Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids that shriek?

285 replies

Turkishangora · 27/06/2021 12:53

Just that really, why?? My 2 don't, not because they're miraculously non shrieking... Because we've drummed it into them not to. I'm not talking toddlers, I'm talking 5+ when they feel the need to shriek, shout and scream all. The. Time

Can you tell my pandemic experience has been framed by the 9 year old twins next door screaming in their garden throughout?

OP posts:
candyflossss · 27/06/2021 15:32

@WorraLiberty was certainly implied.

anyway, wasnt to get into a debate but you both quoted my comment and I'm just saying it isnt anything to do with my mums parenting as we were all brought up the same and very much to do with my sisters character - she is very vocal at times.

FunTimes2020 · 27/06/2021 15:32

@Rabbitheadlights

YABVU ... Some kids shriek my DS is autistic and has sensory processing disorder shrieking is one of the things he does to self regulate. You have no idea of other people's circumstances keep your opinions to yourself and watch for the ledge on that pedastal I suspect you will fall with an almighty bump when one of your perfectly well behaved children mess up.
No need to be bitter and bitchy. OP, I can't bear shrieking kids either!
WorraLiberty · 27/06/2021 15:30

[quote candyflossss]**@XioXio* @WorraLiberty*

who says she was never told to stop? she is one of the loudest people I have ever met. she is told to turn it down all the time. she does for a few minutes and then it's like it goes out of the window. she is just very loud, she always says sorry when she is told to stop. I dont think she means to.

I love when other people on here tell others how to parent as if the thought of simply telling her to stop never occurred to my mum Grin who btw, is a fabulous parent and my sisters loudness is no reflection on her at all - my sister is lovely actually and well behaved generally. she is just very vocal![/quote]
who says she was never told to stop?

I dunno but it certainly wasn't me...

Treehaus · 27/06/2021 15:28

You are being unreasonable to think it's always down to parenting, not unreasonable to find it annoying.

WorraLiberty · 27/06/2021 15:27

[quote Mumdiva99]@WorraLiberty drama llama? Hmmm I'm not the one having a strop over kids playing. I'm telling you all to take a chill pill and leave them be.[/quote]
Perhaps if you turn the drama down a tad, you can concentrate on reading the actual thread. Then you'd realise there was no need for your work of fiction?

Spikeyball · 27/06/2021 15:27

"Admittedly it's probably annoying, but have a bit of compassion for the many parents of kids with additional needs you'll have upset with your post."

Remember there are some children with additional needs who find the sound of screeching and shrieking very distressing. This is why at ds's special school shrieking by those who have control over it, is discouraged including in the playground.

SprinklesMcDoodles · 27/06/2021 15:24

@loopyapp

Let me pause in my day of absent parebtibg to applaud you on successfully repressing your children's happiness to cobforn to your ideal.

Punishing them for being happy and excited and conditioning them to restrain outward representation of their emotions sounds like a well balanced and child focused parenting method.

Personally I think I'll stick to allowing them small blocks of outside play during more neighbour friendly hours and not giving them a complex about how annoying they are when they're happy.

Literally cannot imagine anything sadder than a few kids playing in a pool or with a ball.. Quietly .. How utterly fecking joyless..

Oh and despite their noisy enjoyment of play they can sit respectfully in a restaurant, walk around a supermarket calmly or manage public transport without shrieking.. Funny how allowing them to express themselves appropriately means they can employ restraint when needed..

There’s a huge difference between exuberant play and shrieking. If you don’t teach your kids boundaries or how to be respectful of other people then I feel sorry for them. They’re going to grow up and be the person in the group that everyone is always sick of. If you live out in the middle of nowhere let the kids scream but if you have neighbours then I feel sorry for them. People working nights/twilight shifts obviously get no consideration from you.
Twinsmum2003 · 27/06/2021 15:22

No-one is talking about suppressing joy, just stopping ear splitting shrieks that shred your nerves whether they are from your own kids or others. Nothing is better than children’s laughter. Screams and shrieks are just unpleasant and SN issues aside, they should be reined in FFS.

Permanentlytiredout · 27/06/2021 15:18

There is a big difference between normal playing and excitement noises and screeching and shrieking. I have no issue with hearing kids playing outside and even sometimes shouting to each other, but constant ear splitting shrieking is horrible and they should be told not to if they do not have SN that cause this behaviour. It’s not about discouraging play or breaking their spirit, it’s about teaching your kids what is acceptable in public and to be considerate of other people - they need to understand this as a life skill.

