Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel uncomfortable with celebrity surrogacy?

333 replies

Username91 · 02/07/2021 10:35

After reading about Amber Herd having a baby girl via surrogate it just got me thinking about the amount of famous people who have children this way. I have nothing against surrogacy, it just seems to me that a lot of rich women choose to have children this way and I’m not convinced they ALL have problems carrying children themselves. I find it a bit disturbing and wondered if I’m alone in thinking this?

Once again I’d like to point out I’m not surrogacy bashing here. I just don’t think it should be something that is used by women with money as they don’t like the idea of carrying their own babies, of course it’s very different for women who struggle to conceive/carry themselves.

OP posts:
OrangeBlossomMacaron · 02/07/2021 17:31

@Ericaequites

Egg donation is about building better babies. There are height, weight, health, educational, and psychological requirements. Still, there are no guarantees. What is it like to carry a child not related to you?it’s not something I would want to be involved with, but money can buy everything in some places. If artificial wombs can produce children, some women will opt for those. What would these baked children be like, when compared to a child grown under his mother’s heart?
What a disgusting post.
AngeloMysterioso · 02/07/2021 17:31

I follow a few “feel good” Instagram accounts and have noticed recently (particularly during pride month where the parents were gay men) a lot of them featuring surrogacy stories and showing the moment when, as far as I see it, the newborn baby (or babies, as it quite often seems to be twins) is taken away from its mother and handed over to complete strangers.

Because as far as the baby is concerned, the woman who carried and gave birth to it is it’s mother, whether or not the person actually intending to be it’s mother (or father) is the surrogate’s infertile sibling or Amber Heard. That person is a stranger to the baby.

Why is the parents need to be parents more important than the potential psychological impact that this separation immediately after birth can have on the children?

It’s not ok to take puppies away from their mothers immediately after birth. Why is ok to do it to babies?

ShamedBySiri · 02/07/2021 17:28

@thelegohooverer

Those who say they would do it for love if a sister or friend was infertile, would you be okay in the reverse situation asking them to take the risk for you? Or okay with them refusing to do it for you?

People forget how dangerous pregnancy and birth can be. And surrogate pregnancies are more high risk than normal pregnancies for various reasons. There have been at least four deaths of surrogate mothers in America that I have heard of, but the agencies tend to hush it up when it happens and there are non disclosure agreements so there may well be more. And who is counting the deaths of the poor women of Ukraine and other poor countries that rich westerners go to to obtain a bargain basement baby (I have heard Colombia is a new go to cheap destination)?

And for every death don't forget there will be women who had an extremely dangerous birth and whose health may have been impacted forever.

Personally I would be outraged if one of my daughters put the other at risk in this way. It might be a loving thing to do to offer to carry a baby for your sister but a loving sister will decline the offer. My daughters understand this.

https://www.cbc-network.org/2021/06/surrogacy-can-be-an-orphan-maker/

IcedPurple · 02/07/2021 17:27

@AwaAnBileYerHeid

None of our business. We have no way of knowing if these women do or don't have medical issues which affect them carrying children.

Much like any surrogacy - I'm not away to sit and pass judgement on how any woman chooses to live her life.

Using another woman as an incubator and commissioning babies to order is everyone's business.

Yes, she may be infertile but having babies is not a human right.

osbertthesyrianhamster · 02/07/2021 17:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ericaequites · 02/07/2021 17:11

Egg donation is about building better babies. There are height, weight, health, educational, and psychological requirements. Still, there are no guarantees. What is it like to carry a child not related to you?it’s not something I would want to be involved with, but money can buy everything in some places.
If artificial wombs can produce children, some women will opt for those. What would these baked children be like, when compared to a child grown under his mother’s heart?

ShamedBySiri · 02/07/2021 17:10

I don’t see a problem with surrogacy in the U.K., it’s altruistic. So long as a woman isn’t forced to be a surrogate surely it’s down to them to do it if they want to? I knew of a surrogate who do it because they loved being pregnant, and wanted to help a friend/family. And she was a feminist!

