Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - Princess Diana new statue

788 replies

ForeverAintEnough3 · 01/07/2021 15:31

She was a style icon yet she’s in one of those frumpy waist belts that were only in fashion briefly. The face does nothing to represent how beautiful she was. It’s too harsh.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
29
Frankieirish · 02/07/2021 18:37

What is all this deification of Diana? Yes, it's sad that a young mother died so tragically, but so many young mothers that I know of have died, tragically, since her passing - cancer (I know two who are currently fighting for life) and other causes. Get hold of a back copy of Private Eye, covering the death - and mass hysteria that followed, they do a before- after page of 'journalists'(sic) comments, example - a week before her passing: "who is this spoilt mannequin, destroying our previous royal family (I'm paraphrasing here, but you get the gist) - a week later, same scribe: " the heavens have gained a new star"
If we want to celebrate 'saints', let's put statues up to those selfless people often with very little themselves, who run food banks (I doubt the princess ever went hungry) or are poorly paid carers - I know one, and what she does daily...with a smile. The statue is a waste of money

MarshaBradyo · 02/07/2021 18:37

@LalalalalalaLand123

It is (sadly) truly awful, in so many ways. Giant shoulders and chest, very masculine, doesn't look like Diana at all. Very hard facial expression, no hint of a smile. As one reviewer said, there's something very Soviet about it. To me it just doesn't evoke Diana in any way. I agree with PP who would have used her land mine outfit. But after the disaster with Maggi Hambling's hideous nude statute in memory of Mary Wollstonecraft, I guess I should just be glad that Diana's statue has been given clothes.
Just looked at the Hambling sculpture. She gets a lot of gigs considering

What an odd form

peppermintpat · 02/07/2021 18:37

I like it. Don't love it but it's ok. Not sure I would have bothered with a statue at all but a nice painting.

Victoria319 · 02/07/2021 18:36

I don't think it's especially flattering. But I don't think the medium helps. Is it Bronze? I always thinks that looks hard, usually with sharp edges etc, I think it's the way it's cast.
I think something stone or marble that could be carved and smoothed would have better caught her likeness and also her nature, rather than the sort of dark, spikiness of this offering.

And I don't understand the children. Is it meant to be Harry and William or not? If it is then it doesn't look like them!! And if it's the 'world's children' then there should have been more, and different heights/ages, to represent that.
And her clothes! It can't have been easy to cast those clothes, with the collar, and the pleats, and that belt... but it's just... I don't think I've ever seen a photo of her wearing something like that. And it seems like they spent more effort on the clothes than they did on her face or hair!!

And people saying that it's 3D and it's hard to model a face from photos etc. It's not, not nowadays, madame tussards can and do make waxworks without people having castings (can you imagine the Queen having that goop poured all over her for instance?) and must do so from photographs. I'm sure there are enough photographs of Diana out there, a decent computer whizz with a 3D modelling programme... could have blooming 3D printed a better likeness....

I'm glad Harry and William came together to reveal it. But I think the statue has missed the mark rather.
Just my opinion obviously, and I'm quite sure Harry and William wouldn't have signed off on something they weren't happy with, so they must be, and that's all that really matters. They're the only two people whose opinion actually matters here, really.

But no, you're not being unreasonable! X

LalalalalalaLand123 · 02/07/2021 18:35

It is (sadly) truly awful, in so many ways. Giant shoulders and chest, very masculine, doesn't look like Diana at all. Very hard facial expression, no hint of a smile. As one reviewer said, there's something very Soviet about it. To me it just doesn't evoke Diana in any way.
I agree with PP who would have used her land mine outfit.
But after the disaster with Maggi Hambling's hideous nude statute in memory of Mary Wollstonecraft, I guess I should just be glad that Diana's statue has been given clothes.

Toddlerteaplease · 02/07/2021 18:31

@stairway

I would have put her in that land mine outfit she famously war.
I thought that was what it was at first. Then realised it wasn't.
Passenger42 · 02/07/2021 18:29

Someone on Facebook commented that it looked like Claire Balding which made me Lol 😂

Diverseopinions · 02/07/2021 18:29

It's possible that the Princes, or one of them, suggested alterations and contributed to the vision, after the plans had been formulated, and it was hard for the sculpture to do what was desired.

A straightforward, formal, official dress portrait in bronze is always going to be easiest. Elegant flowing garments. Well, the above applies to representational sculpture. They could have commissioned something more abstract and modern ( like a Moore or Drink) and that might have captured the informal,
joyful and sunny presence of Diana in an amorphous way.

