Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think prizegiving is demoralising for most kids

142 replies

ShameCloud · 02/07/2021 10:17

I was fairly bright and hardworking at school. Never in trouble, polite and well behaved, did my homework, really tried hard and got good grades. But I wasn’t top of the class. Every prizegiving I had to sit through an hour or more of watching other kids go up to receive prizes and never me. Most of the prizes were for the ‘top’ student in each class so ‘near the top’ students didn’t count. There was an effort prize for each year group but always went to a kid who found things challenging but worked hard. I know they can’t give everyone a prize but honestly it was a yearly minor disappointment and then tedious end to term. Now I have kids who are much like me - bright and hardworking but not top of the class - so they too have year after year of sitting through prizegivings watching mostly the same top kids go up and be recognised.

I know I’m going to get a lot of comments about how I’m a snowflake who wants participation prizes but honestly it was just a rubbish experience as a kid. And as a parent it makes the ‘It’s the trying hard that counts’ narrative harder to sell.

OP posts:
MaOfThree · 04/07/2021 10:38

How about a School deciding to end the tradition of honouring all of Year 6 by giving 2/3 a prize this year and leaving out a handful of children for the first time in recent memory?! In front of the whole school and lots of parents .. after the difficult year+ children have had with lockdown and so on.
I couldn’t believe what I sat through last week - and would be saying that regardless of whether my child was a recipient or not! Takes the shine off for everyone and felt very cruel.

GreenWhiteViolet · 03/07/2021 07:10

My primary school used to give out a number of special 'good behaviour awards' in the last assembly every year. I never got one, and I didn't understand why, because I was always perfectly behaved. Mostly because I was terrified of doing the wrong thing and getting in trouble. Now I can surmise that the awards went to children whose behaviour had improved, or who needed encouragement with it, but I still remember the disappointment every year and wondering what I'd done wrong.

I think secondary school awards for the highest attainment are fine as long as it's just the students getting the awards who are invited to the ceremony. I didn't get any until year 11, when I got three for different subjects. I suspect the criteria were changed - I'd have been top in certain subjects before, but had low attendance, rarely did homework, etc, so I can see why teachers wouldn't want to choose me. The school also gave out awards for sports and music, which I think made it fairer.

Lockedup · 03/07/2021 06:40

On that basis schools ought to come up with more experiences that will be a bit miserable for a large chunk of the pupils, to help them build resilience.

You’ve just described the school experience for a huge number of people 😂

sashh · 03/07/2021 05:33

At my school you were only invited to prize giving if you had won.

Prize giving was only about things achieved in school so you could get academic prizes but also prizes for running the school library at lunch and after school, basically every 'librarian' got that and the domestic science group who did an Xmas party for the local OAPs.

Things out of school could be 'presented' at assembly so your Karate grades or cycling proficiency.

I think one of the best systems was at an FE college where they sent, 'postcards home' one student a month from each department got a postcard from the college with a personal message and it could be for anything and everything, hard work, dealing with a difficult situation, helping another. It was discussed at staff meetings and mean it was up tot he student if they shared it.

GrasswillbeGreener · 02/07/2021 22:44

I see well-structured prizegiving as a good thing on the whole but agree it can also be very badly done. (I recall a horror year at one school when they had changed to calculated effort grades and didn't have the sense to see that you do NOT give the achievement and effort awards to the same children!)

I was one who always got academic prizes at school. In my last year I did get an embarassing number of awards, and felt very guilty that the girl who was consistently second to me in maths and sciences (and subsequently became a physics professor) couldn't have been given at least something, as in any other year she would have also been a stand-out. The reaction of other students suggests they all felt my awards were deserved though. But you know the one I am still actually proud of? The one for greatest overall contribution. It was almost always won by a girl who was known for excellence in sports, and also did other things. Sporty I was decidedly not, but I guess I did do just about everything else while I was there. I stlil have most of my school prizes - they were actually quite thoughtful about the books they selected. I agree with those who have said that academic children DO need to be acknowledged. So often you feel like you are good at all the wrong things.

I'm attending leavers' prizegiving on my daughter's behalf tomorrow as she had to choose between it and a sporting event. She's getting well earned music awards as far as I know.

My son's prep school had a lot of trophies which meant they could have a number of awards without it costing them loads every year. What I really appreciated was that there were as many for music as for sports, and several for subjects, so there were a number of boys who could compete for them meaningfully.

