Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To just give them some cows milk?!

64 replies

OhToBeASeahorse · 28/06/2021 12:46

Last summer DS (then nearly 2) started to get bad eczema. He also pood very frequently but that has been since birth. By September we trialled going dairy free and the eczema disappeared- nappy situation remained.

In March the eczema started to reappear. Ge had changed childcare but they are adamant he isnt having dairy.

DD is 8 months and breastfed. When she was tiny I thought that she was more unsettled when I had dairy so I cut it out. 2.nights ago I had a few chocolate buttons and she was slightly more unsettled last night (crap sleeper anyway).

Its doing my head in checking every packet of everything, they are both dairy and soya free and I thought egg might be a trigger for her too so i dont have that.

It's all so unclear. I'm starting to wonder if DS's exzema is a sun or heat related thing.

AIBU to just give them both a mug ful of cows milk and see what happens? I'm so exhausted thinking about it all.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheSandgroper · 28/01/2022 13:19

Doctors know nothing about food intolerance. You need a dietitian. In Australia, you don’t need a referral, just make a booking. I don’t know about going private in the uk.

However, many Australian dietitians do Skype, if you care to look here. www.fedup.com.au/information/support/failsafe-friendly-dietitians-and-other-health-professionals-overseas

Everyone on this list has expertise in food intolerance.

Gc309 · 28/01/2022 12:59

@pastabest lol if you had a brain you’d realise I only came across this recently, and not 7 months ago, so no is the answer to your pointless comment

pastabest · 23/01/2022 08:19

[quote Gc309]@OrangeRug people like you need a slap for your stupidity[/quote]
I don't agree with OrangeRug but has it really taken you 7 months to come up with that retort?

DontWantTheRivalry · 23/01/2022 08:12

My son was diagnosed with potential CMPA when he was 9 weeks old. My doctor told me to go dairy free and then have a major binge on diary to see if anything happened to him as it’s the only way to confirm the diagnosis.

The 6 weeks were really difficult and then when it came to binge day I had two chocolate bars and a huge chocolate milkshake in the space of about an hour, left it for an hour and then breastfed my son.

About 2 hours after his feed his arms and legs came up in the most awful red eczema - they were covered and it looked so inflamed. It appeared over the course of about an hour and I couldn’t believe it!

Needless to say, the allergy was confirmed and I spent a long time checking packaging for ingredients - which isn’t fun at all.

I have known people in your case who have given their older children lots of dairy products just to get an answer one way or the other.

NewtoHolland · 23/01/2022 07:59

@DingleyDel

I really wouldn’t worry about changing your diet for breastfeeding. Despite what mums are told, there is little evidence that allergens in BM are present in enough quantities to cause an allergic reaction in infants. CMPA is massively over diagnosed especially in breastfed infants. There’s a good article in the bmj but it’s behind a paywall but this article sums up the findings. www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/04/200413132756.htm

However, their analysis of 13 studies of breastmilk composition suggests less than one millionth of the protein from cow's milk travels through to breast milk, and this would be too small to trigger a reaction in most allergic children.

With the 2 year old id be tempted to just try the milk ladder thing and see what happens if the GP is useless.

Hmm this is interesting, my children both CMPA, very clear symptoms, stools like mucous and if persisted very grainy stools and then blood in stool. lots of snot and mild rashes accompanied this each time I trialled milk in my diet. This was when they were exclusively breastfed....obv just one experience and anecdotal but am on groups with thousands of mums supporting each other with diet and this seems widely experienced. Honestly I would have done anything to have cheese whilst breastfeeding 🤣. My 7 year old has just managed to start toleratng yoghurt which is amazing..we had to use microdosing in the end with her as advised by the dietician. Preschooler can tolerate step one of the ladder, any further and we get the grainy and mucousy stools and snotty nose and rashes. Neither could tolerate soya in my diet when I breast fed and egg also a prob for the second.

OP is there any reason you've not been referred in for dietician support? Milk ladder should be used for reintroduction/ challenges, still will confirm it for you but unlikely to produce an extreme reaction which a cup of milk would have in either of my kids.

Gc309 · 23/01/2022 07:45

@OrangeRug people like you need a slap for your stupidity

OhToBeASeahorse · 29/06/2021 09:07

So I gave her a bit of a malted milk. Went to bed fine. Very unhappy during the night but has woken up fine again?!?!

OP posts:
ineedaholidaynow · 28/06/2021 23:40

Baby milk formula is made out of cows milk though, and you can use normal cows milk for cooking after 6 months. We were given special formula for DS with the milk protein removed when he had dairy allergy

VestaTilley · 28/06/2021 22:42

YABU anyway- under 1s are not supposed to have cows milk at all, regardless of whether they were bottle fed or breast fed.

Have you heard of the milk ladder? It’s how many of my friends with children who have CMPA reintroduced dairy.

Ask to be referred by your GP to a dermatologist for your child’s eczema.

Pleasegodgotosleep · 28/06/2021 22:42

My LG had cmpa, beef, soya, rye, strawberry, raspberry & pineapple allergies. I bf until she was 18 months. When I reintroduced dairy to my diet I had terrible stomach upsets for a few weeks so just giving them whole milk won't be a reliable test. Lg turns 3 next month and has worked her way to the top of all ladders her only remaining allergy is pineapple. It's bloody hard but they might out grow it. Good luck

mswales · 28/06/2021 22:39

Also OP please note that food intolerance and food allergies are different things

mswales · 28/06/2021 22:38

@user1471538283

Have you tried goats milk? Apparently even I was small I couldnt tolerate cows milk but settled okay with goats milk. I then drank small amounts of cows milk when I was older. I still cannot stomach too much milk and cannot eat cream.
Most people with CMPA (cows milk protein allergy) are also allergic to goats milk
mswales · 28/06/2021 22:37

You need to get your son referred to an allergy clinic to be tested for the main 8 allergens. Dairy and egg are two of them but there are six others. Eczema doesn't come from nowhere or from heat (though heat can exacerbate it), it usually has an allergic cause or at least allergic triggers. My son was covered in eczema as a baby and turned out to be allergic to dairy, eggs, peanuts walnuts and dust mites. He grew out of the dairy allergy aged 2 and a half (I did the milk ladder). The doctor may tell you there's no point doing allergy testing as there are infinite things he could be allergic to but tell him you want him to be tested for the eight main allergens so you at least know whether you need to cut out staples like dairy and egg.
You also need to make sure you only have them in cotton clothes and bed linen and use allergy friendly washing powder and soap. Normal washing powder and shampoo etc aggravates eczema. There's a washing powder brand called Surcare which you can get in sainsbury's whhch is recommended by eczema society.

PaySeeWhiTa · 28/06/2021 22:25

I was told by the Consultant Allergist I saw for my dairy allergic child that goats milk was too similar to cow's milk and it should be avoided too.

I was also told that if someone didn't take a dairy allergy seriously I shouldn't trust them around my child.

OP - dicking around with this could prolong/worsen/reinforce any allergies your children have and could also be incredibly dangerous. Don't be an idiot and don't be reckless with your kid's health and quality of life. Get some advice, call allergy UK in the morning for free and see an allergist via GP or privately.

user1471538283 · 28/06/2021 21:55

Have you tried goats milk? Apparently even I was small I couldnt tolerate cows milk but settled okay with goats milk. I then drank small amounts of cows milk when I was older. I still cannot stomach too much milk and cannot eat cream.

RealBecca · 28/06/2021 21:24

I understand you are tired but you NEED to see a GP. Or a different one. And go back if ypu are confused. You are on the early parenthood days of working yourself up over something and you cant see the woods for the trees.

It is utterly utterly irresponsible to give a child something you think they might be allergic or intolerant to.

Be an adult and follow the process. You cant possibly think you know better than doctors and dieticians that have studied their field for years. Go to a GP and follow their advice or ask for a dietician.

OhToBeASeahorse · 28/06/2021 21:05

So I gave them both a bit of malted milk earlier. DD went to bed happy as Larry. But she has now been crying inconsolably for an hour.

