Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think prizegiving is demoralising for most kids

142 replies

ShameCloud · 02/07/2021 10:17

I was fairly bright and hardworking at school. Never in trouble, polite and well behaved, did my homework, really tried hard and got good grades. But I wasn’t top of the class. Every prizegiving I had to sit through an hour or more of watching other kids go up to receive prizes and never me. Most of the prizes were for the ‘top’ student in each class so ‘near the top’ students didn’t count. There was an effort prize for each year group but always went to a kid who found things challenging but worked hard. I know they can’t give everyone a prize but honestly it was a yearly minor disappointment and then tedious end to term. Now I have kids who are much like me - bright and hardworking but not top of the class - so they too have year after year of sitting through prizegivings watching mostly the same top kids go up and be recognised.

I know I’m going to get a lot of comments about how I’m a snowflake who wants participation prizes but honestly it was just a rubbish experience as a kid. And as a parent it makes the ‘It’s the trying hard that counts’ narrative harder to sell.

OP posts:
ShameCloud · 02/07/2021 13:08

I also hate the ones for younger kids that rotate tbh. Especially as they seem more frequently used as a ‘Not being as much of a dick as usual’ incentive prize for the worse behaved kids.

OP posts:
ShameCloud · 02/07/2021 13:07

At my sons's school, it's held after school hours and only those receiving prizes, and their parents, are invited. Perfect.

That’s ideal.

OP posts:
Hax · 02/07/2021 13:01

To some kids its a real incentive. DS would have loved to excel at sport but didn't. He did play on the school teams though. He did however score 100% in his physics GCSE so thought he would get the physics prize, and got a string of A*s
He got nothing. Not even one of the very many tutor group prizes. He felt humiliated. I imagine most DC really don't care at 16 but to thosr who do it's brutal.

Heatherjayne1972 · 02/07/2021 12:57

I hate the ‘everyone gets a prize for competing ‘ more. Totally pointless

I never ever won anything at school. Left me feeling invisible and that there wasn’t any point in trying

TheKeatingFive · 02/07/2021 12:56

Why shouldn’t the kids who are the best in the category get a prize just because others might feel sad?

But why do they need a prize, what’s the value of that?

Youdiditanyway · 02/07/2021 12:54

My Gran was a primary school teacher for 40 years. She noticed one year a boy who had always been a star pupil suddenly started misbehaving. She couldn’t understand it at all so probed him until he finally told her he was being naughty because he didn’t get rewarded for being good but noticed the naughty children seemed to get special treats. They tried to incentivise the worst behaved with treats if they slightly improved their behaviour and this kid cottoned onto it.

It was the same in my secondary school tbh. The naughty kids were incentivised with special trips with the school mentors. I don’t think I received one reward, aside from my decent exam results I suppose!

JustMarriedBecca · 02/07/2021 12:51

Parent of the gifted child here. Working 2-3 years above her peers across multiple subjects. She has not once, in two years, won a prize (they do them weekly).
She says 'they give it to the kids who try. It's not my fault I don't have to try'
Personally if you are going to do weekly prizes then they should be shared around OR there should be an annual prize for attainment for the top of the class if they aren't going to get the weekly awards for progress.
It sends wholly the wrong message.

doyouneedtowean · 02/07/2021 12:51

YABU. Why shouldn’t the kids who are the best in the category get a prize just because others might feel sad?

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 02/07/2021 12:49

The academic prizes make more sense than attendance. Congratulations for either having a good immune system or attending school and passing on illnesses to your friends...

TheKeatingFive · 02/07/2021 12:48

It’s important to recognise excellence, be it academic, musical, sporting, living the schools ethos etc.

Why?

I question this too. Why?

I’m speaking from the position of the child who won all the prizes. They didn’t make much difference to me, I was absolutely driven at that age, I would have given my all without them. Yet it must have been demoralising for those who worked hard and didn’t get anything.

WhyOhWine · 02/07/2021 12:46

At my (large) school, as I recall they gave out about 4 prizes per subject plus some effort prizes, and also prizes for things like sports and drama. Although there were some students who won prizes in most subjects, the fact that there were 4 per subject meant that a reasonable number got some sort of prize with some variation year on year. I think people just went up once even if they got a prize in more than one subject.

As I recall, the prize ceremony was a relatively small part and there was also lots of music and I don't remember too many people complaining.

I think it is fine to award achievement, but right to focus not just one one particular type of achievement.

At my DDs' school, prize day is just attended by the prize winners and the choir/orchestra (plus their parents). They are very happy with that as they get a half day!

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 02/07/2021 12:46

My DDs recently moved schools. They were at their last school for five terms, including both lockdowns (where they didn't attend). In that time, elder DD never received any awards for anything. In a similar time frame, Younger DD won the biweekly prize twice, the half term prize for school values, and the termly prize for effort.
In the less than a term she's been at her current school, she's brought home three mini awards... that the teacher gives out when she notices something special. She's had it for kindness, for team work and for increased confidence. Her self confidence has definitely improved... and I think its the teacher noticing the small things.

Obviously that wouldn't work in sixth form... but it should be recognised that the middle kids are often trying their hardest, getting on with things and genuinely being nice people.

aiwblam · 02/07/2021 12:45

I think it's part of life.

My dd did a school competition and there were 4 kids in it. There was no chance of any of these kids winning it apart from one of them, who is just loads better than the other 3. Nevertheless my dd just did it, knowing that there was about a 0.1% chance of her winning. It's just something to be sucked up IMO as life is completely and utterly unfair and most things are utterly corrupt.

Shoppingwithmother · 02/07/2021 12:44

I disagree - I think it’s a really good thing to have. My kids are at a school which is pretty obsessed with sport, and children who are good at sport have their achievements trumpeted all the time.
My children are not interested in any of the main sports and not in the teams etc, but they are both very clever.
It is nice to have one day a year where being good at the main purpose of being at school is recognised, rather than being good at hockey, football, etc.
They didn’t have prizes at my school. If they had I would definitely have won some and it would have made me very happy.

Lanique · 02/07/2021 12:42

I used to work for a private school and oh my god the prize giving was horrible! Always the same kids, year after year, often winning four or five prizes each. All it made me think was that a) I would never send my children to such a biased and thoughtless place, and b) there can't have been that many clever, well-taught students if all the prizes went to a select few.

DynamoKev · 02/07/2021 12:35

@Nextchapterofmybook

Nope, it’s part of life. It’s important to recognise excellence, be it academic, musical, sporting, living the schools ethos etc.

Most of us are wonderfully average, me included, but that doesn’t mean those who have excelled shouldn’t be recognised.

It’s important to recognise excellence, be it academic, musical, sporting, living the schools ethos etc. Why?
SingaporeSlinky · 02/07/2021 12:33

I think it’s gone too far the other way now. At my kids school you get a prize for everything. Sports Day has a team that wins on points, a team that wins for best effort, best sportsmanship and best ‘parent cheering’ (back when parents could attend). So it loses all meaning, and the kids can’t even remember if they ‘won’ because basically everyone wins.

They do a ‘Star of the Day’ but even the 6 year olds have realised that basically every kid gets a turn, and the teachers find a way of making even the naughtiest children deserve it that day by overly praising them for just not being disruptive for half an hour. It’s lost all motivational meaning because the kids know they don’t need to try, it’s just a case of how long they have to wait for it to be their turn.

MandalaYogaTapestry · 02/07/2021 12:28

In my DD's school (year 6) they found something to praise and reward in every girl and each one therefore was given recognition. One for outstanding results in Humanities, one for the best progress in Music and History, the other for consistency high marks in Maths and Physics, etc. Extracurricular achievements such as in Ballet or participation in school competitions was also accounted for. All the girls were rightfully proud for their own success, rather than against one "top" measure.

SlipperyLizard · 02/07/2021 12:27

I still remember the run through of our prize giving, where only the prize winners were there to practice (which seems unnecessary!). I can still remember hearing the muttering behind me (from other prize winners) about the girl (me!) who’d won 3 prizes for A level subjects. I wanted to crawl under my chair.

Then the deputy head announcing the prize for English AND history AND biology going to me, and having to reveal myself as the geek in question. £30 of book tokens was not adequate compensation, even back then.

It must be shit for those that come close, and I imagine the kids winning the prizes hardly need the encouragement, but overall I think it is shit for all involved and should probably be scrapped.

ILoveAnOwl · 02/07/2021 12:25

Never won anything but was asked EVERY year to play an instrument or do a reading.

So I was good enough to wheel out and perform but not good enough to actually win anything.

I am still bitter 22 years later...

Missfelipe · 02/07/2021 12:23

Where I work is a bit like this so perhaps it’s not the worst thing to experience when it happens in everyday life. The same group of colleagues are constantly praised, the poor performers get praised for doing slightly more than the bare minimum and then there’s the rest of us, mostly overlooked for being good but not the best!

StellaAndCrow · 02/07/2021 12:20

Similar to Gladiolys I did well academically at school but was bullied for being shit at sports and socially awkward. And not having the latest gear. It was bad enough having to pretend not to hear people making comments in class. It was just awful at prize giving having to go up to get a prize with my bullies sniggering. It's made me feel sick thinking back to it.

And as you say ShameCloud it's shit for those who don't win prizes as well.
I've been to some graduation events in special education schools, and some of these seem to manage the whole thing much better, making it a celebration of individual achievements and qualities.

seventyone · 02/07/2021 12:18

YANBU - all it does is emphasise to kids that they're " just another brick in the wall". They don't need to be taught that, they know it already.

purplebatbear · 02/07/2021 12:14

I'm a teacher and I went to a school where Prizegiving was a huge deal AND I won every year.

And I think it's shit.

I think it's demoralising and just unnecessary.

motogogo · 02/07/2021 12:14

It depends, my dd is autistic and found school very hard, being recognised for her hard work all year was great for her, her peers who either ignored cot at worst teased her would be genuinely happy that she won prizes, ditto when they celebrated her music achievements in assembly, she's very quietly spoken and hides away in class discussions yet could sing opera arias, and bizarrely didn't mind performing at school go figure.