Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel uncomfortable with celebrity surrogacy?

333 replies

Username91 · 02/07/2021 10:35

After reading about Amber Herd having a baby girl via surrogate it just got me thinking about the amount of famous people who have children this way. I have nothing against surrogacy, it just seems to me that a lot of rich women choose to have children this way and I’m not convinced they ALL have problems carrying children themselves. I find it a bit disturbing and wondered if I’m alone in thinking this?

Once again I’d like to point out I’m not surrogacy bashing here. I just don’t think it should be something that is used by women with money as they don’t like the idea of carrying their own babies, of course it’s very different for women who struggle to conceive/carry themselves.

OP posts:
SunSunSunshine · 02/07/2021 16:22

I detest everything about surrogacy especially when used by celebrities.
It never puts the babies needs first.

Theluggage15 · 02/07/2021 16:19

So it wasn’t altruistic at all then? She loved being pregnant, never mind how the baby is affected.

StickyThighs · 02/07/2021 16:15

I don’t see a problem with surrogacy in the U.K., it’s altruistic. So long as a woman isn’t forced to be a surrogate surely it’s down to them to do it if they want to? I knew of a surrogate who do it because they loved being pregnant, and wanted to help a friend/family. And she was a feminist!

FannyCann · 02/07/2021 15:59

@Pinuporc it's a really awful situation.

There's no way of knowing how many babies have been affected in this way, I imagine it's something that surrogacy agencies prefer to keep secret and most surrogate mothers are subject to a NDA.
My guess is that there will be many more. Also in places like Ukraine - how many of those babies stuck there last year are still awaiting collection? It wouldn't surprise me if some commissioning parents decide they don't want a year old baby and just renege on the whole deal and the baby ends up in an orphanage.

ivfgottwins · 02/07/2021 15:30

Hence why the law had to change recently because of the feelings of the children of donations.

Yes that's why on the infertility/ivf groups I'm part of they are all going abroad for donor eggs as it still anonymous there

Just because we don't need a mother or father for a child doesn't mean that a child doesn't need a mother or father.

You only have to watch the documentaries about the triplets separated at birth or the sperm donor lad who went to meet his biological father and half siblings or even long lost family - people will always yearn to know about the other half - or in the case of double donors - where all of their genetic make up comes from

But many people will always prioritise wanting to experience pregnancy themselves rather than considering that a future child wants to be biologically related to both its parents (in a non adoption situation of course)

Beeeeeeeeeeeeeep · 02/07/2021 15:28

Smell is so powerful
You know what your baby smells like and sniffing the top of their head causes a release of bonding hormones. I still smell my son's head when he lets me and he's nearly a teenager. Under the sweat and lynx deodorant I can still smell his baby smell. The physicality of the mother-child bond is intense.
Adoptive parents can and do form attachment relationships as strong as birth parents but to deliberately sever the bond between baby and mother for selfish reasons is heinous.

Recessed · 02/07/2021 15:23

I agree Comedycook seeing the photo of Mark from Westlife and his husband taking their newborn baby home from hospital and away from her mother literally made my heart ache for that baby - and I'm one of the most unsentimental people going! After having my own DC it just seemed so so wrong and massively selfish.

Comedycook · 02/07/2021 15:14

@Recessed

I remember after I had DD2 the wonderful midwife placed her on my tummy and told me to watch what would happen. She little by little "crawled" her way up to my chest and latched on to feed. I was amazed at the time. I asked how she knew and the midwife said scent was a huge part of it as she's so familiar with my scent. Ever since that I've never seen surrogacy the same. No one ever talks about how it's not in best interests of the commodity - the child - but luckily more people are recognizing how it's exploitative of women.
Well exactly and imo surrogacy only works to undermine motherhood and women are reduced to nothing more than an incubator. It's sick.
FannyCann · 02/07/2021 15:07

I remember after I had DD2 the wonderful midwife placed her on my tummy and told me to watch what would happen. She little by little "crawled" her way up to my chest and latched on to feed. I was amazed at the time.

I took DD2 to a uni open day (just before coronavirus) to look at midwifery. We had a trial lecture and they showed a video of that. It was beautiful.

I couldn't resist asking what the point was if these men that strip off to join in with the skin to skin and she said None. Wink

(Though I concede if the mother is not available having treatment in theatre etc there may be a case just for body warmth to comfort the baby until the mother is available).

Recessed · 02/07/2021 14:56

I remember after I had DD2 the wonderful midwife placed her on my tummy and told me to watch what would happen. She little by little "crawled" her way up to my chest and latched on to feed. I was amazed at the time. I asked how she knew and the midwife said scent was a huge part of it as she's so familiar with my scent. Ever since that I've never seen surrogacy the same. No one ever talks about how it's not in best interests of the commodity - the child - but luckily more people are recognizing how it's exploitative of women.

DontDrinkDontSmokeWhatDoIDo · 02/07/2021 14:55

Being unable to have a child when you want one so much must be absolutely unbearable, I completely get that.

But in 'celeb' cases, it's the glibness I find so sickening.

In Made in Chelsea, Ollie Locke and his husband are a literal storyline, talking about how 'next year we'll be parents', and getting a nursery ready before even 'falling pregnant'

They epitomise the commerciality of it.
There is no mention of the pregnant mother other than as a host. The physical,
emotional and permanent impact on her doesn't get airtime at all - it's just product shopping at another level.

Pinuporc · 02/07/2021 14:55

Cross posted @FannyCann

Snog · 02/07/2021 14:54

I think surrogacy is exploitative.
We should address why as a society we are happy to allow such huge extremes of wealth and poverty.

FannyCann · 02/07/2021 14:54

Here is the other one that had been in the news.

nypost.com/2021/03/24/surrogate-caring-for-baby-year-later-due-to-covid-travel-rules/

Pinuporc · 02/07/2021 14:53

Babies learn their mother’s voice in utero
As well. So our babies can recognize our voices when born too.

I think they also recognise smell (isnt a mum advised to put a top/item of clothing in a newborn's cot for reassurance because it smells of them?)
A PP mentioned a lot of surrogate babies that are now several months old and have yet to meet their intended families because of covid travel restrictions. I think that would be incredibly traumatic (for both parties, especially if the birth mother is still with the baby)

MsTSwift · 02/07/2021 14:53

And look there is mission creep. More and more are celebrities doing it. Wealthy normal women will start to do this too. The end result is sinister which is why it should be totally banned.

FannyCann · 02/07/2021 14:51

A pp mentioned babies stuck waiting for collection because of covid.
In fact there are several (nobody knows how many, it's not exactly being advertised) babies that are about a year old still waiting....

This woman had a surrogate baby for a Chinese couple, but she didn't want to risk bonding with it and also it needed to be cared for by a Chinese speaker, so that is in care with a Chinese speaking nanny awaiting collection. Meanwhile she is caring for this one year old, still awaiting collection by the Scottish commissioning parents.
There was another woman in the news also caring for a year old she had given birth to. So that is three, documented that I know of.

Year old babies that will be collected when the commissioning parents finally rock up to collect. No oversight of social services or anything.

Good luck to those parents and the sleepless nights of a screaming baby that wants the person it perceives to be its mother.

www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-9698243/Nanny-raising-UK-couples-surrogate-son-10-months-COVID-19.html

hysteriaonthedancefloor · 02/07/2021 14:50

In essence, a surrogate child is no different to an adopted one

I would be fascinated to hear research bearing that equivalency out.

There isn't any.

MsTSwift · 02/07/2021 14:50

I don’t respect that choice no. It shouldn’t be allowed. How far do you push other people (the surrogate and actually your baby who will be intentionally removed from its mother) to get what you want.

AlternativePerspective · 02/07/2021 14:47

And what about the children?

People seem to only think about the need to have a baby when actually that baby will grow into a child, and then an adult in their own right. Does no-one ever actually consider the impact on that child/adult? The attachment disorders they are probably inflicting it with? There is a lot of evidence that the children of adoption suffer attachment disorder when removed from their birth parent. In essence, a surrogate child is no different to an adopted one, in that to that child, the person giving birth to it is the parent.

Babygotblueyes · 02/07/2021 14:43

@Comedycook

She carried two children for that couple and describes it as the most rewarding thing she ever did

It's only women who have been socialised to such an extent that the best thing they think they've done is for the benefit of someone else with a huge risk to their own health.

Oh stop. My friend is a beautiful, intelligent woman with complete agency. And as I mentioned, in the medical profession. She made a free choice. Not one I would make, but to not respect her in that is plain wrong.
AlternativePerspective · 02/07/2021 14:42

All surrogacy is horrible, including so called altruistic surrogacy.

This may not be a popular opinion, but sometimes people just need to accept that they will never have children. As hard as it is for some people to accept that sometimes, that doesn’t mean that they are entitled to a children at all costs, including to the surrogate and the child.

It’s interesting that we never read anything written by adults who were conceived through surrogacy who talk favourably about the practice.

I feel similar re egg/sperm donation tbh. There is never any consideration given to the child here, the child who will grow up knowing that they only have half of their biological heritage known to them, hence why the law needed to be changed recently because of the feelings of the children of donations.

Tabitha005 · 02/07/2021 14:42

@APJ1

You'll loooove actress Lucy Liu's explanation for using a surrogate. people.com/parents/lucy-liu-gestational-surrogate-son-rockwell/

“It just seemed like the right option for me because I was working and I didn’t know when I was going to be able to stop,”

Ah, too busy, let someone else do it all.

WTF? She actually said that!

I think many 'celebrities' are so completely absorbed by their own existence that they really don't have very much in the way of self-awareness or humility.

MarshmallowSwede · 02/07/2021 14:37

@TastyTicklemore

Babies learn their mother’s voice in utero
As well. So our babies can recognize our voices when born too.

I’ve never seen anyone bring this up about surrogacy. Maybe it causes some confusion for the newborn. But everything is new
to them and perhaps it’s not such a huge impact. I would be curious to know how this affects their first few days of life.

Tabitha005 · 02/07/2021 14:35

We live in a world where money can get you most of your heart's desires, so rich women paying not-so-rich-women to have babies for them shouldn't be considered 'shocking', but I don't think it's ethical in the least.

I have similar feelings about IVF which probably isn't a popular opinion, but whatever.

I think we humans often deem ourselves entitled to everything we can achieve by any means. Surrogacy has become a shitful business.