Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel uncomfortable with celebrity surrogacy?

333 replies

Username91 · 02/07/2021 10:35

After reading about Amber Herd having a baby girl via surrogate it just got me thinking about the amount of famous people who have children this way. I have nothing against surrogacy, it just seems to me that a lot of rich women choose to have children this way and I’m not convinced they ALL have problems carrying children themselves. I find it a bit disturbing and wondered if I’m alone in thinking this?

Once again I’d like to point out I’m not surrogacy bashing here. I just don’t think it should be something that is used by women with money as they don’t like the idea of carrying their own babies, of course it’s very different for women who struggle to conceive/carry themselves.

OP posts:
ConfusedBear · 02/07/2021 21:52

@CP26 thank you for posting the second article about how no difference could be seen in later years. I found that more straightforward to understand. It will be interesting to see what other studies say when they are published.

EmeraldShamrock · 02/07/2021 21:13

Because as far as the baby is concerned, the woman who carried and gave birth to it is it’s mother Parents of surrogate children don't believe that, there has to be a connection.
There is 1000's born yearly and those in denial don't consider the babies who arrive disabled they are abandoned stateless.
Or the selective abortion if your surrogate has multiple embryos.
There's 1000 of DC in Ukraine Orphanages too.

FannyCann · 02/07/2021 20:50

It's interesting how so many on here are against surrogacy. In real life, people think you're some kind of monster for being against it. Friends have looked at me in horror and simply couldn't understand my point of view, because, you know, cute babies, sad people being made happy thanks to others 'being kind', cute babies blah blah

But those same people (f they are women) usually say "oh how wonderful and kind. Of course I could never do it myself..."

And many of those people - male and female - have very limited knowledge if any of what it really involves.

I think for women who have been through pregnancy and childbirth it is more natural to understand the demands it makes on your body, the birth injuries and haemorrhages, the love of their baby, and not even consider that it is an acceptable idea, they are more likely to be in agreement with this from Beeeeep (sorry if I'm a few e's short).

Getting pregnant, gestating and birthing a baby to give away as 'a nice thing to do' is utterly mad. Nobody mentally ok would think of doing that. That must be meeting some need in them.

SunSunSunshine · 02/07/2021 20:47

@Travielkapelka

I know someone who was a surrogate. She had had her family, she was extremely comfortably off. She just felt that she was so lucky to have her kids she wanted to give someone else that chance. She had the baby, handed it to the parents and carried on with her life. I have no issue with this. I think she’s entirely selfless
But it's not all about her. It's about the baby. The baby and it's needs should always come first.
SunSunSunshine · 02/07/2021 20:43

@AngeloMysterioso

I follow a few “feel good” Instagram accounts and have noticed recently (particularly during pride month where the parents were gay men) a lot of them featuring surrogacy stories and showing the moment when, as far as I see it, the newborn baby (or babies, as it quite often seems to be twins) is taken away from its mother and handed over to complete strangers.

Because as far as the baby is concerned, the woman who carried and gave birth to it is it’s mother, whether or not the person actually intending to be it’s mother (or father) is the surrogate’s infertile sibling or Amber Heard. That person is a stranger to the baby.

Why is the parents need to be parents more important than the potential psychological impact that this separation immediately after birth can have on the children?

It’s not ok to take puppies away from their mothers immediately after birth. Why is ok to do it to babies?

When I see this it makes me physically ill and so utterly sad for that newborn baby. As I've said before, you wouldn't take a kitten or puppy away from its mother so why take a human baby? It is so so wrong.
ArabellaScott · 02/07/2021 20:13

YANBU. All surrogacy is problematic, imo, and the celebrity spin on it presenting it as an Insta-friendly lifestyle choice is pretty sickening.

Comedycook · 02/07/2021 20:07

It's interesting how so many on here are against surrogacy. In real life, people think you're some kind of monster for being against it. Friends have looked at me in horror and simply couldn't understand my point of view, because, you know, cute babies, sad people being made happy thanks to others 'being kind', cute babies blah blah

toocold54 · 02/07/2021 19:44

YANBU I watched a celeb talk about it and it was quite obvious that it was more about choosing the sex of the child out of the embryos rather that they couldn’t carry themselves (obviously some can’t.
It feels uncomfortable that you can choose the sex. The embryos are also tested for illness so it’s almost like they’re trying to get the perfect child.

