Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel uncomfortable with celebrity surrogacy?

333 replies

Username91 · 02/07/2021 10:35

After reading about Amber Herd having a baby girl via surrogate it just got me thinking about the amount of famous people who have children this way. I have nothing against surrogacy, it just seems to me that a lot of rich women choose to have children this way and I’m not convinced they ALL have problems carrying children themselves. I find it a bit disturbing and wondered if I’m alone in thinking this?

Once again I’d like to point out I’m not surrogacy bashing here. I just don’t think it should be something that is used by women with money as they don’t like the idea of carrying their own babies, of course it’s very different for women who struggle to conceive/carry themselves.

OP posts:
Twizbe · 03/07/2021 19:56

Adoption leave is 52 weeks, the same as maternity leave. Statutory adoption pay is the same as well. It can also be split like maternity leave. Either parent can take the adoption leave. The other parent gets a variant of paternity leave.

Any legal fees would like have been related to visas or bringing the child into the UK from abroad.

My friend and his husband adopted a child. He took the full year and then left his job and retrained so that he could have 2 years at home and then be around a lot more too. The child has been with them almost 4 years now and it's only recently they've used non family baby sitters or done any preschool setting.

FannyCann · 03/07/2021 19:26

A friend adopted two pre-school siblings, (2 & 4 I think), obviously they must have been through a lot to have been removed from their birth mother and put up for adoption. She gave up work as a teacher to be home with them and for the first year she and her husband devoted themselves to settling the children and establishing security and routine. She gradually introduced the presence of a baby sitter to help with them for the odd hour allowing her to do some tutoring from home. It was only after a year that they actually left the children for short periods in the care of a family member.
It absolutely infuriates me when I see celebrities adopting, eg Madonna or Angelina swooping in to an orphanage in Africa and returning homes with a baby when you know they will just hand those children over to a team of nannies.
Anyway, that sort of thing seems to have gone out of fashion now. Much easier to rent a womb and buy a newborn I suppose.

Sleeplessem · 03/07/2021 18:57

@Beeeeeeeeeeeeeep

There are no legal fees to adopt. When you adopt a child you need to be able to stay home with the child for a decent amount of time. You can't adopt a child and then put them in nursery 3 months later. I imagine that's why your doctor friends were turned down? Adopting a child is not the same as having a birth child.
I think they had adoptive leave through work but perhaps it wasn’t sufficient? I’m not sure, didn’t ask too many questions as they seemed quite upset x
sfeirical · 03/07/2021 18:52

@Singlebutmarried

Their body their choice as to whether they get pregnant or not.

If they choose not to get pregnant, but want a baby then where’s the issue.

The surrogate supplies a service that is paid for, does it really matter if it’s Mrs miggins from next door, or someone who wants a baby but doesn’t want to carry one?

Women are not human incubators.

If people cannot have children naturally, or through IVF, perhaps they should try adoption, instead of thinking it's their god given right to have a child regardless of how completely unethical it is.

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 03/07/2021 18:50

Babygotblueyes what a strange insistence that reality should be recreated as you wish it to be. Seperation of newborn from mother (and a newborn knows the woman in who's womb she or he grows as their mother regardless of what you might prefer) is traumatic.

Just because you don't like reality and find it "vile" doesn't mean that it stops being reality or mean anyone should be shamed into lying to be "kind" at the expense of exploited children and babies created to order to be removed at birth.

Beeeeeeeeeeeeeep · 03/07/2021 18:50

There are no legal fees to adopt.
When you adopt a child you need to be able to stay home with the child for a decent amount of time. You can't adopt a child and then put them in nursery 3 months later. I imagine that's why your doctor friends were turned down? Adopting a child is not the same as having a birth child.

Sleeplessem · 03/07/2021 18:45

@womanity

I actually looked into it prior to having DD, and at least in the UK it does seem incredibly complex and long winded and apparently it’s costly too ( this is all third hand info) and whilst I get there is obviously need to caution and due diligence due to safeguarding and welfare, i do worry the yellow tape acts as a deterrent and then frankly it’s easier to ‘commission’ a surrogate in Eastern Europe

Adopting in the U.K. doesn’t cost a penny. The process is straightforward but can be lengthy. I can imagine that it would be fairly hard for a U.K. power couple to get through the assessment because your need to demonstrate the child would come first, which is at odds with being too busy to carry a child or intending to leave its daily welfare to a fleet of nannies.

Are there not legal fees for adoption? Perhaps the expensive cost was referring to overseas adoption (the couple in question had wanted to adopt from their ancestral home country but were British citizens) .

I think the length of the process easily leads people to think it’s complicated from a timescale v expectation point of view.

