Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What would you think if you saw this dog?

262 replies

Tailbetweenlegs · 25/06/2021 10:47

I’ve bought my dog a bright yellow harness and lead that say I NEED SPACE and NERVOUS in big letters. I got it because he’s a nervous rescue and doesn’t like strange dogs approaching, and can be nervous of people getting too close/if they startle him (he barked and snapped at a woman the other week who I didn’t see come running behind me which prompted me to buy this).
We’re working with a trainer and he’s improved a bit but I think there will always be a management aspect to his behaviour (fairly sure he’s not bitten anyone in his history, not let off the lead, he’s never around children so I don’t think he’s a danger to anyone).

I walked him in his new outfit today and a man rolled his eyes and dramatically jumped out of the way, a woman stopped me to ask if he was nervous (really!) and a woman with a dog walked right past with her dog staring at mine. I normally walk in quiet places, this was just a quick trip round the block and happened to be busier than normal.

So should I not bother with an I NEED SPACE lead/harness. I’m interested to hear how it comes across and what you’d think if you saw a dog in this/if you’d notice. I just mean it as a warning so people give us a bit of a wide berth so they aren’t startled if they get barked at by quite a big dog. I don’t expect people to go massively out of their way to avoid us (he’s on a short lead anyway) but I’m worried it comes across as passive aggressive or will invite attention which is the opposite of what I want. Dog people and dog haters (I know there’s a lot on here) what would you think?

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 25/06/2021 14:25

Shannith
Responsible dog owners already do this.The issue here isn't irresponsible owners not recalling off lead dogs.
The issue is that some people think a coloured lead or harness is a substitute for appropriate safety measures.
If someone is placed in danger in the event they don't see the colour of a dog's lead, then the owner has not done enough as an owner.

As a pedestrian, I should be able to walk along the pavement without dogs running up to me, without dogs jumping up at me, and without dogs snapping at me. I should be able to run and pay attention to my run without risking being snapped at. I should be able to go for a walk and have my attention on my children without an unmuzzled dog snapping at me, and it's owner saying "maybe you should have paid more attention to my dog's lead colour". Simple as that. The responsibility lies with the dog owners.

Bryonyshcmyony · 25/06/2021 14:23

On lead I totally agree. Off lead no, I wouldn't automatically recall without the owner telling me to, and even then I'd suggest they put their dog on a lead if he was reactive.

LST · 25/06/2021 14:19

@Shannith

Can we just make sure that at least every person in this thread understands...

If a dog is on a lead - any lead, pink, purple, bright yellow - recall your dog.

An off lead dog approaching any on lead dog is in danger and creating a potentially dangerous situation - irrespective of the temperament of the dogs.

It's a simple rule. It's common courtesy. There is always a reason a dog is on a lead. You don't need to know why. Recall your dog.

If you can't recall your dog, it's your responsibility to teach it this - for the safely of your dog and others.

Drives me bananas that people don't get this.

This 100% but I would go further and say any dog. Not just on lead dogs. Dogs shouldn't approach an off lead dog either without the ok from the owner. My dog hasn't got any interest with dogs and it pisses both me and him off when a dog comes bounding over just because he is off lead.
Shannith · 25/06/2021 14:16

Can we just make sure that at least every person in this thread understands...

If a dog is on a lead - any lead, pink, purple, bright yellow - recall your dog.

An off lead dog approaching any on lead dog is in danger and creating a potentially dangerous situation - irrespective of the temperament of the dogs.

It's a simple rule. It's common courtesy. There is always a reason a dog is on a lead. You don't need to know why. Recall your dog.

If you can't recall your dog, it's your responsibility to teach it this - for the safely of your dog and others.

Drives me bananas that people don't get this.

epponneee · 25/06/2021 14:14

I think it is a responsible thing to do. I would know not to let me children ask for a stroke and would keep my dogs away.
with regard to whether the dog should be muzzled, I think it depends on how reactive it is and how much you control you have. If you mean it snaps when people touch it or go right up to its face, I think the onus is on them not to do that. Some dogs are nervous and defensive but not actually aggressive and if that's the case I dont think they need muzzling. and a muzzle wont stop them barking and might make them feel more nervous.

However, if it reacts to people/dogs who might be a metre or more away then a muzzle could be worth considering. Also if it is a strong dog that could get away from you, or has any history of biting I'd also get a muzzle. My dog was once attacked and badly hurt by a dog on a lead that got loose. My dog was a large german shepherd and he needed emergency vet treatment. I hate to think what the outcome would be if he'd been a small dog.

strawberrymilkshakeisdelicious · 25/06/2021 14:14

A family member has one for her dog who isn't nasty/vicious (so no muzzle needed) but she's not used to people. She can be quite anxious, nervous, jumpy etc.

I think it attracts MORE attention.

Often from people who think they know better "awww, you don't need to worry about me, girl" ... cue them sitting on the floor trying to touch the dog 🙄🙄🙄

YNK · 25/06/2021 14:12

Another here advocating warning harness AND muzzle!

I have a dog reactive dog that wears both - to protect him from any false allegations!
Some people could see your warning and cause unnecessary drama.

IntermittentParps · 25/06/2021 14:09

Personally I think naughty Fidos need a good nip every now and again to teach them some manners.
I agree. I see a lot of ill-trained and ill-behaved dogs around. I know it isn't their fault, and owners should be better, but you know, red in tooth and claw Grin

JediGnot · 25/06/2021 14:09

@toomanyjobsin1day

There is a risk of it attracting dog-lovers who want to know more, and it is also pretty cheeky - you're giving a warning and telling people to stay away, when really you shoul dbe the one taking 100% responsibility for your dog not scaring or attacking others.

Wtf!

So people should only have dogs that have had a perfect upbringing? This is a RESCUE dog that has probably being through some intense abuse during its life and someone has kindly giving the dog a second chance and a loving home, and just by the nature of the post OP is doing everything to make sure the dog and other remain safe.

What is your answer? To kill all dogs who are not 100% obedient? Through no fault of their own? Get a fucking grip.

My answer would be to have dangerous and aggressive dogs kept out of public places. I hope that can be done whilst keeping the dogs happy and properly exercised.
Willlowbanks · 25/06/2021 14:08

I have a nervous reactive dog. He is terrified by bouncing friendly dogs jumping in his face and will snap. I sit him down well to the side to allow space to pass. If an off lead dog with no recall runs at him I turn and walk away. If the dog follows and continues to hassle us chances are it will get a sharp nip. Sometimes a full on scrap breaks out which I have to deal with while the ineffectual owner runs about shouting 'FIDO, come HERE, naughty dog' and lovely Fido ignores them. It's very tedious. Personally I think naughty Fidos need a good nip every now and again to teach them some manners. This isn't a view that goes down well on MN.

OP I feel your pain, but don't waste your money on fancy harnesses. Decent dog owners will read the situation and keep their dog on lead and well away. The rest, well a harness isn't going to change anything with them anyway.

Shannith · 25/06/2021 14:07

@Bryonyshcmyony

Be very rude and give not two fucks. My dog will kill yours is very effective

Jesus. If your dog killed my dog it would be you who would be to blame, lead or no lead.

Which is why she was muzzled. And had a warning harness. And I wore high viz and I walked her over a farm at odd times and shouted at people to keep back.

She'd been badly treated by humans.

Which is why you should never let your dog run up to an on lead dog, muzzle, warning leads and harness, high viz, person shouting "she's not friendly, recall your dog regardless.

If your off lead dog does not have good enough recall to come back mid approach to another dog, your dog should not be off lead.

Most dogs could (technically) kill your dog.

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 25/06/2021 14:07

unconditional not unconventional!

IntermittentParps · 25/06/2021 14:06

Yes I can read but my 4 year cannot yet, not well, and my 2 year old can't either. Don't you keep them close anyway when there are other people and dogs around?

I would also simply not notice the words until I was too close.
Bright yellow and great big letters. Not sure how you could 'not notice' those TBH.

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 25/06/2021 14:06

toomanyjobsin1day she said she's disinterested - so many people seem to jump to the word "hate" on social media, as though there are no stages between unbridled enthusiasm and unconventional love, and hate...

The OP actually asked "dog haters" to comment, and the post is in AIBU not the doghouse...

LST · 25/06/2021 14:05

@inappropriateraspberry

I would also wonder why someone would take out a dog like this if they are so nervous/edgy/dangerous.
Really? So dogs don't need exercise then?
AssassinatedBeauty · 25/06/2021 14:04

I would be pleased that you were being a sensible dog owner and give your dog a respectable distance when walking past. I think you've been very unlucky with the odd responses that you've had on your short walk, and with some of the odd and hostile responses here.