Annasgirl · 02/07/2021 19:40

All surrogacy is wrong. There are loads of resources on here to back this up. Anyone who support the idea that pregnancy is a service has never studied human biology or in vitro neurological development or the brain shrinkage that occurs during pregnancy or ................

It is always wrong. Whether it is Barbara from next door, or Amber or any other person, the idea that you can buy a human is WRONG.

Ericaequites · 02/07/2021 19:36

@OrangeBlossomMacaron. Egg donation is often a form of eugenics I find disconcerting. You can try to choose the perfect genotype, but the resulting phenotype may be quite different.

FrankButchersDickieBow · 02/07/2021 19:36

@DrinkFeckArseBrick

I can understand people being uncomfortable with paying for surrogacy and see how its exploitative.

Out of interest, why are people still against it when it's done completely freely eg someone offers to help a family member, knowing they have completed their family and pregnancy has been easy for them in the past for example. Yes there are risks but there are also risks in donating bone marrow or a kidney etc.

Are there any studies in the longer term effects on children born to surrogates (I know there are such studies on children adopted out the family from birth)? As this is the main issue I could see if there was any evidence around it

I love my sisters too much to ask them to do something so risky so I could get something I wanted.

They would offer, but I would refuse. I would never in a million years expect someone to carry a child on my behalf.

PurpleDaisies · 02/07/2021 19:35

You have really easy pregnancies until suddenly you don’t. Each pregnancy is a new event. My “I always have easy pregnancies” friend recently had gestational diabetes and needed an emergency c section with baby three after totally straightforward experiences before.

TheWeeDonkey · 02/07/2021 19:29

@Comedycook

Getting pregnant, gestating and birthing a baby to give away as 'a nice thing to do' is utterly mad. Nobody mentally ok would think of doing that

Agree

Me too
Travielkapelka · 02/07/2021 19:11

I don’t agree. I think that there genuinely are peoples or who have had easy pregnancies and who want to be able to offer someone they know (as in this case) the opportunity to be a parent. I wouldn’t have done it for a friend or a random but I had really easy pregnancies and if my sister had been unable to have a baby I would have done it for her without hesitation

Comedycook · 02/07/2021 19:07

Getting pregnant, gestating and birthing a baby to give away as 'a nice thing to do' is utterly mad. Nobody mentally ok would think of doing that

Agree

jeaux90 · 02/07/2021 19:04

Surrogacy is right up there with prostitution for me. Exploitation of women and the very worst of capitalism to commoditise women's bodies

Beeeeeeeeeeeeeep · 02/07/2021 19:02

@Travielkapelka

I know someone who was a surrogate. She had had her family, she was extremely comfortably off. She just felt that she was so lucky to have her kids she wanted to give someone else that chance. She had the baby, handed it to the parents and carried on with her life. I have no issue with this. I think she’s entirely selfless
Getting pregnant, gestating and birthing a baby to give away as 'a nice thing to do' is utterly mad. Nobody mentally ok would think of doing that. That must be meeting some need in them.
clopper · 02/07/2021 18:59

Biarizzcrackers
Surrogacy just keeps getting pushed that little bit further; it used to be something I was fairly comfortable with, as I just thought it seemed a generous, selfless thing to do for people who were unable

This.
I feel like the whole issue of surrogacy has changed from a selfless gesture to a commercial venture. I disagree with it completely, it’s all about the adults not the child.

HerewardTheWoke · 02/07/2021 18:55

@DrinkFeckArseBrick

I can understand people being uncomfortable with paying for surrogacy and see how its exploitative.

Out of interest, why are people still against it when it's done completely freely eg someone offers to help a family member, knowing they have completed their family and pregnancy has been easy for them in the past for example. Yes there are risks but there are also risks in donating bone marrow or a kidney etc.

