Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think table manners are on the decline

114 replies

RankManners · 24/06/2021 11:09

inspired by current thread on table manners...
I work in a primary school and am shocked by the lack of table manners. Thinking that year 3 or 4 (age 8/9) is a suitable age to be able to use cutlery properly, I'd say about 2 children in each class do this. I'm talking eating sweetcorn (and pretty much everything) with fingers, putting a chicken breast on a fork and eating it like a lolly, eating a jacket potato by scraping the insides off on bottom teeth etc.

Similarly in a restaurant, you'll see parents with decent table manners and then kids eating like animals - how can parents not notice this??

(I'm your average WC parent, nothing posh here, but was bought up with standards!)
So AIBU it's the way things are going
YANBU manners separate us from animals

OP posts:
kindaclassy · 24/06/2021 12:57

But it sounds like that isn't typical!

Thank god for that! The last thing anyone need is children "helping' clearing out. It's such a pain when adults do it already.

A simple "can I help you?" is more than enough, they can bring ONE safe item and disappear, and everybody is happy.

BlankTimes · 24/06/2021 12:56

@ExhaustedFlamingo

My now adult DD has those conditions plus many more co-morbids, some of which directly affect eating like jaw (and other joints) hypermobility and intention tremor) I still cut her food up into small pieces before I give it to her and she still takes a very long time to eat.

In restaurants, we sit side by side, swap plates while I cut hers up then swap back.

I know how hard it is, but some of the aids do help, I agree, they don't form a perfect solution, but they do help.
Your son sounds lovely, like me, you'll do what you can to encourage him, but remember what he can achieve within his capabilities and don't push for the impossible.

undermycatsthumb · 24/06/2021 12:50

I wouldn't do that in someone else's house (though I would ask if I could help clear up) - you don't know where anything goes! I'd actually think it quite odd if a guest just took themselves off and put their plate in my dishwasher, and I do think it's a lot to expect of a child. Are you sure yours do it at their friend's houses?

Yes because it gets favourably commented on! I obviously wouldn't expect visiting kids to be loading the dishwasher etc but just taking their plates to the side. Maybe my friends and I are unusual, but we all help clear at whoever's house, and when I have their kids over (as in my friends' kids) they all do the same. But it sounds like that isn't typical!

Ridiculousradish · 24/06/2021 12:39

I often joke with my 11 year old that he eats like a barbarian! He tells me to chill out, he knows how to eat properly and will do it when we eat out. Cheeky bugger! He was telling me the other day about the bad table manners of the other kids at school, so maybe he's not so bad.

My parents were Victorian about table manners when I was growing up. It was incredibly stressful. The only main rule I have is no screens at the table. Oh and don't lick your plate when I'm watching Wink

Hardbackwriter · 24/06/2021 12:31

@undermycatsthumb

*mine have always been taught to clear it

mine are taught not to pile their plate up with ridiculous amounts of food, and to finish what they put when they help themselves,

but if someone else is plating up for them, they absolutely do not have to finish.*

I don't mean clear as in eat all the food off their plate, I mean clear as in take their plate to the side and ideally put any scraps into the food waste and stick it in the dishwasher. Or at the very least take it from the table to the side.

I wouldn't do that in someone else's house (though I would ask if I could help clear up) - you don't know where anything goes! I'd actually think it quite odd if a guest just took themselves off and put their plate in my dishwasher, and I do think it's a lot to expect of a child. Are you sure yours do it at their friend's houses?
1starwars2 · 24/06/2021 12:31

DS1 14 doesn't have great table manners a lot of the time at home.

He is dyspraxic and it takes a lot more time and effort to eat well with a knife and fork.

He is very conscious of this though and if there was anyone but us there, or he was outside the house, he would make the effort, as he would be embarrassed not to.

He would always choose finger food over food that requires cutlery, so his preference would be burger, hot dog, pizza (vege versions).

At home I don't police his table manners. He knows how to do it properly but it's a lot more effort for him.

kindaclassy · 24/06/2021 12:30

I don't mean clear as in eat all the food off their plate, I mean clear as in take their plate to the side and ideally put any scraps into the food waste and stick it in the dishwasher. Or at the very least take it from the table to the side.

That's for your own house! you don't do that as a guest. It might not be rude, but in most houses it would be more than inconvenient if children started doing that when they are invited around.

It's bad enough when adults pretend to "help" that way.

ExhaustedFlamingo · 24/06/2021 12:29

@BlankTimes I have a son who's autistic and also has dyspraxia - we've tried all the things you've mentioned, and more, as recommended by our OT.

My son is now 11 and still struggles to cut anything up. He also still struggles to get the food from plate to mouth. The end result is that mealtimes are incredibly hard work and frustrating for him and he'll just give up because it's too exhausting. I'm fairly relaxed about how he eats at home, I don't enforce cutlery use any more. He's so skinny and scrawny, I don't want him missing out on much-needed nutrition just because it's such hard work to eat. That's not fair. Generally he'll start off using his cutlery and end up reverting to fingers as he gets tired and annoyed with trying.

He knows what table manners are expected in restaurants etc.

I'm not trying to put anyone off trying these things as they have absolutely helped us to make progress. Caring Cutlery and non-slip plates/cups helped a lot especially. But they're not a complete solution by any means when you've got an exhausted child who has to work very, very hard just to get the food successfully to their mouth.

Hardbackwriter · 24/06/2021 12:29

@memberofthewedding

When I was a child of 9 I was expected to use a knife and fork properly and to use proper manners at the table. There were no smart phones then but TV was turned off, and no reading at the table. No elbows on the table and no talking with a full mouth. When we had finished my sister and I had to ask permission to leave the table. By that age I automatically took my own plate and that of my parents into the kitchen to begin the washing up. It was one of my "jobs" to earn my pocket money.
I love it when people describe how well-behaved they themselves were as a child as if it's objective fact. I bet if you asked any of the children OP describes if they eat nicely, if their parents are strict and if they have lots of rules they have to follow the vast majority would say yes. Give it 50 years and those children will be going on about how much better raised they were than the 9 year olds of 2071...
undermycatsthumb · 24/06/2021 12:27

*mine have always been taught to clear it

mine are taught not to pile their plate up with ridiculous amounts of food, and to finish what they put when they help themselves,

but if someone else is plating up for them, they absolutely do not have to finish.*

I don't mean clear as in eat all the food off their plate, I mean clear as in take their plate to the side and ideally put any scraps into the food waste and stick it in the dishwasher. Or at the very least take it from the table to the side.

BrieAndChilli · 24/06/2021 12:25

like @GravityFalls our 10 year old is always reminded about table manners, eating properly etc. we wat most meals as a family and our 12 and 14 year olds manage to eat civily but the 10 year old is postively feral. if we didnt constantly go on at him I'm pretty sure he would just put his face in the plate and eat like a dog!!
I think at school where they dont have parents watching and nagging they just eat however.

I mean im sure even the poshest, most impeccably mannered of us has sat on the sofa and used our fingers or licked a bowl when no-one else is watching!!

memberofthewedding · 24/06/2021 12:24

When I was a child of 9 I was expected to use a knife and fork properly and to use proper manners at the table. There were no smart phones then but TV was turned off, and no reading at the table. No elbows on the table and no talking with a full mouth. When we had finished my sister and I had to ask permission to leave the table. By that age I automatically took my own plate and that of my parents into the kitchen to begin the washing up. It was one of my "jobs" to earn my pocket money.

mbosnz · 24/06/2021 12:21

I found mine got worse when they hit their teens! But they know the limit. No screens when anyone is eating the main meal, or at a table, no eating with their mouth open, talking with their mouth full, and if I see a fork being used as a lollipop stick, God help them. Misusing a knife is punishable by the look of death.

SimonJT · 24/06/2021 12:18

It depends on what you mean by tablemanners, they very much vary by culture, school lunches are also very rushed so children will likely use the fastest method. Plus we know lots of children will only behave ‘properly’ if they know there is an adult who will correct them there and then.

My son has decent table manners, he eats with his left hand (he is a lefty) and generally remembers to not speak with food in his mouth and to actually swallow before he takes a second mouthful.

When we eat at home or with me he eats fairly nicely, he knows he won’t get away with using two hands, or wiping his hand on his clothes. If I’m not there all rules go out the window, he goes for whatever method gets the food in fast enough.

Hardbackwriter · 24/06/2021 12:16

Incidentally the adult I know who has the worst table manners is a foreign office diplomat - I keep thinking that he must behave differently at official meals! He eats with his hands, wipes his fingers on his plate and then kicks them, eats far too quickly... He's a very dear friend but I try and avoid eating with him because it embarrasses me. But it would seem it doesn't hold you back in life to the extent you'd expect!

Ozanj · 24/06/2021 12:14

On the other hand my 18mo insists on using the same cutlery we do (the untold consequence of montessouri parenting!) and I spend mealtimes stressed out as he shovels food into his mouth with a fork the size of his face. I think he has sensory issues with food - doesn’t like touching it - which will probably bring in more problems as he gets older. The kids using their hands to eat are fine and normal.

BlankTimes · 24/06/2021 12:12

DS finds cutlery hard to use (we think he has dyspraxia)

A lot of the time, people don't realise how many things are easily available to help. Some may be available via your OT service, can you self-refer?

There are lots of different types of cutlery for kids and adults who struggle to hold and control the conventional type.

Kuracare Caring Cutlery and other makes of Caring Cutlery have indents that automatically let a child or adult hold them correctly.

Some cutlery has fatter handles for an easy grip.

You can buy soft easy grip tubing to put on ordinary cutlery and lots of other things if the need is only for fatter handles.

There are loads and loads of aids available for mealtimes for anyone who finds some things difficult to master. Plates that don't let the food slide off, cups that don't spill, theraputty, squishy balls, exercise balls and all sorts of things to improve the muscles in the hands and wrists. Posture aids for correct seating position at the table also help digestion.

Hardbackwriter · 24/06/2021 12:12

We're working on not talking with his mouth full with my 3 year old currently - but it's made me realise (because he points it out) how often adults do it! They tend to do it more discretely than a child, but it happens a lot. Same with interrupting while someone else speaks, he's started pointing out when my parents do it (constantly) and when I do (more than I should).

kindaclassy · 24/06/2021 12:11

mine have always been taught to clear it

mine are taught not to pile their plate up with ridiculous amounts of food, and to finish what they put when they help themselves,

but if someone else is plating up for them, they absolutely do not have to finish.

Heneage · 24/06/2021 12:09

It's how the Americans are shown as eating especially in cartoons

RankManners · 24/06/2021 12:09

@GravityFalls I wasn't expecting your post to end like that - made me chuckle, I'm sorry!
@TheLovelinessOfDemons omg you are so right - you could feed the 5000 off our dinner hall floor.

@kindaclassy totally the same here (although I'm thinking I win at table manners and probably lose abysmally elsewhere, eg getting DC doing chores......)

OP posts:
Awalkintime · 24/06/2021 12:08

As a teacher I would agree, most can't use a knife and the majority stick their fork into their food and eat it like a lolly. Eating with their mouths open and talking with food in their mouths is common. It isn't just 1 or 2 it is the majority of children who do this.

undermycatsthumb · 24/06/2021 12:05

I don't recognise the kids not eating with cutlery amongst the school aged children I know but I do remember reading an article about children increasingly arriving at school not knowing how to use cutlery, so there might be something to that. I am always a bit surprised when kids come for a playdate and just abandon their plate at the table, as mine have always been taught to clear it, but that's a pretty minor thing.

Hardbackwriter · 24/06/2021 12:04

@newnortherner111

Not surprised. Also those who might intervene such as restaurant staff will get abuse and not be supported by their managers.
It would be incredibly weird and inappropriate for restaurant staff to start correcting the table manners of their customers.

Like a PP I remember people lamenting this when I was a child, probably about 25 years ago. I think it's one of the constants of human history, just like every older generation complains that respect for elders has disappeared since they were children.

TerritorialPissings · 24/06/2021 12:04

I agree with you; I do wonder if it’s because there are so many more pressures on parents these days (homework in primary school, after school clubs, music practice etc etc) that encouraging good table manners feels like yet another thing to nag about…