Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Having my wedding 3 weeks before my sisters?

242 replies

username2479 · 02/07/2021 20:16

NC obviously very outing.

got engaged last summer, a month later my sister got engaged too (to her partner she’d been split up from a couple of months before so hers came a bit out of nowhere). I found out I was pregnant a few days after my engagement and my sister knew, at the time felt a bit awkward as she literally got engaged the day of my first baby scan which was a bit Hmm but I didn’t say anything because if she’s happy then fine. I’m not big on being the center of attention anyway.

My cousin had a wedding planned for June 22, sister wanted the same date but changed hers to a month after. So has done exactly the same to someone else that she’s mad at me for. Cousin has cancelled her wedding anyway but point is how can she think it’s okay for her to do this but if i do i’m awful?

I mentioned to her yesterday I was going to book my wedding soon and was aiming for end of may/june 22 as then my baby will ideally be weaned and not breastfeeding 24/7. it’s important to me that i get married then because it was always my aim and she knew that. i’ve said for ages i wanted to get married as soon as i finished my degree (may 2022). this isn’t a surprise.

she didn’t say much yesterday and just sent a gif from the movie bride wars so i thought she was being a bit sarcastic but she didn’t say anything else. then today sent her a message with the date and she’s kicking off as if i haven’t made her aware already of when i wanted my wedding? saying i stole her limelight when she literally took over my own engagement/baby news with her engagement to a partner of like 3 months? Confused

our weddings will be completely different. mine is low-key with 40/50 people. hers is a big do with 150. i’m not looking to outdo her, i couldn’t care less about anything fancy. i’m not even sure that i’m going to be getting a dress. all i want is to be married, i’m still happy to be her bridesmaid and plan her hen do etc etc literally all i’m having is a registry office and hiring a nice bar for the evening.

i’d understand if i hadn’t told her but i had, it’s not really my fault that she can’t tell me how she feels until i’ve paid and booked my ceremony.

OP posts:
2pinkginsplease · 03/07/2021 09:43

@username2479 I’m going to take your side here. I have a sister in law exactly like your sister.

Her and my brother had been engaged for a few years before us and no sign of a wedding, we got engaged and booked our wedding for only a few months later, low and behold they booked their wedding for months after us at the exact same venue!

We had our first baby and said we wanted a small gap between our children and after 5 years of saying they were having no more children as one was more than enough they announced they were having a baby who was born a few months before our second.

They then had the baby’s baptism the weekend after my due date to try and deflect from my new baby.

Some may say it’s coincidence but I know how her mind works, I’ve known her long enough and she hates anyone having centre of attention unless it’s her! And my brother is an eejit that goes alongside with it all to keep the peace.

Thankfully we have nothing to do with them all due to their dramas!

Bluntness100 · 03/07/2021 09:24

Some people just never grow out of sibling rivalry. Op you might now want to be the centre of attention, but you’re very big on competing with your sister. Time to grow up and stop that.

nimbuscloud · 03/07/2021 09:19

I feel sorry for your family.

ShortBacknSides · 03/07/2021 09:18

You don’t really like your sister very much, do you?

MikeWozniaksGloriousTache · 03/07/2021 09:11

I don’t think the dates of the wedding are the main issue to be honest, and I’m surprised that others are saying it is because it’s usually the MN view that “no one owns a month” and you should plan your wedding when you want.

However, the whole sibling rivalry thing is ridiculous and I do feel for your parents stuck in the middle of this. If your sister is really the limelight stealing bitch you’re making her out to be you should have been more wary about telling her your wedding plans. She may have orchestrated the whole engagement to deliberately wind you up but you’re an adult and there’s nothing you can do other than to rise above it. Is there anything to get out of it by being constantly annoyed and upset by it? No, so just move on.

With regards to the wedding you have two choices, stick to your guns and possibly have it out with your sister and say she’s being ridiculous, no one is taking away any limelight from her day, the weddings are different so people won’t be comparing them and she either needs to accept it or not. Or you move the date to keep the peace and appease her. Prepare for fall out for option 1 though.

I’d also recommend some counselling as there seems to be massive unresolved issues between you and unpicking them with a professional may help you deal with them better.

SecretSpAD · 03/07/2021 09:10

no they really don’t it’s a one off thing

Obviously not if your sister had booked it!

TimeIhadaNameChange · 03/07/2021 08:43

Your mistake was telling her your plans when you know she's like this.

My sister is exactly the same, older, and thus feels entitled to do everything before me. Thus I tell her, and consequently my mother (who feels obliged to tell her everything), nothing.

LuaDipa · 03/07/2021 08:01

I think your dsis has behaves badly but two wrongs don’t make a right.

Dh and I had a similar situation. We got engaged before we went on holiday and only told two people. We came back from holiday intending to tell everyone else only to find that one of the people we told had also got engaged and booked their wedding for the next year when we planned to marry. It was a bit annoying but they had been together for longer, were older than us and we certainly weren’t going to drag our loved ones through two weddings in a short space of time so we booked our wedding for the year after. No harm done.

I think you need to consider the impact of this, not on your dsis, but on other friends and family members. Why would you want to inconvenience them with two events in close proximity when you could wait a year? Or even try and do it now if it’s a simple wedding. You already have a dc, your dsis may be in a rush to marry and start trying. Just try and look at this from a different point of view.

sunshinepunch · 03/07/2021 06:48

This is what I would do.

  1. Step out of the ring!!
  2. Leg your sister get on with it.
  3. Postpone your wedding until later this year/next year. If you want a dream wedding plan it properly, the day goes so fast.
  4. Stop wasting precious time and your life trying to 'one-up'. All it causes is hatred, jealously and as Mnet knows, comparison is the thief of joy.

