Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ds unhappy about house move - am I a shit parent?

269 replies

SeasideMove · 28/06/2021 08:10

We are moving house next month and last night DS (18) said he was really unhappy about it and didn't want to go.

We're moving about 90 mins drive from our current home. At the moment we rent and we are priced out of buying in the area. We have been able to buy a 4-bed detached property with a garden for the price of a flat or a 2-bed terrace in our current location. DS will have a bedroom (obvs) but also another tv / computer / music room to himself.

DS has seen the house, likes the town and the nearby area etc but is saying that he will be cut off from his friends etc - his main group of friends are now a 90-min train ride away, he is worried about the cost of travel etc. He doesn't yet drive (lessons stopped during pandemic) but will start again and will have use of a car in 6 months or so. He feels as if he won't make friends / connections in the new place, is worried about getting a PT job etc. My argument is that he will still be able to see his friends regularly etc but it will just take a bit more organisation!

He was originally going to go to university this Sept, but decided to take a year out. Like most kids his age, the last year has been pretty shit and unsettling, and I suppose I feel guilty that this is unsettling him even more.

He has said it feels as if we just thought 'oh ds is off to uni, we can just move wherever we like' - which isn't exactly the case! For one thing the timing of the move was not in our control as the house we are in is being sold. However if I'm honest we did take advantage of the relative freedom of not having to worry about schools etc - is that wrong?

I've tried to reassure him that I will help with train fares / car etc, that he'll find a job and make friends/connections, but he is really low, worried about losing his friendship group, and I feel crap about it. This is a huge change for everyone (we're all moving away from friends and family, after all!) but I suppose DH and I are excited about it and thinking of all the positives, and maybe we should have considered DS more? I feel like a shit parent and have been awake half the night worrying about it. But equally, this is our life too, isn't it?

So, I guess AIBU to move my teenage DS away from his mates and his familiar surroundings for the sake of our quality of life?

OP posts:
Fistful · 29/06/2021 17:49

@Bluntness100

Honestly never get this whole “he’s eighteen he’s an adult” thing. It often reads like some posters genuinely believe once your kid hits 18 you owe them fuck all and they can jog on
I don't think anyone has suggested abandoning him on the side of the road, only that as he's set to go away to university in a year, the OP having stayed where she was for the duration of his education to A-levels should not have to lose an opportunity by giving the same weight to his circumstances as she would, say, a younger teenager, whose education as well as friendships would be disrupted by the move.

And yes, that he's old enough to understand something of his parents' circumstances from something other than the 'You're ruining my life!' perspective.

Scaredycatmoo76 · 29/06/2021 17:48

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

Honestly never get this whole “he’s eighteen he’s an adult” thing. It often reads like some posters genuinely believe once your kid hits 18 you owe them fuck all and they can jog on

Neither do l. 18 is young. I always think people who disregard this don’t have 18 year old children.

Or they do And don’t necessarily have the most positive relationship with their 18 year old
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 29/06/2021 17:42

Honestly never get this whole “he’s eighteen he’s an adult” thing. It often reads like some posters genuinely believe once your kid hits 18 you owe them fuck all and they can jog on

Neither do l. 18 is young. I always think people who disregard this don’t have 18 year old children.

Scaredycatmoo76 · 29/06/2021 17:42

@Bluntness100

Honestly never get this whole “he’s eighteen he’s an adult” thing. It often reads like some posters genuinely believe once your kid hits 18 you owe them fuck all and they can jog on
And the number that say “it didn’t do me any harm - and I was living on my own at 16 with three children and a full time job” or along those lines

Whereas I was still ridiculously indulged and spoilt as an 18 year old

And now I’m a professional, very financially able, entirely independent single mother!

aSofaNearYou · 29/06/2021 17:42

@Bluntness100

Honestly never get this whole “he’s eighteen he’s an adult” thing. It often reads like some posters genuinely believe once your kid hits 18 you owe them fuck all and they can jog on
It's not as severe as that. To me when I say "he's eighteen he's an adult" I mean he needs to start understanding things from an adult perspective and showing the appropriate level of maturity. Not that he should be kicked out.

He's old enough to understand the position OP is in regarding her tenancy and finances and he needs to start acting like it.

Hotair1234 · 29/06/2021 17:39

We were in the same position just before lockdown and if I put myself genuinely in my 18 yo DS position my world was my friends back then. So we still moved as planned but we got him a short term let in a shared house. Was about £50 a week which we paid for first three months. If he liked it after that he would start to pay out of wages, if he wasn’t over the moon with self cleaning/bed changing/laundry responsibilities then he could still have planned room at the new house.