Confused0904 · 02/07/2021 18:28

Aahhh the subtle mumsnet racism!

Bard6817 · 02/07/2021 18:24

It’s rubbish. Doesn’t really look like her, and as for the two random kids, is a bit insensitive to her actual kids who don’t feature.

Namechangerextraordinaire1 · 02/07/2021 18:21

I think it's fine personally. Looks fairly like her and her style. I am really surprised by how many agree with you actually!!

AliceLivesHere · 02/07/2021 18:17

I imagine her 2 sons approved it. Surely that's the important bit?

Bubbles90 · 02/07/2021 18:14

very underwhelming.

MumOfScience · 02/07/2021 18:10

Im going to focus on the positive symbolism of the statue - placed to remember someone who was loved in a place they loved, rather than what the face is like and what she’s wearing… She did so much for women - showing that we can be powerful and influential even in very male dominated political arenas. What she did to combat stigma during the AIDS crisis and in the battle against land mines was incredible. I know “no one is saying she wasn’t great” and I’ll get a pile on for being a “spoil sport” but maybe don’t degenerate the topic straight away - I’m certain the tabloids will do this for us (taking the focus away from her power and back into her looks - lest us other women are inspired by her and get ideas above our station).

the80sweregreat · 02/07/2021 18:10

I don't know that area of London : not been ' up town ' for years!
I've forgotten how many statues there are around : they must cost a fortune to make.

toffeebutterpopcorn · 02/07/2021 18:09

The garden was nice before - and quite quiet. I guess it will be busy with sightseers now.

the80sweregreat · 02/07/2021 18:07

At least the garden is nice where the statue is
The Manchester one needs Charlie Dimmock

Bebethany · 02/07/2021 18:06

Me too Thursdayweld, I think it’s really lovely.

I’m really wondering why most people don’t like it?

NeedNewKnees · 02/07/2021 18:05

I think it's a mawkish piece of crap!

Inexpertjuggler · 02/07/2021 18:02

I agree, she was a real beauty, it’s disappointing. Tbf, here’s the princess Diana Memorial in Manchester. It’s so shocking, it makes me think it was installed by someone toadying up to Charles at the time

AIBU - Princess Diana new statue
Blossomtoes · 02/07/2021 17:59

@stairway

The statue that briefly replaced the Colston statue was a lot better ( and cheaper)
And shorter lived.
stairway · 02/07/2021 17:58

The statue that briefly replaced the Colston statue was a lot better ( and cheaper)

speakout · 02/07/2021 17:55

Jacopo
There’s been comment in the press that there aren’t any good sculptors because the skills are no longer taught. That’s simply untrue.

I agree. I have been blown away by some modern sculpture artwork.
I woud have liked something a little more symbolic, still human form, but something that captured her essence rather than a 3d cardboard facimile cut out.

MarshaBradyo · 02/07/2021 17:48

@Jacopo

I have worked with bronze (on a much smaller scale). A few minor tweaks would have improved this sculpture. The belt has been positioned far too low, below the natural waistline, which is where women have worn them recently and where men usually wear them. In the nineties the bottom edge of the belt would have been on her natural waistline and you can see this in the original photo and in other photos of her wearing belts at that time. If the belt was correctly positioned the body/leg proportions would appear more accurate. The material is indeed bronze but the patina which has been applied is very heavy and dull in colour, making it almost leaden. It would have been better to go for a colour and finish that looked lighter and let the sun bounce around it a bit. The pose is very static. Having more movement in the feet, walking, even half running, would have given it much more life. If the children had to be in it ( I would have left them out) they could have been given much more movement too. Choosing a longer, flowing garment would have been another way to give the impression of movement. There’s been comment in the press that there aren’t any good sculptors because the skills are no longer taught. That’s simply untrue. There are plenty of sculptors who could have done a fine job of this, and even this sculptor has produced better and livelier work than this.
I just googled the sculptor as I’m interested in who it was.

I do find it interesting that it’s been roundly criticised - just read Guardian and a few other titles came up.

Would Harry and William have signed off the clay version do you think? I assume you can’t make changes after it’s cast in bronze

Pliudev · 02/07/2021 17:48

It's lumpen. Not a celebration of the woman or a likeness. Surely they could have found someone better? Though, having seen what Maggie Hambling made of Mary Wolstencroft, I wonder if statues are a good thing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread