Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What would you think if you saw this dog?

262 replies

Tailbetweenlegs · 25/06/2021 10:47

I’ve bought my dog a bright yellow harness and lead that say I NEED SPACE and NERVOUS in big letters. I got it because he’s a nervous rescue and doesn’t like strange dogs approaching, and can be nervous of people getting too close/if they startle him (he barked and snapped at a woman the other week who I didn’t see come running behind me which prompted me to buy this).
We’re working with a trainer and he’s improved a bit but I think there will always be a management aspect to his behaviour (fairly sure he’s not bitten anyone in his history, not let off the lead, he’s never around children so I don’t think he’s a danger to anyone).

I walked him in his new outfit today and a man rolled his eyes and dramatically jumped out of the way, a woman stopped me to ask if he was nervous (really!) and a woman with a dog walked right past with her dog staring at mine. I normally walk in quiet places, this was just a quick trip round the block and happened to be busier than normal.

So should I not bother with an I NEED SPACE lead/harness. I’m interested to hear how it comes across and what you’d think if you saw a dog in this/if you’d notice. I just mean it as a warning so people give us a bit of a wide berth so they aren’t startled if they get barked at by quite a big dog. I don’t expect people to go massively out of their way to avoid us (he’s on a short lead anyway) but I’m worried it comes across as passive aggressive or will invite attention which is the opposite of what I want. Dog people and dog haters (I know there’s a lot on here) what would you think?

OP posts:
ProfessorPootle · 25/06/2021 13:10

I have a very friendly dog show likes to approach others, I have met dogs with these harnesses on and we keep a distance. Don’t always notice them though until we’re quite close when walking past on pavement.

loubylou1010 · 25/06/2021 13:09

If I see another dog on a lead I always immediately put mine on a lead until we get past, also if I see even a hint of yellow on a dog I still put the lead on as quite often you can't tell until you get closer if if it says anything or if it's just a yellow lead/collar.

JustMeAndWheatley · 25/06/2021 13:08

I would think you were a fantastic dog owner, trying to do the right thing for your dog, other dogs, and people around. It’s quite common to see people with helpful harnesses where I walk my dogs.

Rae36 · 25/06/2021 13:06

I would think that I shouldn't approach your dog or let my kids approach it. I wouldn't think any more about it than that.

If I did think any more about it i would probably assume it was a rescue dog that had had a tricky time and would be glad it had found a good owner in you.

These harnesses and jackets are not uncommon where we live.

RincewindsHat · 25/06/2021 13:05

I'd think you were a caring and considerate dog owner and I would make sure to respect your dog's clearly identified needs and give you space. I'd make sure my two gave you a wide berth or would put them on the lead if we were on a narrower path where space was an issue.

People ignoring your harness are idiots.

TuttiFrutti · 25/06/2021 13:01

I think the yellow harness is a great idea.

However, I agree with previous posters that you should keep out of other people's way rather than expecting them to keep out of yours. Not everyone looks where they are going, some people are idiots but also some people are running/cycling and won't have time to read the sign on the harness.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 25/06/2021 13:00

I think that its a good idea to have these warnings, although people who don't own dogs may not see them until they are close up.

A muzzel - suitable for exercise - is probably much more of a clear signal to most people to keep away.

Fitforforty · 25/06/2021 12:56

@Snoopysimaginaryfriend

‘a woman with a dog walked right past with her dog staring at mine.’

I get some people are idiots but I can’t dictate what my dog looks at when he’s walking down the road!

It’s also unreasonable to say they ‘walked right past’. Where should they walk? If your dog has the problem you move out of the way.

I completely agree with this.
Douchebaggette · 25/06/2021 12:51

Off tangent a bit but no dog should be wearing a soft muzzle for exercise if it holds their mouth shut - they are for very short periods of time, such as a vet examination or injection.

While exercising the dog should be able to pant and breathe normally so the muzzle must allow the dog to open their mouth naturally.

IntermittentParps · 25/06/2021 12:41

I would worry hugely about a large animal with behaviour issues significant enough for you to feel that this harness was necessary, being kept as a domestic pet.
Don't be so silly.

Those shouty leads are a bit passive aggressive I really don't see how Confused

OP, some people on here are being daft, as was the man
who rolled his eyes. TBF to the woman I think she might have wanted to initiate a chat about the dog. The other woman staring might not have seen that sort of harness before.

I see a few dogs with these harnesses and just sort of think 'note to self', if anything (I don't approach people's dogs anyway, unless the person invites me and/or the dog looks very obviously as if it's wanting to greet me). I would certainly be careful not to squeeze past you in a narrow space like a pavement if I saw this harness. I think it's a helpful thing for you to do.

LolaSmiles · 25/06/2021 12:41

inappropriateraspberry
I think the issue is that some people think using a coloured lead is enough of a precaution for a dog who is liable to snap.

My friend's dog is lovely, but nervous. She uses a lead with nervous on because her dog is better being left alone. She doesn't want strangers or random dogs approaching.. Her dog isn't dangerous and the lead is because her dog's walk is better and happier if people and other dogs don't bother her.

There's other people who have a dog who is likely to be reactive, likely to snap, etc. They want a bubble around their dog and some of these people stick a yellow lead on their dog and then think that if someone passes on the pavement and their dog snaps that everyone else should have known known keep away from their snappy dog.
It's this second group who are problematic.

user1471538283 · 25/06/2021 12:38

It is a great idea! I raised my DS to always ask if he could pet someone's dog because you just don't know if the dog is friendly, in a mood, does not like touch etc. If I saw a dog in this outfit I wouldn't ask and I would give him space.

