Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider Cry It Out?

180 replies

Schrutesbeets · 01/07/2021 10:58

DS is 9 months, has been BF and bed shared since birth, till arohnd 6 weeks ago. he sleeps in his cot for naps but won't at night. Have tried gentle methods, nothing is working and he wakes constantly through the night and wakes DD(3)too.
I was always very opposed to CIO, but I'm going back to work soon and cannot function on as little sleep as I'm having. I am run down, irritable and getting regular headaches as a result. We cannot afford a sleep consultant and now I feel CIO may be the only solution!
Any advice / experience of CIO much appreciated.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
edenhills · 26/02/2022 07:57

We did cry it out with twins at 9 months. We were desperate. It worked, took two nights and they have been great sleepers ever since. I know people think it's cruel but we couldn't parent on no sleep. They are currently 12 and do not seem to have any lasting effects.

CityMumma78 · 26/02/2022 07:34

Controlled crying does work but requires perseverance. Your little one doesn’t know how to self soothe because they have been in bed with you since birth. Break this dependency and stick with controlled crying.

SamuraiPizzaCats · 25/02/2022 20:30

I haven't had time to read all the comments but I just wanted to drop two recommendations in car they haven't been mentioned.

The Baby Sleep Expert - so much free advice online www.instagram.com/babysleepdr/?hl=en

And Charmian Mead's book The Sleeping Baby Routine.

It's probably going to take more of a lifestyle change than a quick fix but I'm sure you know that already!

gingerbiscuits · 25/02/2022 10:41

We tried a sort of controlled, separation crying with our son & I'm not gonna lie... it was the hardest thing I've ever done! But it did work & he's now a strapping 14yr old who sleeps through anything!

We went all in with music/white noise/a cuddle cloth smelling of me etc & started off by first soothing him, lying him back down & then sleeping (attempting to!) on a mattress (which we bought especially - tried an airbed but it crippled me!) on the floor next to his cot. Then we moved to sitting next to the cot, with a hand through the bars if necessary, with the aim of leaving once he'd fallen back to sleep. Then moved on to sitting increasingly further away & no touching. Eventually, a quick soothe & leaving the room altogether. Re-entering after an increasing number of minutes to repeat over & over.

It took a few weeks to move through the stages & almost broke me at times, as he was (& still is!) a very stubborn, persistent little bugger, but it did work eventually & he certainly couldn't remember the whole experience & it definitely didn't 'scar' him in any way.

To be honest, you need to try various different things & do whatever works best for you & your family - regardless of what people say/think. SO many people told us we should/shouldn't be doing this & that, but at 3am when you're beyond exhausted & sobbing yourself, they can all eff off!! You do what you need to, to get through it!!

Good luck. You will crack it & come out the other side. I promise.

Volhhg · 24/02/2022 16:33

Put aside the judgement people make about parents who decide to try this and forget about the contraversy. For the majority of parents I know who tried this CIO method it didn't work for them and yes they did do it properly. The one I know who it did work for had really easy babies anyway and I question whether these babies would have slept well anyway and that they didn't truly have to use this method. You have to face the fact that this probably wont work for your baby no matter how hard you try and at the end of it you will carry around the guilt (although I don't believe you should). I think having babies/kids just unfortunately involves sleep deprivation and unusual sleeping arrangements for all unless you happen to have other family living with you helping out.

Rdsdadmum · 24/02/2022 16:21

My post is not directly aimed at the person who created this thread. It's more aimed at the judgemental people that are pointing the finger at others claiming they are bad parents for allowing their child to cry it out. Ultimately everyone does what they feel is best for their kids and that doesn't mean to say that will be right from one family to the next. One hat does not fit all. Sometimes putting yourself first is putting your chuld first and sleep is probably the most important factor in that scenario. It's being cruel to be kind but as I said in my previous post, help your child and yourself right from the start and don't allow it to progress to this in the first place.

