Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel uncomfortable with celebrity surrogacy?

333 replies

Username91 · 02/07/2021 10:35

After reading about Amber Herd having a baby girl via surrogate it just got me thinking about the amount of famous people who have children this way. I have nothing against surrogacy, it just seems to me that a lot of rich women choose to have children this way and I’m not convinced they ALL have problems carrying children themselves. I find it a bit disturbing and wondered if I’m alone in thinking this?

Once again I’d like to point out I’m not surrogacy bashing here. I just don’t think it should be something that is used by women with money as they don’t like the idea of carrying their own babies, of course it’s very different for women who struggle to conceive/carry themselves.

OP posts:
sashagabadon · 02/07/2021 13:30

I was pro surrogacy or at best indifferent as I had not given it that much thought. In balance I am now anti it with the exception of freely given altruistic surrogacy between sisters for example although even that brings up ethical issues.

Twizbe · 02/07/2021 13:29

What about Hilaria Baldwin who was very pregnant when they impregnated a surrogate. The suggestion is that they did it to ensure they had another girl.

She clearly wasn't infertile as she already had 5 kids.

Or the 20 something woman in Georgia with a much older husband who had 10 surrogate babies in 12 months? She already had one (so able to be pregnant) and it only cost her £1000 per baby (which is a lot of money for those women who's womb she rented)

I'm more ok with a cousin or sister helping a family member to have a baby.

OnlyTheLangOfTheTitberg · 02/07/2021 13:28

@VestaTilley

YANBU, but I don’t agree with surrogacy at all.

It trafficks babies away from their mothers, exploits the poverty of women in favour of richer women and men or male couples, and commodifies babies and motherhood.

It’s an inherently misogynistic practice, as the birth mother is left recovering, bleeding, often damaged while the parents whisk the baby away, no effects on them.

There have been several stories of American and Chinese babies born to Ukrainian and other national mothers abandoned because they’re disabled.

It is unethical in the extreme, and it’s a sign of how sadly our society has become so permissive and unhealthy that so many people think this is a progressive thing to do. It isn’t.

There’s a lobby here pushing for the liberalisation of surrogacy laws. An all male panel of law commissioners produced an appalling biased consultation last year which didn’t take the needs of mothers and babies in to account at all- all viewed from the male perspective.

To say nothing of the poor babies left unbonded with when COVID meant they were left in hospitals and orphanages for weeks.

Just because you’re rich you shouldn’t get to buy a baby. It should be illegal.

I agree with every word of this. And for those who think it’s not harming anyone else so we should butt out…individual women can make choices which harm women as a class by reinforcing the view that a woman’s body is something to be commodified.
Seasidemumma77 · 02/07/2021 13:26

@TinaYouFatLard

All surrogacy is a hideous business. Nobody should be able to rent a woman’s body or buy a baby.

Do you ever hear of a rich, famous woman carrying a baby for a poorer woman? It’s exploitative and revolting.

This
Babygotblueyes · 02/07/2021 13:26

It is not always poor women acting as surrogates. I have a friend who was a surrogate. She loved being pregnant, wanted to give back and knew a couple who could not get pregnant themselves. My friend is a nurse, living in the US, so not poor, or poorly educated. She carried two children for that couple and describes it as the most rewarding thing she ever did.

For movie stars - being pregnant may mean losing work, so I can see why surrogacy would be attractive.

Couchbettato · 02/07/2021 13:25

@Pinuporc

I think it can be quite exploitative to vulnerable women (even in this country) and is not always in a babys best interest.
I agree. 100%
Sleeplessem · 02/07/2021 13:22

@Youdiditanyway

I don’t believe both Kim and Khloe Kardashian have medical issues and ‘need’ to use a surrogate. Kim already had 2 children, she didn’t need to have 2 more and Khloe has 1 so again, doesn’t need to have another. They haven’t disclosed exactly what the issues are but I think most women (if this were true) would just be happy with their existing children rather than paying a poor woman to carry their next child.

Amber Heard story is a bit weird. Mid 30s, maybe has medical issues but again seems more like she doesn’t want stretch marks so has paid another woman to do that for her… In her position I’d be more inclined to adopt if I were truly desperate to have a child but maybe that’s just me.

I don’t agree with surrogacy on the whole either. I think it’s different if it’s a close relative who offers to carry the baby for someone who cannot do it, that is pure altruism with zero financial benefit. Renting a poor woman’s womb seems unethical.

I think Kim K had placenta acreta and pre eclampsia (definitely with her first who was born at 34 weeks and from pap photos of that pregnancy she did look swollen) but yeah you’re right, she had 2 children already, was there a need for more- Absolutely not. Whilst I know it’s not verified, there have been many reports about the strict list of conditions her surrogates had to adhere to which has an exploitative feel. Khloe used a surrogate this far just sounds like I don’t want to gain weight 🤷‍♀️
TinkleTongs · 02/07/2021 13:19

@Youdiditanyway

Ronaldo situation is outright bizarre. He did eventually marry and have a child with his wife but decided to have three children as a single man through a surrogate first? Weird.
Yes really weird

I always thought his girlfriends were beards and assumed he had babies through surrogate to provide grandchildren as otherwise he would never have had kids

The picture of amber heard and her baby was so fake
It’s set up to look like she’s lying in bed against a pillow with her newborn lying on her as if she’d just given birth , obviously reality couldn’t be further from this.

Fake and sterile

VestaTilley · 02/07/2021 13:16

YANBU, but I don’t agree with surrogacy at all.

It trafficks babies away from their mothers, exploits the poverty of women in favour of richer women and men or male couples, and commodifies babies and motherhood.

It’s an inherently misogynistic practice, as the birth mother is left recovering, bleeding, often damaged while the parents whisk the baby away, no effects on them.

There have been several stories of American and Chinese babies born to Ukrainian and other national mothers abandoned because they’re disabled.

It is unethical in the extreme, and it’s a sign of how sadly our society has become so permissive and unhealthy that so many people think this is a progressive thing to do. It isn’t.

There’s a lobby here pushing for the liberalisation of surrogacy laws. An all male panel of law commissioners produced an appalling biased consultation last year which didn’t take the needs of mothers and babies in to account at all- all viewed from the male perspective.

To say nothing of the poor babies left unbonded with when COVID meant they were left in hospitals and orphanages for weeks.

Just because you’re rich you shouldn’t get to buy a baby. It should be illegal.

OliviaBean · 02/07/2021 13:14

I disagree with it on every level.

That picture of Amber Heard looking all glam with the baby sums up celebrities and how wrong it is. Perfect picture but not so perfect really.

thelegohooverer · 02/07/2021 13:14

Those who say they would do it for love if a sister or friend was infertile, would you be okay in the reverse situation asking them to take the risk for you? Or okay with them refusing to do it for you?

IheartJKR · 02/07/2021 13:14

Surrogacy is the exploitation of women.

Women’s bodies are NOT FOR SALE.

You only have to read about the poor women who have their passports confiscated. The women housed in dormitories. The Japanese man who had 19 different children via surrogates….. it goes in and on and on.

And no….there are no wealthy educated women being surrogates.

In the global North the narrative is altruistic. In the global south the narrative is that it’s honest work and a good way out of poverty.

They frame it whichever way makes it most palatable… meanwhile the people who make the real money are the brokers.

Not the women or the children.

Menora · 02/07/2021 13:13

I think it can exploit women, especially in poorer countries or those with less regulation

I can understand why people who cannot have a child at all would want to do this having explored all other options but does make me uncomfortable seeing rich celebs do it

Youdiditanyway · 02/07/2021 13:10

Ronaldo situation is outright bizarre. He did eventually marry and have a child with his wife but decided to have three children as a single man through a surrogate first? Weird.

Youdiditanyway · 02/07/2021 13:08

I don’t believe both Kim and Khloe Kardashian have medical issues and ‘need’ to use a surrogate. Kim already had 2 children, she didn’t need to have 2 more and Khloe has 1 so again, doesn’t need to have another. They haven’t disclosed exactly what the issues are but I think most women (if this were true) would just be happy with their existing children rather than paying a poor woman to carry their next child.

Amber Heard story is a bit weird. Mid 30s, maybe has medical issues but again seems more like she doesn’t want stretch marks so has paid another woman to do that for her… In her position I’d be more inclined to adopt if I were truly desperate to have a child but maybe that’s just me.

I don’t agree with surrogacy on the whole either. I think it’s different if it’s a close relative who offers to carry the baby for someone who cannot do it, that is pure altruism with zero financial benefit. Renting a poor woman’s womb seems unethical.

Sleeplessem · 02/07/2021 13:06

@TinkleTongs

I think these celebrities see it as the easy way and it’s vanity.

They don’t want to get stretched and puffy and give birth.

I don’t believe KK had those conditions at all , total vanity to have further babies through surrogate , she was quoted as saying she disliked being pregnant.

In my opinion these mega rich celebs see babies as commodities

Also Ronaldo bought babies too , used a surrogate , the mother is not involved at all , I always felt that was to provide grandchildren for his mother , totally weird and bizarre but hey , if you’re a mega millionaire then what’s stopping these people.

Just doesn’t sit right with me at all

The Ronaldo thing is particularly strange. MJ did similar didn’t he?

Probably going to articulate this poorly but it’s the driver to have a child that is ‘biologically yours’ above all else, including ethics both medical and more general that makes me feel uneasy.

That being said, I think there is nuance when individuals do it for a loved one, sister, dear friend etc

TeaAndStrumpets · 02/07/2021 12:59

Before the invention of safe formula milk wealthy families would routinely employ a wet nurse for their babies. Outsourcing has a long history among the idle rich.

Beeeeeeeeeeeeeep · 02/07/2021 12:56

Why do you have nothing against surrogacy? You really should

MsTSwift · 02/07/2021 12:55

No choice is made in a vacuum though is it? Do you see wealthy women acting as surrogates because I don’t.

Penistoe · 02/07/2021 12:54

I’m reading a lot of:

Woman should have body autonomy and choose what they do with their own bodies

So if they choose to be a surrogate that’s ok

No they only get to to with their bodies what I feel is morally right.

Hmm
MsTSwift · 02/07/2021 12:54

Totally agree.

TeaAndStrumpets · 02/07/2021 12:54

@Clymene

Outsourcing pregnancy to another woman is a profoundly misogynist act.
Women as livestock.
Clymene · 02/07/2021 12:43

Outsourcing pregnancy to another woman is a profoundly misogynist act.

Sleepyquest · 02/07/2021 12:41

I don't agree with any surrogacy unless it's being done for love, I.e your sister carries your baby for you because you physically can't.

The idea that rich women, particularly in America, are doing this mainly because they've let time run away from them let's be honest, by putting their careers first, makes me very uncomfortable.

There are some things in life that I don't think should be bought, including having a baby.

thecognoscenti · 02/07/2021 12:40

Also, no one has the right to have a child. It's not an essential part of life. Until rich western women are having babies for poor women in developing countries it will never be fair.

Swipe left for the next trending thread