Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids that shriek?

285 replies

Turkishangora · 27/06/2021 12:53

Just that really, why?? My 2 don't, not because they're miraculously non shrieking... Because we've drummed it into them not to. I'm not talking toddlers, I'm talking 5+ when they feel the need to shriek, shout and scream all. The. Time

Can you tell my pandemic experience has been framed by the 9 year old twins next door screaming in their garden throughout?

OP posts:
candyflossss · 27/06/2021 16:46

you can repeatedly tell a child to be quiet/keep the level down all you want - if they are loud then they are naturally loud. like I said my sister is generally well behaved in all other aspects, does well in school and is charming (albeit a little cheeky at times!) but she does operate a good decimal above the rest of our family.

that's nothing to do with lazy parenting - she gets told all the time, asked to come in when shes getting too much. she remembers to keep it down for all of a few minutes and then gets excited all over again. in comparison me and my other sister are a lot more shy in real life than she is.

I would hate if she was constantly punished though for being who she is. I acknowledge some people really cannot tolerate it but I think some people genuinely are just a lot louder.

kindaclassy · 27/06/2021 16:37

Same parents who want their little darlings to "express themselves" and let them jump on people's furniture, scribble on walls... Lazy parenting at its best.

kindaclassy · 27/06/2021 16:33

Sadly, there are too many lazy parents around.

The ones who pretend that "kids need to have fun" and its not possible to enjoy yourself without shrieking.

Most of us manage to have children enjoying garden, parks, anything without ridiculous amount of noise though. It's not just adults who are bothered, it's other children too! Parks, beaches, playgrounds, parties.. all full of children having fun, only a couple shrieking and smug lazy parents thinking everybody else is enjoying the show.

Pretending that the only choices are silent repressed bored children or feral ones is ridiculous.

You are not doing your children any favour whatsoever when you don't bother to set up a few easy rules.

Wearywithteens · 27/06/2021 16:31

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

User135644 · 27/06/2021 16:26

@MissMissTorrance

Dd's friend (10) is a shrieker and I've had to tell DD she is not allowed to invite her into the house anymore as she frightens our dog and makes me feel very anxious. I've also stopped inviting this particular friend on trips out to the park/shops with us as it's just too much. I've asked her to quieten down a bit, as has my DD ( who isn't a shrieker) but a couple of minutes later she's at it again.
Sensory conditions aside, that really isn't normal at 10 years old! They'll be starting senior school next year.

I can't bear it.

loopyapp · 27/06/2021 16:19

@vivainsomnia

I feel enormously sorry for any child that is repeatedly told to "be quiet" I never told my kids to keep quiet but to take it down one or two levels.

I also taught them that their joy, happiness and fun are not more worthy than anyone else, ie. that consideration for others go a long way.

The selfishness of some people is unbelievable.

The lack of ability to actually read everything I said or decision to cherry pick what suits you adequately makes my point.

I clearly stated, three times now, that my children are considerate of their neighbours by adhering to the play schedule we agreed on that minimises interruption of the adult neighbours without need to nag happy children to "take it down one or two levels".

That said I would rather a load of uptight strangers online think I'm selfish than my children paranoid about having fun!!!

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 27/06/2021 16:19

YABU. You don't what's wrong with a child. I'm delighted your kids are perfect little Saints and enjoy the smugness but You don't know how your own are going turn out in 10 or 15 years into the future.

chickenyhead · 27/06/2021 16:18

I do find that one person's interpretation of shrieking can be different to another's. My child giggling, literally giggling, enrages my neighbour hugely. We only let her out there for a few (separate) hours a day during weekends. It just isn't worth the aggro.

Twinsmum2003 · 27/06/2021 16:14

@loopyapp

Have another read of my post and try again.

I live in a very close knit street and I know all my neighbours very well. I did say they get small blocks of outdoor play during neighbor friendly time.

I also clearly stated that they manage public spaces just fine without any carrying on because they are permitted healthy outlets of their emotions without being told they're an inconvenience!

I feel enormously sorry for any child that is repeatedly told to "be quiet" and admonished to their room or denied privilages because keeping up appearances is more important to their highly strung and rigid parents.

And again, you are suggesting those who don’t want to put up with shrieking and screaming are crushing their children’s spirits and trying to keep up appearances with their robot children but that wasn’t what OP and many others are trying to say. Laughter, giggles and yells of excitement are delightful and I could listen to them all day long. Screeching is like fingernails down a blackboard, so while I want my children to be happy, they learned that screeching isn’t okay, in the same way that biting, hitting and destructive behaviour isn’t. I’m not sure why you have gone straight to insinuating that you want your children to be happier than other parents do?
prettyLittlefool · 27/06/2021 16:12

It is just terrible parenting in my opinion. Sensory problems or not it can be nipped in the bud

Gorkastalker · 27/06/2021 16:10

Mine play loudly, which sometimes involves shrieking. It is what it is, tbh. One has ADHD, but the other doesn't, so can't even blame it on that!!

showerbeer · 27/06/2021 16:09

I’m a teacher (and I used to teach eyfs) so I’m essentially desensitised to children screaming in work hours. My classroom is right on the playground so I get a couple of hours of children screaming outside my windows while I’m trying to teach a bunch of ten year olds how to multiply fractions.
I can just about deal with it in work and then when I leave work I can’t even have the radio on in the car because I feel so “noised out”. The sound of children shrieking would probably finish me off.
I think it’s plain for anyone to see that there’s a difference between a child with SEN shrieking and one who is just being noisy.

vivainsomnia · 27/06/2021 16:04

I feel enormously sorry for any child that is repeatedly told to "be quiet"
I never told my kids to keep quiet but to take it down one or two levels.