HavelockVetinari · 27/06/2021 15:17

This thread is so incredibly thoughtless to parents who have DC with SEN/disabilities.

I'm lucky that DS (3) doesn't shriek, but I don't think it's my 'superior' parenting.

For many NT kids, you might be able to stop the shrieking through immense persistence, but there are far more kids with SEN out there than many folk seem to think.

Unless you're well acquainted with both the neurological status of the kids and the parenting style of the parents (I.e. you actually know them/socialise with them) then I'd let it slide.

Admittedly it's probably annoying, but have a bit of compassion for the many parents of kids with additional needs you'll have upset with your post.

LoveFall · 27/06/2021 15:16

There is a large complex of daycare centers behind our building. More than six of them in a cluster, catering to different age groups.

At one of them a few off the children shriek all day, with a couple of breaks, presumably for lunch/nap.

It is extremely annoying. Sometimes it triggers a reaction in me bas if a child is being harmed. I am convinced the staff encourage it with chasing games or hiding and leaping out to scare the kids.

There are also kids who cry. I understand that young ones cry, but I agree with the posters who say it is due to parenting/adult supervision or the lack of it.

It drives me crazy when I am trying to concentrate on work. It starts at 8 am and goes until 6 pm.

vivainsomnia · 27/06/2021 15:13

Please tell me how. We have shriekers. Asking/telling them not to, hasn’t proven too successful so far
Of course not, kids usually need more than asking to stop doing something they enjoy.

I warned my kids before going out that if they started being loud, they would be told to come back in. They got one warning, and they then had to come back in. They didn't get to go out again for hours. It didn't take too many instances before they for it.

UhtredRagnarson · 27/06/2021 15:12

@loopyapp

Let me pause in my day of absent parebtibg to applaud you on successfully repressing your children's happiness to cobforn to your ideal.

Punishing them for being happy and excited and conditioning them to restrain outward representation of their emotions sounds like a well balanced and child focused parenting method.

Personally I think I'll stick to allowing them small blocks of outside play during more neighbour friendly hours and not giving them a complex about how annoying they are when they're happy.

Literally cannot imagine anything sadder than a few kids playing in a pool or with a ball.. Quietly .. How utterly fecking joyless..

Oh and despite their noisy enjoyment of play they can sit respectfully in a restaurant, walk around a supermarket calmly or manage public transport without shrieking.. Funny how allowing them to express themselves appropriately means they can employ restraint when needed..

😂😂😂
candyflossss · 27/06/2021 15:10

@loopyapp

Let me pause in my day of absent parebtibg to applaud you on successfully repressing your children's happiness to cobforn to your ideal.

Punishing them for being happy and excited and conditioning them to restrain outward representation of their emotions sounds like a well balanced and child focused parenting method.

Personally I think I'll stick to allowing them small blocks of outside play during more neighbour friendly hours and not giving them a complex about how annoying they are when they're happy.

Literally cannot imagine anything sadder than a few kids playing in a pool or with a ball.. Quietly .. How utterly fecking joyless..

Oh and despite their noisy enjoyment of play they can sit respectfully in a restaurant, walk around a supermarket calmly or manage public transport without shrieking.. Funny how allowing them to express themselves appropriately means they can employ restraint when needed..

🙌🙌
BojackHorsewoman · 27/06/2021 15:10

TV time / screen time privileged removed in our house, after two warnings.

vivainsomnia · 27/06/2021 15:10

Do I live in an alternate universe. Don't we all want to encourage kids outdoors to play, let of steam and be kids
No we really really really don't all want to encourage kids, to be loud, disturbing others and just inconsiderate.

My kids managed to have a great childhood with lots of fun playing outside without screaming, shouting and being a pain.

There's certainly been a common theme amongst the families of such kids I've lived next to: They have parents who are just as loud and inconsiderate and these parents are rarely around in the garden with their kids when they are screeching. They ne er call their kids back inside when they do.

RickiTarr · 27/06/2021 15:10

Insisting that DC don’t do really annoying thing seems to be advanced ninja parenting, unavailable to most of the world, for some reason. 🤷🏻‍♀️

LakieLady · 27/06/2021 15:09

@Justyouwaitandseeagain

Please tell me how. We have shriekers. Asking/telling them not to, hasn’t proven too successful so far.
A warning, followed by time out if he persisted, worked for my DSS.
loopyapp · 27/06/2021 15:08

Let me pause in my day of absent parebtibg to applaud you on successfully repressing your children's happiness to cobforn to your ideal.

Punishing them for being happy and excited and conditioning them to restrain outward representation of their emotions sounds like a well balanced and child focused parenting method.

Personally I think I'll stick to allowing them small blocks of outside play during more neighbour friendly hours and not giving them a complex about how annoying they are when they're happy.

Literally cannot imagine anything sadder than a few kids playing in a pool or with a ball.. Quietly .. How utterly fecking joyless..

Oh and despite their noisy enjoyment of play they can sit respectfully in a restaurant, walk around a supermarket calmly or manage public transport without shrieking.. Funny how allowing them to express themselves appropriately means they can employ restraint when needed..

LakieLady · 27/06/2021 15:04

@AcrossthePond55

Children with SEN aside, I agree with OP. I don't mind the noise or the normal shouting/yelling that goes on with children playing. But the intentional screaming is just too much.

We recently returned from a camping trip to Disney World. Two sites over was a family group with two little girls who thought it the height of hilarity to have 'screaming contests'. They'd stand facing each other and take turns emitting ear piercing shrieks to (apparently) see who could scream the loudest. No one on that campsite batted an eyelash, in fact at one point they applauded and judged who was loudest! Eventually someone must have called the reception outpost because a CM was dispatched to ask them nicely to pipe down as they were disturbing other guests. To their credit the family did comply and other than normal play noise the two little girls were kept quiet.

I feel your pain.

My ex and I once cut short a camping holiday because of a family of shriekers on the same site. They started before 8am and didn't go to bed till 10.00. We got sick of spending all our time and not being able to just sit and chill now and again.

We thought they'd be going home on the Sunday, but it turned out that it was half-term and they were staying all week.

candyflossss · 27/06/2021 15:02

@XioXio @WorraLiberty

who says she was never told to stop? she is one of the loudest people I have ever met. she is told to turn it down all the time. she does for a few minutes and then it's like it goes out of the window. she is just very loud, she always says sorry when she is told to stop. I dont think she means to.

I love when other people on here tell others how to parent as if the thought of simply telling her to stop never occurred to my mum Grin who btw, is a fabulous parent and my sisters loudness is no reflection on her at all - my sister is lovely actually and well behaved generally. she is just very vocal!

CagneyNYPD · 27/06/2021 15:02

@Mumdiva99

Omg....this is one of the few times I read MN and think WTAF!!! Kids are shrieking in the garden and there is outrage. Seriously. One person is moaning because the dad is out with the kids playing noisy games.

Do I live in an alternate universe. Don't we all want to encourage kids outdoors to play, let of steam and be kids.

Oh no....we should be supressing their natural exuberance. Control those children who are having fun. Stop the play. And god forbid if adults actually encourage it. Don't forget children should be seen and not heard......

That would be me "moaning about the dad playing outside with his kids". Except I'm not. I am stating that playing outside on the street with your children, running up and down shrieking and shouting at the top of your voices for hours on end is not normal, neighbourly behavior. Especially when you have just moved in and you have a decent sized rear and front gardens.
BojackHorsewoman · 27/06/2021 14:58

It definitely isn't NOTHING to do with parenting. Some parents may be fighting a losing battle. Some are just shit.

TentTalk · 27/06/2021 14:56

Some kids (people) are naturally shrill. And yes, as a parent you can reduce it, but if it's their natural pitch you can feel as though you are telling them off constantly which I'd imagine is horrible when they shriek out of excitement and joy - give them a surprise or a gift and then tell them off. Take them to their favourite place, tell them of. Must be horrible.

I've been blessed with 2 non-shriekers. It's nothing to do with my parenting.

BojackHorsewoman · 27/06/2021 14:51

@thewreckingcrew

We have a beer garden behind our house, one with children's play equipment.

I can tell you now, the adults make way more loud irritating noises than the children do, especially men.

Yes, that can also be true. Especially when England are playing football! Luckily they don't do well enough internationally for that to be a common occurrence 🤭