Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider Cry It Out?

180 replies

Schrutesbeets · 01/07/2021 10:58

DS is 9 months, has been BF and bed shared since birth, till arohnd 6 weeks ago. he sleeps in his cot for naps but won't at night. Have tried gentle methods, nothing is working and he wakes constantly through the night and wakes DD(3)too.
I was always very opposed to CIO, but I'm going back to work soon and cannot function on as little sleep as I'm having. I am run down, irritable and getting regular headaches as a result. We cannot afford a sleep consultant and now I feel CIO may be the only solution!
Any advice / experience of CIO much appreciated.

OP posts:
Schrutesbeets · 03/07/2021 09:42

@DrCAMHS

As other posters have said - not to question your credentials as such, but - how can you attribute the reason for their mental health concerns, down to sleep training?
Sleep training was so commonly used and advised by HVs and GPs, that surely statistically the chance of many of your service users having been sleep trained is fairly high. Does correlation prove causation?

And aside from the correlation, which only serves to make parents feel guilty, what advice do you give then to parents who are seriously suffering with THEIR mental health due to lack of sleep and chronic exhaustion?
What information have you got regarding the wellbeing of children raised by overworked, overstretched, and overtired parents? And how do you suggest solving that?
Thanks.

OP posts:
Chiwi · 03/07/2021 06:09

In my very healthy and well adjusted person clinic almost everyone has been sleep trained. 🙄

I'm sure there are absolutely no other factors that have lead to those children being in a CAMHS clinic. None at all. Just the sleep training.
(I work in CAMHS and I call bullshit!!!!)

propertealady · 02/07/2021 22:41

Absolute hero

Chicchicchicchiclana · 02/07/2021 22:26

I'm a giraffe with a degree in astro physics and a strong penchant for Tia Maria over ice. I'd like to ask Dr Cahms how they know that virtually all the children they see in clinic have been sleep trained. Is it a standard question on a form? What other questions do you ask?

Sometimeswinning · 02/07/2021 20:39

I did it with my second. He was 16 months. It worked. I dont regret it. It worked. Took 3 nights. I think I literally changed overnight on the 4th night when he slept. It worked out well for us. (He's 9 now. No sleep issues) Just monitor it. If you cant do it then dont. Good luck!

Sleeplessem · 02/07/2021 20:39

Just to further on from my comment @DrCAMHS, advice such as sleep when baby sleeps or co sleeping sometimes isn’t practical or safe (low birth weight/ prem for instance) and a lot of people don’t have a support network to lean on.

(Just to be clear this isn’t an attack on credentials or advice, i am genuinely curious as when DD was born she never settled unless held due to TT and I was on the verge of a breakdown after living on 2 hrs sleep a day for months )

Maggiesfarm · 02/07/2021 20:37

Thanks for your posts, DrCAMHS.

Sleeplessem · 02/07/2021 20:35

@DrCAMHS

And in response to the calls for peer reviewed papers on long term impact of CIO/CC - there aren’t any direct ones. Some might consider this a “win” for the pro-camp, but the reality is that an ethics board in today’s society would understandably never give authorisation for such a study to take place, for the simple reason that you would be assessing a potentially harmful practice to a child’s development. What clinicians and researchers in the field use, therefore, is the myriad of peer-reviewed studies in the areas of attachment (including the impact of neglect on the developing infant brain), neuro-physiology, neuro-development and child development to inform our practice and the development of our theoretical understanding in this area.
Completely get what you’re saying and it’s compelling, it’s why we didn’t sleep train BUT what about desperately sleep deprived parents, some of which might inadvertently resort to unsafe sleep practices out of exhaustion and simply just conking out.

What would you recommend instead?

DrCAMHS · 02/07/2021 20:31

And in response to the calls for peer reviewed papers on long term impact of CIO/CC - there aren’t any direct ones. Some might consider this a “win” for the pro-camp, but the reality is that an ethics board in today’s society would understandably never give authorisation for such a study to take place, for the simple reason that you would be assessing a potentially harmful practice to a child’s development. What clinicians and researchers in the field use, therefore, is the myriad of peer-reviewed studies in the areas of attachment (including the impact of neglect on the developing infant brain), neuro-physiology, neuro-development and child development to inform our practice and the development of our theoretical understanding in this area.

DrCAMHS · 02/07/2021 20:23

Child clinical psychologist here - please do not sleep train your baby (in any way). A child that young is not neurodevelopmentally ready to ‘self-soothe’ (this comes much later on in a child’s life) and the key to true self-regulation skills (and most importantly, healthy secure attachments) is consistent co-regulation by a safe adult. A child that age is not “greedy” for your attention, they will not “learn” to self-calm or that you will keep coming back. A child that age has no concept of time, or of making sense of their own internal distress. On the contrary, prolonged parental absence and poor attunement at times of distress at this age (including via regular ‘check ins’), leads to a deactivation of natural attachment behaviour - the baby will give up calling for you (they will stop crying), they may even sleep from exhaustion, but their ability feel truly calm will be missing. Blood tests prove this. I rarely come across a child in my clinic now who was not sleep trained.

LemonRoses · 02/07/2021 20:15

@mn2022

research actually disagrees and shows opposite.

Sorry but what a load of bollocks.

There is an abundance of research both supporting and against CIO, you don't just pick and choose which sort you want to highlight,

I’m afraid you’re wrong. There is no research that shows long term harm. Unless you can point towards it?
Sleeplessem · 02/07/2021 16:35

I’ve read depending on age, controlled crying can actually distress them even more. This held true for DD around this sort of age, her sleep was awful around 10 months. I was very against any sort of cio but in desperation tried modified Ferber and it was awful and she’d get more distressed from our presence going in and then walking out.