Rdsdadmum · 24/02/2022 16:14

Literally no evidence to suggest that this causes harm to children. I used CIO with both my girls and it wasn't hard for anyone concerned. I believe the reason why it was soo seemless for us was because we didn't do co-sleeping, after a feed both girls would fall asleep and were put straight into their moses basket right from an early age. If you set the tone with your children early there is no stress for either party. Ultimately you should know the difference between baby cries, I'm hungry to I'm in pain to I want some attention and you react accordingly. There are parents out there that will do everything with their baby including sleep and then wonder why baby is under soo much stress when you try and change that routine when they have to go back to work, so yes it's cruel to let your child cry it out because now they cannot understand why things are different from before. Start the process right from day one, we all love our children and would love to hold them all day but IMO this is a selfish act that sets up your child for heartache going forward. When babies are born they are a 'blank canvas' and will look to their parents to soak up as much as they can, are children born clingy? I don't think so I believe this is a learnt behaviour. My eldest daughter whose now 10 never had a dummy growing up and never longed for one, she would see other children with dummies but still never longed for one and the reason being is because we never introduced that into her life, so ultimately she never went through a painful weaning process and us as parents didn't have to suffer through that either. Children are conditioned to what you have introduced them to at the end of the day, so when we're all loving the baby and passing it round like a joint at summer camp ask yourselves is this what the baby needs or is it for your own selfish wants? Babies are born and they eventually grow to live in the big wide world where they will need to be
independent and make decisions without their mum or dad so why do we insist on doing things that are going to have the opposite effect of that and then stress and worry about why your child is soo needy and clingy all the time. There's more to caring for a baby than the immediate we have to look at the bigger picture and do what's best for our children in the long run. Just so people know I do hug and love my children so they know they are loved, my youngest daughter is starting to say words now and I love you is very much a part of her vocabulary but she isn't needy and will go to bed without much fuss at all. Which proves to me that I don't need my child to be hanging on my hip all day long for her to know that she is loved and cared for and she certainly doesn't need to sleep with me and mum either.

For me it's quite simple if you allow a dog to climb on the sofa on a regular basis and then one day don't allow it how do you think it's going to pan out? Again, set the tone early don't make your baby suffer because you feel that's what your baby wants or more to the point because it's what you want, you are setting them up to fail and that is what is cruel.

Thehop · 13/07/2021 13:29

Sorry I didn’t read the full thread, really pleased it was what you wanted and worked for your family.

Thehop · 13/07/2021 13:28

It’s good for some, not others.

I would suggest you google the negative effects before you decide if it’s for you, though, go into it with all the facts.

MonkeyPuddle · 13/07/2021 13:27

Ah I’m so pleased for you OP! It’s such an improvement! Me and DP started being so much nicer to each other with more sleep under our belts!

MaMaD1990 · 13/07/2021 08:24

Congratulations! You must feel on top of the world right now!

Whogotdakeystomabeamer · 13/07/2021 08:14

@JaniieJones

Brilliant news op! it'll be encouragement to those traipsing across the landing every hour to a toddler (like we used to do!).

Parents need to bite the bullet knowing breaking the crying habit is vital for everyone's health and well being.

Thank you! I really never ever believed that it would work - like some of the other posters, I really thought sleep training would be cruel, weeks of screaming, and then sleep by submission. The longest he has been even slightly upset for, is 3 minutes. THREE MINUTES. And I have just had a full night's sleep for the first time in 10 months. And all it took was 3 minutes. I wish I'd known this with DD who was a terrible sleeper for years. I'm amazed!
SueSaid · 13/07/2021 08:06

Brilliant news op! it'll be encouragement to those traipsing across the landing every hour to a toddler (like we used to do!).

Parents need to bite the bullet knowing breaking the crying habit is vital for everyone's health and well being.

Schrutesbeets · 13/07/2021 06:45

Last night (night 3) update...

Bath, books, feed, and song with DS/DD.

Took DS into his room, kisses, cuddles, little song.

Put in cot awake, left the room... NOTHING! Not one. Single. Peep. I even went and sat in my bedroom, fully expecting to have to go in at least once.

He's still asleep now.

I CANNOT BELIEVE IT!!!!!!

OP posts:
NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 12/07/2021 15:31

Btw op, re sleep training generally, I and most of my friends and relations were sleep trained as children, and not in the "gentle" way either. I'm from a happy home with loving parents, and I have a great relationship with them and no issues at all with attachment/relationship forming. I have no mental healthy or anxiety issues at all and sleep well.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 12/07/2021 15:20

Can you maybe start by reducing the reliance on nipple in mouth to sleep, without going full hog to CIO?

I would start by rocking and patting etc but not offering the breast constantly (you might need to involve your DH). He will cry if he is very in the habit of sucking, but you could use a dummy if you wanted and the point is you will be there to comfort him. Once you break the association of wanting to bf constantly to sleep, you will find it's a much smaller leap to get them sleeping longer chunks without input from you.

MyFartWillGoOn · 12/07/2021 14:30

Well done OP, you've handled this thread and some of the relies with grace.

So pleased you have found a method that works for you and DS

We did similar with mine at 7 months and used the same method. Overnight he went from being a tired, irritable baby as he was constantly waking, to a happy, content boy.

SueSaid · 12/07/2021 14:21

'I'm not saying leaving a child sobbing for hours on end would be the same, but what I've done has been incredibly gentle, and moreover ITS WORKED'

Well done op. It is hard but it needs doing. Honestly people that think tending to their toddler every hour overnight is normal or healthy are deluded. They need to sleep, we need to sleep.