I’ve also known a couple (doctor and teacher) that were highly scrutinised for ‘not having the time for the child’ when they’d made perfectly sensible arrangements, their careers were apparently deemed too time consuming. Again second hand info but I don’t believe they went on to adopt

IcedPurple · 03/07/2021 18:42

@M0nkeybars

A lot of judgement on this thread. I'd be interested to know how many of those of you totally against surrogacy have struggled with infertility or have had multiple losses and surrogacy is one of the very few options available for you to have a child of your own? What about LGBT+ couples who can't carry a biological child? Or single people?

And please don't say "just adopt" - it's not that simple.

At the end of the day having a 'child of your own' is a want, not a need.

Yes, I know that some people want their own child desperately and their inability to do so is deeply sad for them. I feel sorry for these people, but wanting something very much does not give you the right to have it at all costs.

womanity · 03/07/2021 18:32

I actually looked into it prior to having DD, and at least in the UK it does seem incredibly complex and long winded and apparently it’s costly too ( this is all third hand info) and whilst I get there is obviously need to caution and due diligence due to safeguarding and welfare, i do worry the yellow tape acts as a deterrent and then frankly it’s easier to ‘commission’ a surrogate in Eastern Europe

Adopting in the U.K. doesn’t cost a penny. The process is straightforward but can be lengthy. I can imagine that it would be fairly hard for a U.K. power couple to get through the assessment because your need to demonstrate the child would come first, which is at odds with being too busy to carry a child or intending to leave its daily welfare to a fleet of nannies.

EmeraldShamrock · 03/07/2021 18:28

whatever you think about surrogacy, some of the opinions on here implying that children who are not biologically carried by their parents are traumatized are vile. Really, you should be ashamed of yourselves.
Some DC will be emotionally damaged being removed at birth, similarly to babies born at risk removed.
I personally think there is a risk of emotional damage throughout their teenage years when they truly realise the story of their arrival and question who gave birth to them, why did she do it? Was she poor exploitable in a country with little respect for women? Was she trying to feed other DC.
It's like when men excuse renting the ladies in Thailand for a week as a guide and sex toy.
They excuse it thinking at least she's in a nice hotel, getting paid and fed.
If they were so concerned about her life give her the cash without expectation.

CastawayQueen · 03/07/2021 18:25

@M0nkeybars

A lot of judgement on this thread. I'd be interested to know how many of those of you totally against surrogacy have struggled with infertility or have had multiple losses and surrogacy is one of the very few options available for you to have a child of your own? What about LGBT+ couples who can't carry a biological child? Or single people?

And please don't say "just adopt" - it's not that simple.

As a bisexual woman (who has dated other women for years) and the daughter of a mother who produced several stillborn siblings after me - a child is a human being, not an object of desire. Nobody has the ‘right’ to a child. A child is not food, water or shelter.

Furthermore - LGBTQ+ couples can’t reproduce. This is natural. Why so many feel the need to override this I don’t understand. We can’t simultaneously say that we want to be the way nature intended AND then go along wanting to have our own biological children like straight couples. It blows my mind.

Beeeeeeeeeeeeeep · 03/07/2021 18:21

@Babygotblueyes

whatever you think about surrogacy, some of the opinions on here implying that children who are not biologically carried by their parents are traumatized are vile. Really, you should be ashamed of yourselves. Rather that kind people get have children however they can, than judgemental people reproduce themselves.
Children separated from their mothers at birth experience a traumatic event. This is FACT. Whether they are able to recover from that or not, they still experience it. Whether they remember it or not, they still experience it. It's not 'vile' to state facts.
Comedycook · 03/07/2021 18:11

@M0nkeybars

A lot of judgement on this thread. I'd be interested to know how many of those of you totally against surrogacy have struggled with infertility or have had multiple losses and surrogacy is one of the very few options available for you to have a child of your own? What about LGBT+ couples who can't carry a biological child? Or single people?

And please don't say "just adopt" - it's not that simple.

Because to me the reason someone can't have a child is secondary to my moral stance on surrogacy. I'm sure it's incredibly painful to want a child and be unable to have one but it does not give you the right to rent out a woman's womb
Babygotblueyes · 03/07/2021 18:10

whatever you think about surrogacy, some of the opinions on here implying that children who are not biologically carried by their parents are traumatized are vile. Really, you should be ashamed of yourselves. Rather that kind people get have children however they can, than judgemental people reproduce themselves.

Sleeplessem · 03/07/2021 18:03

[quote grey12]@Sleeplessem I know what you mean. To be honest with you, even though we have 3 kids, if we could afford it we would still adopt (can't afford a big enough house to give them their own space. It's tight as it is)

However, if we couldn't have kids, yes, adoption would be our choice.

