Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is the Methodist Church right to allow same sex marriage? And what does this mean for C of E and Catholic Church?

229 replies

Notfeelingsopeachyandkeennow · 30/06/2021 16:15

Personally, I am very pro this and think its about time!

I have just read that the Methodist Church is the 4th largest Christian denomination in Britain.

So - do you think that the Catholic Church and Church of England will inevitably follow suit at some point in time - even if that's still 50 years away?

And are you in favour of these changes?

OP posts:
ClareBlue · 02/07/2021 00:49

The state recognises equality for same sex marriage. That is all that matters.
Nobody forces anyone to be a member of a religious club. But if you are a member then why do you want to change the belief system. The Catholic church belief system is that marriage is between a man and women for the purpose of bringing up children. So if you don't believe that is what marriage is, then don't have a Catholic wedding.

VerticalHorizon · 01/07/2021 21:27

@MissConductUS

I don't believe it's true that all other Christian denominations have been ordaining closeted gay priests. In fact, I know it's not true.

If the candidates for ordination were concealing their sexual orientation, how would the denomination know? And how do you know that this isn't true?

Because not all other denominations have priests, and and you stated you found it hypocritical, which implies awareness of ordaining homosexuals. It can't be hypocritical if they do so without being aware.

As I said, that is a far cry from accepting that lots of gay priests HAVE been ordained. Of course they have, but not 'officially' in the full knowledge of the Church.

MissConductUS · 01/07/2021 21:18

I don't believe it's true that all other Christian denominations have been ordaining closeted gay priests. In fact, I know it's not true.

If the candidates for ordination were concealing their sexual orientation, how would the denomination know? And how do you know that this isn't true?

goneroguetoday · 01/07/2021 21:02

A lot of my friends are in their 20s and some early 30s. Most traditional Catholics who prefer the latin mass. Nearly all are or are planning to homeschool and older friends in late 30s and 40s have between 5 and 9 children! Abortion is considered evil. Contraception nat natural family planning is not accepted. There is no way they would accept homosexual marriage as marriage. To Catholics, the family (in a very traditional sense) is the heart of everything and when that is destroyed, society is destroyed.

VerticalHorizon · 01/07/2021 20:43

[quote goneroguetoday]@VerticalHorizon sorry but the majority of catholic priests are gay. My brother was at seminary and has commented on this. There were also a lot of issues with alcohol.[/quote]
I never said they weren't.

What I argued was that I didn't believe ALL other Christian denominations were doing so. I also said there was a far cry between openly ordaining gay men, and doing so unwittingly.

I have no doubt whatsoever that loads of priests are gay (and loads are not). Similarly in many other denominations.

goneroguetoday · 01/07/2021 20:24

@VerticalHorizon sorry but the majority of catholic priests are gay. My brother was at seminary and has commented on this. There were also a lot of issues with alcohol.

VerticalHorizon · 01/07/2021 20:21

I don't believe it's true that all other Christian denominations have been ordaining closeted gay priests. In fact, I know it's not true.
That's not to say it's never happened.

Also, it's a far cry from ordaining a gay priests or ministers (Methodists don't have priests) knowingly, and happening to ordain them as closeted gay men.

Hypocrisy in the Church? It's always been that way. But it's pretty basic human behaviour to be hypocritical I'd argue.

The Church is littered with countless schisms and this will be one more. There's nothing new under the sun as Mr Shakespeare once surmised.

MissConductUS · 01/07/2021 19:52

Sadly, it most evidently IS up for debate!

Sadly, the Episcopal Church's support for gay marriage and the ordination of openly gay priests has led to a movement to expel us from the Anglican Communion. I find this hypocritical in the extreme because all other Christian denominations have been ordaining closeted gay priests for centuries. My admittedly cynical view is that what has kept that from happening is the EC's considerable financial support for the AC, which would be sorely missed if they tossed us out.

VerticalHorizon · 01/07/2021 19:16

@UrAWizHarry

Of course they are right, it's not even up for debate.
Sadly, it most evidently IS up for debate!
UrAWizHarry · 01/07/2021 19:12

Of course they are right, it's not even up for debate.

VerticalHorizon · 01/07/2021 19:07

Homosexuality is a MASSIVE deal for churches, in face sexuality in general has always been an issue.