See it for what it is. You're BOTH trying to out-do eachother. What will this achieve? Certainly not happiness.

Weddings are not about who has it first.

What will you and your sister miss out on life trying for the next thing to out-do eachother with? Cars? Houses? Children? Headstones?

Take a step back and a deep breath. You dont have to rush this. It does not matter who gets married first. Will you be, if you're lucky enough, 90 looking back smugly thinking jeez that was great I won having my wedding first?!

You have the ability to stop this pattern now.

stellaisabella · 03/07/2021 04:07

I think it's quite clear YABU, no matter how much you insist you aren't.

Oceanbliss · 03/07/2021 03:53

Look for what it’s worth if you told her you wanted to book your wedding on a particular day/month at this venue then it wasn’t nice of her to then book her wedding on that same day/month and venue.

The appropriate response is to communicate with her about that and tell her exactly how you feel about it.

Retaliating by booking your wedding 3 weeks before her wedding isn’t going to solve anything. It isn’t the mature way to handle things. It doesn’t look like it’s making you happy either. Also, it seems to be creating more stress than if you’d simply planned your wedding later on another day/month not too close to your sisters wedding.

QueenBee52 · 03/07/2021 03:53

OP you do whatever makes YOU happy for your Wedding Day.. 🎂

Enjoy being a Bride and Congratulations on your pregnancy 🌸💕

Oceanbliss · 03/07/2021 03:45

AnotherDayAnotherCake
Are you older OP? Just asking because you sound desperate to do everything first.

Your reply:
no i’m younger and that’s part of the reason why i think she felt the need to hop in and get engaged

I knew it! I have seen this so many times with younger siblings. “It’s not fair older sister or brother gets to do such and such and I don’t get to because Mum Dad said I’m not old enough.” Followed by tantrum to force parents to change their mind. Then resentment, retaliation towards older sibling.

@username2479 You are not a child anymore. You are an adult and a parent. It’s time to let go of this competitive resentment towards your sister. Let it go.

ElephantMoth · 03/07/2021 02:52

If you just want to be married just go and do it without all the bridezilla drama from you both, why wait when you can have a small intimate ceremony?

PrincessNutella · 03/07/2021 02:27

When people come to your wedding, do you want them to a. think kind thoughts about you and be focused on wishing you well; or b. be laughing behind your back at what a bridezilla you are and wonder what kind of nasty person gets married three weeks before her sister? The choice is yours.

gobackanddoitproperly · 03/07/2021 01:13

Is there an unwritten rule that if you get engaged first in a family, you should be the first to marry?

Montii · 03/07/2021 00:57

Honestly I think it’s rude of the sister to book her wedding date in without checking with you first, particularly if you were engaged first.

I don’t really understand why you are getting so much hate here.

Throwntothewolves · 03/07/2021 00:31

I got engaged a few months before my sister. They set the date for around when we thought we might have got married, so we deliberately got married the following year so as not to 'steal the limelight' and avoid this sort of carry on.
I think you both need to grow up a bit and stop trying to get one up on eachother, it's petty and ridiculous.

BuggersMuddle · 03/07/2021 00:28

You both sound incredibly immature tbh. Unless you’re making life difficult for people (travel, weird requests) no-one will give a shiny shit.

Rosebel · 03/07/2021 00:21

YABU. My brother did exactly the same to our older brother and it just made him look shitty and jealous. There is however a massive backstory to this but I still think it looks bad.
Why can't you have your wedding a few weeks after her? It does sound like you want to steal her thunder tbh.

Newcastleteacake · 03/07/2021 00:10

@Sssloou

Congratulations on your pregnancy and engagement - and good luck with your degree and wedding planning.

You have a lot of amazing life experiences happening at once - you can choose to focus on enjoying those precious times and cherishing the moments or miss it all by becoming preoccupied with negativity and locking horns with a toxic dynamic that I assume has been throughout your life and will continue to pollute your future if you let it.

You can’t be in two emotional places at once - choose wisely.

Choose to stop, disengage, detach become distant and dignified - so that you can focus on the good people and things in your life. Fade this nonsense out. Get your head out of this game.

100% this. Life is way too short for this bullshit.
Biancadelrioisback · 02/07/2021 23:48

Aw man! This is going to get deleted isn't it?

Sssloou · 02/07/2021 23:24

So you had your first scan last summer - baby must have been born somewhere between Nov - Feb and by May/June 22 would then be 18-20 months .... and should then “was aiming for end of may/june 22 as then my baby will ideally be weaned and not breastfeeding 24/7.”

I would give your health visitor a call if you believe that your baby will only be weaned and not BF 24/7 by next summer.

Doesn’t add up.

BackforGood · 02/07/2021 22:23

I think it is pretty poor of you to book your wedding three weeks before your sisters.

And it is absolutely bizarre that you have an issue with her announcing her engagement the day of your baby scan, I can’t even work out what you mean.

Both of these.
I hope you have accepted by now YABU and this is a rubbish thing to do. You have even admitted you are being petty, before you started trying to add bits in in an effort to make your sister look petty.
It is clear from 7 pages of answers that it is unanimous that everyone thinks swooping in and setting up your wedding 3 weeks before your sister is getting married is just nasty. Everyone in your family will also think this even if they don't say it outloud.

Blackjeans88 · 02/07/2021 22:06

My sister and I got married within 2 months, and then had our babies 4 days apart!
Some people would say that's full on (especially our poor parents) but the relationship we have can handle that, we are very close, and open with how we feel, but ultimately just want the best for each other.
To be honest my worry would be if I was you, can your relationship with your sister handle this stress? Will you end up falling out and ruining the friendship (if any) you have? If the answer is yes, then you should move your wedding. If the answer is no, then just get on with it and stop getting worked up and enjoy each others special day.