He loved it and stayed the full year and now going to uni. I don’t think he probably did clean as often as I would’ve but a little independence just before uni I think did him good.

We didn’t see him as often as intended due to lockdown but this year have gone down every two weeks to meet up for lunch, mooch round town (abs secretly so I can check his fridge has fruit and veg etc..).

Might not be ideal but kept us sane and everyone as happy as could be.

Bluntness100 · 29/06/2021 17:30

Honestly never get this whole “he’s eighteen he’s an adult” thing. It often reads like some posters genuinely believe once your kid hits 18 you owe them fuck all and they can jog on

Anastar23 · 29/06/2021 17:29

You can’t live around your children forever, there has to be a time you make a decision for you as adults.
He can move back and rent a place there, get a job etc?! If he is that upset about it.
Like others have said he will likely move away after uni anyway. Don’t feel bad!

user1472151176 · 29/06/2021 17:25

At 18 he is an adult. If he's taking a year out I suspect he'll want to find a job where he'll meet new friends and have money to visit old friends. Its only a year before he goes to uni anyway and you have to look to your future now he is grown up

Bluntness100 · 29/06/2021 14:10

I can see both sides and why you feel bad, you put yourself first but at a cost to him and you know it. Ideally waiting a year till he went to uni would have been better. 90 mins away is a fair distance. It’s a three hour round trip just to see his mates.who he wasn’t planning on leaving for another year.

Hopefully he gets a job and doesn’t find himself sitting at home snd missing much of his friendship group and it works out.

TatianaBis · 29/06/2021 14:01

Bar work is ideal for him to meet new people quickly.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 29/06/2021 13:36

Yanbu..most 18 year olds head off to uni without their school friends and manage just fine.

Encourage him to get stuck into making a solid plan for the gap year - does he have a university place ready that he will defer?

Dont let him just drift about for a year, encourage him to do a useful training course, get a job and earn some money, use it to travel etc. A friend worked for half their gap year then did an immersive language course in Italy for the second part which I thought was a great idea.

Scaredycatmoo76 · 29/06/2021 13:11

I even plan to move by the sea when I retire
Mainly so my home becomes a holiday place for my children and their families!

That really is a bit ott Grin

Scaredycatmoo76 · 29/06/2021 13:10

There is nothing wrong with what the op is doing
And no she shouldn’t feel guilty at all

Would I do it? No. Simply because I would not want to move away and then children rarely come back from uni and don’t enjoy the kooonnng holidays because no friends around.
Plus, I wouldn’t move from current area where I have friends myself, just for extra space.

But that’s me. And that’s the OP. Nothing right or wrong with either surely

aSofaNearYou · 29/06/2021 12:36

[quote MyDcAreMarvel]**@Zzelda* have you read OP's posts?* did you read mine? I wasn’t suggesting staying in a rental , I was saying the op can afford to stay by buying a 2 bed. There is no reason that 2 bed could be sold in a few years and the big move happen when her ds has moved out.[/quote]
Yes, but for the sake of a few extra months closed to a group of friends who will all naturally be scattering anyway, that would be a ridiculous amount of upheaval and potentially sacrifice if it makes OPs chances of a decent mortgage down the line worse. The fact that she COULD do this does not make it in any way a good idea or a worthwhile guilt trip.

MyDcAreMarvel · 29/06/2021 12:29

@Zzelda have you read OP's posts? did you read mine? I wasn’t suggesting staying in a rental , I was saying the op can afford to stay by buying a 2 bed. There is no reason that 2 bed could be sold in a few years and the big move happen when her ds has moved out.

GhoulWithADragonTattoo · 29/06/2021 12:23

Glad to hear DS is feeling more confident. It’s true most people stay put for secondary school but you have done that. The fact that your hand was forced means you are not unreasonable. Has DS thought about to uni in September and make a new friendship group straightaway? He would obviously also make friends if he does get a job in new area.

VestaTilley · 29/06/2021 08:44

YANBU. I can completely see why your DS would feel hurt and worried, so I’d suggest making a fuss of him, asking how his room should be decorated; make it clear you’ll pay his train fare and make it clear you’re not doing it because he’s off to uni and that he’ll always have a home with you.

But. You need to get on the property ladder, you were forced out of your old home anyway because it was being sold, and you’ll all have a better quality of life with more space and a garden.

Suggest he looks for work in his year out or joins as many clubs etc in the new area that he can to meet people. See it as an opportunity. You’re doing the right thing.

SeasideMove · 29/06/2021 08:41

Thanks all, there have been some really helpful posts on this thread that have given me some good perspective.

I love the idea of the camper van @sashh Grin I actually used to own one, and ds and I did lots of fun trips and weekends away when he was little, but they are a money pit so I had to get rid, sadly.

We had another chat last night, and he seemed much more sanguine about it all than he did the other day. It is a big upheaval for all of us, and I think the uncertainty of this last year has just exacerbated the feeling of 'wobbliness' about leaving what's familiar. But he's identified a couple of activities that he wants to get involved with in the area, his friends are already booked to come and stay for a weekend, and we talked about the possibility of us sorting him out with a car once he's passed his test and had some driving experience. Plus the area that we're moving to has lots of hospitality vacancies so I have no worries he'll find a job even if it's just bar-work for a few months.

I don't expect him to fall in love with the place but I hope he'll feel as if it's home, where his family is, and he'll be able to see the positives in time.

OP posts:
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 29/06/2021 08:41

Nope, no one’s moved. Ds moved to London for 2 years but got sick of the cost and came back. So he moved, but none of his friends have.

Why a ‘fantastical place?’ It just has a stable population. I taught in the nearby massive comp in catchment. Very little movement there either. Maybe 4 or 5 children left/ moved in per year.

Didicat · 29/06/2021 07:29

I don’t think you’ve been unreasonable, but having moved in Covid times to a new area and found it really hard to make friends I can understand his reticence.

Positive maybe that he may be more willing to work more hours at a local job if his friends aren’t about. I made loads of temporary friends through summer work, a few I kept hold of.

Good luck with the move! Don’t change course this is a big positive for you and he will just need some extra nursing through the transition.

MoreAloneTime · 29/06/2021 06:18

I think the tricky thing is we all know that over the next year these friends are likely to start drifting, once at uni he will make new friends, people will start moving on anyway etc but as an 18 year old he doesn't have this perspective. It's not the end of the world in the long term but when you're 18 it genuinely feels like the end of the world.

I was older but I have been through a phase in my life where all my friends were distance friends (90 mins was the minimum) and it was hard. It was either an infrequent months in advance planned meetup or a virtual friendship. I remember desperately missing those impromptu raid the supermarket and have a little BBQ because the weather was unexpectedly good or that last minute let's meet at X text's. You can keep up friendships over distance but the dynamics are very different and I can imagine it's harder when you're younger.

That said it is what it is. The move sounds like a sensible one and your hand was pushed anyway. I think all you can do is be appropriately sympathic to your DS and play the long game. This isn't going to ruin the rest of his life.

Fistful · 29/06/2021 05:34

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

No none of them.

It’s very difficult to buy a house in the area. And once people are in, then they stay for good. People rarely leave the area. I think 2 of ds’s friends moved when he was in infant school, and that’s about it.

And no one ever moves on for work, and your 27 year old’s friends moved away for university? Or weren’t able to afford to live or buy their own place in this fantastically desirable area, so moved somewhere else?
sashh · 29/06/2021 05:30

As others have said he does have options, if he can find a job where you are moving from.

I like the idea of the intensive driving course, I did one for my motorbike licence.

Here's a really 'out there' suggestion but as there is a 'spare' room would you consider having one of his friends move with you? Maybe for a defined time, 3 months or 6 months so your ds has a friend with him to explore his new "really arty / music-led vibe" town.

I've grown to love exploring new places but at 18 it would have been easier with a friend.

Or have his friends on a rota type thing, one weekend he has a friend come to stay, the next he stays with friend in the old town that way when he goes back there are some shared experiences to talk about.

A final thought, rather than access to a car could you fund a second hand camper van? So he can go over to see friends but has somewhere to crash if he wants to stay over.

I know that sounds crazy but a former colleague whose son has autism bought a van so when they visited a place as a family he (son) had his own safe space

PawsQueen · 29/06/2021 00:17

It'll be fine. I grew up in pubs and we often got 2 weeks notice of a move, never saw the accommodation or school before
Moved age 1,3,4,5,10, 13 (2 nurseries, 3 primary schools, 3 secondary schools, 2 colleges and 1 uni..) and then my parents vanished off 3hrs away when I was 18 and left me at uni and holidays with my Nan Grin

The only thing it's left me with is a total hatred of moving Grin and I've lived in the same place since I was 19