You are being responsible. Some people are just idiots.

TheHoundsofLove · 25/06/2021 12:33

I’ve also got a nervous rescue dog. Tbh, I think you need to be prepared for the fact that people will let other dogs run up to you no matter what you do. Which is irritating. My dog’s always on a lead, but we quite regularly have an off lead dog appear almost as if out of nowhere. We’ve even had dogs jump out of gardens. We’re like a magnet!

81Byerley · 25/06/2021 12:31

I would think you're being sensible, and it's a warning that you can cite if someone's dog does get too close.

ladycarlotta · 25/06/2021 12:27

I'm not a dog person but I know what the yellow harness indicates and I make sure to respect it when I see it. Some dogs are nervous and need some extra space - doesn't mean they don't get to have a walk or go to the park.

I'd also be grateful for the sort of indicator you are providing: my toddler is very interested in dogs and while I'm doing a lot of work with her re not approaching without permission, let dog sniff you first etc etc, a clearly signposted nervous dog would make it easier for me to cut her off at the pass and avoid a stressful situation.

theemmadilemma · 25/06/2021 12:26

People are arseholes. But I agree with it being your job to move to the side, stop, redirect yourself - whatever we all the know tricks, not other peoples' job to avoid you as such. It's just letting them know why you're giving them a wide berth and not to approach, lead their dog etc.

A muzzle would garner you a lot more space from people if that's what you want. People will move themselves usually then.

ravenmum · 25/06/2021 12:25

@andweallsingalong

I think it's a good idea, but think there needs to be more awareness.

Round here I usually get a strange look for giving a wide berthed to dogs with yellow harnesses / leads / accessories only to be told they're perfectly friendly the owner just liked the colour / visibility and hadn't heard yellow = nervous / reactive.

I wish they'd do more luminous / bright colours for those who just like them.

Yes, I randomly had a yellow lead for a while and didn't realise what it meant at first. Joining a FB dog group has been really useful for learning about that sort of thing, but it would be good if it was mentioned on the packaging.
Chiantina · 25/06/2021 12:14

Not a dog person, had no idea red/yellow warning leads were a thing. If I saw a dog with the harness you describe I'd think it was a service animal and you were the one who was nervous and needed space. But the effect would be the same, as I'd give you a wide berth!

As PPs have said, a warning on a lead isn't going to help people who pass from behind you and may not even have seen you have a dog. You'll need to monitor your surroundings and take steps to keep others safe too.

inappropriateraspberry · 25/06/2021 12:12

I would also wonder why someone would take out a dog like this if they are so nervous/edgy/dangerous.

inappropriateraspberry · 25/06/2021 12:11

I'd steer clear as I would think they could be dangerous.

Happymum12345 · 25/06/2021 12:08

I would stay away from other dogs as much as possible. If dogs are having a run around off lead, they can’t read ‘nervous dog’ on a harness and may be want to play. Yes, the owner should make sure their dog doesn’t go near yours, but in reality it’s quite hard to manage in an open field of you haven’t yet seen the nervous dog.

GlassOnTheLawn · 25/06/2021 12:06

What would I think if I saw your dog with his coat? My first thought ‘I hope she/he can hold him’.

I didn’t know luminous yellow means nervous!

If I was with my dog-reactive dog I’d give you as much space as possible and make mine sit between my legs with his head held to one side. I’d expect you to also pass with as much space as possible.

If I was without dog and with DC I’d still give you a wide berth but I do that for any dog even if we have to detour around you into a quiet road. If the path was narrow or road busy I’d expect you to stop and hold your dog on a short lead while we pass. And I’d put myself between my DC and your dog.

But if DC were running or scootering ahead of me (eg on a path through the park) I’d expect you to keep your dog well away from them. Mine know not to run or scoot or shout near dogs but they’re very young and might not see you nearby or not see you in time.

Scattyhattie · 25/06/2021 12:02

Perhaps the lady staring was just trying to read the text, sometimes that is the issue with these dog warning tabards too as it can draw those your wanting to avoid closer as people are nosey and want to read it.

Those recommended soft, fabric muzzles, these aren't kinder and should only be worn very briefly such as a vet or grooming visit. Basket/mesh muzzles such as the Baskerville are better for airflow and should be used for any exercise as dogs need to be able to open their mouths fully in order to pant to regulate temperature.

I've had random kids ambush us and grab dogs head, one ran past and whacked him with a stick and parents didn't even say anything. I would work on your dog accepting a muzzle if have to walk in places that risk people running past closely or idiots trying to stroke her. From my experience with newly retired greyhounds, muzzles have effect of people giving you a wider berth but those with offlead dogs aren't bothered so your best off just trying to walk in places with less dickhead dog owners about to limit the negative dog interactions so they can build up confidence.

muddyford · 25/06/2021 12:02

I have yellow leads as they are more visible in low light and easy to find if dropped. I would not automatically presume that you had an issue with your dog. I think it is up to you to muzzle him if there is any doubt about his temperament. By trying to warn people off in this way, you would be legally liable if anyone got hurt as it could be shown that you knew there was a problem. It's the same with Beware of the Dog signs.

maneandfeathers · 25/06/2021 12:00

I had a nervous aggressive dog that would have snapped if someone spooked her.

She was always muzzled. We tried a nervous harness but people (wannabe dog whisperers!) still touched her!!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread