Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel uncomfortable with celebrity surrogacy?

333 replies

Username91 · 02/07/2021 10:35

After reading about Amber Herd having a baby girl via surrogate it just got me thinking about the amount of famous people who have children this way. I have nothing against surrogacy, it just seems to me that a lot of rich women choose to have children this way and I’m not convinced they ALL have problems carrying children themselves. I find it a bit disturbing and wondered if I’m alone in thinking this?

Once again I’d like to point out I’m not surrogacy bashing here. I just don’t think it should be something that is used by women with money as they don’t like the idea of carrying their own babies, of course it’s very different for women who struggle to conceive/carry themselves.

OP posts:
WeRoarSometimes · 03/07/2021 16:38

@Twizbe
Thanks for sharing, really pleased you have the family you waited so long for.

ArabellaScott · 03/07/2021 16:36

I do empathise with people who have struggled to conceive, I imagine it must be very hard.

Buying a child is not a solution, and having a child is not a 'right'.

Twizbe · 03/07/2021 16:25

@M0nkeybars

A lot of judgement on this thread. I'd be interested to know how many of those of you totally against surrogacy have struggled with infertility or have had multiple losses and surrogacy is one of the very few options available for you to have a child of your own? What about LGBT+ couples who can't carry a biological child? Or single people?

And please don't say "just adopt" - it's not that simple.

I went through years of infertility. I'm against surrogacy. Near the end of our journey (we were lucky and have children now) I started to make peace with not having a child. Adoption wasn't an option for me so that left embracing a childless life.
Maggiesfarm · 03/07/2021 16:17

@M0nkeybars

A lot of judgement on this thread. I'd be interested to know how many of those of you totally against surrogacy have struggled with infertility or have had multiple losses and surrogacy is one of the very few options available for you to have a child of your own? What about LGBT+ couples who can't carry a biological child? Or single people?

And please don't say "just adopt" - it's not that simple.

I agree that 'just adopt' is ridiculous and an insensitive suggestion. Adoption is not an easy process.

Personally there has been no struggle with infertility but I have been very close to some people who have had fertility problems. Not the same I know but I cannot imagine any of them hiring a surrogate. They were able to come to terms with it: one couple never had a child but had a blessed and useful life throughout their marriage, which they appreciated. Another couple did adopt two children. A relative of mine did eventually become pregnant after virtually giving up and had a much loved child, now adult. Someone else I knew remained bitter.

Regarding LGBT+ couples and single people, in past years they would have just known that having a child was not on the cards and lived their lives as fully as they could without. I've known a couple of gay couples who would never in a million years have thought of such a thing.

Nobody has a right to a child and you don't just have one because you want one, we all have things we would like but have to do without - and get on with it.

I wonder what happens if, and how often, a child born by surrogacy does not bond with his or her biological mother, or rather the mother does not bond with the child. We don't hear about that but it must happen.It's so unfair on the child. A baby is not a commodity. Those of us who have a child or children may be told we just don't understand but we are not stupid or totally lacking in empathy.

WeRoarSometimes · 03/07/2021 16:16

@M0nkeybars
Many of us are not judging, we are worried about the rise of normalising surrogacy and the huge health risks for a section of women in society this represents.

I have a history of late pregnancy loss that spanned several years.
But, my desire for parenthood can't warrant another woman risking her health to give me a baby, whether there is money involved or not.

In the UK, surrogacy is being aligned to the rights of the LGBT community in the mainstream media. Whether it's a heterosexual parents or a lone parent or parents from the LGBT community, expecting women to risk their health to provide a baby shouldn't be something we can readily commission.

grey12 · 03/07/2021 16:03

I'm against surrogacy

If you can't get pregnant and want a baby then adopt

Maggiesfarm · 03/07/2021 16:01

@CounsellorTroi

I had fertility issues and never did have a child but we would never have considered using a surrogate.
Quite right Counsellor, good for you. I hope your life has been and continues to be, a good one.
Maggiesfarm · 03/07/2021 16:00

