Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think prizegiving is demoralising for most kids

142 replies

ShameCloud · 02/07/2021 10:17

I was fairly bright and hardworking at school. Never in trouble, polite and well behaved, did my homework, really tried hard and got good grades. But I wasn’t top of the class. Every prizegiving I had to sit through an hour or more of watching other kids go up to receive prizes and never me. Most of the prizes were for the ‘top’ student in each class so ‘near the top’ students didn’t count. There was an effort prize for each year group but always went to a kid who found things challenging but worked hard. I know they can’t give everyone a prize but honestly it was a yearly minor disappointment and then tedious end to term. Now I have kids who are much like me - bright and hardworking but not top of the class - so they too have year after year of sitting through prizegivings watching mostly the same top kids go up and be recognised.

I know I’m going to get a lot of comments about how I’m a snowflake who wants participation prizes but honestly it was just a rubbish experience as a kid. And as a parent it makes the ‘It’s the trying hard that counts’ narrative harder to sell.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Nohomemadecandles · 22/07/2021 21:33

I was like you OP but it didn't bother me. Dunno why. Probably glad not to have to go up on stage.
I'm sure it chauved other kids though.

Tivadiva · 22/07/2021 21:31

Couldn’t agree more about vivacious v quiet kids. Prizewinners achieve no more or do any more than DD but they shove it in peoples faces whereas DD is quiet and pretty self effacing and as a result at this school will I’m sure never win a prize.

MauveMavis · 21/07/2021 21:10

I have mixed feelings about this. I was an academic child.

I'm not arty and I'm really really not musical. I am enthusiastic rather than talented at sport - the 3rd XI was my home turf.

So I never got rewarded for any of those things. My first school was really big on music and art. Huge concerts - lots of fanfare over the soloists. Big exhibitions with work by pupils from throughout the school on show.

Unsurprisingly I got very little recognition. No one ever commented on my very solid academic performance.

Changed schools (we moved). Still music/ art culture but an academic prize giving. It felt really great to finally get some recognition.

I think they tried to spread the stuff around but there were still a few familiar names appearing repeatedly.

My last school had a massive sports culture. I was there because it was also very academic. The only time of year I ever got to shine was academic prize giving. In fact at the end of my first year in the school I think it was the first time some people in my year realised I even existed (I was very quiet in those days)...

I didn't really think about it until we cleared our family home. We found the old programmes. My siblings ripped the piss out of how many things I won (I think they got a prize each over their whole school careers). They love me and thought it was laughable so maybe others did too...

Blackhawkdown2020 · 21/07/2021 20:27

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

StepladderToHeaven · 21/07/2021 19:33

It varies. In my DD's primary class, the sporty kids were completely different from the academic kids, so sports day was a nice opportunity for them to shine and the bright kids had prize giving (although there were still some kids who didn't do well in either).

But in DS1 and DS2's classes, there was a small group of kids who genuinely were the best at both schoolwork AND sport.

MrsFin · 21/07/2021 18:58

Some kids will win academic awards, some kids will win sports day awards, some kids will win work experience awards; and they usually aren’t the same kids

I disagree. Bloody Lydia in DD2's year was Mary in every nativity bar one - when she was ill.

Same DD - girl in her year got an award for attending every orchestra practice and concert. DD also attended every practice and concert. No award.
DD is quiet
Other girl is vivacious.

Ozanj · 21/07/2021 18:17

Some kids will win academic awards, some kids will win sports day awards, some kids will win work experience awards; and they usually aren’t the same kids.

If you’re the best you will win. I don’t agree that kids who plod along getting average grades but never giving their best or working their hardest should get anything. And I don’t agree with this notion that kids on a G&T programme are somehow getting top marks without working hard. They do work hard. Many kids on G&T programmes have SEN that means while they are really intelligent it takes a lot of effort for them to achieve in a structured learning environment.

MrsFin · 21/07/2021 17:58

And it continues in the world of work too.
I'm fed up of people being nominated for awards in work when I know they only succeeded because of the work I someone else did.
It has the opposite of the intended effect, at least as far as I'm concerned. I find it demoralising.

ChocolateCakeYum · 21/07/2021 17:56

@ChocolateCakeYum

Urgh they should be banned. In college I was told I was getting student of the year. Come prize giving my name wasn’t called because my English teacher and I had had a falling out and that’s when I realised that a lot (though not all) are popularity contests.

The worst one I ever witnessed was my sons. All the awards went to one student and they invented awards and prizes not only for this kids parents but also his grandparents too. Insanity! Everyone was gobsmacked.

My sons nursery prize giving. Not his prize giving. Poor chap didn’t get a single prize that day (though to be fair neither did anyone else apart from one boy).
mintginger · 21/07/2021 17:54

At the school mine has just left, you only get invited to the prize giving if you have won a prize. So the vast majority don’t get the email or give it a second thought. Also, in a subject with a large cohort (eg Maths or English) they might give several prizes, but only one prize is given for a smaller subject where there might be only five in the class! My DS only got a prize for the first time this year (Year 13). It’s a very selective school where practically everyone gets 8/9 across the board at GCSE. In a way, that level of competition is healthy because they learn very quickly that it’s absolutely ok to be very average in terms of that cohort. If you get a prize then that a bonus, but no more. Many will come out with all 9s at GCSE and A* at A-level and never had had a whiff of any prize, but it’s good training for uni because you are used to competition and are under no delusions about being special / ‘top’ etc.

ChocolateCakeYum · 21/07/2021 17:54

Urgh they should be banned. In college I was told I was getting student of the year. Come prize giving my name wasn’t called because my English teacher and I had had a falling out and that’s when I realised that a lot (though not all) are popularity contests.