Schrutesbeets · 12/07/2021 13:25

As someone that previously felt a lot of what some of you are saying (that is just simply "bad" to sleep train), I can tell you that there is no way my son has learnt that I don't respond to him being left for 3 minutes on his own. No way.
Since Saturday night, the longest he has been upset was for 3 minutes, and the most I've gone in is 3 times so that's only 3 x 3mins of crying (not screaming or bawling). And I greet him with cuddles and kisses then just put him down again.
Thankfully he has just rolled over and gone to sleep after that.
I've just put him down for his nap, he got upset when I initially left the room, so I started the 3 minute timer and before it had even been 60 seconds he'd rolled over and gone to sleep.
I can categorically say there has not been any trauma caused, I am rested and over the moon, so I'm way more engaged and patient with both children in the day.
I'm not saying leaving a child sobbing for hours on end would be the same, but what I've done has been incredibly gentle, and moreover ITS WORKED.
I couldn't be happier and less worried about the outcome.
Thabsk again for all the support from all.

OP posts:
georgarina · 12/07/2021 12:06

Yes in terms of attachment if they learn that you don't come when they cry, they stop trying to tell you when they wake up. This kind of parenting, done consistently not as a one off on a bad day, leads to insecure avoidant attachment and a host of emotional difficulties and relationship struggles in adulthood.

Sleep training doesn't cause avoidant attachment. Sleep trained babies still cry for their parents and are soothed by their presence. Avoidant/insecure attachment comes from an unstable/inconsistent parenting figure that results in longterm fear and uncertainty in the child and has obvious symptoms, like not seeking help from the parent or going to the parent for comfort but then shying away. If this was happening to sleep trained babies it would be well known.

The scaremongering is ridiculous and inaccurate.

caringcarer · 12/07/2021 12:06

Too late now I know but always best to put them in cot from day 1. In same room as you at first. Then move into their own room when they drop night feed. You can check them on the monitor. I never took babies into our bed except to feed the quick nappy change and back in cot often all done in the dark as lights on just wakes them up too much.

You can introduce controlled crying but it will be hard for you to bear if they cry a lot. It has to be done at some time though to get them into their cot so probably easier sooner rather than later. Just keep a careful eye on the monitor. Don't give in though it just drags it all out for much much longer. Some parents keep giving in as they can't stand to hear their baby crying so much, but it just makes it harder for baby as getting mixed messages. After 5-7 days baby should have learned to sleep in cot. I put all of my children in cot to sleep everyday for proper nap after lunch unless we were out and then they had to nap in pram. I know fashions change but all of my children were no trouble at all for sleeping because they got into routine early so knew no other way. My children all grown up now but my dd has used this routine with her children and been successful and she has friends who started cuddling baby to sleep and then struggled to get them to sleep in cot later.

TheSlayer · 12/07/2021 11:51

We've been pushed to the absolute limit 2 hourly waking minimum for 16 months. Right now l am trying three minutes out, like the op, then in till he's comforted then out 3 minutes etc. It's not working please help.
Fyi I already co sleep, cuddle him every time he cries so you can't say I have not given it a good go. 16 months of sleep no longer than an hour by the time I have drifted off. It's not right. All my NCT group babies slept through from six months. I'm fucking tired.

5475878237NC · 12/07/2021 11:45

Yes in terms of attachment if they learn that you don't come when they cry, they stop trying to tell you when they wake up. This kind of parenting, done consistently not as a one off on a bad day, leads to insecure avoidant attachment and a host of emotional difficulties and relationship struggles in adulthood.

SueSaid · 12/07/2021 11:38

'They just don't alert their parents when they wake.'

That's kind of the point. As a pp said, everyone has cycles and wakes then goes off to sleep again. Dc need to learn to self soothe and as parent it is our job to help them do that. Rocking, feeding and constantly faffing on with them perpetuates the problem.

Our youngest dc would still cry for us if there was a problem, if they felt ill or whatever but not just because they'd woken and didn't know how to get back to sleep without parental enforced rituals.

Chiwi · 12/07/2021 11:27

@ThirdElephant I would be interested to see those studies and the sample size etc. I did gentle sleep training with her, she is 18 months and has been going to bed at 7, self settling for roughly 6 months. I watch her on the monitor fall to sleep in less than 2 minutes pretty much every night. If I go to bed at midnight I can watch her solidly sleeping from 7-12 and then she very loudly alerts us at 6/7am when she wakes up. So yeah, I don't believe she gets less sleep when she was crying an insisting on feeding to get back to sleep every 2 hours and sometimes taking an hour to fall to sleep. Also if she is unwell, she very loudly lets us know she isn't asleep and can't settle herself. Maybe it's just her, but I doubt it.

Just saying 'studies' is not the same as actual evidence.