OhHolyJesus (are you really dear Lord :-)?:

"The focus is always on the desires of the commissioning parent or parents, it's never about the child at the centre and the woman who gives birth shuffles off home with cash in the bank to her own kids and family, or alone, with her pills to stop the milk coming in and the sanitary pads big enough to feel like an adult nappy, to recover and more often than not I think, do it all over again as soon as her body allows."
.......
Yes - and what about if she had to have an emergency Caesarian? It's horrible and it is selfish. I understand the desire for a child but some people are able to cope without resorting to using or hiring someone else's body for the purpose. It's even worse when it is a second child they are so desperate to have - they are extremely fortunate to have one!
I suppose they just don't think it out properly. If it was banned altogether they would have no choice!

CounsellorTroi · 03/07/2021 16:00

I had fertility issues and never did have a child but we would never have considered using a surrogate.

M0nkeybars · 03/07/2021 15:56

A lot of judgement on this thread. I'd be interested to know how many of those of you totally against surrogacy have struggled with infertility or have had multiple losses and surrogacy is one of the very few options available for you to have a child of your own? What about LGBT+ couples who can't carry a biological child? Or single people?

And please don't say "just adopt" - it's not that simple.

WeRoarSometimes · 03/07/2021 15:51

@OhHolyJesus
You've hit the nail on the head.

Surrogacy is a Service for the wealthy and those with access to fertility experts, fertility clinics, solicitors and generally power.

Most surrogate mums have already had children i.e successful pregnancies.
They are more likely to be in lower paid work, restricted by their academic achievement, skills, family background or childcare needs.
And the huge amounts available - tens of thousands of pounds will be money they may not be able to imagine achieving.

Earlier in this thread, there was comparison to cleaning and retail work, which are dominated by female participation. In those roles, women can choose to leave their employer. They are not risking their lives by that undertaking. Their bodies are not burdened with the huge health risks being undertaken for surrogacy.
And nor are they left with irreversible consequences and responsibilities, as they would be in surrogacy should commissioning parents change their mind about the baby.

This is why some of us are frightened about what surrogacy means for the future of women. In the UK, particularly the push for allowing commercial surrogacy is scary.

Deadringer · 03/07/2021 15:50

I am anti surrogacy but can't really add anything to the argument as so many good points have already been made. Aside from all the ethical issues, on a practical level I think that people tend to forget how risky pregnancy can be, (and it seems to be more risky when the baby is not genetically related to the birth mother) and how birth injuries are pretty much ignored by the medical profession. Tears, incontinence, post birth sex issues etc are seen as 'expected' and something that women just have to live with. I know these sort of things are seen as private but i really think that some people, especially gay men for example, won't have a clue of the risks involved. Perhaps if this sort of stuff was highlighted more in the media people would be less inclined to see surrogacy as an easy solution for infertility.

ConkerBonkers · 03/07/2021 15:26

Singlebutmarried great trolling!

Belliphat · 03/07/2021 14:37

It’s utterly grim. I have seen a sister carry a baby for her infertile sibling - no issues with that genuine altruistic surrogacy. Beyond this type of situation it appalls me. The baby isn’t centred, the birth mother expendable and the commodification of women continues at the detriment to their value.

OhHolyJesus · 03/07/2021 14:26

I haven't read the whole thread but have been reading a lot about surrogacy since I learnt about proposed law reform in the U.K. from MN.

Celebrity culture is definitely popularising surrogacy, with the success stories and posed photographs of newborns against white backdrops like Heard, or baby feet with manicured nails like Naomi Campbell recently. The birth mother barely gets a mention, sometimes it's about protecting her identity but sometimes I think it's to sweep away the blood, stitches, scars and wobble tummies to sanitise all the horrid, ugly realities of pregnancy and labour that doesn't for with celebrity culture.

The focus is always on the desires of the commissioning parent or parents, it's never about the child at the centre and the woman who gives birth shuffles off home with cash in the bank to her own kids and family, or alone, with her pills to stop the milk coming in and the sanitary pads big enough to feel like an adult nappy, to recover and more often than not I think, do it all over again as soon as her body allows.

