Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Swimming

108 replies

yesokthen · 26/06/2021 07:26

Aibu to wonder how far your child can swim? I understand the National goal is that kids can swim 25 metres by the end of primary but I keep hearing of all these 5 year olds and younger that can already do this.

OP posts:
Xmassprout · 26/06/2021 15:46

My 4 year started waterbabies at 6 weeks old and can't swim. She could go quite some distance with a float if she wanted to. But she doesn't really enjoy the class structure and stubbornly refuses to do half the stuff. With more confidence and willingness she would most likely achieve a lot more but I'm not that fussed, I'm not going to force her and make her reluctant to go into the water at all

Looubylou · 26/06/2021 15:39

My son is 10 but hasn't swam since he was 8 due to pandemic. He learnt at 5 - just with occasional visits to pool with me. He very quickly could swim 10m and last time he went could def. do 25m. However, he is not interested in how far he can swim - he much prefers to be under water swimming or collecting diving toys. He flatly refuses to go to classes, which is a shame as he is confident and fast but has no style at all 😂

mog27 · 26/06/2021 15:32

@willstarttomorrow I completely agree it's more about the technique than distance now. Mine are teenagers now and were extremely lucky that my sister is a swim coach so we had free lessons. Both my sister and myself have swam competitively at national level and it was definitely more a focus on distance when we were younger.

willstarttomorrow · 26/06/2021 15:27

Like PP have pointed out, most swim schools now focus on building good technique rather than distance. DD started proper swimming lessons at around 4 and moved up pretty quickly but got a bit stuck at level 6 because her left foot position when doing breast stroke. She is now 14 and no longer has lessons but could swim 1/2 mile and did junior life guarding before she stopped in year 6. I think this is pretty standard for children who carry on through the stages although lots drop out when they can swim reasonably well.

AledsiPad · 26/06/2021 15:24

DS3 is 9 and in year 4. They’ve been swimming with school this half term. Usually, the ones who can only do a couple of sessions then stop going. This year, there are so few able to do 25m that all 90 are completing the course.

COVID has affected things like children’s swimming hugely.

Incidentally, my DS can swim 25m, but we paid for very expensive 1:1 lessons a couple of years ago to get him to a stage where he was safe around water as he has ASD so couldn’t cope with group lessons. His progress was rapid, and we’ve swum with the DC as much as possible over the past year or so because we live near the coast and need them to be safe. They (DC3 & DD, who is 7) are definitely the outliers in their peer groups for their swimming at the moment though.

ChocolateCakeYum · 26/06/2021 15:21

Ds is 7 and still uses a float to swim on his front. On his back he happily swims around like an otter.

He gets free lessons through his school (they have their own pool) and I used to take him but he’s not progressed very far yet. Plenty of time. I couldn’t swim until I was 10. Within a few months I was doing the 1500m.

mog27 · 26/06/2021 15:16

Honestly it depends on the child. My eldest wasn't a natural swimmer and done his 25m and gave up, he was around 8 when he did that and I didn't want to push him into something he wasn't enjoying. The youngest is totally different, she swam her mile at 7 and took to swimming straight away. She's gone on to swim for her primary and secondary schools and has always done well.

I think every child is different and for me the goal was teaching them to swim so they could be safe in the water. Every child has different abilities and won't be good at everything plus with all the pools being closed this past year I don't think you can put an age on anything because they've lost a year of lessons.

BabyFartsDoStink · 26/06/2021 15:07

We have a 7m old and are a few lessons in. I don't have much expectation about when he will swim properly. He just likes going, and with me back at work, it's our only activity. DH and I rotate.

I think for us it's water exposure and the social side. We like seeing him so happy and that's enough.

Paddingtonthebear · 26/06/2021 15:04

Mine is 8yrs old, has done 100m but the swim school she is with focuses more on technique and stamina than ticking off the big distances. She can do all four strokes proficiently, her front crawl with side breathing is way better than mine. Lots of swim schools just go for distance awards but technique is often flappy, head-up swimming. They also cover proper water safety skills too which is v important

SaltAndVinegarSandwiches · 26/06/2021 14:36

I also think technique is much more important. MY now 9 year old at 7 could technically swim 20m but it was what my husband called slow drowning. Basically a frantic doggy paddle where he barely kept himself above the surface and used up every ounce of energy and endurance he had. He didn't want to go under water or get his face wet so he wasn't in the correct position. Once he got over his fear of the water he progressed really quickly and learned a decent technique in 3 strokes in a few months of private lessons. He is definitely not a natural sportsman so if he can do it almost any other kid can! DD on the other hand at 5 could swim 10m but with a decent technique and made steady progress all the way up to now where she can swim distances confidently.

kindaclassy · 26/06/2021 14:28

Mumsnet will be full of super swimmers all doing 100m at 4 years old.

smirk aside, I don't think there was one child in my kids class who didn't take swimming lesson from reception and earlier, Y1 at the very latest. All the swimming clubs always have very long waiting lists.

Lockdown has messed up everything, but swimming lessons are considered a basic for most families, so children DO swim.

