Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To cry because one my my jabs is the unregistered AZ Indian one...

342 replies

Oxonschools · 02/07/2021 09:55

And we are supposed to be going as a whole family, with the grandparents, to France on Sunday.

Does anyone know how I can find out if I will be let into France.

OP posts:
Belladonna12 · 06/07/2021 14:49

There may be a list of agencies considered acceptable but it still requires time and effort to make the decision as to which ones to accept.

You are not making sense. If they have a list of agencies they consider acceptable it's not going to take time and effort to consider which ones to accept. They can just use the list when considering which people can be considered vaccinated. No further effort required.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 06/07/2021 13:43

They won't have to say "woohoo" lets take them all. There is already a list of agencies considered acceptable! In addition the EU have said that because the company is on the WHO Health Organisation Emergency Use List it is okay for countries to admit travellors that have been vaccinated with AstraZeneca manufactured by the Serum Institute of India It's the largest manufacturer of vaccines in the world.

There may be a list of agencies considered acceptable but it still requires time and effort to make the decision as to which ones to accept. It took time and effort to decide to give blanket acceptance to EMA approved vaccines only. It will take time and effort to decide to accept those approved by WHO and/or counties with MUAs. The other option is woo-hoo.

Anyway, this is going round in circles so I've made my point and will leave it there.

foxandbee · 06/07/2021 13:42

Thanks @chocolatesaltyballs22 - I might have to do the same.

chocolatesaltyballs22 · 06/07/2021 13:32

@foxandbee I didn't risk it - I asked the GP's surgery to change my name back so that it matched.

foxandbee · 06/07/2021 13:30

@chocolatesaltyballs22

Having just flown to the Balearics I can tell you they're not even looking at this. All they want to see is your PLF.
@chocolatesaltyballs22 did you have any issues re your passport being in your maiden name and vaccine cert in married name?

Have a lovely time!

Belladonna12 · 06/07/2021 13:26

@OchonAgusOchonOh

Why would it involve time, effort and money to accept travellors who had been vaccinated with batches of AstraZenca, Pfizer or Moderna that had been manufactored by companies that had been inspected by the WHO or regulators with whom the EMA already have agreements in place?.

Because you can't just say woo-hoo, let's take them all. You need to create a list of those that are acceptable. As I said, the next logical step is to accept all vaccines approved by the WHO. They haven't done that yet. That makes it more awkward for some third countries but them's the breaks.

They won't have to say "woohoo" lets take them all. There is already a list of agencies considered acceptable! In addition the EU have said that because the company is on the WHO Health Organisation Emergency Use List it is okay for countries to admit travellors that have been vaccinated with AstraZeneca manufactured by the Serum Institute of India It's the largest manufacturer of vaccines in the world.
OchonAgusOchonOh · 06/07/2021 13:08

Why would it involve time, effort and money to accept travellors who had been vaccinated with batches of AstraZenca, Pfizer or Moderna that had been manufactored by companies that had been inspected by the WHO or regulators with whom the EMA already have agreements in place?.

Because you can't just say woo-hoo, let's take them all. You need to create a list of those that are acceptable. As I said, the next logical step is to accept all vaccines approved by the WHO. They haven't done that yet. That makes it more awkward for some third countries but them's the breaks.

Belladonna12 · 06/07/2021 13:02

Why would they expend time, effort and money doing that for third countries? They accept vaccines approved by the EMA at the moment. The next logical step would be to consider accepting those approved by WHO or all countries with whom they have an MUA.

Why would it involve time, effort and money to accept travellors who had been vaccinated with batches of AstraZenca, Pfizer or Moderna that had been manufactored by companies that had been inspected by the WHO or regulators with whom the EMA already have agreements in place?.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 06/07/2021 12:56

@Belladonna12

You are basically looking for the EU to make an exception to their processes for a vaccine that is approved in the UK but has not been approved in the EU. There is absolutely no reason they should do so, particularly as individual EU countries can make their own decision as to which they will allow (sovereignty, don't you know).

Why do you think they should make an exception for the UK? The UK is a third country and is being treated as such.

I am not saying that they should treat the UK as an exception at all. It would be wrong to treat travellers from other countries as if they were unvaccinated in this scenario too.

So you are saying they should make an exception for the UK and some other random list of countries.

Why would they expend time, effort and money doing that for third countries? They accept vaccines approved by the EMA at the moment. The next logical step would be to consider accepting those approved by WHO or all countries with whom they have an MUA.

Individual EU members can make their own decisions as to which they accept. However, the EU have stated all EMA approved vaccines are acceptable everywhere within the EU so any country that wishes to, can accept all those without having to do any further research/approvals.