RedHelenB · 03/07/2021 10:53

Surrogacy shouldn't be allowed full stop.

TheWeeDonkey · 03/07/2021 10:51

@FannyCann

I think offering to pay for egg freezing is deeply cynical or at any rate extremely ill informed Counsellor The success rate is very low and women have an unrealistic sense of security after choosing this option. As they age there is a higher chance of the frozen eggs working with a younger surrogate mother than the owner of the eggs. There is also the issue that the process of going through ovarian stimulation and egg freezing may impact their health.
I was watching something on breakfast news about this a few years ago. It was being promotedd as a positive thing (women taking control of their careers, that kind of thing) but it struck me as deeply cynical and quite the opposite of supporting women in the workplace. I think its down there with companies that have 'perks' that are really just an incentive to create a workaholic culture.
NCwhatsmynameagain · 03/07/2021 09:58

Babies to order, from rent-a-wombs, and commodification of women’s bodies to serve the needs of other more wealthy individuals is deplorable, and should not be allowed.

PurpleDaisies · 03/07/2021 09:35

@MihaelaCW

Most people are OK with much worse things happening to women's bodies to create a never ending stream of vile porn. It's apparently cool to be cool about that, so I don't get too worked up about surrogacy if it's done in an ethical manner by mentally sound people.
Where on earth have you got this view from? Most people are ok with women being exploited to make porn? Really? By “most people” do you really mean male consumers of violent porn?
EmeraldShamrock · 03/07/2021 09:22

Most people are OK with much worse things happening to women's bodies to create a never ending stream of vile porn. It's apparently cool to be cool about that

No they certainly are not okay about it on MN, there is nothing cool around porn women being trafficked for sex/rape/exploitation.
I don't know why you think that?

so I don't get too worked up about surrogacy if it's done in an ethical manner by mentally sound people.

Good for you, somewhat like BLM, vulnerable exploitable women's lives matter it isn't a case of "well worse things happens"

FannyCann · 03/07/2021 09:17

Here is an interesting podcast interview with a woman about her egg freezing experience.

podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/venus-rising/id1481872967?i=1000461279868

If you like listening to podcasts (I find these are just the right length for my journey to work) Venus Rising has lots of really interesting interviews.

CounsellorTroi · 03/07/2021 09:11

I agree Fanny.

FannyCann · 03/07/2021 09:07

I think offering to pay for egg freezing is deeply cynical or at any rate extremely ill informed Counsellor
The success rate is very low and women have an unrealistic sense of security after choosing this option. As they age there is a higher chance of the frozen eggs working with a younger surrogate mother than the owner of the eggs.
There is also the issue that the process of going through ovarian stimulation and egg freezing may impact their health.

FannyCann · 03/07/2021 09:03

@MihaelaCW So how do you suggest this sort of case should be managed? A woman with clear mental health problems and yet eager baby buyers kept on using her and in the later pregnancies when she was no longer able to choose the DIY self inseminate option a fertility clinic treated her and impregnated her despite clear health and mental health contraindications?

"When she had her first baby for a couple, she lied to her bosses about the pregnancy. She invented a boyfriend and then claimed the baby had died, causing her colleagues to send her sympathy cards.
And a year after she became a surrogate mother for the third time, she was diagnosed with depression.

At one point in 2004, she felt so miserable that she attempted suicide by taking an overdose."

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2166750/amp/Jill-Hawkins-Surrogate-mother-given-birth-TEN-children-mothers-says-time-stop.html

CounsellorTroi · 03/07/2021 09:00

Companies will pressure women not to take time out - there is minimal maternity rights in the USA anyway and firms are now offering fertility expenses as part of the benefits package for men as well as women which can be used to pay for surrogacy. So women will be expected to take that route rather than getting the same amount to spend on MATERNITY for themselves.

I think some companies will pay for egg freezing to encourage employees to get pregnant later rather than sooner.

Swipe left for the next trending thread