What did work for us was bedding in and hand holding but appreciate that’s not for everyone. I also pumped for night feeds, once at her bed time and then at mine to ensure it wasn’t pure hunger causing the waking.

This worked up until a point and then anything we did distressed her, any sort of contact and hand holding that used to sooth her just made her scream. One time we waited 5 mins to give her chance to settle and she did and slept through ever since. Probably should have given her chance to settle before. But I think they call that method extinction. It’s not what we intentionally used. But I’ve read it tends to work better than Ferber for older babies xx

mn2022 · 02/07/2021 16:20

@memberofthewedding

When I was a kid in the 1940s children were commonly left to CIO. We still grew up!
'growing up' is the bare minimum expected.

Please don't act as if simply surviving into adulthood is the best you can do.

memberofthewedding · 02/07/2021 16:16

When I was a kid in the 1940s children were commonly left to CIO. We still grew up!

mn2022 · 02/07/2021 16:13

@Maggiesfarm

I cannot in a million years imagine leaving a baby crying for two hours.
How wonderful.

Maybe you should work on your empathy skills?

Charbead49 · 02/07/2021 16:10

So you are going from nursing to sleep to CIO. I can't imagine a less gentle thing to do. 3 DC under 4 here and it's tough and the modern world certainly doesn't support babies being dependant on mums however I don't think you have tried everything.

Have you looked into night weaning? Reducing time on breast etc. Then there is breaking the feed to sleep association - I did this with DS2 when she was about 10 months in a gentle way and used the time for a different connection.

Also as you suggest, hubby needs to get involved. It's not easy on parents but I works seriously think about the impact and break in trust with your DC with CIO.

Maggiesfarm · 02/07/2021 15:51

I cannot in a million years imagine leaving a baby crying for two hours.

mn2022 · 02/07/2021 13:21

research actually disagrees and shows opposite.

Sorry but what a load of bollocks.

There is an abundance of research both supporting and against CIO, you don't just pick and choose which sort you want to highlight,

Schrutesbeets · 02/07/2021 09:07

@propertealady

We did CIO with my first child, at six months. I'd tried Ferber, which just riled him up. It took three nights. On the worst night he cried for 2 hours. Dons shield He was almost instantly a happier baby. He'd smile when I put him down to bed. And 3 years on he's still a happy, well adjusted toddler with good sleep habits. Google Professor Emily Oster and her thoughts on sleep training - a lot of the "research" was done in extreme conditions like Romanian orphanages or clinical settings where children would obviously be more distressed than in a loving home environment.
Ah that's really interesting, I'll be sure to read up on that. And as I'd thought - I wondered what the other factors in those children's lives were and how they could deduce it was specifically down to being left to cry. Thanks for sending that.
OP posts:
propertealady · 02/07/2021 09:03

We did CIO with my first child, at six months. I'd tried Ferber, which just riled him up. It took three nights. On the worst night he cried for 2 hours. Dons shield
He was almost instantly a happier baby. He'd smile when I put him down to bed. And 3 years on he's still a happy, well adjusted toddler with good sleep habits. Google Professor Emily Oster and her thoughts on sleep training - a lot of the "research" was done in extreme conditions like Romanian orphanages or clinical settings where children would obviously be more distressed than in a loving home environment.

LemonRoses · 02/07/2021 07:42

Lifesaving and marriage saving. I haven’t read all the comments because there will be those saying it’s cruel and damaging- research actually disagrees and shows opposite.

Sleep deprivation is much, much more damaging to everyone. Our life was transformed by sleep training. It’s hard to do, it needs a strong nerve, but only for three or four days usually.

It has long term benefits too.

Schrutesbeets · 02/07/2021 07:23

Unlatches *

OP posts:
Schrutesbeets · 02/07/2021 07:22

This isn't right, that's an excessive amount of waking and i think you you should look into if there's any issues.

Hi olderthanyouthink!
I know it sohnds like there's probably something going on, but it's because he's so used to being latched on, and then when he inevitably falls asleep and I latches, he wakes and it starts again. I will be following the advice of night weaning and then CC using the Ferber Method I think!
Thanks so much for those links, I really appreciate it.

OP posts:
midsummerflowers · 02/07/2021 07:20

I had a really awful day with ds when he was about four months. We were due to go on holiday but OH was farting about so we were trapped in the house. Ds was desperate for sleep but wouldn’t and was frantic with exhaustion. I was so fraught and upset I ended up putting him in a basket in another room while I calmed down and dried my hair (hadn’t even been able to get ready!) and when I checked on him he’d fallen asleep.

But it wasn’t settled sleep. He was still sobbing Sad crying slightly in his sleep, hiccuping. He just looked so small and defeated somehow. And he woke ten minutes later anyway. So it wouldn’t be for me.

With that being said I do sympathise op and I do wish I had a suggestion for you because mine is unsettled at the moment (teeth) and it’s a nightmare.

One thing I would say is he gets two good chunks of sleep in the day and is in bed at 7. While cutting back the naps help?

olderthanyouthink · 02/07/2021 07:07

"My son wakes every 20-30 and even in between is either actively suckling, or restless."

This isn't right, that's an excessive amount of waking and i think you you should look into if there's any issues.

For DD her breathing isn't right, she breaths through her mouth, we saw a dr and the latest theory is somethings up with her tonsils or adenoids... waiting to see someone about that. At her worst she was waking every 45/60 mins at 2! She's started grinding her teeth and sleeping better but that's not great either.

When I was trying to figure out wtf was going on I found this test through Beyond the Sleep Training Project and it suggested possible issues and I spoke with the Woman behind it (she's a whole lot more qualified than most sleep trainers) who gave me some direction.

evolutionaryparenting.com/test/bitss/

evolutionaryparenting.com/about/