Are there any studies in the longer term effects on children born to surrogates (I know there are such studies on children adopted out the family from birth)? As this is the main issue I could see if there was any evidence around it

Live donation of a kidney or bone marrow carries risks but it is done to save an existing life, and it is only ethically acceptable when done in a way that minimises risk to the donor (e.g. the donor usually retains the biggest kidney), and we don't allow payments from recipient to donor.

If organ/marrow donation doesn't happen, the chances are that somebody dies (or has a massively reduced life expectancy). It is a balance of risk to the donor and benefit to the recipient.

If surrogacy doesn't happen, nobody dies. That's the ethical difference. You're creating a completely new risk of someone dying (the surrogate mother) for no medical benefit to another individual. And the way surrogacy is done is often more high risk than a normal pregnancy - e.g. implantation of multiple embryos.

Comedycook · 02/07/2021 18:55

@Travielkapelka

I know someone who was a surrogate. She had had her family, she was extremely comfortably off. She just felt that she was so lucky to have her kids she wanted to give someone else that chance. She had the baby, handed it to the parents and carried on with her life. I have no issue with this. I think she’s entirely selfless
Like I said, only women are conditioned to be so accommodating and giving of themselves
UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 02/07/2021 18:48

DrinkFeckArseBrick very few things like this are done completely freely - there's always going to be an element of emotional blackmail even if unintentional. The intensity and complexity of emotions around the creation and raising of a baby through extended family or friends surrogacy is very hard to imagine.

There are many anecdotal accounts of so called altruistic surrogacy gone wrong, and of course no matter whether money changes hands a baby has been created for the express purpose of removing it from its mother (as far as the newborn is concerned) with the associated issues.

There are plenty of accounts similar to this to be found:

nordicmodelnow.org/2020/01/29/i-was-an-altruistic-surrogate-and-am-now-against-all-surrogacy/

DontDrinkDontSmokeWhatDoIDo · 02/07/2021 18:46

@HerewardTheWoke

YANBU OP. Irrespective of why people opt for surrogacy:
  1. It's wrong to create a pregnancy with the express intention of separating child from birth mother - separation from a birth mother is damaging for the child and should only ever be as a last resort to protect the child.
  1. It's wrong to use your greater economic power to incentivise a poorer woman to take grave risks with her health and life.
  1. It harms women as a group by encouraging society to see our bodies as resources that can be bought.
  1. If it becomes widespread enough, it may ultimately end up entrenching inequality between rich and poor women - i.e. if 'high-flying' wealthy women increasingly use surrogacy, it will correspondingly redistribute the social, physical and economic impacts of pregnancy to poorer women. That's not the way to overcome sex-based inequality.

I'm going to save your post, @HerewardTheWoke - you've summarised my thoughts perfectly.

TheVanguardSix · 02/07/2021 18:46

People have NO idea. Just because we can’t remember being born doesn’t mean that it’s not traumatic for a baby to be removed from its birth mother. Why do you think parents who adopt continue working on helping their children with attachment disorders? Do parents of babies born via surrogacy work through attachment disorders as well (genuine question)?

Travielkapelka · 02/07/2021 18:39

I know someone who was a surrogate. She had had her family, she was extremely comfortably off. She just felt that she was so lucky to have her kids she wanted to give someone else that chance. She had the baby, handed it to the parents and carried on with her life. I have no issue with this. I think she’s entirely selfless

Sleeplessem · 02/07/2021 18:35

@Ginger1982

I was (and wasn't) surprised when Khloe Khardashian was talking about it. She's been told it would be dangerous for her to carry another pregnancy but she 'needs' to give her daughter a sibling so a surrogate is just the obvious solution rather than just sticking with one child. That annoys me.
Yup same. I saw a clip and the doc said she’d be in the high risk category but that’s not directly synonymous with it’s incredibly dangerous to carry another baby. I guess it depends on the reasons, none of which have been stated. But you’re spot on, the obvious answer is to stick at 1 (biological) child, especially in her case with the father being as he is
Swipe left for the next trending thread