Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To move DD (yr 10) into private and even consider repeating a year

62 replies

tommyketchup · 24/06/2021 15:56

DD has been on steady decline wrt school work since the start of year 9 and then lockdown was a complete disaster (she did literally nothing when we weren't at home which as key workers wasn't muchSad) and is now on course to fail her GCSE's having previously been a bright if not particularly diligent student. Year 7 & 8 she was predicted 6 & 7's with a couple of 8's, this slipped to 5/6's possible few 7's by the end of year 9 and now she'll be lucky to get 5's in even her best subjects.

When we realised how bad it had got (with hindsight too late) we tried to work with her current school to get her re-engaged but frankly, they have been shit and we are now seriously considering moving her out of her current school into private either for year 11 or possibly to repeat year 10.

The idea of moving schools won't phase her but I don't think going down a year will go down so well Confused. The school we have in mind has a place and is willing to discuss repeating a year but we need to decided ASAP. It's not particularly academic (which is fine) but will have far higher expectations in terms of workload & class engagement plus is one of the top performers in her sporting passion so an amazing opportunity in that respect but clearly very late in her academic career to consider a move. Due to her sport, she mixes with a lot of private school children anyway and has always been a bit 'they are so lucky woe poor me' and is very competitive and driven in this area so private school is definitely something I've always thought she'd suit but has never been on the cards financially until now.

Are we mad? Is it even worth it if she's only going into year 11? Has anyone else ever moved this late or put their child down a year? Help - we need to decide in the next 2 weeks as they are closing for the summer soon.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
tommyketchup · 17/07/2021 23:33

I just thought I'd post and update as everyone was so helpful before and we have a plan that seems to both excite (& will hopefully motivate) DD that isn't as drastic as dropping a year which she was really against in the end not to mention stressful given how little time there was before the end of term.

So, I have booked in a serious of tutors, friends uni kids and online tutorials over the summer (3 x 2 hours a week so hopefully enough but not too intensive) to try and help her get back on track and have promised to extend extra tutoring into year 11 if she's showing commitment on the promise of a place at the private school for sixth form. She seems genuinely excited at the prospect and determined to get the necessary grades for A levels. This will be quite a stretch as she is a long way off right now BUT they also offer a Btec in sport (which might actually suit her better anyway) and this has a 5 grade 4+ entry requirement which is more realistic.

I feel so happy she is actually showing some interest and enthusiasm for something post GCSE and that there's a chance she might get to go to her 'dream school' where she can excel at her sport and if nothing else have a few more years to mature and find her way. Fingers crossed and thanks again to those who posted.

OP posts:
steakandcheeseplease · 25/06/2021 15:55

OP I have two kids in private school and I wouldn't do what your proposing.

The school your suggesting isn't academically challenging - Find out why. They might be a school with a very high SEN rate. We left our old Indi when it got to 59% SEN. You can find out on the ISI.

I'd keep her in that school and invest in private tutoring.

Cattitudes · 25/06/2021 15:36

I am not sure the social disruption is worth it for yr11 and they probably have a different syllabus. Would she be able to have a taster day? Redoing yr10 sounds like the best solution. Existing school sounds a bit like a disaster waiting to happen so if she won't go to yr10 I would be throwing summer school and tutors at her.

Your dh might have coasted and was fine but with covid still around it is a risky strategy even for next year. Some of my yr11's grades are based on yr10 work and might not be as high despite working really hard in yr11 (and in yr10 but with covid disruption).

Powerof4 · 25/06/2021 15:21

Can you get private tutors and have a meeting with school where they detail for you anything she particularly needs to work on? They should have this info from mocks or assessments. Tutors could then help her catch up with the most important areas. I think working with the school could be really helpful and hopefully they could help motivate her by asking her teachers to give regular feedback on areas where she is catching up/making progress.

Bryonyshcmyony · 25/06/2021 14:42

My dds school wouldn't take anyone in year 11.

CakesOfVersailles · 25/06/2021 14:38

I might be going against the grain here but if you can't get her to repeat, I would still consider moving her for year 11 on the proviso that she is tutored over the summer or attends a summer school.

It really depends on the school but I have seen kids turn around in about a term and a half. Not from C->A* (or 4/5->9 nowadays) but definitely upwards (about 4->6). Also knew a girl who was on track to fail in year 10, moved schools for year 11, scraped passes in most subjects with one A in in something obscure, and finished up with ABC at A-Level which was beyond her wildest dreams in year 10. So her GCSEs might not be great but it is possible to keep that upwards momentum going if she starts improving at her new school.

Can she also manage the number of GCSEs down if she moves? I have known some students to take ridiculous numbers which is fine if they are high performing but can cost time and valuable energy is they need to focus on passing.

The main concern I would have is if she doesn't do well, will the school keep her for 6th form?

SpaceRaiders · 25/06/2021 14:18

As an aside, I didn’t know you could repeat a year in state schools.

I’ve only ever heard of it in private, I know few summer born Y6’s have effectively taken a year out and will restart Y7 this September as the eldest in their years.

TaraR2020 · 25/06/2021 13:39

Do everything you can, if that means tutors and / or private school then definitely go for it. I would also have her repeat the year, it's only a big deal in her head - had a couple of friends who did so at school (high performing state school) because they were either on track to fail gcses due to personal issues or didn't make the grades they wanted for uni at a level. No one batted an eyelid and it paid off in both circumstances.

She can always tell friends it was her idea, puts her in control of the situation and she can brazen it out if it helps her feel better about it.

ScrollingLeaves · 24/06/2021 20:02

“PuffinMcHuffin

@tommyketchup - do you have strategies for productivity and motivation?

They are very good to learn early - happy to DM you some things that may help if you would like?“

That sounds very interesting, Puffin. Would it be complicated to roughly outline them here, or point the way to a book or article?

Elnetthairnet · 24/06/2021 19:49

What about a gcse summer school to consolidate what she’s missed in yr 10 so she goes into yr 11 with a better start, then tutors, then private for 6th form she wants to move?

Bryonyshcmyony · 24/06/2021 19:38

Also if she's doing nothing at home after school what is this sport?!

Bryonyshcmyony · 24/06/2021 19:35

@Powerof4

Move and repeat. As a former English teacher I would say it’s very difficult to make up a lost year 10. A private school is likely to make a big difference to her work ethic for the reasons you stated. Is the sporting opportunity enough of a carrot for her?
If she needs to concentrate on GCSEs then playing sport to a high level is the last thing she should be thinking about
Powerof4 · 24/06/2021 19:32

Move and repeat. As a former English teacher I would say it’s very difficult to make up a lost year 10. A private school is likely to make a big difference to her work ethic for the reasons you stated. Is the sporting opportunity enough of a carrot for her?

tommyketchup · 24/06/2021 19:11

@PuffinMcHuffin no I dont and that would be amazing if you would dm me. To be honest I'm at a total loss as when there's nobody there to force her I feel completely powerless. Unfortunately the trigger is most likely when I went back to work full time as I was no longer there to see what she was up to & supervise homework. Dh was never pushed at home & is luckily naturally bright so thinks if she doesn't want to do it we can't make her.

OP posts:
hellywelly3 · 24/06/2021 19:07

If I could afford it then all 3 of mine would be in private. Do it x

PuffinMcHuffin · 24/06/2021 19:03

@tommyketchup - do you have strategies for productivity and motivation?

They are very good to learn early - happy to DM you some things that may help if you would like?

Was there any trigger to the change in her motivation prior to the pandemic. Year 9 is a difficult year for some people - it does really sort out who is a self starter and motivated.

tommyketchup · 24/06/2021 18:57

Yes that's exactly what she is @PuffinMcHuffin lazy & unmotivated and whilst I agree private school per se isn't the key to success, I'm hoping all the elements of private that aren't part of her current school might make a difference: smaller class size so less chance of going unnoticed/being over looked; more accountability for things like lack of or poor homework; parental communication - we literally get nothing from school except a yearly report and yearly data. They offer lots of help and it's all very softly softly which is great for many but someone like my daughter who just isn't bothered, I want mandatory not optional. Another big plus is a longer day and when she's home along she really does do sweet FA! So rather than home and watching YouTube from 4pm until I get home at 6:30 ready for a daily argument about homework , she won't be back until gone 6 having done most of it at school.

I'm completely sold on the idea (I would have done it without even asking her if we were able in year 9) but need to speak to the school again tomorrow and see what they say.

OP posts:
Mugsen · 24/06/2021 18:56

I think I would just take more interest myself and try and get her grades up. Buy revision guides, test her, work with her, help her plan. They've got more than a year to go. Having been to private school myself, it isn't a magic guarantee, you still have to work hard. What makes you think she'll work harder in a different school?

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 24/06/2021 18:50

I think I would but I'd also try and address the reasons why she is so disengaged with it. In another year she would be expected to do a lot more self study. Was it completely the schools fault that her grades are slipping? Is she going to commit to work harder and engage more if you move her? If she cant be arsed to do any work then private school might be a giant waste of money

NumberTheory · 24/06/2021 18:49

@Imapotato

I’ll go against the grain here and say I wouldn’t do it.

My reasons are, that being predicted 5s isn’t failing. A 5 is a high C low B. It may not be the stellar grades you were hoping she would achieve, but hey, she didn’t put the effort in, but actually still has time to improve them if she gets her head down and works.

My second being, if she’s not going to get her head down and work now, then I very much doubt she will thank you for making her repeat a year. It could really damage her self esteem and make her push back harder.

If she likes the idea of private and is capable of getting higher grades with a bit more effort. Why not get her a tutor for now and make a deal that if she gets her arse in gear does well at GCSE, she can go private for 6th form. It might motivate her to try harder without making her feel like a failure.

^^ I think there’s a lot of wisdom in this.
Vispa · 24/06/2021 18:48

Should have said, I was the same age as your DD so re-did a year of my gcse's. It definitely worked for me x

Vispa · 24/06/2021 18:46

I left my high school due to being bullied, and repeated the year in my new school as it had badly affected my grades. I went from getting D's to A's and did really well academically. It's been such a horrible, difficult year for poor kids and teens - its not surprising some are now really unmotivated and fed up. I would definitely look at moving my child in your shoes...is there anything you can do to help motivate her to redo the year and try again - perhaps some kind of reward that she would love, so it doesn't feel like a punishment..?

jeanne16 · 24/06/2021 18:45

There is no point moving her to a new school for y11. They effectively have 1 teaching term left and will not be able to perform miracles. Move her for y10 if she is willing and committed to really work hard.

Embracelife · 24/06/2021 18:44

Do what you can year 11 tutors etc.
Private sixth form

Bryonyshcmyony · 24/06/2021 18:40

@HugeAckmansWife

but the new group would be her peers. We often have kids repeat y10 and really it is fine. However, I also had two kids start in Y11 this year and they worked hard, learnt the style of qs etc that differed from the specs they'd done before and were fine. I doubt she'd do LESS well by moving than by carrying on in her present way.
They wouldn't be her peers!

Tutors OP!