Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel uncomfortable with celebrity surrogacy?

333 replies

Username91 · 02/07/2021 10:35

After reading about Amber Herd having a baby girl via surrogate it just got me thinking about the amount of famous people who have children this way. I have nothing against surrogacy, it just seems to me that a lot of rich women choose to have children this way and I’m not convinced they ALL have problems carrying children themselves. I find it a bit disturbing and wondered if I’m alone in thinking this?

Once again I’d like to point out I’m not surrogacy bashing here. I just don’t think it should be something that is used by women with money as they don’t like the idea of carrying their own babies, of course it’s very different for women who struggle to conceive/carry themselves.

OP posts:
DrinkFeckArseBrick · 02/07/2021 18:33

I can understand people being uncomfortable with paying for surrogacy and see how its exploitative.

Out of interest, why are people still against it when it's done completely freely eg someone offers to help a family member, knowing they have completed their family and pregnancy has been easy for them in the past for example. Yes there are risks but there are also risks in donating bone marrow or a kidney etc.

Are there any studies in the longer term effects on children born to surrogates (I know there are such studies on children adopted out the family from birth)? As this is the main issue I could see if there was any evidence around it

Pinuporc · 02/07/2021 18:33

I saw a programme earlier this year about surrogacy (no celebs involved) in the uk. It followed a couple of women who were surrogates.one was a surrogate for her boss who was I think, infertile, and another young, single mother, was a surrogate for a gay couple. I thought the single mother seemed vulnerable and iirc had experienced some MH problems. I found it interesting but quite uncomfortable viewing.

osbertthesyrianhamster · 02/07/2021 18:33

You’re the one being unnecessarily prickly - bad day?

Hmm I'm not the one who got personal with another poster.

Screening or no, there isn't one for autism. Anyone using an egg donor is hopefully made aware of the fact that there are no guarantees but then, I'm not in favour of gamete donation myself.

CastawayQueen · 02/07/2021 18:29

@osbertthesyrianhamster

And your point is - what exactly?

Well, it's pretty clears yours is to be rude AF. Hmm

It was in response to Ericaqueties's post about egg donation not being a guarantee. I just forgot to quote it. That okay with you?

It's a statement of fact. She's a friend of mine. She donated before she had children herself.

I have a child with quite severe autism myself.

Carry on jumping all over me and looking for stuff that's not there in a statement of fact.

You’re the one being unnecessarily prickly - bad day? Without the quote your post implies something against autistic people. It’s true though that nobody’s eggs are any guarantee - just tuat an ‘unknown’s is presumed to be screened
HerewardTheWoke · 02/07/2021 18:28

YANBU OP. Irrespective of why people opt for surrogacy:

  1. It's wrong to create a pregnancy with the express intention of separating child from birth mother - separation from a birth mother is damaging for the child and should only ever be as a last resort to protect the child.
  1. It's wrong to use your greater economic power to incentivise a poorer woman to take grave risks with her health and life.
  1. It harms women as a group by encouraging society to see our bodies as resources that can be bought.
  1. If it becomes widespread enough, it may ultimately end up entrenching inequality between rich and poor women - i.e. if 'high-flying' wealthy women increasingly use surrogacy, it will correspondingly redistribute the social, physical and economic impacts of pregnancy to poorer women. That's not the way to overcome sex-based inequality.
Ginger1982 · 02/07/2021 18:24

I was (and wasn't) surprised when Khloe Khardashian was talking about it. She's been told it would be dangerous for her to carry another pregnancy but she 'needs' to give her daughter a sibling so a surrogate is just the obvious solution rather than just sticking with one child. That annoys me.

EmeraldShamrock · 02/07/2021 18:23

Yanbu. It is very wrong and acceptable for many.
The photos of stranded babies in the Ukraine over lockdown should have highlighted it, money talks.

TheWeeDonkey · 02/07/2021 18:20

Its making a commodity of children and of women's bodies, its a lucky woman who has a straight forward pregnancy and birth.

I do feel sorry for these children, outsource the pregnancy and birth, outsource the parenting and trot them out every so often for a lovely photo op. What kind of life is that?

awaynboilyurheid · 02/07/2021 18:20

I thought the picture of Amber Heard and baby was strange, it looked like she had given birth to it, but she looked perfectly made up, hair and make up perfect, then I read it was a surrogate, seemed odd, like she was conveying she had given birth in the image, but look at me I still look great! Well no wonder!

frogswimming · 02/07/2021 18:15

I feel sorry for the babies always now. It's like they are a commodity. Adopting a newborn when the mother can't look after it is obviously a wonderful thing to do. But in surrogacy a baby is purposely created to be separated from its biological mother. That doesn't seem right.

Especially when I think of breast feeding, the third trimester and the wanting to be held.

CaptSkippy · 02/07/2021 18:07

Surrogacy is a form of modern day slavery, which is evidenced by the fact that it's not the rich women being the surrogates, but the women with little to no income. In many countries paying for surrogacy is illegal and yet it still happens. Surrogates at the most earn less than a year's worth of minimum income, despite having their bodies occupied for someone else's use for three quarters of a year, not including time to recover afterwards.
I think the practice is abhorrent. If you are incapable or unwilling to carry your own child, it does NOT give you the right to burden another women with the risks of complications and permanent alterations to her body.
Nobody is entitled to having a child.

minniebin · 02/07/2021 18:06

Well Kim Kardashian likely did it for vanity. I have bad pregnancies so can totally see why it would be preferable.

Bumblenums1234 · 02/07/2021 18:04

I just csnt understand why people would assume that she did this due to vanity and not that she was infertile. I just can't imagine the pain of being in the room at scans of someone else who is carrying your child and not getting to experience it all. It must be so hard and I can't see why anyone would choose that option unless they really saw it as a last resort.

I loved being pregnant, maybe that is why I just can't see why someone would volunteer to outsource it.

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 02/07/2021 17:55

Egg donation also has serious health consequences for the donor, sometimes (ovarian hyper stimulation syndrome being the most obvious risk). Its all massively exploitative and misogynistic, as well as reducing babies to commodities.

minniebin · 02/07/2021 17:55

One area I find interesting is the idea that genetic material passes between the mother & foetus. Some scientists think this DNA can be good or bad for the mothers health even years later eg increasing or decreasing cancer risks. Definitely potential ethical concerns there for a surrogate.

osbertthesyrianhamster · 02/07/2021 17:53

Another utterly abhorrent post. You should be ashamed of yourself.

Um, no, why should I be? It's a statement of fact. She worries about those people now. She had no idea and feels she carries a heritable form of the condition.

If you want to go around looking for defensiveness in posts where it isn't there, go ahead.

osbertthesyrianhamster · 02/07/2021 17:51

And your point is - what exactly?

Well, it's pretty clears yours is to be rude AF. Hmm

It was in response to Ericaqueties's post about egg donation not being a guarantee. I just forgot to quote it. That okay with you?

It's a statement of fact. She's a friend of mine. She donated before she had children herself.

I have a child with quite severe autism myself.

Carry on jumping all over me and looking for stuff that's not there in a statement of fact.

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 02/07/2021 17:51

YANBU - surrogacy is not in the best interests of the children created to supply adults wants, as well as reducing poor women to commercially available disposable vessels.

Removing a newborn from his or her mother (and to the baby the woman in who's womb they grow, who's heartbeat and voice they hear in the womb is their mother) is only appropriate where an existing foetus is at risk from their mother - where babies are removed from their mothers it should only be to make the best of a bad situation, where they already exist but are only safe if removed. Adoption at birth isn't acceptable in the UK because its recognised that there are long and short term negative consequences for the child. It is sometimes the least bad option for a baby already in existence, but creating a baby for removal is a human rights violation.

Comedycook · 02/07/2021 17:50

@womanity

I don’t know why they don’t buy the babies when they’re a bit older. A newborn is tricky if you’ve a career to manage.

I’m surprised more of them don’t wait til the kid is toilet trained, or even better, in school.

If you're extremely wealthy, I'd imagine having a newborn has as much effect on your career and life as you want it to...
CastawayQueen · 02/07/2021 17:48

@osbertthesyrianhamster

I know someone whose donated eggs resulted in, that she knows of, 3 lives births. She has 3 herself. All of them have autism, 2 will never live independently. They had different dads and she believes her father had autism and her mother as well.
And your point is - what exactly?
womanity · 02/07/2021 17:41

I don’t know why they don’t buy the babies when they’re a bit older. A newborn is tricky if you’ve a career to manage.

I’m surprised more of them don’t wait til the kid is toilet trained, or even better, in school.

minniebin · 02/07/2021 17:41

I'm uncomfortable with elements of it definitely.

randomkey123 · 02/07/2021 17:34

And how many of these celebs actually raise the baby themselves?

IcedPurple · 02/07/2021 17:34

@phoenixrosehere

I feel uncomfortable telling women what they can and can’t do with their bodies and that includes surrogacy. We can agree that women are not incubators but if a woman makes the informed choice to be one for someone else who am I to tell her she can’t or to tell someone they have to have a baby using their own body or they’re not a mother or should have a baby.
But we tell women - and men - that they can't sell organs. We tell them they can't ingest certain drugs. We tell them they can't go around naked in public.

Bodily autonomy is not absolute. There are always restrictions, which differ from one society to the next. But no society believes that anyone can just do what they like 'with their body'.

Not to mention that surrogacy doesn't just involves adults making 'choices'. It involves the creation of an innocent baby, with the express intention of taking it away from its mother at birth. And yes, as far as the baby is concerned, the woman who carried them for 9 months and gave birth to them is their mother. They know nothing of 'parental orders' or 'surrogacy journeys'.

Separating newborn animals from their mothers is considered unethical. But it's OK for human babies, so long as the wealth adults who 'commissioned' them gets what they want?

OrangeBlossomMacaron · 02/07/2021 17:32

@osbertthesyrianhamster

I know someone whose donated eggs resulted in, that she knows of, 3 lives births. She has 3 herself. All of them have autism, 2 will never live independently. They had different dads and she believes her father had autism and her mother as well.
Another utterly abhorrent post. You should be ashamed of yourself.
Swipe left for the next trending thread