25m is one length in many swimming pools, some are much longer obviously. It's hardly comparable to running a marathon.

SirenSays · 26/06/2021 14:22

I got my 1500m badge in year 4. My neice has just turned 8 and can do 5m unaided or 10m with a float. She has a real issue with her face getting wet though so it's a slow process.

looptheloopinahulahoop · 26/06/2021 14:00

I just had a look at my son's swimming badges and certificates. He got his 800m and ASA silver awards in the week he started secondary school.

looptheloopinahulahoop · 26/06/2021 13:54

Actually I could swim 400m when I left primary but was definitely get down the pool any old how, mainly on my back and legs only!

looptheloopinahulahoop · 26/06/2021 13:54

Mumsnet will be full of super swimmers all doing 100m at 4 years old

Grin Mine hadn't even started swimming lessons at 4 :) He started learning when he was about 5.5.

I could swim 50m when I left primary but it was "get down the pool any old how" whereas he could swim properly with decent stroke technique.

SmokeyDevil · 26/06/2021 13:50

25m seems like a tiny amount to expect a child to be able to do by the end of primary school. Based on my rather small swimming pool at school, that's 1.5 lengths or 3 widths. Confused We could do that from the age of 4 (widths only, they wouldn't let us go to the deep end until we were taller).

Swimming club from age 8 consisted of about 20 lengths as a warm up. Then you got way more for actual tuition, and then more for a cool down. This wasn't even a competitive team or anything, you took part in competitions if you wanted, but it wasn't expected. This was to get you fitter and stronger in water.

If a kid is only expected to be able to swim 25m by the time it's 11, and that's all they can do, I'd be very worried about their fitness level as that's very low. They stand no chance in the sea. Sad Just quite worrying really as people will expect that they are competent then but they most likely aren't, that's how you end up in dangerous situations.

Glittertwins · 26/06/2021 12:11

As long as your DC enjoy the swimming, they'll get there in their own time.

One of them is now top 10 in the region on fly now despite having zero coordination and being kept down a level because they couldn't do it.

Gibbonsgibbonsgibbons · 26/06/2021 11:52

My older kids could both do that easily at 6yrs old but my current 6 yr old hasn't been able to start lessons & didnt even get to go swimming with us for months so I suspect there will be a cohort of kids who are "behind" by age due to COVID restrictions.

im2sad · 26/06/2021 11:38

My 6 year old can, I'd say that's pretty average for around here. There's one older child in her class but the others look the same age. I'd say 90% of her class take lessons and are at a similar level.

funtimefrank · 26/06/2021 11:34

We were lucky that mine had swimming lessons at the council pool from 3.5 when we moved here. We hit a patch where they had a gap and once they were in they were in.

They had lessons from them until yr 5 and by the end were swimming a mile. We stopped because they got through all the levels and next stop was proper swimming club which they weren't good enough/interested in.

School took them for a term in yr 4 I think. They have just taken those in their class who don't have their 25m (yr 6) and about 50% of them went.

TeenMinusTests · 26/06/2021 11:25

The primary school my DDs went to is within walking distance of a swimming pool.
When they did lessons in y4, both times about 1/3rd were non swimmers, another 1/3 could swim but couldn't swim 1 length, and 1/3rd were reasonable.
I used to help walk to swimming not just when my DDs year had swimming but other years too. Some years they needed an extra teacher as there were so many non swimmers. Once I saw a child unable to even walk across the very shallow 'learner pool' without holding onto the edge.

Swimming lessons were great for DD2. It was the only thing she was better at than most of the class throughout primary. It is such a shame there were only 6 or 8 lessons.

Usernamenotallowed · 26/06/2021 10:55

My kids go to the pool at least 3 times a week on top of their swimming lessons which probably makes a difference. My 6 year old can swim over 400m doing proper strokes. My 4 year old can't do proper strokes but can get across the length of the pool, mostly under water. He's just started to learn front crawl this month.

Tigger85 · 26/06/2021 10:51

My D's is 3 and can't swim at all, he went to water babies until I couldn't afford it anymore and used to be able to surface then hold onto the side, now he would just sink. He's on the waiting list for swimming lessons but they are only allowing older children to have lessons, presumably because covid restrictions mean parents are not allowed poolside and children are expected to change themselves alone.

Badassbreastfeeder85 · 26/06/2021 10:33

I took my son swimming every week from 3 months and he loved it and was pretty good when he started formal lessons at 4,by 5 he could do 25m+ and 200m+ by 6

Robostripes · 26/06/2021 10:22

My 5 year old in reception started lessons in September, they were interrupted by Covid between November and March so it felt almost like starting again when he went back. He could happily swim doggy paddle with arm bands before he started lessons and now, almost at the end of the year, is almost there swimming 5m without any aids, but sometimes still puts his feet down. I’m happy with his progress! In his class there are a few who can swim well who had proper lessons before Covid, lots who haven’t started lessons and the rest at the same sort of level as he is.
25m by the end of primary seems perfectly achievable if most start lessons around 5.