Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What would you think if you saw this dog?

262 replies

Tailbetweenlegs · 25/06/2021 10:47

I’ve bought my dog a bright yellow harness and lead that say I NEED SPACE and NERVOUS in big letters. I got it because he’s a nervous rescue and doesn’t like strange dogs approaching, and can be nervous of people getting too close/if they startle him (he barked and snapped at a woman the other week who I didn’t see come running behind me which prompted me to buy this).
We’re working with a trainer and he’s improved a bit but I think there will always be a management aspect to his behaviour (fairly sure he’s not bitten anyone in his history, not let off the lead, he’s never around children so I don’t think he’s a danger to anyone).

I walked him in his new outfit today and a man rolled his eyes and dramatically jumped out of the way, a woman stopped me to ask if he was nervous (really!) and a woman with a dog walked right past with her dog staring at mine. I normally walk in quiet places, this was just a quick trip round the block and happened to be busier than normal.

So should I not bother with an I NEED SPACE lead/harness. I’m interested to hear how it comes across and what you’d think if you saw a dog in this/if you’d notice. I just mean it as a warning so people give us a bit of a wide berth so they aren’t startled if they get barked at by quite a big dog. I don’t expect people to go massively out of their way to avoid us (he’s on a short lead anyway) but I’m worried it comes across as passive aggressive or will invite attention which is the opposite of what I want. Dog people and dog haters (I know there’s a lot on here) what would you think?

OP posts:
user1495884211 · 25/06/2021 17:55

I don't particularly like dogs and I try to ignore them and avoid looking at them as attention seems to encourage them to bound up with their horrible muddy paws and slobbery jaws so I would be unlikely to notice a harness.

If I did notice, I would assume it meant not to approach your dog rather than to go out of my way to avoid passing it. As many others have said, if your dog can't cope with passing someone on the pavement, it's your responsibility to make space, not other people's.

epponneee · 25/06/2021 17:44

Some of the responses here are ridiculous. If the dog is so far away that you cant see the yellow harness then it is probably fair to say you are too far away for there to be an issue!

And yes of course it the ultimate responsibility for the dog lies with the owner. But

  • As a society, we can all take reasonable measures to be helpful to each other. I wouldnt expect people to have to go completely out of their way but nothing wrong with asking people to give the dog a little more space than they might do automatically
-There are in fact lots of people who love dogs and like to say hello, so it is good for those to know not to approach
  • While mumsnet expects all dogs to have perfect recall at all times,this is something that can take time to get perfect so if you have a puppy or young dog who is still learning then you would know to keep your dog on a lead

Also, in terms of runners, I would expect runners to generally give any pedestrians a bit of a wide berth coming past as it can be quite intimidating to have someone rush past a few inches away even if you aren't a nervous dog!

gordongrumpy · 25/06/2021 17:40

Dog owner- I think these leads are really useful.

Ronnii · 25/06/2021 17:37

I haven't RTFT but I know what yellow harness means so even without the writing on I would keep my dog away. I think it's a good thing to wear the harness.

LST · 25/06/2021 17:29

@Bryonyshcmyony

On lead I totally agree. Off lead no, I wouldn't automatically recall without the owner telling me to, and even then I'd suggest they put their dog on a lead if he was reactive.
He isn't reactive. He just doesn't want some bounding over friendly dog in his space when he is minding his own business
VodkaSlimline · 25/06/2021 17:15

Have not RTFT but honestly, I would think he was some sort of emotional support dog and that the I NEED SPACE and NERVOUS messages related to you...!

Brainwave89 · 25/06/2021 17:10

I cycle on country lanes a lot. I would have no idea what a particular harness meant and would not see any writing until I was level, which might be too late. If a dog is likely to go for me, my (reasonable) expectation is that the dog is properly controlled via muzzling or the owner having it on a very short lead.

SimonJT · 25/06/2021 17:08

I sometimes walk a neighbours dog and she had a yellow harness and a thin coat stating she is nervous and to keep away.

People, well idiots, still try to approach her, or worse allow their children to run up to her. Sadly when we live in a world where people will touch paint if they see a sign that says “wet paint” we can’t be surprised when they are irresponsible.

InTheNightWeWillWish · 25/06/2021 17:03

From a distance, you can’t always see a yellow lead or even if the dog is on a lead, so sometimes these leads and harnesses aren’t all that clear from a distance. There are also a few different things that a yellow harness/coat/lead, it could be assistance dogs or nervous or just general high vis. Both our dogs are black and particularly in winter they wear high vis coats to be visible, it’s not because they’re nervous although I’m not fussed if people don’t bother them.

When I see a dog on lead, I’ll put mine on lead. If I see the nervous coat/harness/lead then I’ll sit my dogs down and give them a treat while you pass. I can’t stop them staring at your dog though Confused If I don’t see the nervous lead, then we will continue walking towards you with our dogs on lead. I would say at that point if we’ve not noticed your lead, it’s not because we don’t care it’s just we haven’t noticed and so if that isn’t enough space for your dog, I would expect you to stop and give your dog the space it needs until we’ve passed.

LolaSmiles · 25/06/2021 16:57

inappropriateraspberry
It works for me too and I keep away.

I'm just very wary of people thinking that if they put a certain harness on then the responsibility to avoid being snapped at lies with the general public to prioritise looking at any dog in the vicinity to check their leads and harnesses, rather than the owner.

inappropriateraspberry · 25/06/2021 16:56

@sillysmiles Yes I know dogs need walking etc, but perhaps there is a better way than down a busy road.
Or don't be surprised that people are looking to read the harness or wondering what the dog is like.

inappropriateraspberry · 25/06/2021 16:53

@LolaSmiles

inappropriateraspberry I think the issue is that some people think using a coloured lead is enough of a precaution for a dog who is liable to snap.

My friend's dog is lovely, but nervous. She uses a lead with nervous on because her dog is better being left alone. She doesn't want strangers or random dogs approaching.. Her dog isn't dangerous and the lead is because her dog's walk is better and happier if people and other dogs don't bother her.

There's other people who have a dog who is likely to be reactive, likely to snap, etc. They want a bubble around their dog and some of these people stick a yellow lead on their dog and then think that if someone passes on the pavement and their dog snaps that everyone else should have known known keep away from their snappy dog.
It's this second group who are problematic.

I wouldn't know the difference in coloured leads or harnesses. I appreciate the warnings on the lead, and it would keep me away, but having 'nervous' and 'I need space' relates to me as 'caution' and 'dangerous.' But it would work and keep me away.
LolaSmiles · 25/06/2021 16:51

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland
I agree with you, and if not necessarily aggressive, they display behaviour thay highlights they are an animal who is likely to behave unpredictably. The responsibility lies with the owner to exercise their dog in a appropriate space or put in place necessary measures, not rely on other people paying attention for a special harness. Sometimes posts from some owners of reactive dogs can feel a bit victim blamey in my opinion as it quickly comes down to "I put my dog in a coloured harness/lead, you should have noticed it, if your attention was elsewhere and you didn't see it then you asked to be snapped at".

My friend put it really well when discussing her nervous dog: the yellow lead is there to promote the conditions for her dog to best enjoy their walk without being bothered by other dogs.It's not there as a get out of jail free card for a dog snapping at strangers.

TheHoundsofLove · 25/06/2021 16:49

Whilst people approaching unfamiliar dogs / letting off-lead dogs run up to you etc.. are totally in the wrong, I do think you have to almost assume that you will have runners going past, bikes going by quickly, children being loud and messing about on the way past etc. They're just part of life and you're not going to be able to avoid it, especially if you live in a more populated area.

Dogfan · 25/06/2021 16:37

I think these are great and I wish more people would use them. I can't always tell when other dogs are nervous or aggressive and this way you definitely know! I've seen people wearing tabards as well which is helpful. I'm all for it!

Legoninjago1 · 25/06/2021 16:36

I saw this on a gorgeous little dog recently and just gave him a wide berth. However if I'd had my kids with me I'd have been more worried about keeping them safe.

cupsofcoffee · 25/06/2021 16:31

A thread about a dog who snaps at passers-by is always going to end up being about muzzles, though.

Unfortunately for you, the law changed recently and a dog no longer has to make contact for it to be deemed aggressive, dangerous or out of control. If a passer-by is scared of your dog and fears they may be bitten or attacked, they can report you.

I think it's great that you're getting professional advice, however strangers aren't going to know that, and as you can see, you will be judged for having an aggressive, un-muzzled dog in public.

cakewench · 25/06/2021 16:14

FWIW I wouldn't notice unless I was right next to the dog. I've seen people here annoyed because people don't follow the signs they've put on their dogs, but I'm sorry, I don't scrutinise every dog from a safe distance before approaching its general vicinity. I barely notice what humans are wearing much less dogs.

I think it's good as a deterrent to people who might be the sort who come up wanting to pet or play with it, but that's about it. If it's a bitey dog, you need to get some sort of muzzle.

Tailbetweenlegs · 25/06/2021 16:07

@cupsofcoffee

A dog snapping is a warning, it would happen whether the dog was muzzled or not.

Absolutely, but a muzzle prevents a bite. If your dog bites someone then at best, you could have no choice but to muzzle and leash your dog in public. At worst, your dog could be taken off you and put down.

You have a dog who is aggressive and who snaps at strangers. If your dog bites and its' history is known, a court will question why on earth you didn't muzzle it before.

I have a dog who snapped at a stranger. I’m aware it could happen again but it’s not a regular occurrence. He has been assessed by behaviourists at a dog rescue which advises lots of their dogs to be muzzled but didn’t think it was necessary for him, he has also been seen in quite a busy park by my own vet recommended behaviourist who also didn’t advise muzzling. I am speaking to her again and will fully explain what happened, ask about muzzling and take her advice. I’m not opposed to muzzling, I have used one with a previous dog. I didn’t start this thread to ask about muzzles though.
OP posts:
HeronLanyon · 25/06/2021 16:07

I don’t own a dog. I walk miles where dag are routinely walked off and on a lead.
I’m not sure I we ever seen a yellow harness. I would have no idea what it meant until I got closer but I might not know to read whatever and I might not have my reading glasses on on a walk. In fact I think if I saw a coloured harness from a distance I’d think it might be a dog in training and maybe for that reason give wide berth or speak to passing dog Walker.
There’s quite a bit of high handed thinking on this thread from dog owner that we would know and know how to behave and if not we are responsible. !

cupsofcoffee · 25/06/2021 15:56

A dog snapping is a warning, it would happen whether the dog was muzzled or not.

Absolutely, but a muzzle prevents a bite. If your dog bites someone then at best, you could have no choice but to muzzle and leash your dog in public. At worst, your dog could be taken off you and put down.

You have a dog who is aggressive and who snaps at strangers. If your dog bites and its' history is known, a court will question why on earth you didn't muzzle it before.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 25/06/2021 15:53

Lolasmiles

You are so right. "He's anxious", "she's nervous of kids" - none of these dog owners use the word aggressive which is what has been accurate in situations I've seen.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 25/06/2021 15:52

The point being that a muzzle guarantees that the dog cannot bite a human or another dog. Your dog has not bitten. Yet. The snapping indicates its anxious and its behaviour is not under control - you simply don't know how the dog may react if provoked inadvertently, and you can't risk anyone getting hurt.

LolaSmiles · 25/06/2021 15:51

Tailbetweenlegs
That's the point though. People are entitled to go about their day on public paths without having to be on watch for coloured leads, or risk being snapped at if they happen to have their attention elsewhere.

I keep my distance if I see a yellow lead & keep my dogs away, but if I'm out running and don't see a lead because I'm focusing on running then it's not ok for a dog to snap at me.

"They're just nervous, it's just a warning, it's not a bite, people should see the lead colour, it's up to them if they pay attention to my coloured harness or not" is just as annoying and irresponsible as owners saying "they're just friendly, it's just their way of saying hello" in my opinion.

MRex · 25/06/2021 15:49

By the way, did you ask the vet about anxiety medication? It isn't necessarily what you'd want long-term, but might help for a while as you build up good habits. A friend's dog did quite well on it, though I've no idea what drug specifically.

Swipe left for the next trending thread