I have this strong image in my head of a nice room full of surrogacy babies without mothers because of Covid travel restrictions Angry how horrible!!!! That alone should make anyone's skin crawl[/quote]
I’ve always said 2 Bio children is my max and if we have the means to expand our family further it would be adoption.

I actually looked into it prior to having DD, and at least in the UK it does seem incredibly complex and long winded and apparently it’s costly too ( this is all third hand info) and whilst I get there is obviously need to caution and due diligence due to safeguarding and welfare, i do worry the yellow tape acts as a deterrent and then frankly it’s easier to ‘commission’ a surrogate in Eastern Europe

grey12 · 03/07/2021 17:35

@womanity sorry you went through so much Thanks

You're right, the surrogate mothers are hardly mentioned or cared for. Anyone seen "the handmaid's tale"?? So it's super hard for those women to give away their "rape babies" but it's suddenly not if it's a surrogacy?......... because it doesn't come on TV with a nice production?........

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 03/07/2021 17:35

M0nkeybars when you say "or single people" do you mean single men? Single women are no more likely than women in relationships to use surrogacy. Do you believe single men have a right to be provided with a newborn baby?

aSofaNearYou · 03/07/2021 17:30

What about LGBT+ couples who can't carry a biological child?

I mean you've got to be pretty tone deaf to think that people who believe surrogacy is unethical would change their mind for this reason...

womanity · 03/07/2021 17:28

@M0nkeybars

A lot of judgement on this thread. I'd be interested to know how many of those of you totally against surrogacy have struggled with infertility or have had multiple losses and surrogacy is one of the very few options available for you to have a child of your own? What about LGBT+ couples who can't carry a biological child? Or single people?

And please don't say "just adopt" - it's not that simple.

I’m infertile and very anti-surrogacy.

After years of TTC/miscarriages/hospitalisations and all sorts of shit, I ‘just adopted’.

It’s those experiences that have led me to my anti-surrogacy position.

I nearly died through pregnancy, it’s not okay to expect someone else to take that risk for you.

And I see my DC every day struggling with issues of identity because they were separated from the birth family. (For good reason, but still.) In the adoption world, we know separating children from mothers causes huge harm, I don’t know how people can pretend it’s different in surrogacy.

grey12 · 03/07/2021 17:26

@Sleeplessem I know what you mean. To be honest with you, even though we have 3 kids, if we could afford it we would still adopt (can't afford a big enough house to give them their own space. It's tight as it is)

However, if we couldn't have kids, yes, adoption would be our choice.

I have this strong image in my head of a nice room full of surrogacy babies without mothers because of Covid travel restrictions Angry how horrible!!!! That alone should make anyone's skin crawl

Twizbe · 03/07/2021 17:17

@MrsSchadenfreude

I know a couple who had a child via a surrogate in Ukraine. I don’t understand why they didn’t do it in U.K. but they went off to Ukraine. When they came back with their baby, I asked how the birth mother was, and they looked a bit puzzled and said she was fine, they thought, she had left hospital the next day. Their concern for her and their gratitude for what she had done were non-existent. Especially as they had apparently mandated that she give birth without an epidural or other intervention unless medically necessary. I understand their sadness at being childless and their desperation but their attitude stank.
My gosh that's awful. They mandated that she should not be given pain relief.
MrsSchadenfreude · 03/07/2021 17:13

I know a couple who had a child via a surrogate in Ukraine. I don’t understand why they didn’t do it in U.K. but they went off to Ukraine. When they came back with their baby, I asked how the birth mother was, and they looked a bit puzzled and said she was fine, they thought, she had left hospital the next day. Their concern for her and their gratitude for what she had done were non-existent. Especially as they had apparently mandated that she give birth without an epidural or other intervention unless medically necessary. I understand their sadness at being childless and their desperation but their attitude stank.

PurpleDaisies · 03/07/2021 17:07

@ArabellaScott

I do empathise with people who have struggled to conceive, I imagine it must be very hard.

Buying a child is not a solution, and having a child is not a 'right'.

So many posters assuming if you’re infertile you’re pro surrogacy. It’s a lazy assumption.
Sleeplessem · 03/07/2021 17:03

@grey12

I'm against surrogacy

If you can't get pregnant and want a baby then adopt

I’m iffy on surrogacy but I don’t like the rhetoric that says can’t get pregnant adopt. Adopted children shouldn’t be seen as a ‘last resort’ / back up plan for people who can’t have children by natural meals.
FourTeaFallOut · 03/07/2021 16:47

It took us forever to conceive our first child. So I've had my nose right up against my principles long enough to discount hypocrisy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread