Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is the Methodist Church right to allow same sex marriage? And what does this mean for C of E and Catholic Church?

229 replies

Notfeelingsopeachyandkeennow · 30/06/2021 16:15

Personally, I am very pro this and think its about time!

I have just read that the Methodist Church is the 4th largest Christian denomination in Britain.

So - do you think that the Catholic Church and Church of England will inevitably follow suit at some point in time - even if that's still 50 years away?

And are you in favour of these changes?

OP posts:
VerticalHorizon · 30/06/2021 20:26

@Knitwit99

I would not say homosexuality was condemned - nobody stood in a pulpit proclaiming it to be the work of the devil, but it wasn't embraced either. As with most churches, things are hush hush, or passively frowned upon

I think that was the case in much of society until fairly recently, not just church.

I remember leaving church one Sunday after a sermon about accepting homosexuality. One elderly man spoke to me later when we were having coffee and I'll never forget it. He said "Do you honestly accept people being gay?" and I said yes, it doesn't bother me at all. He said he was envious of me and he wanted to feel the same, but his whole life everyone had told him it was terribly wrong. Family, friends, church, school, the law, workmates, everyone. People could be and were jailed within his lifetime, being gay was seen as a depraved thing. And now in his 80s he was being told it was actually okay and he was finding it really hard to change his viewpoint. I felt for him. That conversation has made me more patient with people who are slow to accept change. When you've been conditioned one way all your life it is hard to change as quickly as society is changing around you. So long as there is a willingness and an open-mindedness around it I am happy to give people time (maybe I would be less patient if I was gay).

Absolutely. It was illegal until 1967, and even then, it discriminated on age (arguably for good reasons, but still).

I think this is where the church is still at. More and more people have come to terms with it (secular or otherwise), but for churchgoers, it's more difficult, because of all the past teachings - either explicit condemnation, or implied.

Again, the explicit condemnation was never 'they'll all burn in hell!', but it was clear 'man shall not sleep with man' etc, and that was enough to spell it out as 'wrong'. There was no real discussion of the interpretation of that, at least not until the late 80;s when people felt a need to start looking at how to get out around that interpretation.

For me, the Church is still playing that game, perhaps not purposely, but subliminally... how can we reinterpret it in a way what works, without making our previous interpretation look wrong?

Knitwit99 · 30/06/2021 20:07

I would not say homosexuality was condemned - nobody stood in a pulpit proclaiming it to be the work of the devil, but it wasn't embraced either. As with most churches, things are hush hush, or passively frowned upon

I think that was the case in much of society until fairly recently, not just church.

I remember leaving church one Sunday after a sermon about accepting homosexuality. One elderly man spoke to me later when we were having coffee and I'll never forget it. He said "Do you honestly accept people being gay?" and I said yes, it doesn't bother me at all. He said he was envious of me and he wanted to feel the same, but his whole life everyone had told him it was terribly wrong. Family, friends, church, school, the law, workmates, everyone. People could be and were jailed within his lifetime, being gay was seen as a depraved thing. And now in his 80s he was being told it was actually okay and he was finding it really hard to change his viewpoint. I felt for him. That conversation has made me more patient with people who are slow to accept change. When you've been conditioned one way all your life it is hard to change as quickly as society is changing around you. So long as there is a willingness and an open-mindedness around it I am happy to give people time (maybe I would be less patient if I was gay).

BlackLambAndGreyFalcon · 30/06/2021 20:02

I am a practicing Anglican and a PCC member at my local church. I'm strongly in support of the decision taken by the Methodist Church, but unfortunately I can't see the C of E changing any time soon.

There is a "review" for want of a better word going on at the moment called "Living in Life and Faith", however the sub-title is "Christian teaching and learning about identity, sexuality, relationships and marriage" - the word order there is very telling!

