Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sorry we've lost our nice view?

155 replies

Timetochange11 · 25/06/2021 07:44

We have an elevated bit of garden level with our upstairs windows with a lovely view of a field and woods. Yesterday our neighbour put an office type chalet up in the field right in our line of vision, sure we'll get used to it but it looks so out of place in the country.

OP posts:
Scaredycatmoo · 25/06/2021 08:57

Upstairs window… you’ll get used to it.

Dining room / lounge - would take longer to get used to but you would

I find those types of garden rooms very attractive

stairgates · 25/06/2021 08:57

I believe if it is on the wooden base, so not directly on the floor similar to the one shown in the picture is, then it is classed as moveable/temporary/caravan rules so allowed unless it is being used as a bedroom so doesnt need any permissions.

IrmaFayLear · 25/06/2021 08:56

I second the observation by a pp that it might be intended for air b&b, or teenage use (if she has any).

My aunt has a structure like that in her garden (with great view) and it is fully booked for summer. It is a shed, albeit poshly done out and with a shower room.

Timetochange11 · 25/06/2021 08:55

Doginatent, I'm sorry we've got to look at it so yes it bothers me. I don't imagine she did it just to annoy though, more that she probably didn't think about the impact on others.

OP posts:
netstaller · 25/06/2021 08:55

@NettleTea

you do realise you can report it without giving your name. I certainly would give the planning dept a heads up
This. If it ruins your view and shouldn't be there you should do it.
TheoMeo · 25/06/2021 08:51

Phone the company and ask anonymously if it is possible to move a built hut/house.
If it's possible to move it it's worth contacting planning dept (also anonymously initially).

averylongtimeago · 25/06/2021 08:51

You can't just fence off part of a field you own next to your house and call it garden.

We had exactly this situation near us: all you can do with such a piece of land it mow it a couple of times a year. No ornamental plants, no kids toys, no patio etc. A whole row of houses had bought a strip of land from the local farmer and incorporated it into their gardens without permission.
They got away with it for a few years, then someone reported them to the planning department.
It took months, but they all had to apply for planning permission and had to remove sheds, greenhouses and the like. All they were allowed to do was use it as grass and for fruit trees.

If you are bothered, report anonymously, then they can move the shed nearer their house.

Tulipomania · 25/06/2021 08:51

It's very uneighbourly of them not to have consulted you about it, especially since it could have been in a different position.

Timetochange11 · 25/06/2021 08:50

@whatevernext33 that was my next question. What should I plant treewise? I'll look at birch @Timetochange11
@NettleTea I've checked planning portal, no permission

I agree with everything that's been said, Its a small community and not worth falling out over. That said there are a couple of people here who moan about everything so she may get some grief from them.

OP posts:
billy1966 · 25/06/2021 08:50

Awfully ugly and very upsetting.

She would know well that that she would be spoiling YOUR view doing something like that.

I would not be happy and would not keep the peace.

That's what people like that depend on.

Clymene · 25/06/2021 08:49

The OP has already said there's no permission @NettleTea

@Timetochange11 - I would speak to the council. AONBs are for everyone to enjoy.

DogInATent · 25/06/2021 08:49

AONB and designated agricultural land? - have a word with the neighbour on the Parish Council. I believe that there may be a problem both with the 'summerhouse' and the adoption of additional land as garden.

I think she might get in trouble from the council, I've checked - there is no planning, but it won't be from me
So it doesn't really bother you?

Grimacingfrog · 25/06/2021 08:49

@Zanzibar55

I agree it spoils the view, but even if planning permission had been needed, what is the OP going to do about it? She's going to be extremely unpopular with the neighbours, whom she has said she likes, if they are forced to remove it. On second thoughts, I suppose they could site it closer to their house where it wouldn't be such a distraction, but I think either scenario would cause tensions.
Exactly. They don't have to remove it, they just have to put it in a part of their actual garden. It's a question of suiting them less, not depriving them of something vital.
NettleTea · 25/06/2021 08:48

you do realise you can report it without giving your name. I certainly would give the planning dept a heads up

NettleTea · 25/06/2021 08:48

@LIZS

Fencing off an area does not make it into garden.
agree. and I would step very careful here with the ignoring it, because if they have 'created' a new area, sperate from the official curtilage of the house, you have the first steps to a whole new property.

You may think they wont do that, but its happened alot around here.

is it simply a summerhouse, or has it got water/electricity? Do you think they are going to AirBnB it, as lots of people do this, under the radar of the council. And might be a reason why its been placed outside of her garden, because she doesnt want the bother of seeing guests.

Dustyblue · 25/06/2021 08:47

Ah OP, I'd be so disappointed too. No idea about planning permission where you are (in on the south east coast of Australia) but I share your pain.

We bought a house next to an empty block at the end of the main drag in our town. It's an elevated spot so lovely views of the distant hills from the back and side.

Inevitably someone built a house on the vacant block, so we lost our beautiful side views. Sad, but nothing to be done. At least the tenant is nice :)

I like the idea of trees. Feeling your pain.

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 25/06/2021 08:46
Sad
LIZS · 25/06/2021 08:42

Fencing off an area does not make it into garden.

dogwalker88 · 25/06/2021 08:40

Don't say anything as too late now and the potential for a bad atmosphere will be worse in long run.
Just remember it if you ever want to do anything 👍👍
Lot worse things going on in the world.....
Also at least it looks a nice one.

NettleTea · 25/06/2021 08:40

you can put one in your garden as a summer house/ home office etc so long as it complies with permitted development

You DH is wrong though,. you CANNOT just plonk one down in a field, it absolutely IS change of use.

Having spent lots of time going through all this with a fine toothed comb I think you would be able to object to this.

and in an AONB they laws around permitted are even tighter and local planning would need to approve.

have a serach on your local planning portal - you would see if there was permission granted

TheoMeo · 25/06/2021 08:38

I used to have no truck with so-called nimbys but recently realised how important veiws, trees, landscapes are to well being.
People buy a property with a view or close to countryside - it's not nimbyism to be upset that the point of your purchase is changed by someone else. It's also the biggest purchase you will make in your life and can't be easily changed if you don't have the money.

Zanzibar55 · 25/06/2021 08:38

I agree it spoils the view, but even if planning permission had been needed, what is the OP going to do about it? She's going to be extremely unpopular with the neighbours, whom she has said she likes, if they are forced to remove it.
On second thoughts, I suppose they could site it closer to their house where it wouldn't be such a distraction, but I think either scenario would cause tensions.

Whatevernext33 · 25/06/2021 08:37

If it's not in curtilage then there are no permitted development rights on the land and it needs permission. Esp if in aonb.
I'd also be miffed they didn't mention anything.
If the one they've put in has lighting etc ecology impacts may need to be considered.
If you want to plant, maybe birch would be good, quick growing and screening but.not so dense they feel imposing. Group or a line or a grove of them looks lovely too.

Timetochange11 · 25/06/2021 08:37

@gryffsmum @ did you mean dick Grin I wont, as you say it's a shed and we can still see the view around it. I think she might get in trouble from the council, I've checked - there is no planning, but it won't be from me. She just fenced off part of her field so her garden is bigger and then it went up!

OP posts:
GryffsMum · 25/06/2021 08:31

Soooo many typos!!!