WiddlinDiddlin · 02/07/2021 21:59

I wasn't especially arsed about winning prizes at school for achieving grades - I didn't win because I put in the minimal effort required for an acceptable result (typically B+ student, could have been A* but couldn't be bothered)... and that's fair enough.

But our school was heavy on rewarding those who either were naturally brilliant but put in no effort...

Or those who were average but put in a ton of effort, excessively so, that did not actually add to their academic achievement... and I never understood this.

For example, an A+ for effort when someone has written 1000 more words than requested, but hasn't actually made any more relevant points or discussions in an essay than the person who wrote exactly the right word count AND hit all the relevant points... (this particular person was in for a MASSIVE shock when she got to college and discovered writing excessive amounts over the requested word count would LOSE her marks rather than gain them!)

This was an actual example held up to me when I was told off for 'coasting' and 'putting in the bare minimum effort'.. and I do not understand to this day where the value lies in doing MORE work than is necessary to achieve the same result, surely thats just time wasting.

If I put in 8 hours more than the 10 hours a client pays me to do, for a result I could have done in 10 hours, they will NOT be overjoyed at being billed for those extra 8 hours will they!

Theres was also the usual shitty stuff, attendance awards were a thing even then - hurrah, little Sarah has not been off all year, have a certificate.

No certificate for WiddlinDiddlin who has had flu and been off 3 weeks and then been dragged across the country and sent to another school for 6 weeks by her useless father who then gave up on parenting and sent her back to her mothers..... I really should have just pulled my socks up and tried harder eh!

CatsArePeople · 02/07/2021 21:21

scrap them altogether. It cause more grief and headache than actual joy for the winners.
Those good at academics, will get good grades. Those good at sports or arts will win competitions. That maters. In real life nobody cares if you won an "effort" award in 5th grade.

memberofthewedding · 02/07/2021 20:48

I was a swot at school although I worked hard to get my top class grades. When I whinged that an older bigger boy picked on me my father took me into the back yard every night for a week and taught me to box. I was black and blue but I learned how to punch. Next time he bullied me I broke his nose. I was never bullied after that.

Of course the school did nothing because it was shameful for a boy to get beaten up by a girl.

Yolande7 · 02/07/2021 20:47

Could you provide some evidence for that claim please?

MH problems are not caused by a lack of resilience. They are caused by chemical imbalaces in the brain, trauma, a large number adverse childhood experiences (ACEs), genetic predisposition, substance abuse and other things. I have never seen the lack of award ceremonies mentioned.

notanothertakeaway · 02/07/2021 20:45

@TheWitchCirce

At my sons's school, it's held after school hours and only those receiving prizes, and their parents, are invited. Perfect.
I like this idea
NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 02/07/2021 20:39

Excellent students get a lot of recognition anyway: they get fantastic grades, teachers often choose them for special things, pretty much everyone knows they are doing well

This isnt always true. Yes you get the grades but that often means little to a teenager. Teachers often have little time for high achievers, the special things always go to struggling kids for "effort". More often than not your peers are bullying you for your academic success.

If we can't celebrate effort and achievement things can become very joyless.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 02/07/2021 20:36

Mini pie

They try to do this more and more. Schools have things like "failure week" where you are made to do things you aren't good at etc.

LemonRoses · 02/07/2021 20:36

Our children’s Prizegiving /Speech day was the highlight of the year. Huge event with a massive marquee, performances, prizes, speeches, music, etc. Full runway, event projected onto screens around the tent. Great fun and loved by most of the students.
Followed by house picnics and various matches and displays. Nobody really worried whether they had prizes or not. Very much a culture of ‘not everyone can win’.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 02/07/2021 20:35

When I was at school, prize giving happened one evening and only kids who were winning something and their parents were invited.

The prizes weren't solely academic, there were extra things so there were governing board prizes which went to kids in that worked hard but aren't top sort of bucket, and a couple for contributing to school life who went to quite random kids each year but were always well earned.

minipie · 02/07/2021 20:27

You can only build resilience through tough experiences and never winning a prize is a relatively harmless way to build some resilience

On that basis schools ought to come up with more experiences that will be a bit miserable for a large chunk of the pupils, to help them build resilience.

Yolande7 · 02/07/2021 20:20

@Nextchapterofmybook

Nope, it’s part of life. It’s important to recognise excellence, be it academic, musical, sporting, living the schools ethos etc.

Most of us are wonderfully average, me included, but that doesn’t mean those who have excelled shouldn’t be recognised.

Excellent students get a lot of recognition anyway: they get fantastic grades, teachers often choose them for special things, pretty much everyone knows they are doing well - them included, they get scholarships etc. None of them have self-esteem issues when it comes to achievement. Is it really them who need more recognition?

I was an excellent student. I have one child who is well above average and one who can be excellent, mediocre or fail, depending on the day due to MH issues. My children need recognition much more than I have ever needed it. And they should get it, because I did not have to work particularly hard to get top grades (sorry, I don't want to boast. I just at some point understood what teachers were looking for).

I think effort should be rewarded and there should be awards for many different things, if a school chooses to have awards.

junebirthdaygirl · 02/07/2021 20:14

My dd constantly won prizes..academic, representing the school on all occasions etc..you name it she won it. I was nearly embarrassed but proud. Her two brothers thought it was hilarious and felt they would be mortified if they were up there among ..in their words..the swots!
All working now. Both boys have much higher paid jobs with prospects of promotion and perks. DD is very happy in her line of work but she will never be rich so winning prizes is no indication of anything going forward.
But, as she didn't win matches/ races etc it was her day of glory and l have no problem with it. Glad l haven't to sit through those speeches anymore though!!

Getawaywithit · 02/07/2021 20:02

If the winners aren’t even having fun, why are we still doing this!

There’s argument for not letting one person win everything (this is something my school guards against) but I do think it’s important that hard work is recognised, celebrated and rewarded.

Againstmachine · 02/07/2021 19:49

When being bullied for most of my secondary school I can safely say, this was one of least bits I cared about.

It may be demoralising to some but to me it was a tiny thing in a shitty school system.

Clickbait · 02/07/2021 19:24

Like a pp, my DC's prizegiving (secondary school) is outside normal school hours and only the prizewinners and their parents are invited.

At primary school, everyone in year 6 got a prize for something (and parents weren't invited below year 6).

So my experience has been positive! Although I think my DC found it boring when they were in reception to year 5 and had to sit through it.

HeadNorth · 02/07/2021 19:18

Prizegiving is dull as, even when your child wins prizes. Fortunately ours were never that bothered & were soon happy to skip it.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 02/07/2021 19:17

I agree, I regularly won prizes and would feel sick at the thought of going up infront of everyone to be recognised officially as a massive shot, I hated it.

Polkadots2021 · 02/07/2021 18:43

@ShameCloud

I was fairly bright and hardworking at school. Never in trouble, polite and well behaved, did my homework, really tried hard and got good grades. But I wasn’t top of the class. Every prizegiving I had to sit through an hour or more of watching other kids go up to receive prizes and never me. Most of the prizes were for the ‘top’ student in each class so ‘near the top’ students didn’t count. There was an effort prize for each year group but always went to a kid who found things challenging but worked hard. I know they can’t give everyone a prize but honestly it was a yearly minor disappointment and then tedious end to term. Now I have kids who are much like me - bright and hardworking but not top of the class - so they too have year after year of sitting through prizegivings watching mostly the same top kids go up and be recognised.

I know I’m going to get a lot of comments about how I’m a snowflake who wants participation prizes but honestly it was just a rubbish experience as a kid. And as a parent it makes the ‘It’s the trying hard that counts’ narrative harder to sell.

Yeah this bothered me, too, but it's a learning to lose thing. I ended up creating lots of opportunities for myself later in life to win instead, which I did (won't say what as it's too outing). If you put the right spin on it & learn from it, it can drive you on pretty well to make your own path where you don't have to rely on anyone else to decide whether you should get a medal or not.
ShanghaiDiva · 02/07/2021 18:29

At my dd’s former school prizes were awarded as follows:
Grade per subject maximum of 7- you receive and award if you achieve x points in total and a different award if you achieve x points for consecutive terms ie the number of students who can achieve an award is not capped.
Additionally awards for progress, art, drama, sport, music and community service.

drumandthebass · 02/07/2021 17:56

At my sons school they have an awards evening so only pupils receiving them go. I had a phone call from the school one day to say that DS was going to receive an award, but they wouldn't say what for so it was a surprise. We all thought (including DS) that they'd made a mistake Grin,