This woman has two children of her own, nearly died with a life threatening haemorrhage that needed a spell in ICU with her fifth surrogate pregnancy and has carried on to have another two. (Nine births in total).

Personally I am shocked and appalled that IVF clinics would carry on using her like this. She delivered the sixth in December 2019 and the seventh was due in March 2021 meaning she must have been impregnated around six months after the previous one. How can that be healthy? I think she's had the seven over a period of about eight years.

The NHS has to pick up the pieces and deal with these high risk pregnancies while the private IVF clinic makes its money.

And what of her own children? She has prioritised breeding babies for strangers over the care and welfare of her own children who could have been orphaned. However much some women may love being pregnant and feel well, there's no way she can run around playing football with her son and daughter in the park. What life have those children had while she is busy meeting up with potential commissioning parents and going to fertility clinics and spending time in hospital?

I don't think loving being pregnant is a great reason to be a multiple surrogate mother - it's deeply selfish.

I love giving birth. This is my seventh surrogate baby’.

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/a5a8dbd8-4ac5-11eb-81f9-1b786036a268?shareToken=cc100bd93dc1a3e12fab2d998e6355fbb_

Aspiringmatriarch · 02/07/2021 17:02

Maybe Amber Heard is on psychiatric medication that would be harmful to a baby? I'm not comfortable with surrogacy because of the trauma to the baby and potentially to the mother (i.e. the woman who actually carries the child), but it's one of many things I feel have ethical problems, from sweatshop workers to animal welfare. I don't know, it's just the world we live in I guess. Sad
I have to say I don't envy any child having Amber Heard as a mother either.

Beeeeeeeeeeeeeep · 02/07/2021 17:02

@phoenixrosehere

I feel uncomfortable telling women what they can and can’t do with their bodies and that includes surrogacy. We can agree that women are not incubators but if a woman makes the informed choice to be one for someone else who am I to tell her she can’t or to tell someone they have to have a baby using their own body or they’re not a mother or should have a baby.
Do you think people should be able to donate organs for pay? If not, what's the difference?
osbertthesyrianhamster · 02/07/2021 16:59

It's legalised and sanctioned organ and baby selling.

TinkleTongs · 02/07/2021 16:58

@Antiqueanniesmagiclanternshow

I disagree with surrogacy completely. I especially disagree with amber heard being allowed to have a child! Hardly good parent material!
True - this is the woman who shit in Johnny depps bed and has anger issues ie : court evidence of her chucking stuff about

What is she going to do when real mother hood kicks in and baby not sleeping and she’s up all night …

Oh that’s right , hand the baby to the nanny and swan off for “ self care “

phoenixrosehere · 02/07/2021 16:52

I feel uncomfortable telling women what they can and can’t do with their bodies and that includes surrogacy. We can agree that women are not incubators but if a woman makes the informed choice to be one for someone else who am I to tell her she can’t or to tell someone they have to have a baby using their own body or they’re not a mother or should have a baby.

Antiqueanniesmagiclanternshow · 02/07/2021 16:50

I disagree with surrogacy completely.
I especially disagree with amber heard being allowed to have a child! Hardly good parent material!

Beeeeeeeeeeeeeep · 02/07/2021 16:49

Neither have I except one a few years ago and she had her second child through a surrogate because she had a horrendous time, nearly dying, producing her first. The child came from her egg and her husband's sperm so biologically hers and her husband's baby.

It's very sad when this happens but the answer is to stop at one child not put another woman through the same risk to provide you with more babies

FourTeaFallOut · 02/07/2021 16:48

The child came from her egg and her husband's sperm so biologically hers and her husband's baby

Well, genetically, you might argue although there is the influence of the pregnant woman on gene expression to complicate that fact but biologically?

Biologically another woman's body built that IKEA flatpack handful of cells and nourished and nurtured each and every cell of that baby for 9 whole months thereafter.

stairway · 02/07/2021 16:44

I don’t agree with any type of surrogacy. Renting out women’s bodies is hardly a step forward for woman. Even altruistic surrogacy is riddled with ethical issues. I can’t imagine Amber Heard being a good mother either.

Sleeplessem · 02/07/2021 16:40

@CastawayQueen

YANBU - but IMO because I’m uncomfortable with the idea of buying and selling humans (which is essentially what surrogacy is). Furthermore I think it’s selfish. If people are that rich they can adopt - why do they need a baby from their OWN genes? Smacks of egoism and that they don’t want to love a child, they just want a copy of themselves.
Yesss! It’s the child that is ‘biologically theirs’ above all else, including ethics, that weirds me out. Especially when it’s for women who have already had several children eg. Kim K, Hilaria Baldwin or women that want to opt out of pregnancy for some bS reason e.g. khloe k and Lucy lui
Maggiesfarm · 02/07/2021 16:40

@Aprilx

I haven’t heard of many celebrity women having children by surrogate. So I’m going to give the benefit of the doubt and assume it was one of a limited number of choices she had.
Neither have I except one a few years ago and she had her second child through a surrogate because she had a horrendous time, nearly dying, producing her first. The child came from her egg and her husband's sperm so biologically hers and her husband's baby.
Clydesider · 02/07/2021 16:32

I'd never really thought about celebrities paying other women to have babies for them until I learned about Camille Grammer on Real Housewives of Beverly Hills.

It's a disgusting thing to do, rent a woman's uterus, her body, to get yourself a child. I'm absolutely against surrogacy. It sickens me to think some of these high profile women will have used surrogates purely to keep their own 'flawless' bodies.

SunSunSunshine · 02/07/2021 16:28

@Recessed

I agree Comedycook seeing the photo of Mark from Westlife and his husband taking their newborn baby home from hospital and away from her mother literally made my heart ache for that baby - and I'm one of the most unsentimental people going! After having my own DC it just seemed so so wrong and massively selfish.
That poor baby that has been with his/her mum for 9 months to just be taken away like that makes me so sad. You would not take a kitten away from its mum for the first 8 weeks so why is it ok to take a human away from its mum. It is so utterly selfish and narcissistic. It is all about the parents wants and needs.
CastawayQueen · 02/07/2021 16:28

Also to add - it’s putting another human life at risk for NO REASON other than to satisfy someone else’s selfish desire.
Of course one could argue that the surrogate chose it (like ones pp mentioned who luuurve being pregnant) but people who choose to put someone else at risk like that are disgusting. Idk if they should be having children

BalladOfBarryAndFreda · 02/07/2021 16:28

Surrogacy of any kind is immoral, especially when we know so much about the importance of the ‘fourth trimester’ to a baby’s emotional and physical development.

CastawayQueen · 02/07/2021 16:26

YANBU - but IMO because I’m uncomfortable with the idea of buying and selling humans (which is essentially what surrogacy is).
Furthermore I think it’s selfish. If people are that rich they can adopt - why do they need a baby from their OWN genes? Smacks of egoism and that they don’t want to love a child, they just want a copy of themselves.

SunSunSunshine · 02/07/2021 16:23

@TinaYouFatLard

All surrogacy is a hideous business. Nobody should be able to rent a woman’s body or buy a baby.

Do you ever hear of a rich, famous woman carrying a baby for a poorer woman? It’s exploitative and revolting.

Completely agree!
SunSunSunshine · 02/07/2021 16:23

@Aprilx

I haven’t heard of many celebrity women having children by surrogate. So I’m going to give the benefit of the doubt and assume it was one of a limited number of choices she had.
Kim Kardashian, Aida Williams, Alex baldwins wife are a few
Swipe left for the next trending thread