Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids that shriek?

285 replies

Turkishangora · 27/06/2021 12:53

Just that really, why?? My 2 don't, not because they're miraculously non shrieking... Because we've drummed it into them not to. I'm not talking toddlers, I'm talking 5+ when they feel the need to shriek, shout and scream all. The. Time

Can you tell my pandemic experience has been framed by the 9 year old twins next door screaming in their garden throughout?

OP posts:
Spikeyball · 27/06/2021 17:41

"There are different things in life that can upset a range of people but you cannot adjust your behaviour all the time."

Yes but you can show consideration for other people and not do things that you can easily not do when you know that doing them distresses others. I guarantee that there are things that my severely learning disabled teenage son might do if I always let him fully express himself that you wouldn't like being done around you.

ViciousJackdaw · 27/06/2021 17:40

@Goldenbear I'm sorry, are you trying to be sarcastic there? It's just that finding the juvenile screech to be earsplitting isn't really an original opinion. Many people cannot abide it, as you will have already discovered. It has nothing to do with 'curtailing joy' and everything to do with the fact that high pitched squeals, screams and screeches are painful.

thecognoscenti · 27/06/2021 17:38

YANBU. Additional needs aside it's horrible. Not every kid who shrieks has SEN. Some just have parents who can't be bothered to stop them and don't care that other people (some of whom might have additional needs themselves) are being disturbed.

Goldenbear · 27/06/2021 17:37

Some great detective work there, I literally posted the fact that I don't think it is the end of the world or even unacceptable that children shriek occasionally. I have never come across children shrieking morning/noon and night but it seems the OP has say perhaps I don't really have a right to comment.

BojackHorsewoman · 27/06/2021 17:34

I did say "preparation for school and adult life". For clarity, this did not mean that I believed that 9/10 year olds were starting work right now.

Yaykyay · 27/06/2021 17:34

@Goldenbear

'Lazy parenting'?? No just not micro managing parent! That's the way my DD and her friends tend to expres their feelings of happiness, I wouldn't curtail that as it is momentary and actually lovely to see that level of joy over not much, there's an innocence to it which I think is beautiful.
Sounds like you're one of the parents op is talking about.
Goldenbear · 27/06/2021 17:32

ViciousJackdaw, really original opinion you have there.

There's not a problem with school and last time I checked 9/10 year olds don't go to work in this country so interview preparation a long way off.

BojackHorsewoman · 27/06/2021 17:28

And this is much better preparation for adult and school life where "sorry teacher, I'm just expressing myself" or "sorry I'm not coming for interview as it isn't how I express myself" obviously won't work out so well.

ViciousJackdaw · 27/06/2021 17:28

@Goldenbear

'Lazy parenting'?? No just not micro managing parent! That's the way my DD and her friends tend to expres their feelings of happiness, I wouldn't curtail that as it is momentary and actually lovely to see that level of joy over not much, there's an innocence to it which I think is beautiful.
That's nice. Personally, I find it fucking annoying.
Goldenbear · 27/06/2021 17:28

Well I'm referencing my experience which has been in my house. I'm not sure we can curtail natural exuberance whatever our good intentions. There are different things in life that can upset a range of people but you cannot adjust your behaviour all the time. One of the girls in my DDs friendship group cannot curtail it so there isn't much you can do about it.

Yaykyay · 27/06/2021 17:27

All of the kids shrieking aren't autistic, have tourettes or other neuro divesity. Sorry but they just aren't.

So yes that might be your individual circumstances, but come on they aren't the circumstances of every child.

BojackHorsewoman · 27/06/2021 17:26

Expressing yourself is wonderful, until it encroaches on other people to an unacceptable extent. So, children giggling, squealing occasionally, chattering, sometimes crying because they're upset, all those normal noises are what you expect living with or near children. But screaming as if you have been stabbed is not what people expect to hear for a significant portion of the day with children nearby. Of course SEN is different or someone screaming because they're genuinely terrified. But when children include full blown screaming as part of their daily playtime, it is inconsiderate parenting not to even attempt to encourage them to rein it in. That isn't proactive parenting. And parents who don't allow it aren't controlling "everything their DC does" or "uptight". There are many aspects of play parents obviously don't have any involvement with, but when it becomes dangerous (eg jumping on someone's head) or bothers most other people who happen to be in the vicinity, yes, for me, then it's time to get involved.

Smokeymirror · 27/06/2021 17:25

lol it’s clear on here which parents have the shriekers !! How ridiculous to say it’s breaking their spirit by not allowing them to shriek like banshees annoying everyone around them? Playing and laughter is lovely, sn aside there is zero need for shrieking snd squealing!

Spikeyball · 27/06/2021 17:20

What about the upset it causes other children?

Goldenbear · 27/06/2021 17:20

My DD and her friends are most certainly happy when this happens as it is expression of joy that can't be articulated with words, the joy is beyond words. I'm sure they will grow out of it but in the mean time yes, they are expressing who they are.

Goldenbear · 27/06/2021 17:15

I don't get it - what's the catch and joke about 'expressing themselves'. Yes, I like my children to express themselves and not in a fashion that I decide.

Far from 'lazy parent', I actually think it's harder on a parent to advocate this type of parenting as it is mocked quite a bit and uptight parents tend to hate that you don't control your children in every aspect of their lives.

kindaclassy · 27/06/2021 17:10

see? Didn't take long about the "expressing themselves" bollocks Grin.

They ALL express themselves. Shrieking and screaming is really not necessary. It's hardly a sign of happiness either, it sounds too hysterical to be healthy.

But lazy parents can't be bothered, it's a shame.

Couchbettato · 27/06/2021 17:10

Yanbu op.

My cousin's kids come visit during the day sometimes when I'm working because my nan is off work and we live together.

They're shriekers and it's made working from home unbearable but I'm just not in a position to go back into the office.

Also the sound of shrieking kids makes my ovaries shrivel.

Goldenbear · 27/06/2021 17:08

'Lazy parenting'?? No just not micro managing parent! That's the way my DD and her friends tend to expres their feelings of happiness, I wouldn't curtail that as it is momentary and actually lovely to see that level of joy over not much, there's an innocence to it which I think is beautiful.

billy1966 · 27/06/2021 17:07

IMO there is a world of difference between happy excited fun, which can be a bit noisy and shrieking.

Shrieking is something else entirely and it's about being just noisy.

Laughi g and having great fun doesn't involve non stop shrieking in my experience.

I have no problem with one but the other is intolerable and goes through me.

NewlyGranny · 27/06/2021 17:03

iwantadog, have you tried whispering games with your 3yo? You can download various volume monitoring apps, too, with fun graphics where you can show her how loud your voice and her sibling's and her own are and let her play around with finding a level.

Is she struggling with her hearing at all? Or is she struggling to be heard through family conversations? Shouting children often seem to come from talkative families where they struggle to get a word in. As the youngest, she might be strategising the shouting just to get her share of airtime. She's old enough to ask, I'd say.

You'll never have to worry about her not speaking up for herself, though!

Goldenbear · 27/06/2021 17:01

YABU, we are not all the same! Some children are more animated than others, that's personality. My DD and her friends who are 9/10 tend to shriek quite a bit when together, her 14 year old brother finds it amusing and irritating but unless it is ridiculous I don't think it should be controlled.

DroopyClematis · 27/06/2021 16:56

And no... no SEN.

DroopyClematis · 27/06/2021 16:55

I don't mind children squealing with delight or shrieking with fun but I really object to constant screaming.
I have neighbours whose two delightful, junior age children scream... all the time... constantly.
Only respite is during school hours.
Neighbours feel the same. We daren't say anything for fear of nastiness.
Interesting that the children are outside yet both back doors are shut and no adult outside.
Even their poor dog is outside, all the time, just barking and whining.
Pisses me off and our neighbours.

NewlyGranny · 27/06/2021 16:55

vivainsomnia, I would have been tempted to hang over the fence and shriek full volume at the mother. And at the kids every time they did. It might have given them a moment of pause and it would certainly have been therapeutic for you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread