Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel uncomfortable with celebrity surrogacy?

333 replies

Username91 · 02/07/2021 10:35

After reading about Amber Herd having a baby girl via surrogate it just got me thinking about the amount of famous people who have children this way. I have nothing against surrogacy, it just seems to me that a lot of rich women choose to have children this way and I’m not convinced they ALL have problems carrying children themselves. I find it a bit disturbing and wondered if I’m alone in thinking this?

Once again I’d like to point out I’m not surrogacy bashing here. I just don’t think it should be something that is used by women with money as they don’t like the idea of carrying their own babies, of course it’s very different for women who struggle to conceive/carry themselves.

OP posts:
thelegohooverer · 02/07/2021 12:03

I was on the fence about surrogacy but reading about it and listening to stories of people who’ve been surrogates has been eye opening.

I don’t think the effects on the children are considered. We’ve learned a lot about the damaging effects of adoption. And our views as a society reflect this (eg it’s not acceptable to kidnap dc of minority ethnic groups or sell the dc of of unmarried women) yet we embrace surrogacy. Celebrity endorsement helps drive that acceptance.

I was listening to an interview with a woman who had been a surrogate four times, and was very positive about her choices, but it was a heart breaking listen. She wasn’t criticising the companies she worked with but her story was very unsettling. At one point she availed of psychiatric support and then went on to have more babies to ease the burden of guilt and failure she carried. I suspect that an independent psychiatrist, who wasn’t being paid by a surrogacy company, might have explored those feelings further.

MsTSwift · 02/07/2021 12:02

Really not seeing that equivalence either

Comedycook · 02/07/2021 12:02

[quote Moorelewis]@Comedycook I'm talking about your patronising phrase 'I'm lost for words', because someone disagrees with your opinion.[/quote]
Because I'm baffled that anyone would think paying a doctor to perform ivf is the same as paying a woman to use her womb.

playinghippiefamilies · 02/07/2021 12:01

I feel uncomfortable about it. I understand if someone cannot carry a child, that they may prefer surrogacy to adoption. But I do find it weird when someone who is perfectly able to carry a child chooses to use a surrogate.

Moorelewis · 02/07/2021 12:00

@Comedycook I'm talking about your patronising phrase 'I'm lost for words', because someone disagrees with your opinion.

Beamur · 02/07/2021 12:00

I can totally understand the desire for a baby. But I do worry about the exploitative side of commercial surrogacy.
I don't think you should be able to buy someone to gestate a child to order.

PurpleDaisies · 02/07/2021 12:00

[quote Moorelewis]@PurpleDaisies your decision. As it was my cousins decision to be a surrogate for her sister.[/quote]
You totally missed the point of my post these.

Jobseeker19 · 02/07/2021 11:59

Let's be real, they do not want to have their body changed by a pregnancy so they are getting a poorer woman to have their child.

They get the baby and to keep their slim bodies which doesn't have stretch marks, incontinence and all the other stuff we risk when we get pregnant and give birth.

What it does it create a class system where women who have given birth are seen as lesser and undesirable.

Comedycook · 02/07/2021 11:58

[quote Moorelewis]@Comedycook oh get off your high horse. Not all situations involve 'paying' for a womb. Unless you have had something awful happen to a family member, you wouldn't understand[/quote]
I have no idea what you mean.

I'm against surrogacy in all circumstances, however sad they are. I'm not on a high horse at all.

Moorelewis · 02/07/2021 11:57

@PurpleDaisies your decision. As it was my cousins decision to be a surrogate for her sister.

PurpleDaisies · 02/07/2021 11:56

[quote Moorelewis]@Comedycook oh get off your high horse. Not all situations involve 'paying' for a womb. Unless you have had something awful happen to a family member, you wouldn't understand[/quote]
I will never have my own children. That doesn’t give me the right to potentially inflict life changing birth injuries on another woman so I could have a baby.

Don’t assume this issue divides nearly down women with experience of infertility and those who don’t.

YouShouldLeave · 02/07/2021 11:56

[quote LizziesTwin]@YouShouldLeave

*” It's so entirely centred around the needs of the adult to have a baby, without thinking of the issues that the child may endure”

Same could be said about every pregnancy ever.*

But when I chose to become pregnant I assumed the risk. So I was at risk of any of the life-long conditions that a woman is exposed to by carrying a child to term. Any stretch marks, varicose veins, gestational diabetes, happened to me. Having a child is one of the most dangerous things a typical woman can do.[/quote]
Ooops! I read it as in issues that the child may endure.

Moorelewis · 02/07/2021 11:53

@Comedycook oh get off your high horse. Not all situations involve 'paying' for a womb. Unless you have had something awful happen to a family member, you wouldn't understand

PurpleDaisies · 02/07/2021 11:53

I am very concerned about the exploitation of women in this way. I don’t think paying another woman to take all the risks of pregnancy for you is morally right.

FourTeaFallOut · 02/07/2021 11:53

I do think egg donation is morally suspect too.

I just think that infertility should not be overcome by swapping out parts of women to produce a child whose access to knowing who their mother is via complicated philosophical questions that amount to biological top trumps.

Moorelewis · 02/07/2021 11:52

@Bksjshsbbev2737 well in this circumstance, yes. My cousin had a hysterectomy aged 17 due to cancer. She kept her ovaries. Her sister kindly offer to be her surrogate, as for obvious reasons, she was unable to have IVF. She would have been unable to have her own children any other way.

Comedycook · 02/07/2021 11:51

[quote Moorelewis]@Comedycook which you have to pay for often and involves another woman's eggs sometimes?[/quote]
If you think paying doctors for performing a medical procedure is the same as paying woman for the use of her womb then really I'm lost for words.

Bksjshsbbev2737 · 02/07/2021 11:50

@Moorelewis it’s buying a baby from a poor woman/woman who needs to do it for the money
IVF is buying a medical procedure to have a baby

BruceAndNosh · 02/07/2021 11:50

Amber - "the nature of my job compels me to take control of this"

So actually BEING pregnant might be inconvenient?

CP26 · 02/07/2021 11:47

@Username91 Cambridge also tracked the experiences of surrogates over a long period and found it positive. None of them expressed regrets. I’ll try and link to the study

www.family.law.cam.ac.uk/sites/www.law.cam.ac.uk/files/images/www.family.law.cam.ac.uk/documents/surrogacy/cfr_publications_on_surrogacy_2012-2019_.pdf

How do you know celebrities are choosing it rather than being infertile? It’s perfectly possible to be an infertile celebrity.

Moorelewis · 02/07/2021 11:46

@Comedycook which you have to pay for often and involves another woman's eggs sometimes?

Comedycook · 02/07/2021 11:45

@Moorelewis

All the people saying surrogacy is essentially 'buying a baby', then what is IVF?
A medical procedure
Moorelewis · 02/07/2021 11:39

All the people saying surrogacy is essentially 'buying a baby', then what is IVF?

Username91 · 02/07/2021 11:37

@CP26 what about the effects on the surrogates though? And my point is that women seem to be choosing this rather than it being because they are infertile.

OP posts:
CP26 · 02/07/2021 11:32

Infertility doesn’t discriminate. Being a celebrity won’t prevent you from being infertile, it’s just that we’re more likely to hear about it.

As for the effects on children, Cambridge University has a long standing research study into surrogacy born children (and other non-traditional ways of building a family) and the results show they are as well adjusted as children born ‘the normal way’.

Swipe left for the next trending thread