I don't think its inviting a discussion nor is it passive aggressive.

maneandfeathers · 25/06/2021 14:04

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland it’s interesting that you mention the suitability of these dogs as pets.
At the risk of being publicly lynched on mn I sort of agree with what your saying. I had a rescue dog who was nervous. She wore a yellow harness, muzzle, was kept away from anyone and everything etc. We attended more training sessions than I thought possible but the dog never really improved so we just bumbled along.
One day we were walking and someone was passing. I asked the dog to sit, which she did and the woman ran over and sort of grabbed/stroked the dog around the head and had no clue at all that the dog may not have wanted to be touched. The dogs back was to the lady so perhaps she didn’t see the muzzle.
Anyway the dog reacted very very badly and if she wasn’t muzzled the woman would have been hurt.
We also had a few incidents of children almost running up to her which was awful, even being hit by a muzzle as a child would have been painful.
After discussing it with a behaviourist (more than one actually!) we had the dog put to sleep as we had young children and couldn’t take the risk of her escaping or something bad happening (like me falling or something) and someone touching her causing the same reaction.

I also realised owning this dog now clueless people actually are about dogs. Personally I would never touch a dog that was not mine but so so many people do and I felt it was my responsibility to make sure nobody would be hurt by my pet. I’m not saying this is what’s right for everyone’s dog but for me a dog is meant to be a happy addition to the family and sadly for mine she was anything but enjoying life Sad

wingsofsteel · 25/06/2021 14:04

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland

Amazed by the following:
  • the number of people saying they have "nervous" or "anxious" rescue dog. Are these animals actually suitable as pets?
  • people who think anyone other than a dog owner would/should so much as notice what colour harness a dog has, let alone know that the colour signifies anything. I am completely disinterested in dogs and generally ignore them when out walking. I would have no idea at all what harness colours mean.

The general public are not required to be knowledgable or interested in dogs.

Many rescue dogs are nervous/anxious at least when first rescued. They have at best had their lives disrupted and been taken away from the surroundings they are used- and in many cases they have suffered neglect and abuse. This is one of the reason that most will not allow people with young children to adopt a rescue dog. With love, patience and care most rescue dogs overcome their anxiety but they need training to do this- which involves safely getting used to walks/strangers/other dogs etc.

I can only speak for myself but I do not expect other people to be interested in or knowledgeable about my dog. However, I know that a lot of people like dogs and might want to pet mine and/or introduce their dog to mine. A visible clue that he's not ready for this is helpful. However, many people ignore that, and also ignore me telling them clearly that he does not wish to be approached. I muzzle mine when in public (despite him not having bitten) so that if people touch hum on purpose or by accident and he feels threatened he cannot bite.

FamBae · 25/06/2021 14:04

I do agree with pp if as you say your dog snapped at someone you really do need to muzzle it, keep the harness but do be aware that not everyone will be able to read it until it's too late. I have a nervous dog, we jog on fine but take corners wide as I know if we bumped into another dog she would be startled and bark defensively, also are you checking your body language, if you tense upon encountering someone coming towards you with a dog your dog will pick up on it.

toomanyjobsin1day · 25/06/2021 14:02

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland

Amazed by the following:
  • the number of people saying they have "nervous" or "anxious" rescue dog. Are these animals actually suitable as pets?
  • people who think anyone other than a dog owner would/should so much as notice what colour harness a dog has, let alone know that the colour signifies anything. I am completely disinterested in dogs and generally ignore them when out walking. I would have no idea at all what harness colours mean.

The general public are not required to be knowledgable or interested in dogs.

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland
Rescue dogs generally are nervous and anxious because they have often being through horrific abuse by other humans. Good people then go on to care and provide homes for these dogs.

They may not be ideal pets but they are living creatures - if people shouldn't have them as pets, what is your answer?

If you hate dogs so much and are not interested why are you even commenting on his thread.

By the way you sound lovely.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 25/06/2021 14:02

Intermittent

Yes I can read but my 4 year cannot yet, not well, and my 2 year old can't either. I would also simply not notice the words until I was too close.

LST · 25/06/2021 14:02

My dog wouldn't approach another dog anyway but I'd keep him and my DC away.

If he is likely to snap I would definitely consider a muzzle

IntermittentParps · 25/06/2021 13:57

people who think anyone other than a dog owner would/should so much as notice what colour harness a dog has, let alone know that the colour signifies anything. I am completely disinterested in dogs and generally ignore them when out walking. I would have no idea at all what harness colours mean.

The OP's dog harness also says I NEED SPACE and NERVOUS in big letters. One assumes you can read.

CatherineMorland · 25/06/2021 13:56

I would take the hint and keep my dog away, thinking you were a sensible and responsible dog owner.

HeronLanyon · 25/06/2021 13:51

I suppose the problem is that some people seeing this then take time to read it and are more likely as a result to be closer to your dog and then to talk to you about it than not ! Kind of counter productive.
Bit like a ‘quiet lane’ sign which makes people think ‘oh wonder what’s up there, let’s go have a look’.

Swipe left for the next trending thread