Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel uncomfortable with celebrity surrogacy?

333 replies

Username91 · 02/07/2021 10:35

After reading about Amber Herd having a baby girl via surrogate it just got me thinking about the amount of famous people who have children this way. I have nothing against surrogacy, it just seems to me that a lot of rich women choose to have children this way and I’m not convinced they ALL have problems carrying children themselves. I find it a bit disturbing and wondered if I’m alone in thinking this?

Once again I’d like to point out I’m not surrogacy bashing here. I just don’t think it should be something that is used by women with money as they don’t like the idea of carrying their own babies, of course it’s very different for women who struggle to conceive/carry themselves.

OP posts:
FannyCann · 02/07/2021 14:34

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

feellikeanalien · 02/07/2021 14:32

I used to be fairly neutral about surrogacy but I now am very uncomfortable with it.

When I had DD I had to have an emergency hysterectomy and had been in hospital for 3 weeks before DD was born.

Giving birth is not a risk free procedure. To me the whole thing makes commodities out of babies and also the women whose bodies are used. What if the surrogate dies or suffers birth injuries? I doubt that she will receive any support from the person/people who commissioned the surogacy. What would be the effects on her existing family?

I am lucky to have DD. At one point before I became pregnant with her I thought I was not going to be able to carry a pregnancy to term. The feeling that you might not be able ever to have a child is a horrible one but I don't think that surrogacy is the answer.

ivfgottwins · 02/07/2021 14:30

I don't agree with surrogacy unless it's say offered by a family member like a sibling (I do know 2 families actually where a sibling has been a surrogate for their sister)

I have a much bigger issue with donor sperm and eggs and think that should be much more restricted though

CP26 · 02/07/2021 14:20

@ConfusedBear the author of the study explains that in a summary article

“ The study also found that children born through surrogacy do not experience psychological problems. When we looked at the data over-time we found that whilst all the children scored within the normal range for psychological health, children born using surrogacy experienced more difficulties at age 7 compared to children born through sperm or egg donation. However, this difference was no longer present at age 10. The temporary difference could be due to a majority of surrogacy children being aware of their birth story (versus a minority of the children born following gamete donation) and thus having to deal with this knowledge at an earlier age. At age 14, we found no differences between children born following surrogacy and the other groups in terms of their well-being, self-esteem, and emotional or behavioural problems. If the birth story had an influence on children’s difficulties at age 7, these did not continue into adolescence.”

surrogacyuk.org/2018/10/14/research-findings-from-a-longitudinal-study-of-surrogacy-families-in-the-uk/

TinkleTongs · 02/07/2021 14:15

@APJ1

You'll loooove actress Lucy Liu's explanation for using a surrogate. people.com/parents/lucy-liu-gestational-surrogate-son-rockwell/

“It just seemed like the right option for me because I was working and I didn’t know when I was going to be able to stop,”

Ah, too busy, let someone else do it all.

Oh for god sake that’s awful

That rich celebs can eliminate all the hassle with their money , I find this disgusting actually.

AnneLovesGilbert · 02/07/2021 14:09

As others have said, you should have a problem with surrogacy, not just when it’s bought be the rich and famous.

Exploitative and wrong.

Sexlife · 02/07/2021 14:05

Op,I agree.

MolyHolyGuacamole · 02/07/2021 14:03

Are they not? I thought one was. Either way yeeeesssh. Basically just bought a baby.

That's the story that he has always given. But none of those children are in any way half black.

APJ1 · 02/07/2021 14:03

You'll loooove actress Lucy Liu's explanation for using a surrogate. people.com/parents/lucy-liu-gestational-surrogate-son-rockwell/

“It just seemed like the right option for me because I was working and I didn’t know when I was going to be able to stop,”

Ah, too busy, let someone else do it all.

hysteriaonthedancefloor · 02/07/2021 14:02

there are no wealthy educated women being surrogates

Interestingly, there are plenty of educated women who will probably quite soon be wealthy who have been egg donors while at college.

Wealthy educated women tend to have spent their most fertile years working. They're not necessarily against being a surrogate, that chance to carry children has just gone for them.

ConfusedBear · 02/07/2021 14:01

"Results: Although children born through reproductive donation obtained SDQ scores within the normal range, surrogacy children showed higher levels of adjustment difficulties at age 7 than children conceived by gamete donation. Mothers who had kept their child’s origins secret showed elevated levels of distress. However, maternal distress had a more negative impact on children who were aware of their origins. Conclusions: The absence of a gestational connection to the mother may be more problematic for children than the absence of a genetic link."

@CP26 thanks for posting a link to research. Above is from the first page of the report. Which to me seems more nuanced rather than completely positive regarding surrogacy.

C8H10N4O2 · 02/07/2021 13:58

Commoditisation of less well off and poorer women's bodies again. How many wealthy women take money to be a surrogate?

There is no right to another human being's body (adult or child) and "choice" is moot when its generally poor or at least poorer women with less life changes being procured for surrogacy

MolyHolyGuacamole · 02/07/2021 13:57

And no….there are no wealthy educated women being surrogates

Well there are no wealthy educated women lots of jobs, that many do for pay because we all need money to live.

And to be clear, I find surrogacy exploitative, but I don't get this argument.

Maybe all work is exploitative...certainly feels like it to me 🤷🏽‍♀️

hysteriaonthedancefloor · 02/07/2021 13:55

If she did without having a medical reason why sheer couldn't carry the baby herself, I have a problem.

If the surrogate hasn't completed her own family, doesn't have a history of easy births or comes from a very low income background, I have a problem.

Otherwise, I don't.

ThunderBitch · 02/07/2021 13:53

YANBU. It's buying and selling babies at the end of the day.

I don't really have a problem if it's done within families, e.g. the pp who said her cousin was a surrogate for her sister. As long as there is honesty and family connection/love, I feel like that could work. But buying a baby should not be morally acceptable. It's disturbing how this has become a 'thing'.

A lot of gay/trans couples seem to be doing this now as well.

TastyTicklemore · 02/07/2021 13:48

In my opinion these mega rich celebs see babies as commodities

This is perhaps the biggest challenge celebrit babies face - not how they came into being but why

wheresmymojo · 02/07/2021 13:47

@Moorelewis

All the people saying surrogacy is essentially 'buying a baby', then what is IVF?

Again, in the UK you cannot be paid anything other than expenses for sperm or eggs for the same reason.

wheresmymojo · 02/07/2021 13:43

I'm anti-surrogacy or at least the concept of paid for surrogacy.

I think(?) I'm okay with the British way of handling it as it means it's limited to women who really want to do it without any potential for economic coercion.

I absolutely think it should be like organ donation where you cannot be paid/pay.

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 02/07/2021 13:40

I'm very skeptical of the stories about surrogates who found the experience amazing and had absolutely no motives for doing it besides enjoying being pregnant. Very.

Sleeplessem · 02/07/2021 13:39

@MolyHolyGuacamole

The Ronaldo thing is particularly strange. MJ did similar didn’t he?

Probably going to articulate this poorly but it’s the driver to have a child that is ‘biologically yours’ above all else, including ethics both medical and more general that makes me feel uneasy.

Which makes MJ even weirder, as those kids aren't biologically his Confused

Are they not? I thought one was. Either way yeeeesssh. Basically just bought a baby. Shock
Ylvamoon · 02/07/2021 13:37

I'm against surrogacy. It's baby farming and inhumane.

Once you have grown and birthed a child you are attracted to this child. Your hormones ensure that you will take care of this child... I can't imagine anyone (even the white wash surrogates) not thinking/ wondering about the little human being they have carried for 9 months.

Sleeplessem · 02/07/2021 13:37

@Twizbe

What about Hilaria Baldwin who was very pregnant when they impregnated a surrogate. The suggestion is that they did it to ensure they had another girl.

She clearly wasn't infertile as she already had 5 kids.

Or the 20 something woman in Georgia with a much older husband who had 10 surrogate babies in 12 months? She already had one (so able to be pregnant) and it only cost her £1000 per baby (which is a lot of money for those women who's womb she rented)

I'm more ok with a cousin or sister helping a family member to have a baby.

This^^ the Hilaria Baldwin thing, when she was already pregnant just to have a girl. Plain consumerism at the end of the day
MolyHolyGuacamole · 02/07/2021 13:36

The Ronaldo thing is particularly strange. MJ did similar didn’t he?

Probably going to articulate this poorly but it’s the driver to have a child that is ‘biologically yours’ above all else, including ethics both medical and more general that makes me feel uneasy.

Which makes MJ even weirder, as those kids aren't biologically his Confused

CroydianSlip · 02/07/2021 13:35

Surrogacy makes me feel incredibly uncomfortable.

Human babies learn their mother's voice, heartbeat, scent and they are calmed and quietened by the sounds and people they have known through their time in the womb. To disregard and deny that this is important to the child, and that the commissioning parents need to be parents outweighs the baby's need to be cared for by the woman who gestates them is wrong imo. We know there are circumstances where the risk vs benefit decision is different in the case of care proceedings and adoptions BUT this should be avoided not deliberately created.

The argument about bodily autonomy and choice is absolute nonsense. You don't find women of independent means and opportunity arguing for the right to be a commercial surrogate.

Comedycook · 02/07/2021 13:31

She carried two children for that couple and describes it as the most rewarding thing she ever did

It's only women who have been socialised to such an extent that the best thing they think they've done is for the benefit of someone else with a huge risk to their own health.

Swipe left for the next trending thread