I also taught them that their joy, happiness and fun are not more worthy than anyone else, ie. that consideration for others go a long way.

The selfishness of some people is unbelievable.

CoffeeBlackNoSugar · 27/06/2021 16:00

YANBU.

As a parent with autism I can not cope with screeching. Just cannot cope with it. So there is zero tolerance for screeching in my family. All my children tried screeching but were taught not to, you know to be tolerant of other people.

I once went to the supermarket and there was a child there screeching. I could barely finish the shop and had to spend the rest of the day in my bed because of the sensory overload. I didn't know if the child had SN or not, it didn't particularly matter as the result to me was the same.

If you have a screecher, for whatever reason. I think it's only kind to be aware of the affect their behaviour has on others. So yes, you don't leave them to play out in the garden all day everyday if they're continually screaming!

vivainsomnia · 27/06/2021 15:58

Kids shrieking is very hard on the nerves,but the worse is by far their parents who don't care and think it's their right to do so.

Last year my nerves were tested so badly, kids in the garden, shrieking, screaming, fighting for hours on hands, no parent to be seen, I finally snapped and asked them to keep down. Firm voice but not shouting.

They ran inside the house and came the mother, a rare sight, who want on to tell me not to speak to her kids. I calmly said that it me very anxious to listen to her kids shrieking as it made my heart rate go up every time. She responded with a few F words the sane than some parents here have that their kids were entitled to have fun, be as loud as it makes them happy, and if I didn't like it, it was tough. I dreaded the nice days again, but amazingly, one day I came home from work and they were gone. A new family came, two kids, who also e joy the nice garden. They laugh, have fun, but don't scream and shout. They are lovely. Completely different experience.

Gothichouse40 · 27/06/2021 15:55

I think it's actually got worse. If a child has a health issue that is the reason for the screaming, of course that is completely different. When I was younger and of course being a child myself, it was only toddlers that engaged in this behaviour. Nowadays I cannot count the amount of times I'm in cafe or restaurant and there is always, without fail a screaming child, but what is surprising is it's not toddlers. Im talking 8, 9 and 10 year olds who ( unless the children have health/spectrum issues) are usually well past this stage. Im sorry but I cannot stand that high- pitched screaming. I never let my own two away with it and glad to say my grandchild very rarely does it. Babies and toddlers scream and I do make allowances that at times it can be very difficult to calm children down.

Ritascornershop · 27/06/2021 15:54

My niece and nephew, neuro-typical kids, shrieked constantly and I found it completely stressful, as did my kids (who were each one year younger than their cousins). Their parents never said boo to them about it, it wasn’t a priority to them. I think (when not SN) it’s nature and nurture.

loopyapp · 27/06/2021 15:52

Have another read of my post and try again.

I live in a very close knit street and I know all my neighbours very well. I did say they get small blocks of outdoor play during neighbor friendly time.

I also clearly stated that they manage public spaces just fine without any carrying on because they are permitted healthy outlets of their emotions without being told they're an inconvenience!

I feel enormously sorry for any child that is repeatedly told to "be quiet" and admonished to their room or denied privilages because keeping up appearances is more important to their highly strung and rigid parents.

Royalbloo · 27/06/2021 15:49

YANBU I cannot stand it and mine doesn't do it

RoseMartha · 27/06/2021 15:46

One of my dc teens shrieks a lot, she does have asd though. However it is disturbing and annoying. Trying to train her to not do it.,

theliverpoolone · 27/06/2021 15:44

@Spikeyball absolutely. My dd has SN and has always been very sensitive to loud noises - she would become very distressed if another child shrieked near her. Other parents who commented on how sensitive she was weren't wrong, but it would have been appreciated if they'd have also told their dc's to tone down the shrieking, rather than smiling indulgently Hmm

WorraLiberty · 27/06/2021 15:43

@Twinsmum2003

No-one is talking about suppressing joy, just stopping ear splitting shrieks that shred your nerves whether they are from your own kids or others. Nothing is better than children’s laughter. Screams and shrieks are just unpleasant and SN issues aside, they should be reined in FFS.
I know, I'd like to say I'm surprised that isn't painstakingly obvious but reading the replies, it seems that to a minority on this thread it isn't.

I can't imagine how home schooling went during lockdown, if reading and comprehension is that bad.

Still, bonus points for some of the creative writing in some of the replies.

Kneel · 27/06/2021 15:35

Oh man. It's breaking their spirit to teach a NT child that prolonged screaming and screeching is not on? That's hilarious!

FakeColinCaterpillar · 27/06/2021 15:34

I have neighbours with 3 primary age children, can hardly hear them when they are outside. Next door to them are 2 children (one primary, one secondary) who alternate between shrieking and shouting all bloody day. The dad comes outside and basically shouts every single bloody word he says.
I actually know them, there’s no SN, they are generally very inconsiderate people anyway. Their neighbour told me it also is the same in the house and she can hear it through the walls from 6am, so should be pleased I don’t live next to them.

iwantadogdhdoesnt · 27/06/2021 15:34

My 3 year olds natural speaking voice is REALLY loud. Drives me insane as I am very intolerant of loud noises. My 6 year old operates at a normal volume. Other than to remind her to speak in a normal voice not sure what else one is meant to do? Thankfully she doesn't shriek but she is loud