Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be utterly shocked by the penalty charge notices I have received from Waltham Forest?

519 replies

libertybonds · 01/07/2021 11:37

I'm interested to know whether I am just a bad driver. I have received two penalty charge notices from Waltham Forest based on CCTV footage for the following 'offences.' I should mention that I don't know these roads and I was using satnav:

  1. I approached a large junction. Painted on the road was an indication that you could go left or straight. I mistakenly thought the bus lane was the left turn lane so I moved there to turn. There were no buses around, and in the footage it's clear that I moved to this lane just as I approached the junction. I'm 100% sure that after I turned left I realised my error and moved to the correct lane. Again, no buses anywhere in sight.
  1. I entered into a box junction behind a large vehicle. Traffic suddenly slowed and the tail end of my vehicle was in the junction. In the footage, you can actually see me move my vehicle into a lane that would take me in the wrong direction from where I wanted to go in order to move out of the box junction.

So, who is right? Me or Waltham Forest? Do I deserve to pay a combined £260 for these offences?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
TheReluctantPhoenix · 01/07/2021 13:40

Enforcement by camera is harsh, although ‘fair’ in the sense the cameras cannot be biased.

The bus lane offence seems pretty stupid and I have little sympathy (although it is annoying). Some box junctions, on the other hand, do seem designed to raise revenue rather than improve traffic flow, and I do think the penalty should only apply if you are actually obstructing.

There is one I know in London which is massive ans sandwiched between two lights. You either wait for it to be completely clear, by which time the lights have changed again, or go in the hope that you will glow through it. It is notorious as a revenue raiser.

Nocutenamesleft · 01/07/2021 13:39

You were in the wrong both times

Glad they’re finally picking up on this stuff

VerticalHorizon · 01/07/2021 13:39

*in, not it!

viques · 01/07/2021 13:39

A heads up to the OP, since they are not very clear about road markings. Watch out for motorcycle and bike boxes when approaching traffic lights that are on red. Many people don’t realise that stopping in them when the lights are red can also get you fined.

VerticalHorizon · 01/07/2021 13:38

So who did the car park belong to?

Not 100% sure, but they'd had prior agreement to use it.
I think the actual owners then brought it a private parking firm to run it (or parts of it). However, they clearly tried their look by fining all cars on the park that had been there prior to the signage going up.

It was resolved and they still use the same car park. It was the private company taking a liberty (I would guess it's worked for them in the past!)

ThePlantsitter · 01/07/2021 13:35

Which is worse @TastyTicklemore, the fine or the horrific feeling of everyone HATING you because you're holding them up? I once accidentally blocked four lanes of traffic and a bus lane (very bad error) and just sat there saying 'fuck fuck fuck fuck' and not making eye contact with anyone around me until it cleared. I would honestly have paid 75 quid instantly if it meant it all went away.

pussycatlickinglollyices · 01/07/2021 13:35

I have had a car since December and I haven't had any issues
You mean you haven't been stopped/fined for any other issues.
Do you have a UK license? The box junction one is a basic if you've done a UK test.

yourestandingonmyneck · 01/07/2021 13:35

@Killahangilion

Wow, that seems steep for making minor errors with road markings that didn’t lead to an accident.

In contrast:
Another parent driving to school hit me sending me flying. Ambulance was called etc.
I was about 100 yards from the same school she was driving to, walking my son. She cried to the judge (big heaving sobs) and got fined a paltry €100 for careless driving. I felt very ragey that day!

God that's awful
mag2305 · 01/07/2021 13:33

I've clocked up so many fines in London over the years so I feel you, but I got to realise that some of them are really there to catch people out and just generate money. I got caught out at a box junction in Highgate. When I looked into it, so many other people had too, to the point where that one junction alone had made £1 million in a year! How crazy is that!

Also left my car no more than 5 mins over the resident permit holders time in Chelsea one morning. I came outside to find my car had disappeared. It had been taken to a pound. I had to pay £350 for it's release!

I've just chalked it up as lessons learnt now. Annoying but not much you can always do.

DynamoKev · 01/07/2021 13:33

@VerticalHorizon

Not all fines are fair...

My son's firm used a car park freely for some time. One day, a private company turned up, and erected signage and decided to charge to park there. They issued everybody with PCN's.

Thankfully it was all caught on CCTV, and dropped with haste! CF's!

So who did the car park belong to?
godmum56 · 01/07/2021 13:33

[quote libertybonds]@godmum56 and yet I know for a fact that in NJ you would not have huge fines every time you made a mistake while adjusting to the different rules and conventions.[/quote]
I never found out because i never played silly devils whan I was driving. My point was that its no excuse to say "oh I am a good driver in xxx country" because you are NOT THERE.

TastyTicklemore · 01/07/2021 13:31

For me...

The bus lane will come down to whether or not there was adequate signage. All bus lanes I've seen have been very clear what they are through road makings - but I appreciate that might not be the case everywhere.

The box junction was a clear error. The offence is entering the box when the way out is not yet clear (apart from right turns). You entered when the way out was not clear but you thought it would be by the time you got to the other side - you gambled and lost.

Most of us have had fines (I've had one for a heavy traffic London box junction Grin). They sting, sometimes feel unfair but you rarely make the same mistake again, so...

ThePlantsitter · 01/07/2021 13:31

It happens OP.

Yes the fines are expensive and annoying and you might be right that it mirrors our generally unforgiving culture, although you will probably find we are forgiving in areas you don't anticipate like getting income tax bills wrong for example (not council tax though bloody hell never try to get out of paying that). You're going to have to suck it up but it's not a reflection of you as a driver really, it was a mistake. Maybe you will have to factor in some fines until you get used to it (and know where the cameras are!)

thedancingbear · 01/07/2021 13:30

You need to stay out of bus lanes and yellow boxes, OP. They're both there for a good reason - to help people get where they're going more quickly and safely.

How would you like to see these rules enforced, if not with fines?

Piglet89 · 01/07/2021 13:30

I live in next door Wanstead and avoid driving in Walthamstow and surrounds wherever possible - it's a total nightmare for motorists.

BronwenFrideswide · 01/07/2021 13:30

I didn't think I would be caught out by slow moving traffic and end up in the box junction. I didn't do it on purpose.

That's bad planning and anticipation on your part. Think ahead.

and yet I know for a fact that in NJ you would not have huge fines every time you made a mistake while adjusting to the different rules and conventions

and how do they know you are just adjusting to the different rules and conventions? Do you have a sign on your car to that effect? What other laws should that be applied to do you think?

VerticalHorizon · 01/07/2021 13:29

Not all fines are fair...

My son's firm used a car park freely for some time. One day, a private company turned up, and erected signage and decided to charge to park there. They issued everybody with PCN's.

Thankfully it was all caught on CCTV, and dropped with haste! CF's!

godmum56 · 01/07/2021 13:27

[quote libertybonds]@C8H10N4O2 I didn't think I would be caught out by slow moving traffic and end up in the box junction. I didn't do it on purpose.[/quote]
nobody does.....box junctions are easy...unless you are turning right and ONLY prevented by MOVING oncoming traffic then don't enter unless you can see room for your car on the other side. In slow moving traffic you should be more careful not less as you don't know if it will slow further or stop

Sirzy · 01/07/2021 13:27

Adjusting to different rules is irrelevant. You drive on the roads in a country you pay attention to the rules of the road.

Albien · 01/07/2021 13:26

Unfortunately you did commit the offences and the fines are steep to prevent you doing it again. I once paid to park in a bay and I got fined £75 because my bumper was overhanging the kerb by a couple of inches. They said I had only paid for the parking space within the lines and it wasn’t permitted to park over the kerb. Unfair perhaps? But I did position my car with the bumper over the kerb.

VerticalHorizon · 01/07/2021 13:25

I got a fine for crossing the line at a red light (to let an ambulance through!). I contacted them and they decided to let it go, although technically, I was still in the wrong.

libertybonds · 01/07/2021 13:24

@godmum56 and yet I know for a fact that in NJ you would not have huge fines every time you made a mistake while adjusting to the different rules and conventions.

OP posts:
BronwenFrideswide · 01/07/2021 13:23

[quote libertybonds]@Freckers both of these were accidental? I didn't think I would be caught out in the box thing. I sincerely didn't realise I was in a bus lane.

I'm a very experienced driver in another part of the world where slightly different traffic rules apply, and where there is no CCTV enforcement. Minor errors aren't fined like this unless someone causes an accident or a police officer sees you (though this probably wouldn't happen where there is a clearly unintentional mistake). Maybe it's the culture here - so strict and unforgiving.[/quote]
So what? You drive to the rules of the road of the country you are in.

VerticalHorizon · 01/07/2021 13:23

130 quid is a deterrent.
You've been very unlucky twice in a day, but it can happen.

I think most people get with a fine or two in their time, and mistakes will happen with learner drivers, or just complacency (something almost all of us are guilty of).

The fine is meant to hurt. It will sting most people for months and curtail you. It'll certainly make you take more notice of signs etc.

I absolutely do sympathise in cities, where town planners really do go a little crazy at times. Usually through evolution, road layouts get messier and messier until they reach a point where a total overhaul / redesign is needed... at some cost!

Chamonixshoopshoop · 01/07/2021 13:22

I think the Op is getting a hard time, I've traveled a few feet in a bus lane to turn at a junction before and I've ended up being a few feet in a box junction for 10 seconds or so before being able to move into another lane. I am a pretty good driver (17 years, no accidents) and I am considerate, we all sometimes make mistakes.
I find especially when driving around unfamiliar cities with quick decision making required!

Swipe left for the next trending thread