Belladonna12 · 06/07/2021 12:41

You are basically looking for the EU to make an exception to their processes for a vaccine that is approved in the UK but has not been approved in the EU. There is absolutely no reason they should do so, particularly as individual EU countries can make their own decision as to which they will allow (sovereignty, don't you know).

Why do you think they should make an exception for the UK? The UK is a third country and is being treated as such.

I am not saying that they should treat the UK as an exception at all. It would be wrong to treat travellers from other countries as if they were unvaccinated in this scenario too.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 06/07/2021 12:21

@Belladonna12

As it stands, the decision has been made to approve all EMA approved vaccines for entry. The next logical step would be to approve all WHO approved vaccines rather than doing so for individual agencies. If they were to do it by individual agency, they would need to make the decision on an agency by agency basis. That is not practical.

The Astra Zenaca vaccine is approved by the EMA. The maufacturing facility in India hasn't been inspected by the EMA but it has been inspected by the MHRA and has completed the WHO Health Organisation Emergency Use Listing process. Therefore it would be entirely practical for EU countries to decide to accept Covisheild vaccinated people. The fact that most have demonstrates this!

The EMA approval does not include Covishield.

You are basically looking for the EU to make an exception to their processes for a vaccine that is approved in the UK but has not been approved in the EU. There is absolutely no reason they should do so, particularly as individual EU countries can make their own decision as to which they will allow (sovereignty, don't you know).

Why do you think they should make an exception for the UK? The UK is a third country and is being treated as such.

Belladonna12 · 06/07/2021 11:55

As it stands, the decision has been made to approve all EMA approved vaccines for entry. The next logical step would be to approve all WHO approved vaccines rather than doing so for individual agencies. If they were to do it by individual agency, they would need to make the decision on an agency by agency basis. That is not practical.

The Astra Zenaca vaccine is approved by the EMA. The maufacturing facility in India hasn't been inspected by the EMA but it has been inspected by the MHRA and has completed the WHO Health Organisation Emergency Use Listing process. Therefore it would be entirely practical for EU countries to decide to accept Covisheild vaccinated people. The fact that most have demonstrates this!

Cailleach1 · 06/07/2021 11:29

Yes, there is a Mutual Recognition Agreement between the EMA and the FDA. There is a list of countries with which there are cooperation and collaboration agreements in place.

www.ema.europa.eu/en/partners-networks/international-activities/bilateral-interactions-non-eu-regulators/united-states#mutual-recognition-agreement-and-gmp-compliance--section

This is a list of the countries with which the EMA have 'Bilateral interactions with non-EU regulators'.

www.ema.europa.eu/en/partners-networks/international-activities/bilateral-interactions-non-eu-regulators

Cailleach1 · 06/07/2021 11:18

There may be agreements in place with some other countries which cover this. Some sort of M.O.U. will mean they are not treated the same as a 3rd country without an M.O.U.

So, maybe inspections by the FDA are recognised. I don't know if that is the case. Just we have to bear in mind that other 3rd countries will have agreements in place that mean it is not the same relationship as with all other 3rd countries.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 06/07/2021 11:17

The issue is not whether we are being treated differently to other "third" countries. It whether people who have been vaccinated with batches made in factories that while not inspected by the EMA have been inspected by agencies with similar standards including the FDA or MHRA should be treated as vaccinated.

As it stands, the decision has been made to approve all EMA approved vaccines for entry. The next logical step would be to approve all WHO approved vaccines rather than doing so for individual agencies. If they were to do it by individual agency, they would need to make the decision on an agency by agency basis. That is not practical.

I expect a decision will be made to approve all WHO approved vaccines in time.

I think they should be and that the decision not to is political and nothing to do with public health or safety.

And I think the sensible approach is to start with EMA approved vaccines and then look at all WHO approved vaccines. All decisions are political. The decision will consider public health, resources required to do assessments, etc. Approving at the micro level (by agency) makes no sense from a cost or efficiency perspective. Approving at a macro level (WHO) does make sense.

Belladonna12 · 06/07/2021 11:06

@OchonAgusOchonOh

As I said, I don't think we should be treated differently to other "third" countries

So no problem then as the UK is being treated the same as any other third country. The manufacturing process is part of the approval process.

The issue is not whether we are being treated differently to other "third" countries. It whether people who have been vaccinated with batches made in factories that while not inspected by the EMA have been inspected by agencies with similar standards including the FDA or MHRA should be treated as vaccinated. I think they should be and that the decision not to is political and nothing to do with public health or safety.
OchonAgusOchonOh · 06/07/2021 10:53

As I said, I don't think we should be treated differently to other "third" countries

So no problem then as the UK is being treated the same as any other third country. The manufacturing process is part of the approval process.

