Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel uncomfortable with celebrity surrogacy?

333 replies

Username91 · 02/07/2021 10:35

After reading about Amber Herd having a baby girl via surrogate it just got me thinking about the amount of famous people who have children this way. I have nothing against surrogacy, it just seems to me that a lot of rich women choose to have children this way and I’m not convinced they ALL have problems carrying children themselves. I find it a bit disturbing and wondered if I’m alone in thinking this?

Once again I’d like to point out I’m not surrogacy bashing here. I just don’t think it should be something that is used by women with money as they don’t like the idea of carrying their own babies, of course it’s very different for women who struggle to conceive/carry themselves.

OP posts:
FannyCann · 03/07/2021 08:58

City firm gives staff £45k ‘fertility perk’.

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/b9b2c570-cd25-11eb-9bfa-a3bc386e6928?shareToken=cb3e1c67c608d99d065e34428f59af088_

In the U.K. £45k will fully cover surrogacy costs. It costs about double that in the USA but it wouldn't surprise me if some employees are able to make it work for them by having a secondment to the U.K. for a year or two and availing themselves if the cheaper costs over here.

CounsellorTroi · 03/07/2021 08:57

@Comedycook

It's interesting how so many on here are against surrogacy. In real life, people think you're some kind of monster for being against it. Friends have looked at me in horror and simply couldn't understand my point of view, because, you know, cute babies, sad people being made happy thanks to others 'being kind', cute babies blah blah
Some people just think baby being born equals good thing and can't see any further than that. You see it on here - people ask "should I have a baby in X circumstances" and some people always say yes go for it no matter how bad the circumstances are.
MihaelaCW · 03/07/2021 08:55

Most people are OK with much worse things happening to women's bodies to create a never ending stream of vile porn. It's apparently cool to be cool about that, so I don't get too worked up about surrogacy if it's done in an ethical manner by mentally sound people.

FannyCann · 03/07/2021 08:51

*status of battery chicken

FannyCann · 03/07/2021 08:50

@Jobseeker19 yesterday 11:59

Let's be real, they do not want to have their body changed by a pregnancy so they are getting a poorer woman to have their child.

They get the baby and to keep their slim bodies which doesn't have stretch marks, incontinence and all the other stuff we risk when we get pregnant and give birth.

What it does it create a class system where women who have given birth are seen as lesser and undesirable.

The normalisation of surrogacy is already leading to a situation where wealthy "higher class" women can and do choose not to go through pregnancy and birth. Meanwhile a lower class of women are becoming the "breeder" class, providing gestational services to the wealthy. Not just women but also men - some gay but now we have single men who don't want the bother of a relationship with a woman demanding the right to "fertility equality" and buying babies for themselves. There is precious little safeguarding for the babies in the way potential adopters are screened and already there have been some shocking cases in USA of the babies being abused and even killed.

This is terrible for babies obviously.

It is also terrible for women and society.
Hands up who wants to be a breeder? No? Then why should other women be consigned to the stays of a battery chicken?

It also means that for Hollywood types (and it will obviously filter down to all high performing women in a range of careers) that soon it will become unacceptable for them to take time out to have a baby. They will not be able to choose to get pregnant the normal way and have their own baby. Companies will pressure women not to take time out - there is minimal maternity rights in the USA anyway and firms are now offering fertility expenses as part of the benefits package for men as well as women which can be used to pay for surrogacy. So women will be expected to take that route rather than getting the same amount to spend on MATERNITY for themselves.

Remember in the Brave New World how disgusted Linda is by pregnancy and childbirth as she had been conditioned to believe it was unnatural? We are fast approaching that point in some circles.

BTW if you have never read Brave New World now is a good time to get stuck in.

Beeeeeeeeeeeeeep · 03/07/2021 08:11

@TreeSmuggler

I am against surrogacy but many of the arguments on this thread don't make sense.
  • Why don't they adopt - Adoption is about finding a child a home, not for parents to find a child.

  • You wouldn't take a kitten/puppy away from its mother - That's only because you would be taking it away to a house with only humans, if you were taking it to a willing surrogate cat/dog mother that would be fine.

  • Why do they even want a child, it's selfish - Exactly the same for every person who has a child by whatever means.

  • The child will have attachment disorder - No study has ever shown this. Comparisons to adopted children are meaningless as they have basically always been adopted past the newborn stage, after years of neglectful parenting.

Before I get flamed note that I am against surrogacy, but I think we should stuck to factual arguments.

Why don't they adopt - totally agree with this. The question should be why don't they accept that they can't have a child, it's sad but it's life

The kitten/puppy argument - would it be ok to do this though? If you went to a breeder and said please sell me this newborn puppy I have a bitch at home who will foster it would they sell you the puppy? I doubt it.

The selfish argument - of course everyone who has a birth child deliberately does so from selfish motivations but the point being that this is such an excessively selfish and harmful thing to do in pursuit of a bio child - it's above and beyond the selfish urge to reproduce, as it causes harm to the baby and the (birth) mother.

I have never seen it said that babies will have attachment disorders. This would be an ignorant and misleading claim. However, it DOES disrupt the attachment relationship and disregards the importance of prenatal attachment on the mother/baby dyad. Just because most babies will recover from that disruption doesn't mean it's ok to do.

WeRoarSometimes · 03/07/2021 07:52

When certain practices become common place amongst celebrities, we often assume they are doing something because they can afford to pay for something, many of us cannot.
However, we should put the economics arguement to one side.
Surrogacy is an exploitative practice. People travel to countries to pay surrogate mothers because the feel the laws in the destination country are 'flexible'. This usually means that commercial surrogacy is permitted and surrogate mums have few rights in legislation.
It is exploitation, but has been branded as something 'kind', 'amazing' to do for child free adults, who want a child and create one for the sole purpose of separating child from its birth mother.

SunSunSunshine · 03/07/2021 06:13

@TreeSmuggler

I am against surrogacy but many of the arguments on this thread don't make sense.
  • Why don't they adopt - Adoption is about finding a child a home, not for parents to find a child.

  • You wouldn't take a kitten/puppy away from its mother - That's only because you would be taking it away to a house with only humans, if you were taking it to a willing surrogate cat/dog mother that would be fine.

  • Why do they even want a child, it's selfish - Exactly the same for every person who has a child by whatever means.

  • The child will have attachment disorder - No study has ever shown this. Comparisons to adopted children are meaningless as they have basically always been adopted past the newborn stage, after years of neglectful parenting.

Before I get flamed note that I am against surrogacy, but I think we should stuck to factual arguments.

Adoption is about putting the child's needs first. Surrogacy is about the adults wants and needs.
TreeSmuggler · 03/07/2021 03:16

I am against surrogacy but many of the arguments on this thread don't make sense.

  • Why don't they adopt - Adoption is about finding a child a home, not for parents to find a child.

  • You wouldn't take a kitten/puppy away from its mother - That's only because you would be taking it away to a house with only humans, if you were taking it to a willing surrogate cat/dog mother that would be fine.

  • Why do they even want a child, it's selfish - Exactly the same for every person who has a child by whatever means.

  • The child will have attachment disorder - No study has ever shown this. Comparisons to adopted children are meaningless as they have basically always been adopted past the newborn stage, after years of neglectful parenting.

Before I get flamed note that I am against surrogacy, but I think we should stuck to factual arguments.

FlyingPandas · 03/07/2021 00:49

YANBU

I am deeply uncomfortable with the idea of surrogacy in any circumstances BUT having said that, have a DSIS who cannot have her own children and there have been times when I've thought, I could have a baby for her, my own family is finished etc etc.

It would never have been an option as DSIS would not have accepted the offer (she and her DH are devout Christians) but I'd be lying if I hadn't considered offering.

Celebrity surrogacy I am opposed to on every single level going, simply because I am deeply cynical about celebrities in general (and American/Hollywoodised celebrities in particular) and would absolutely assume they simply do not wish to carry their own pregnancy. I am massively unfair in this assumption, perhaps, but I don't believe any of them actually have any infertility issues at all. They simply want to select the sex of the baby and maintain their perfect bodies. They don't care which poor woman they exploit to get their perfect child. (Can you imagine how someone like Naomi Campbell most likely treated her surrogate? The mind boggles). These vacuous individuals want total control and picture-perfect babies to boast about on Instagram. Said babies will almost certainly be raised by a brace of nannies. And I would bet everything I own that if any celeb surrogate baby had a whiff of a disability, they would be up for adoption in a nanosecond.

Sorry if that sounds cynical and unfair. But I loathe celebrity culture with a passion and celeb surrogacy just feels like a dysfunctional extension of that. It's wrong on pretty much every level going.

HerewardTheWoke · 03/07/2021 00:36

@secsee

Seeing a lot of "rich women are never surrogates for poor women"

Honestly, I don't support surrogacy really, but this argument makes no sense

You also don't see rich women cleaning poor women's houses, or serving them at tills. Not equivalent to 'slavery' or 'exploitation'. All it means is a rich woman would need more money to consider surrogacy - which a poor woman couldn't offer

Rich people don't always use poor surrogate mothers. They may well be similar social status. I'm obviously against outsourcing to people who genuinely are destitute and feel compelled. But come on, simple thinking here.

But serving on a till doesn't put you at risk of serious illness, permanent disability or death. All of which can and do happen to women in this country as a result of pregnancy and childbirth.

A better analogy would be paying a poorer woman to remove asbestos in your house with no protective equipment. That would be exploitative, because of the known risks.

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 03/07/2021 00:30

You also don't see rich women cleaning poor women's houses, or serving them at tills.

Nobody claims that women clean houses or serve at tills for altrustic reasons, because they just love it soo much. That's what people claim about surrogates.

potatoocity · 03/07/2021 00:21

@irishfeminist

Secsee, cleaning someone's house is not the same as gestating a child for them. If you can't see that I don't know how to help you.
No, it's an example of why rich people aren't carrying a baby for a poor woman, who is also a stranger. Not difficult to understand

A rich woman would want more than £2k, for example, if that was the budget for a poorer couple. Unless they are very well acquainted, why would she offer?

irishfeminist · 03/07/2021 00:07

Secsee, cleaning someone's house is not the same as gestating a child for them. If you can't see that I don't know how to help you.

irishfeminist · 03/07/2021 00:06

It's horrific how normalised it's becoming. In Ireland most people seem to be paying surrogates in Ukraine, an extremely poor country. I find it especially sickening as we're still supposedly hand-wringing over how we treated our own unmarried mothers and babies in recent history.

secsee · 03/07/2021 00:02

Seeing a lot of "rich women are never surrogates for poor women"

Honestly, I don't support surrogacy really, but this argument makes no sense

You also don't see rich women cleaning poor women's houses, or serving them at tills. Not equivalent to 'slavery' or 'exploitation'. All it means is a rich woman would need more money to consider surrogacy - which a poor woman couldn't offer

Rich people don't always use poor surrogate mothers. They may well be similar social status. I'm obviously against outsourcing to people who genuinely are destitute and feel compelled. But come on, simple thinking here.

osbertthesyrianhamster · 02/07/2021 23:51

I just feel there are so mani kids waiting to be adopted. And to take a baby away from the person who carried them is wrong, it's all they've known, the voice, the smell etc. That's how I feel anyway.

Whilst I disagree entirely with surrogacy and egg donation, children up for adoption are not consolation prizes for infertile people. There are more kids waiting to be adopted than there are suitable homes as many children up for adoption in the UK have only been removed after significant problems and are far from babyhood.

hysteriaonthedancefloor · 02/07/2021 23:38

When is it ok to ask a poorer woman to risk her reproductive health to give you a baby?

Who is going around posing this question to a woman?

espressoontap · 02/07/2021 23:23

@IHaveBrilloHair

I'm completely anti surrogacy
Me, too.

I just feel there are so mani kids waiting to be adopted. And to take a baby away from the person who carried them is wrong, it's all they've known, the voice, the smell etc. That's how I feel anyway.

FannyCann · 02/07/2021 23:11

@WeRoarSometimes Welcome back. Roaring all the louder after a break! Smile

MrsRockAndRoll · 02/07/2021 22:54

[quote WeRoarSometimes]@FannyCann
@ArabellaScott
Hear hear. Haven't been online for a while.

Extreme wealth in a country with huge inequality in society develops a market place for surrogacy. Think the US, Ukraine and Colombia.

We should be asking ourselves why is surrogacy banned in countries with better social care systems such as Sweden or the Netherlands? Perhaps they recognise the risks posed to women of poorer backgrounds.

When is it ok to ask a poorer woman to risk her reproductive health to give you a baby?[/quote]
@WeRoarSometimes

Fully agree.

I'm still enraged by the Lucy Liu quote upthread that she was too busy working to have her own baby..: only someone rich would think that's acceptable. She obviously didn't think she was too busy to care for a child!?

WeRoarSometimes · 02/07/2021 22:45

@FannyCann
@ArabellaScott
Hear hear. Haven't been online for a while.

Extreme wealth in a country with huge inequality in society develops a market place for surrogacy. Think the US, Ukraine and Colombia.

We should be asking ourselves why is surrogacy banned in countries with better social care systems such as Sweden or the Netherlands? Perhaps they recognise the risks posed to women of poorer backgrounds.

When is it ok to ask a poorer woman to risk her reproductive health to give you a baby?

CatsArePeople · 02/07/2021 22:32

YANBU. Some of those "celebrities" are like 60 years old. No business of having babies in that age. And of course, it is nannies raising those babies, not "mothers".

IcedPurple · 02/07/2021 22:13

@Travielkapelka

I know someone who was a surrogate. She had had her family, she was extremely comfortably off. She just felt that she was so lucky to have her kids she wanted to give someone else that chance. She had the baby, handed it to the parents and carried on with her life. I have no issue with this. I think she’s entirely selfless
Oh, how cute and adorable.

How did her children feel about the fact that mummy was pregnant but 'handed' the baby over and 'carried on with her life'? That must have been puzzling for them.

How did the baby feel about being seperated at birth from the only mother it had ever known?

What if she had become pregnant with a child with a congenital disorder and the 'parents' decided they didn't want it?

It's great that this person was so very happy and 'selfless' and that the 'surrogacy journey' went as glibly and smoothly as a Hallmark card slogan, but that dosnt change the fact that surrogacy is a moral and ethical minefield.

Maggiesfarm · 02/07/2021 22:09

@EmeraldShamrock

Because as far as the baby is concerned, the woman who carried and gave birth to it is it’s mother Parents of surrogate children don't believe that, there has to be a connection. There is 1000's born yearly and those in denial don't consider the babies who arrive disabled they are abandoned stateless. Or the selective abortion if your surrogate has multiple embryos. There's 1000 of DC in Ukraine Orphanages too.
I honestly believe the mother who gives birth should hold, feed and generally care for the baby for a few weeks, handing over to the other parents gradually so the baby is comfortable with them too. Obviously that means her living with the couple and having the grief of parting with the child, an expensive business too. It's a nightmare really and a great pity surrogacy was ever thought of but here it is and not going away (though I believed it was illegal in this country).
Swipe left for the next trending thread