OP posts:
GalaxyGirl24 · 28/06/2021 20:33

I wouldn't give them a full cup of cows milk OP, might make them feel awful and it won't be nice for you either.

I'm not sure if you have eczema but I do (heat/stress/dairy and sugar induced) and it's bloody awful and relentless and deeply psychological is the need to itch/damage cycle. So potentially giving a trigger and causing a reaction won't be pleasant.

The IMAP ladder looks worth a go as PPs have said.

I know it's stressful though checking every single thing. Currently going through process of having DD tested for egg/dairy/banana/tomato/chicken allergies 😖 v hard finding foods for her and she's BF too so managing my diet too is hard work. My sympathies to you 💐 x

PaySeeWhiTa · 28/06/2021 20:00

I just want to share my experience. I have had two kids with allergies/eczema. My husband also has had eczema since he was an infant and still suffers as an adult. He also has food allergies - some he grew out of, some persisted.

Eldest child - had some mildish dry eczema at a few months old. Had a really bad reaction to a cradle cap shampoo which left him with a raw and bleeding scalp. When first introduced to peanut butter at 7 months old came out in hives, vomited, coughed, upset tummy after. GP referred us for allergy testing - the waiting list was over a year (this was pre-pandemic). Weaning is such an important window - introducing a food to a baby and then not repeating that exposure can increase risk of allergy, as can not introducing it early enough. As DC had eaten other things that meal and I wasn't happy to just exclude things from his diet if it may not be necessary/actually increase the risk of an allergy I paid for private testing. Skin prick came up positive for peanut, also got advice on how to manage his eczema at the same apt. So excluded peanut from his diet/our house etc. Got on top of eczema.
I was told that one of the reasons eczema is important in allergy is that if baby gets exposed to food proteins via the skin rather than digesting them they are more likely to be coded as foreign substance/threat to immune system and so baby becomes sensitised. So could have happened if we had just eaten peanut butter for example and handled DC when he had excoriated/eczematous skin eg when he had reaction to cradle cap shampoo.
Over a year later I got my apt with the NHS allergist. Now skin prick came up negative, as did a repeat skin prick, so we peanut challenged him at home (gave him ever increasing amounts of peanut) and he had no reaction. So he has grown out of his peanut allergy which is fantastic. I was never told to eliminate peanut from my diet whilst breastfeeding but I pretty much did as I didn't want to worry about contamination (from contact not through breast milk).

Youngest - again mild eczema at around 5 months old. As we were aware this could increase risk for allergy we treated this early. However when six months old and first ate porridge came up in hives. Again, by the time we'd have waited for an NHS allergy apt we'd have missed a really important window, especially as excluding dairy is such a big exclusion from a young child's diet and I didn't understand the advice for me to exclude dairy as I had been eating it for the whole 6 time I'd been breastfeeding and she was a happy baby with no symptoms of a reaction all that time. So off to private allergist again.
Skin prick came up positive to milk and peanut. Eczema reviewed and allergist felt it was just the dry kind of eczema babies get and unlikely to be anything to do with allergies. As she is in important window for possibly reducing allergy by exposure referred to NHS clinic where they do a peanut challenge. Unfortunately when they skin pricked her on the day of this challenge her reaction was too big to do a challenge, as she would be to likely to react badly. However her reaction to milk had improved so we did a step of the milk ladder (baked milk). She had no reaction to this. We have been told to stick at this step for a few months before reviewing it to see if she can move up. She must avoid peanuts and has an EpiPen.

All three allergists I have seen have said I personally do not need to exclude allergens from my diet whilst breastfeeding (peanut or milk) as my babies didn't have a reaction to my breastmilk, just the actual substance. I imagine this would have been different had I had unhappy, rashy babies with digestive issues or poor weight gain. The allergist advice differed from the Paeds/GP advice on this.
Allergist has referred me to a dietician to talk about youngest's diet. If this hadn't happened I would have spoken to allergy UK as they have dieticians that can speak to you once you have a diagnosis.