SenecaFallsRedux · 30/06/2021 19:56

@VeryQuaintIrene

Some of the Anglican communion like the Episcopalians are already OK with same-sex marriagem, so I reckon it's just a matter of time. At least, I hope so.
The Episcopal Church in the US, which is part of the Anglican Communion, voted in 2015 to allow same sex marriage and to change the marriage liturgy to reflect that.
Viviennemary · 30/06/2021 19:55

I wasn't meaning siblings were allowed to marry. Shock I was meaning the laws regarding inheritance tax. Giving the two sisters rights as regards inheritance tax.

VerticalHorizon · 30/06/2021 19:55

The Catholic Church used to condemn loans with interest.
I don't think that's the case now.

It also didn't condemn slavery. It does now.

Admittedly, something as fundamental as sexuality is a lot harder to change stance on, but it's still possible, in time.

The eternal law of God is a bit of a bugger though (pardon my French!)

peachyandkeen · 30/06/2021 19:52

@JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn

The Catholic Church doesn't allow its priests to get married there's no way they'll allow same sex marriages.
It'll become a case of adapt or die out eventually - even if that's in 500 years time. As the world liberalises the congregation will simply fall away if they don't 'get with the programme'
Dignityandworth · 30/06/2021 19:52

@YoungestSpinster

Our local cofe school is ok with same sex marriage and has had a few ceremonies. Only the most recent vicar though, the one before him wouldn't do it.
Then he/she is actually doing these against CofE regulations and could be suspended or removed from ministry if reported. The CofE does not even allow blessings of same sex marriages. You can say a special prayer for them but that's it. I'm sure many CofE vicars do surreptitious blessings though, given almost 50% voted that they wanted to be able to do that.
VerticalHorizon · 30/06/2021 19:52

@Bumblenums1234

I can't see the Roman Catholic Church ever recognising gay marriage. If they do not belive it is right, and they seem to strongly believe this, then they aren't going to change just becuase another church has.

Why would someone want to marry in an institution that has scorned their lifestyle and the love they share with their partner since creation?

Tricky one that, but it happens. Some folks are brought up in a certain religion or denomination and possibly commit to it before they realise they are gay, or because in their heart of hearts, they want their church to accept them and keep holding out for the day it does.

Sometimes a person's local church (friends and community) are accepting, but 'The Church' isn't. So people can still wish to be married in their local church amongst friends, and simply feel condemned by The Church, not their actual one.

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 30/06/2021 19:48

The Catholic Church doesn't allow its priests to get married there's no way they'll allow same sex marriages.

Bumblenums1234 · 30/06/2021 19:47

I can't see the Roman Catholic Church ever recognising gay marriage. If they do not belive it is right, and they seem to strongly believe this, then they aren't going to change just becuase another church has.

Why would someone want to marry in an institution that has scorned their lifestyle and the love they share with their partner since creation?

YoungestSpinster · 30/06/2021 19:44

*cofe school and church.

YoungestSpinster · 30/06/2021 19:44

Our local cofe school is ok with same sex marriage and has had a few ceremonies. Only the most recent vicar though, the one before him wouldn't do it.

VerticalHorizon · 30/06/2021 19:43

Would it be terribly inappropriate for me to hand a bottle of communion wine around?

When I say communion wine, it's a 10.99 best buy from Tesco. But it's the sentiment that counts!

MrsFin · 30/06/2021 19:43

@Viviennemary

Yes. I read ages ago about two elderly sisters who lived in a property worth a lot. When one died it would have to be sold to pay the inheritance tax and the surviving sister would lose her home. Don't know if the law has changed since.
That's what I was getting at. I'd read about something similar. Doesn't seem fair that two friends could claim to be in a relationship and marry for financial reasons, but two family members can't.
peachyandkeen · 30/06/2021 19:30

@LibertyMole

‘Arguably friends too - or anyone that has built a life together where there is this kind of financial intertwining and dependency upon one another.’

Yes absolutely. Civil partnership should be available to any two adults.

Strongly agree.
VerticalHorizon · 30/06/2021 19:27

*Where? I was brought up as a Primitive Methodist fgs (and after c. 1965 a Methodist), and never heard anything homophobic or detrimental towards homosexual/gay people ever. And I attended a lot of church and church stuff.

