Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry the new health minister Sajid Javid will privatise the NHS…

120 replies

Ijustknowitstimetogo · 28/06/2021 13:23

But not before running it into the ground?

He’s reassigning from his position at US bank JP Morgan where he earns £150k as an advisor.

JP Morgan say they "see the opportunities that lie ahead" for private healthcare.

He’s already making promises that we will never return to Coronavirus rules. Shouldn’t that be decided by any future epidemiology and health service data? Not just an empty promise based on finance only.

Not looking good, is it?

OP posts:
Againstmachine · 28/06/2021 21:54

Yes, many hospitals are on lease and it’s bankrupting them slowly

Yep PFI's private company's involved with the workings of hospitals, when it would have been cheaper at the time for them to borrow the money rather than get involved in these schemes.

Echobelly · 28/06/2021 21:52

Much as I hate the Tories, I don't actually think they have an intention to change the whole thing to a US system.

They will, however, award contracts to 'partnerships' to run things, where all the risk goes to the NHS and all the profit to private sector, no matter how incompetently the latter run things.

I do think it wouldn't be a bad idea to have a German style system where households like mine pay something towards a health system that keeps it free for those in need. But the Tories would never do anything that sensible.

ivykaty44 · 28/06/2021 21:51

It's not just the Tory's, Tony Blair's labour was upto it too.

Yes, many hospitals are on lease and it’s bankrupting them slowly

ltappleby · 28/06/2021 21:50

If it could be achieved I'd prefer a system such as found in the rest of Europe or Australia, where the State acts as an insurer, rather than provider. For many people, the NHS really isn't working at the moment. I know several people who've had to pay £thousands for knee and hip replacements, because of quotes of 2 year waits on the NHS, and these aren't rich people, with money to spare.

ivykaty44 · 28/06/2021 21:50

This is how they do it 'more efficiently'. Cream off all the super easy cases and enjoy the profits. Anything even slightly complex goes back to the NHS.

What's worse is I then had to be referred into the NHS and back on a waiting list so I still haven't had it done

Which means that private healthcare will make profit from our NHS and ultimately the tax payer

Againstmachine · 28/06/2021 21:44

It's been Tory policy for years, they've been selling it off piecemeal in the hope that we don't notice.

It's not just the Tory's, Tony Blair's labour was upto it too.

GreenWillow · 28/06/2021 21:40

Creating a competitive market will also hugely increase nurses’ pay too, such an irony given the rabid opposition of the Unions to the idea.

GreenWillow · 28/06/2021 21:38

There needs to be competition at the level of the consumer (patient) for this to work.

The only way for service standards to improve is for individual patients to be given the opportunity to vote with their feet in the event of receiving unacceptable treatment/service.

This is the issue with the NHS, can you imagine if your local Sainsbury’s shut up shop for an hour at lunchtime to restock the shelves?

It’s just a risible suggestion, but in the monopoly that is the NHS, it is somehow seen as perfectly acceptable because there is no competitive pressure to work creatively.

Longdistance · 28/06/2021 21:30

I’m lucky enough that dh has BUPA cover for us all through his work. I completely forgot about it until he reminded me.
I’ve a really painful knee and talking to my GP (over the phone) she couldn’t give a crap, it keeps me awake at night in agony. I got ‘here’s some ibuprofen cream’, she couldn’t examine my knee as it was over the phone, said she’d get me physio, letter came, letter states they are not seeing patients.
Booked through BUPA, consultant examines my knee, now booked into having an MRI on it. No dicking about. Happy days, I’m getting somewhere. It’s been months through the NHS.

FleetwoodRaincoat · 28/06/2021 21:24

It won't be up to him. It's been Tory policy for years, they've been selling it off piecemeal in the hope that we don't notice.

SJ is every bit as much of a wanker as the rest of them.

osbertthesyrianhamster · 28/06/2021 21:23

He’s already making promises that we will never return to Coronavirus rules.

Good!

And no, non-elected officials should not be deciding that, the electorate should, that's democracy.

MrsFin · 28/06/2021 21:12

I don't understand the objection to some contribution, for those who can, at point of delivery. Yet we cling onto the idea that it must all be free to everyone.

It's not free though is it? We pay for it though our taxes, whether we use the service or not. And those who earn more, pay more.
I've paid taxes all my working life, but have only really used the NHS to have two babies. That's not a complaint - I'm lucky to never have been in need of medical treatment - it's just an example of the NHS not being free.

MrsFin · 28/06/2021 21:05

The problem is businesses are not about caring for the vulnerable

There are lots of good, privately run hospitals already. Also care homes and schools. And the NHS uses loads of agency nurses etc.

You'd be surprised how much of the NHS is privately run already, with the NHS paying the private company.

Private business isn't all bad. I think it's worth a go anyway.

Blossomtoes · 28/06/2021 15:51

@Imasoulman

Just another spineless hypocrite. He resigned as Chancellor because he couldn't work within the confines of a Johnson government...... But here he is again!
No, he resigned because he refused to be bullied by Cummings, let’s not rewrite history.

There’s no doubt that the NHS needs root and branch reform, it’s a mess, particularly since the 2012 Health and Social Care Bill.

Imasoulman · 28/06/2021 15:46

I'm trying to think of one thing that the tories have privatised that has since improved or been better value for the end user

Purplewithred · 28/06/2021 15:14

Define privatisation. Do you mean people paying for care, or do you mean the government buying in services from private companies? Buying in services from private companies is something the NHS has always done - GPs are private businesses and always have been - And it can be an excellent way of providing care. From what I see of integrated care services that are offered by NHS-only organisations they are still horribly fragmented and often very badly run.

BareGrylls · 28/06/2021 15:09

It would be pretty hard to make things worse. Someone needs to grasp the nettle and do things differently.
Other countries do things far better with a mix of free and insured provision. I don't understand the objection to some contribution, for those who can, at point of delivery. Yet we cling onto the idea that it must all be free to everyone.

TheQueef · 28/06/2021 15:04

Not saying he wouldn't but I reckon Dido Harding and her new job at the NHS will accomplish this before he gets a chance.

EeeByeGummieBear · 28/06/2021 14:59

@Letsallscreamatthesistene the introduction of privatisation has made it worse. I can't imagine that privatisation will improve physical care because the drive is profit, and each company serving its own interests rather than those of the patient.
Yes- mental health services need a massive overhaul. They really aren't fit for purpose.

TheGumption · 28/06/2021 14:53

Yanbu to think it but it needs to happen to some degree. The NHS is broken. I won't even start on my rant about GP's but at this stage, some level of privatisation would be fine with me if it meant I could actually get my sick baby seen.

Letsallscreamatthesistene · 28/06/2021 14:52

@EeeByeGummieBear

In my experience, the involvement of private companies has seriously affected mental health provision locally. No one provider takes full responsibility for the patient, just offers brief care. The NHS provider gets referred the complex cases (which are not profitable) by the assessment service (private company) because they know they will take responsibility. If they are full, patients get passed from pillar to post with inappropriate interventions which cost hundreds if not thousands overall, with very little benefit to the poor patient. I thought the competition would be good, and that it would help the NHS. It hasn't. I left- I couldn't be complicit in it anymore. I wasn't replaced, so less NHS practitioners available, more patients going to (inappropriate) private companies, who just find a way to make money. The staff they employ care, but aren't given the tools to do the job effectively.
Mental health provision is a shit show regardless. Its appalling tbh. I think the MH care system needs an entire overhaul. It cant be equated to the physical health system because its in such a worse off position
EeeByeGummieBear · 28/06/2021 14:51

@MoMuntervary

My experience of that *@MrsFin* was that I was offered care from a private company (through the NHS, not by choice). Waited on their list, eventually got to see them and was shunted off their list as I wasn't 100% straightforward. Nothing complicated, just a prexisting condition that meant there was a very small chance of needing additional aftercare to their standard package. In other words, potentially not profitable.

This is how they do it 'more efficiently'. Cream off all the super easy cases and enjoy the profits. Anything even slightly complex goes back to the NHS.

What's worse is I then had to be referred into the NHS and back on a waiting list so I still haven't had it done.

Really sorry to hear this, but it doesn't surprise me at all. Hope you get the treatment you need soon.
EeeByeGummieBear · 28/06/2021 14:50

In my experience, the involvement of private companies has seriously affected mental health provision locally. No one provider takes full responsibility for the patient, just offers brief care. The NHS provider gets referred the complex cases (which are not profitable) by the assessment service (private company) because they know they will take responsibility. If they are full, patients get passed from pillar to post with inappropriate interventions which cost hundreds if not thousands overall, with very little benefit to the poor patient.
I thought the competition would be good, and that it would help the NHS. It hasn't. I left- I couldn't be complicit in it anymore. I wasn't replaced, so less NHS practitioners available, more patients going to (inappropriate) private companies, who just find a way to make money.
The staff they employ care, but aren't given the tools to do the job effectively.

midgemagneto · 28/06/2021 14:43

Could you give me example of what is meant by part privatisation

I certainly would be horrified at a system like America

Justcallmebebes · 28/06/2021 14:41

I agree with part privatisation of the NHS. It's funny how it seems to work perfectly well in most other countries but the merest whiff of it here meets with such resistance. Our health service could not get any worse so I am all in favour of a different model.

As for Sajid Javid, I like him and hopefully he'll bring us out of these never ending lockdowns.

All good as far as I'm concerned

Swipe left for the next trending thread