If for just one industry and a women in [insert industry here] does not already exist then set one up and you might find yourself eligible for grants and sponsorship to the point it could be a full time job for you

TractorAndHeadphones · 31/08/2021 22:23

What problem are you trying to solve?
A lack of resources? There are an abundance of mentorship programs, coaching and online forums etc , for free.
A lack of experience? That's what unpaid internships and competitions etc are for. If people could afford to do that why would they pay for the privilege?

Having attended a lot of these and myself changed career - impressing colleagues opened doors. My boss (who gave me a chance) started on tech support for example. 'Mentors' can give generic advise but the people who truly made a difference were those I worked for and whom I proved myself to over a period of time.

You could try working with companies to organise programs that bring in diverse talents. Like case study days held by management consulting companies, or PwC's women in businesss. These are all legitimate work experience, organised by the company, leading to paid jobs.

However the idea of a paid platform for work experience is unethical

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 31/08/2021 21:55

Until recently I belonged to a paid Facebook group for professional cake decorators. Sadly the owner is moving her business into a different area abd is closing the group. I paid £10 a month with access to a Facebook group, different training every month with professional women on non-craft aspects of the business eg. Creating reels for insta. The trainings were recorded and uploaded to a website where you could review them as many times as you wanted.
This sort of set up might be a toe in the water at low cost to see what the market is

Professionallytorn · 31/08/2021 21:10

There is a lot of free support already out there, eg National Careers Service and the Young Womens Trust ... So no I wouldn't pay.

Lonecatwithkitten · 31/08/2021 10:15

@WhatWouldKalindaDo

I wouldn't pay for this. I'm in the veterinary profession, and unless you also had someone quite senior in that exact area it would be very hard for me to get value from the service. I would imagine lots of other professions are the same.

Some skills just aren't transferrable across different sectors.

It already exists in our sector for free. Vets stay, go, diversify offers it.
Peoniesandpeaches · 31/08/2021 09:37

It already exists (at least in large part). I can’t think of the name of the platform as my company bought it in for international women’s day last year but I’ll try find it later. There’s also the 10,000 women project and other platforms to offer free training for women so competition would be incredibly stiff.

Iwantcauliflowercheese · 31/08/2021 09:08

I work for a charity that provides all this for free.

CounsellorTroi · 31/08/2021 08:59

Something like this may already exist. I know someone who works for a charity mentoring and coaching women who have been out the workplace for a time to find work.

WhatWouldKalindaDo · 31/08/2021 08:53

I wouldn't pay for this. I'm in the veterinary profession, and unless you also had someone quite senior in that exact area it would be very hard for me to get value from the service. I would imagine lots of other professions are the same.

Some skills just aren't transferrable across different sectors.

Rugsofhonour · 31/08/2021 08:49

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

Manicpixiedreammollusc · 31/08/2021 08:44

I run a mentoring programme for my sector. I do this voluntarily on top of my day job. It isn’t a huge amount of work. None of these mentors get paid - they are senior so already earning a good salary, and they do it because they want to give back. It works well because these people are motivated by trying to help people, rather than by money. To be honest I’d be really suspicious of any mentor who wanted to be paid. I think it would be much more worthwhile to set up a similar mentoring programme for your industry, if it doesn’t already have one.

LAgeDeRaisin · 31/08/2021 08:37

It's a hard sell to the mentors if you are paying them to do it. I'll take an example: DH uses a physicist friend of mine who consults for various companies. He charges £300/hour.

Your idea of 1:1 with him for one person interested in physics in business for an hour would be £300. That's 1 hour for one person and costa a year and 3 months worth of subscriptions, if you have zero overheads, which you won't have.

I know he wouldn't want to volunteer his time for a company that was doing it for profit. He might do something for free as outreach or charity and indeed has done some of these things.

Most lawyers will be charging in the 100's per hour too. I'm a doctor and wouldn't be keen to volunteer my time for a company that was profitting out of it. I would be happy to volunteer as part of a school visit, and have given some guidance and practice interviews to students looking to apply to Cambridge as it's my alma mater.

Honestly I think your model is all wrong.

It needs to be charitable to encourage people. No successful person wants to work as a mentor at slightly over minimum wage so that you can make a profit, when they can do it for free and feel good about themselves.

ThinWomansBrain · 31/08/2021 08:29

I mentored undergraduate students (voluntarily) through the business school where I did an MSc, which continued beyond their studies.
Don't most universities have similar schemes?

KintsugiCat · 31/08/2021 08:24

No.

LAgeDeRaisin · 31/08/2021 08:21

I came from a relatively affluent family and wouldn't have paid for this when I was at university age, so I think the idea of someone from a less affluent family paying is really very unlikely.

Very few people at that age, regardless of background, would pay £20/month for something so intangible as advice. I think even fewer in the socioeconomic group you are aiming at.

People would likely use the service if it were free, but you'd be competing with a great many other CV websites, independent companies, and recruitment companies who all do this sort of thing.

It just wont work.

Bunnycat101 · 30/08/2021 22:19

I don’t think you can monetise it. I’ve been a mentor for young people thorough charities and my own sector. I wouldn’t do it as part of a money-making scheme.

user1471447863 · 30/08/2021 22:10

The sort of people who mentor tend to do it because they like to help people get on and better themselves or to impart knowledge. The moment you start buying mentors you'll be attracting the sort of people who attend meetings and go on courses as an alternative to doing real work - the chancers and the fly guys.

Many companies already run their own mentorship schemes for the young up and comings that bother to seek them out and participate.

I'd also say by restricting it to women its a bit discriminatory - how would it go down if you said you were creating a platform for men to have 1 on 1 calls with men who have experience/are accomplished in their careers and can act as a mentor?
Not only that you'd be cutting off half of your potential customer base too.

Planty13 · 30/08/2021 21:22

I think the people that NEED it, wouldn’t pay for it. There are so many free resources that could meet their needs

Kisskiss · 30/08/2021 21:15

@idontlikealdi

We already do this in my industry for free
Yes, in mine too. I’ve participated a few times as mentor (for free) , but would not do it if the students were paying for the service.
CurlyMango · 30/08/2021 21:10

No this is insuffienct and would not be of value to either parties

Douknow · 30/08/2021 13:56

Exactly - please be aware that there are companies out there that claim to do mentoring but unfortunately they use tactics of coercive manipulation. LIG (Lighthouse International Group), Lighthouse Kidz, the Legends Network, bethechangeagency.org - avoid them.
Young entrepreneurs, professionals, students get sucked in because they actually care and due to our universal human response to group and situational pressures they don’t realize what is happening at which point coercive manipulation has disabled their critical thinking - Reddit has some seriously important information about this organization and what to look out for - this might not be the right thread but crucial to be on your guard!

SchrodingersImmigrant · 03/07/2021 18:54

I think that's what Bright Network does. Free to students so I assume they make money from companies

StartingGrid · 03/07/2021 18:52

Haven't read all replies, but personally I think you'd have more success in getting companies to pay for advertising space/partnership publicity and put forward people from their own staff internally, than by charging the users. Maybe a few speculative messages to large companies with a heavy social media presence could see if you're onto anything viable, as the service in itself sounds like it has potential.

I have a friend who is a director of a small business and would totally be on board for something like this, they do volunteer their time for people in a fairly similar way already.