In fact I would credit my Methodist ministers for my liberal attitudes.

Sorry your church/minister was so awful.*

Well, I'm not a churchgoer, but I was when I was much younger.
I attended a very popular progressive Methodist church and most of the congregation enjoyed a tipple!.

I would not say homosexuality was condemned - nobody stood in a pulpit proclaiming it to be the work of the devil, but it wasn't embraced either. As with most churches, things are hush hush, or passively frowned upon.
Gay ministers didn't exist (not officially at least), and whilst anybody gay was never condemned, the act of homosexuality was. It was considered wrong. This was from the 1970's right up until early 90's when the general change in public perception of homosexuality also started to change.

Let's not forget, 'Queer bashing' was common place in the 80's. The 'gay plague' was not an uncommon term. A great number of folks in the UK had little problem with homophobia, so it was not particularly controversial for the church to poo-poo it either.

In my view, churches are still very uncomfortable with it. It still causes divide. However, they've had to be politically astute and not be seen to condemn it. Some churches have accepted it (I'd be reluctant to say embraced it). Others have tolerated it. And others have tried to find ways to acknowledge it, in part, without ever actually declaring it 100% valid in God's eyes - most likely because there are still significant numbers of the congregation who aren't sure and struggle with it. I think many 'want' to accept it, but because it goes against what they've been traditional taught through scripture, it causes internal conflict within themselves.

'Marriage is the union between man and woman'. The implication has always been that that marriage cannot exist in any other form (without saying it). Now it can. And that messes with the heads of almost all Churches (imo)

LibertyMole · 30/06/2021 19:26

‘Arguably friends too - or anyone that has built a life together where there is this kind of financial intertwining and dependency upon one another.’

Yes absolutely. Civil partnership should be available to any two adults.

NiceGerbil · 30/06/2021 19:26

C of E yes will follow but no idea on timescale

RC no way whatsoever

peachyandkeen · 30/06/2021 19:23

@Knitwit99

Yes it's right that the Methodist Church allow this and I hope others move in the same direction. I can't see the RC Church changing in my lifetime. I'm Church of Scotland, we're turning to go in the right direction but it's like turning (something very slow and cumbersome, I've forgotten my metaphor).

My God loves everyone and would change and adapt like the rest of us. So would Jesus in my opinion. He would not want us to be bound by 1000 year old rules and never able to change and improve. Simple as that to me.

I like this :)
peachyandkeen · 30/06/2021 19:22

Its not marriage in the romantic sense - but rather in the contractual sense - to provide protections for the party left behind. Financially etc.

Its not about incest or anything like that.

Knitwit99 · 30/06/2021 19:21

Yes it's right that the Methodist Church allow this and I hope others move in the same direction. I can't see the RC Church changing in my lifetime. I'm Church of Scotland, we're turning to go in the right direction but it's like turning (something very slow and cumbersome, I've forgotten my metaphor).

My God loves everyone and would change and adapt like the rest of us. So would Jesus in my opinion. He would not want us to be bound by 1000 year old rules and never able to change and improve. Simple as that to me.

peachyandkeen · 30/06/2021 19:21

@LibertyMole

The sisters example is important. One of the reasons why people wanted gay couples to be able to marry was because if one died the other would have financial security and not be left destitute or homeless.

It is reasonable that the same should apply to siblings who have built an adult life together. This was argued at the time when civil partnerships were brought in.

Arguably friends too - or anyone that has built a life together where there is this kind of financial intertwining and dependency upon one another.
LibertyMole · 30/06/2021 19:15

The sisters example is important. One of the reasons why people wanted gay couples to be able to marry was because if one died the other would have financial security and not be left destitute or homeless.

It is reasonable that the same should apply to siblings who have built an adult life together. This was argued at the time when civil partnerships were brought in.

SimonJT · 30/06/2021 19:15

@MrsFin

Can same sex siblings get married, to avoid inheritance tax etc? Seems only fair.
Why does siblings being able to get married seem fair?
Swipe left for the next trending thread