The worst one I ever witnessed was my sons. All the awards went to one student and they invented awards and prizes not only for this kids parents but also his grandparents too. Insanity! Everyone was gobsmacked.

PandemicAtTheDisco · 21/07/2021 17:41

To think prizegiving is demoralising for most kids

I think it's demoralising for some kids - not all. I don't think most kids are that bothered. The same children seem to always be first on sports day too but no one makes a fuss then. Why is it so different for class work?

Tivadiva · 21/07/2021 17:29

Not unreasonable. My DD is bright, popular, scores well in tests etc. but never wins a prize. All the things that would get someone selected for a prize (I’ve asked!) she does. I can only conclude that the perception is that she’s doesn’t need the encouragement. It makes me livid each summer we have to go to these events. I’ve decided that this will be the last time I go. DH happy to attend, and although DD would be delighted to get a prize, she doesn’t dwell on it. I don’t get over it for weeks, and so far it has ruined the start of the summer holidays as usual. I don’t see why on earth the same children should be awarded the same prizes year in year out. It it utterly nonsensical. Rewarding excellence is fine by me, but when else in life would anyone be judged 7 years running on the same criteria for the same prizes in the same group of people? While some kids repeatedly get nothing. It discourages the majority and provides false validation to the group who are selected again and again. The whole thing is complete BS.

Wearywithteens · 08/07/2021 00:18

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Thaddit · 04/07/2021 13:35

At primary school I won all the prizes bar one for best project completed that year. They were the only academic prizes I won ever and I can still remember the pleasure of winning a plastic red rose brooch at age 9 and a 25p book token at age 10 which I spent on a book of Spike Milligan poems.

Healthy competition within reason is fine.

abrighterday · 04/07/2021 13:22

@Thisisworsethananticpated

Agree it’s always the same Either the class alpha Or the class struggling kid being rewarded for not misbehaving

Angry

This a million times over.

In DC school there is one prize at the end of the year given to one child from each class. It’s always top of the classers or a child chosen to help encourage them with their behaviour.

Why on earth there isn’t 2 or 3 prizes given out baffles me. Give some middle of the road kids a chance for goodness sake.

a8mint · 04/07/2021 13:19

Should we ban sports days and concerts too them?

BlackCherryCandle · 04/07/2021 13:06

In high school 1 girl and 1 boy for each subject got a prize.

For 1 of my GCSE subjects I was the only girl in that subject so of course I got the prize. It was very embarrassing as I then took it to ALevel and again was the only girl...

As soon as my parents got the invite I knew which subject I was up for.

WeAllHaveWings · 04/07/2021 12:54

Ds is one of the top 4 students in his school year of 250+ kids, puts the hours in and works really hard for his grades but has never received a prize for academic achievement as there are a couple of really naturally academic kids in his year.

This year he did really well in his main assessments, got 5As for his Scottish Highers and got his first ever invite to prize giving, they don't say in advance why they have been invited. He excitedly thought maybe he'd managed to get the top grade for one subject, or they were maybe giving out a certificate to recognise the only 4 students that got 5As. He got called up and and was given a certificate for attending and getting good feedback from a virtual work experience, he was disappointed, mortified and raging as everyone else got "proper" prizes, the picture of him on the school website holding his certificate shows exactly how he felt about it 🤣.

Macncheeseballs · 04/07/2021 12:54

In my kids school prizes are given for most effort, or best improvement etc, to try and reward the under achievers, not sure that works too well either

lordalmighty · 04/07/2021 12:31

My DD is polite, hard working and has moved up to the top groups in her class this year and is still disappointed that she didn't get the 'Star Pupil' award. It's given out weekly so plenty of time for each child to get one but some of the children were given it multiple times. She was disappointed but I just tried to explain that some people need extra encouragement to feel proud of themselves and it doesn't mean she hasn't done well. I think it's also due to the fact she doesn't understand why others are being rewarded for I.e. trying hard to listen when most of them do that anyway. She's fine & will get over it but kids do take it to heart when they don't get anything despite trying their best.

Brefugee · 04/07/2021 12:21

I sometimes got prizes, sometimes not. It didn't bother me and later on it only really bothered the girls (girls school) with the ultra competitive parents who brought them up to think that anything less than number 1 was losing big time (for eg: If i don't get all As on my O-level certificate i'll rip it up)

it helps build resiliance and hopefully helps build graciously winning because life isn't prizes for all is it? the candidate who tried hardest in the interview for the job gets nothing compared to the best candidate who got it etc etc

JudgeJ · 04/07/2021 12:19

@3cats4poniesandababy

What also used to annoying me (a top of middle level cbild) they did away days for the gifted and talented group, away days for those who were less academic, away days for those who English wasn't a first language. Essentially so many groups had various away days that around 90% of people got to do one. I never fell into any if the groups so year after year I had to see all the groups go while we were still sat in class.
In the past the badly behaved pupils were taken out on jollies as well which also led to the well bahaved being quite rightly disgruntled, Our reward for working hard is to stay in school to work! In the '80s when the initiatives were targetting girls and the gifted/talented many of the average/below average ability boys felt they were being side-lined, it influenced their behaviour and achievement accordingly.
Thisisworsethananticpated · 04/07/2021 12:14

Agree
it’s always the same
Either the class alpha
Or the class struggling kid being rewarded for not misbehaving

Angry
TeenMinusTests · 04/07/2021 12:02

Ma That is appalling. Shock

Swipe left for the next trending thread