Belladonna12 · 06/07/2021 10:34

@OchonAgusOchonOh

The fact that they could diverge is not relevant if they haven't!

Of course it is.

The processes used are not a secret; they are fully published and if a country's licensing authority has the same standards or higher than those of the EMA it is ridiculous to not let those who have been vaccinated with vaccines that have been authorised by them into an EU country.

The processes used may not be a secret but in order to ensure they are compliant, they would have to be checked. If they are checked for one third country, other third countries would reasonably expect the same treatment.

You are either a member of the EU or you are not. The UK is a third country. They are being treated the exact same as other third countries. That is fair and transparent. If you start making exceptions, it becomes an administrative nightmare.

As I said, I don't think we should be treated differently to other "third" countries. It would be equally ridiculous not not accept people who had been vaccinated with Pfizer batches from factories authorised by the FDA because the EMA hadn't inspected the factory.
Cailleach1 · 06/07/2021 10:32

There may be a memorandum of understanding between the US and the EU. There are different layers of cooperation which may be relevant. Not saying there is, but there could be.

Belladonna12 · 06/07/2021 10:28

The EU have made a decision that the only vaccines approved for people entering into the EU are those approved by the EMA. It's a public health decision. It applies to all vaccines not approved by the EMA. Why would one third country's approval process be treated any differently that of another third country?

I havn't said that "one country" should be treated differently. I would say the same thing if people from the US who were vaccinated with a Pfizer vaccine weren't let into EU countries because a batch had been made in a US factory that had not been inspected by the EMA even though it had been inspected and authorised by the FDA.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 06/07/2021 10:14

The fact that they could diverge is not relevant if they haven't!

Of course it is.

The processes used are not a secret; they are fully published and if a country's licensing authority has the same standards or higher than those of the EMA it is ridiculous to not let those who have been vaccinated with vaccines that have been authorised by them into an EU country.

The processes used may not be a secret but in order to ensure they are compliant, they would have to be checked. If they are checked for one third country, other third countries would reasonably expect the same treatment.

You are either a member of the EU or you are not. The UK is a third country. They are being treated the exact same as other third countries. That is fair and transparent. If you start making exceptions, it becomes an administrative nightmare.

Belladonna12 · 06/07/2021 10:12

@Cailleach1

MHRA are simply rubber-stamping marketing authorisations decided by the EMA at the moment. They only changed from 'emergency use' for AZ in the UK, to full marketing authorization by adopting the EMA decision. This is expected to continue for a year or two. This is just for centrally authorised products; as they are the ones the EMA approve.

The issue with the Indian manufactured AZ batches is probably the manufacturing site. The product has to be approved, but also the manufacturing plants which make the product has to be approved by the regulatory authority. So the MHRA just adopted the EMA decision for the product marketing authorisation, but have approved the Indian manufacturing site themselves. The approval of the manufacturing site in India which produced some AZ batches is probably the crux here.

I presume no batches of AZ from India were used in the EU. There were four plants referred to in 'that' contract, none being in India.

Yes, the MHRA approved the manufactuing plant in India themselves. There is nothing to say that the EMA wouldn't have rubber stamped and approved the site following the MHRA decision but they didn't need to as those batches weren't used in the EU.
OchonAgusOchonOh · 06/07/2021 10:09

@Belladonna12

Same way the EMA treat any authorising agency from other countries.

The EMA make the decisions on what vaccines should be used in the EU. They aren' tinvolved in deciding who should and shouldn;t be allowed into the EU based on which vaccines they have had. That is a policital decision.

The EU have made a decision that the only vaccines approved for people entering into the EU are those approved by the EMA. It's a public health decision. It applies to all vaccines not approved by the EMA. Why would one third country's approval process be treated any differently that of another third country?
Belladonna12 · 06/07/2021 10:06

Same way the EMA treat any authorising agency from other countries.

The EMA make the decisions on what vaccines should be used in the EU. They aren' tinvolved in deciding who should and shouldn;t be allowed into the EU based on which vaccines they have had. That is a policital decision.

Belladonna12 · 06/07/2021 10:02

@OchonAgusOchonOh

The standards in the EU member standards aren't superior to other licensing authority standards and the MHRA certainly won't have dropped their standards since leaving the EU. The EMA was in London until a couple of years ago and the two agencies employed many of the same people.

It doesn't matter whether standards have dropped or diverged. The point is that, as a third country, they can diverge so are treated differently. Same way the EMA treat any authorising agency from other countries.

The fact that they could diverge is not relevant if they haven't! The processes used are not a secret; they are fully published and if a country's licensing authority has the same standards or higher than those of the EMA it is ridiculous to not let those who have been vaccinated with vaccines that have been authorised by them into an EU country.