Sex before marriage is still frowned upon, and actively discouraged.
Promiscuity is also looked down upon.
The various 'forms' of sex tend to be brushed over, but I think she's a general disdain for anything adventurous!

MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously · 01/07/2021 19:07

Also, atheism is surely the absence of belief rather than a belief system?

MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously · 01/07/2021 19:06

I think a state church, that holds political power, such as the CofE should be obligated to follow the law and therefore should perform same sex marriages. Or give up its political power.

Mind, I also think that churches (of all faiths) should only be allowed to perform legally binding wedding ceremonies if they offer those ceremonies to all people allowed by law to marry. If not, then they should only have the power to perform blessings.

ApplesinmyPocket · 01/07/2021 19:03

I certainly hope all churches will follow suit. There should never have been any such embargo in the first place.

VerticalHorizon · 01/07/2021 18:57

You can't just pick and choose what you want, but there are some variations in interpretation and personal morality.

On the whole, religion's the same as any society - there are a set of formal codes (some of which we disagree with break anyway, plus some moral / ethical codes that are left up to us to decide about).

I think most religious people still adhere to things because they believe it is the right (God's) way, when their own feelings / desires / humanity tempts them to do something else.

MissConductUS · 01/07/2021 18:55

@VeryQuaintIrene

Some of the Anglican communion like the Episcopalians are already OK with same-sex marriagem, so I reckon it's just a matter of time. At least, I hope so.
I'm an Episcopalian and am thrilled that we allow same-sex marriage and openly gay and lesbian priests. We also started ordaining women long before the C of E did so.
LaurieFairyCake · 01/07/2021 18:54

Well it has meaning to the people who get married there

Why shouldn't gay Christians get their marriage done in church?

Mymapuddlington · 01/07/2021 18:52

@LaurieFairyCake
If that’s the case then what’s the point in religion and being married in a church anyway? If you can just pick and choose what you want from a religion then surely it’s meaningless?

LaurieFairyCake · 01/07/2021 18:50

Well yes, and Moslems and Jews don't eat meat and dairy together

And some men do beat their wives with a stick

It doesn't mean that veils/sticks/no meat and dairy together is REQUIRED

Just like being anti-gay is not REQUIRED of Christians

goneroguetoday · 01/07/2021 18:47

@LaurieFairyCake actually a lot of catholic women do cover their heads in church with a veil called a mantilla. Also, lots of people wear veils when getting married.

VerticalHorizon · 01/07/2021 16:12

Jesus only ever referred to marriage in the context of a man and woman. What readers choose to make of that leads us to still be debating the issue 2000 years later!

If you are anti-gay marriage, Jesus is confirming it should be man and woman. If you're pro-gay marriage, then he's hardly ruled it out!

VerticalHorizon · 01/07/2021 16:07

Some of the issue stems from Pauline testimony, and his mention of homosexuality (condemnation). Traditionally, his letters were interpreted very negatively towards homosexuality, particularly male.

More recently (and arguably due to a pressing need to reinterpret!), more accommodating interpretations have been made e.g. that Paul's criticism of homosexuality was related to men sleeping with boys, not so much men with men.

Paul also expressed what we would consider today to be diminutive views of women. The repercussions of which still exist today.

LaurieFairyCake · 01/07/2021 15:59

It's not spoken at all about by Jesus - on the contrary he says 'love your neighbour as yourself'

And there's HUNDREDS of Bible instructions which are pretty clear that have multiple cultural/customs that we obviously don't do:

  1. Like hitting your wife with a stick no thicker than your thumb
  1. Covering your head in church if you're a woman
  1. Eating dairy and meat together
  1. Marrying your brother in law if your husband dies
  1. Fucking a servant to get a kid

(Now I would argue the above are all wrong/misunderstood/stupid in today's society)

But they're still SAID

Mymapuddlington · 01/07/2021 15:37

I think anyone who marries should be allowed to, however there’s lots of options not involving the church.
I just think it’s hypocritical to allow something happen in the church which is spoken against so clearly in the bible.

LaurieFairyCake · 01/07/2021 15:34

Methodist Evangelicals is a much smaller group within the Methodist Church

And they will likely splinter off now that this has been decided - this is REALLY likely

They do not represent Methodism Hmm
Just like those nutty Westboro Baptists don't represent the Baptists in America

Or that group in the Catholic Church against all contraception

Swipe left for the next trending thread