Sorry this has been such a long winded way of making the points that

  • if you can I would pay for private testing as eliminating foods can increase risk of allergies and also has a huge impact on a growing baby's nutrition etc It also provides a bit of clarity as allergies can be so worrying and avoiding them such a large impact on daily life
  • Their allergies do not automatically mean you should exclude foods from your diet if breastfeeding. GPs/Paeds aren't always best placed to advise on this. If you exclude dairy you need to take a calcium and vitamin d supplement yourself. However if you eat the allergens you have to be careful of contact etc (so I only eat dairy when youngest is in bed).
  • There are different milk ladders for IgE/non-IgE allergies. A cup of milk contains thousands and thousands of times the amount of allergen that breastmilk etc would do which is why my youngest doesn't react to my breastmilk but came out in hives eating porridge. So please just don't give your kids a cup of cow's milk, it could cause a severe reaction and sensitise them more.
  • When they are young this is an important time to expose them to allergens, if you need to push for advice on how to so this I would. You should be going up ladders etc with guidance. I wonder if you could have a private apt where they skin prick and then advise you on the next step/ladders etc all in one go. My private apts have been test + advice + referral to NHS service. The vast majority outgrow milk allergy so you want to be facilitating this and reducing the amount of time they don't eat it as much as possible.
  • I would also push for dietician advice. Like I said I think allergy UK can provide this, they will also talk through with you the complexities of the situation because it really is complex!
  • It is important to treat eczema as well as possible (again pushing for specialist advice if you need to) for preventing allergies too. My allergy apts have also included advice on eczema.

So that's my experience and understanding of milk allergies. Best of luck.

MrsAvocet · 28/06/2021 17:25

There seem to be quite polarised views on the whole inside vs outside thing re eczema, even within health care professionals. Personally, I think the fact that different people respond to different approaches suggests that eczema is not actually one entity and that there are many different types of trigger. My own eczema is massively affected by stress. One of my children had a strong dietary connection, another has mainly environmental triggers and the third is somewhere in between. And there is probably a genetic component underlying it all.
There's always going to be an element of trial and error unfortunately, but hopefully you'll get there in the end OP. Hang on in there. I remember the misery but for my children fortunately its eventually gone from being something that our lives used to revolve around to a minor irritation. There is hope!

Conchitastrawberry · 28/06/2021 16:11

My daughter has had eczema since a baby. She’s 15 now and it flares up really badly with heat. It took a long time to figure out as everyone kept telling me to treat eczema from the inside so we’ve gone years cutting stuff out, keeping food diaries etc but it’s definitely heat/sun.

LizJamIsFab · 28/06/2021 16:03

I definitely would give them some, using “milk ladder” a good idea. Clear skin a good starting point.

TooOldandTired · 28/06/2021 15:12

The sun (and suncream) are very likely to be impacting eczema.
My son has quite bad eczema and I have private allergy testing then went to see a consultant dietician who told me those tests were pointless and don't work.
The only reliable way to know if the cows milk is causing eczema is to cut it out (which you have) and then gradually reintroduce.

MrsAvocet · 28/06/2021 15:11

the bloods will give you a much clearer picture from the start
Or they might not. It isn't always that simple.
Blood tests measure specific IgE levels, but not all allergic reactions are IgE mediated. Skin prick tests are the same, and the size of the reaction on testing doesn't always correlate with the severity of the clinical reaction either.
My younger son has a mixture of IgE and non IgE allergies and has been hospitalised by reactions to foods which according to his blood tests he isn't allergic to. Fortunately for us his immunologist is extremely thorough and has helped us identify a number of non IgE mediated reactions which were making him extremely ill.

Caspianberg · 28/06/2021 14:55

I would def get allergy tests done.

When Ds was 6 months he had an allergic reaction whilst sitting at the table with us at lunch where we had a variety of foods at the table. Doctor said it was probably dairy, maybe gluten… but luckily took blood tests straight away. We were told to avoid all dairy and gluten until results were back.

Turns out he’s highly allergic to nuts, and has no allergy at all to dairy or gluten. Had tests not been done we would have been trying to avoid the wrong things for months and probably given nuts again as things like nut butters perfect if dairy free!